Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

X-Trail goes diesel

  • By Keith Didham
  • The Mercury
image The X-Trail will come with a choice of two turbocharged diesels, both a variant of the same of 2-litre motor sourced from alliance partner Renault Photo Gallery

Customer demand drives change in line-up.

Nissan, which has been scrambling for sales with its restyled X-Trail, will add more fire power to the compact-sized wagon by finally adding a diesel version to its line-up this week.

A year ago, Nissan repeatedly dismissed the diesel as a viable option, saying there wasn't a business case for it in Australia, but its change of heart has been driven by customer demand.

Nissan has set the price of the diesel at just $1000 over comparable petrol models, admitting the petrol versions were subsidising the cost of the diesel so it could come to market at the budget price.

The X-Trail has been travelling a rocky road of late. It was once the best selling compact wagon in the market, but sales of this latest version, launched late last year, have according to Nissan's marketing manager Ross Booth, been “disappointing”.

Nissan, he admits, was caught napping — too slow to react to an intensive price cutting blitz from its rivals like Subaru and Toyota.

With that lesson learnt, Nissan has now retaliated with a new marketing campaign, effectively lowering the price of the petrol models by picking up on-road costs, while its dealers have also come to the party by doing drive-away, no more to pay deals.

So far this year the X-Trail has been convincingly outsold by market leader, Toyota's RAV-4, Subaru's Forester and Honda's CRV while Mitsubishi's Outlander has rapidly closed in on X-Trail's fourth place.

Nissan says the X-Trail is the first volume seller in the compact SUV market to offer a diesel. Suzuki launched its diesel Grand Vitara earlier this year but Booth doesn't see the fellow Japanese brand as a volume seller nor a serious rival.

DRIVETRAINS

The X-Trail will come with a choice of two turbocharged diesels, both a variant of the same of 2-litre motor sourced from alliance partner Renault. But one of the new diesels comes with a penalty.

A big selling point for the X-Trail has been its class-leading 2-tonne tow capacity — and by Nissan's own reckoning 80 per cent of buyers use the wagon for towing.

While the six-speed manual version retains the maximum braked trailer rating, those opting for the six-speed automatic will be limited to just 1350kg. The difference in tow capacity is governed by how the transmissions are cooled: manual models feature a conventional separate external oil cooler for the gear box; the auto is water cooled internally from the engine and cannot take the added tow load.

Nissan, based on past experience, expects 60 per cent of X-Trail buyers will opt for the automatic so those wanting to tow heavier boats or caravans will have to buy the petrol model which retains the 2-tonne rating.

The auto also doesn't match the manual for power and torque either. It will come with an 110kW/ 320Nm version of the turbocharged diesel; the manual gets more potency with a 127kW and 360Nm.

Both engines are economical, rated at 7.4l/100km for the manual and 8.1l/100km for the auto. Peak torque is achieved at just 2000rpm, with 90 per cent of maximum torque on tap from a low 1750rpm.

SPECIFICATIONS

There will be two specification grades: the TS and premium TL both of which have similar equipment to petrol models. Pricing starts at $36,990 for the TS manual and $38,990 for the automatic. The better equipped TL starts at $39,990 for the manual and the auto comes in at $41,990. The price of the diesel has been pegged at just $1000 over petrol versions.

But in a bid to cut costs and keep the $1000 price premium, climate controlled air conditioning (standard air con fitted instead), leather wrapped steering wheel and leather gear knob have been dropped in the TS and replaced with a vehicle alarm.

The TS comes with Nissan's smart All Mode switchable all-wheel drive system with hill start and downhill assist, six air bags, anti-lock brakes with electronic brake distribution and brake assist, cruise control, keyless entry, alloy wheels, six-stack audio and trip computer. The TL adds leather upholstery, power adjustable front seats with seat heaters, huge sunroof and climate control air conditioning.

DRIVING

If you exclude Suzuki's Grand Vitara, the X-Trail gains bragging rights over its main rivals for being first in this compact SUV market with a diesel.

But the timing isn't brilliant; Nissan should have had this engine option available more than six months ago when Australians were quickly warming to the advantages of having an efficient diesel over a petrol motor.

Now that there is an ever-widening gap between petrol and diesel pump prices, some of that advantage has been lost so the appeal of a diesel X-Trail is not as strong.

Nissan's rivals will be closely monitoring the diesel wagon's take up rate — Nissan expects it will account for about 40 per cent of volume — to see if there is still a strong demand by buyers for an oil burner. As such, the arrival of the diesel is really a toe in the water exercise for all the major players.

Nissan's inability to offer the maximum two-tonne tow rating on the automatic will hurt, especially when trying to attract business from buyers looking for the combination of an all-road wagon, diesel engine, automatic transmission and big towing ability.

The X-Trail however should be a very attractive proposition to fleets and private buyers on its fuel efficiency alone.

The auto wagon is not a bad thing and nice to drive; but the manual offers a more spirited edge, although both suffer from a noisy diesel clatter, especially at idle.

The X-Trail has already proven itself as a competent, well designed family wagon; the diesel just adds icing to the equation.

And the big factor in Nissan's favour is the price. Diesels normally command a hefty premium over petrol models, so Nissan's bid to keep the price to $1000 is a marketing winner.

 

Nissan X-Trail

Pricing: TS manual $36,990, automatic $38,990; TL manual$39,990, automatic $41,990.

Engines: 2-litre four cylinder diesel, 110kW at 4000rpm (six speed automatic) 127kW at 3750rpm (six speed manual).

Torque: 320Nm at 2000rpm (auto); 360Nm at 2000rpm (manual).

Fuel consumption: 7.4l/100km manual, 8.1l/100km auto

Emission: 198g/km; Euro IV compliant.

Acceleration: zero-100km/h 10s (manual), 12.5s (auto).

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 29 comments

  • I’ve just discovered tonight the same problem that John Kohen mentioned ... will be contacting my Nissan dealer tomorrow.

    SJ of Melbourne Posted on 28 July 2011 10:28pm
  • I have a 2010 Nissan X-Trail TDI 6 months old and the vehicle is only lockable 10% of the time. The keyless entry and locking system has a major problem which means you cannot take the car out because you cannot lock the boot door and most times any of the other doors it is not the keys We have been back to the Dealer two days straight they either don’t know what to do about it or ?. Has any other people or dealers with X- Trails had this problem.

    john kohen of Wollongong 2500 Posted on 08 February 2011 9:50pm
  • I have just bought the latest 2011 diesel X-Trail. It runs beautifully. Has plenty of acceleration, quiet, almost like a petrol, the fuel light came on at 650 kms(city and motorway). The dealer filled it so not too sure how much they put in, it showed full when I picked it up. It cruises along @ 100km/h @1800 revs. Very comfortable too. I?m wrapped with it so far. NOW to fill it and really see how many kms I get to the tank.

    david wright of booval, qld Posted on 05 December 2010 10:20pm
  • I have a 2003 ST manual X-Trail, which has done 136000 km with no issues whatsoever. It is great for towing, and has pretty good off road capability for a small car. It keeps up with the big boys on sand too, except for the lack of low range. I am now looking for a later model automatic X-Trail.

    Sigi Keller of Morisset NSW Posted on 06 September 2010 5:32pm
  • nissan x trail

    van eng tran of sydney Posted on 07 June 2010 4:45pm
  • We have a 2003 X-Trail and have travelled over 117,000kms on all types of surfaces, hauled a caravan. As far as we are concerned it is a great SUV. Never meant to be a full 4WD, go-anywhere vehicle. If you want to go on sand, through mud and over rocks, get yourself a 4WD but don’t expect a SUV to do that. They built for a purpose… not a ‘do everything’ 4WD.

    Les Paton of vic Posted on 28 April 2010 4:58pm
  • Hi all potential X Trail owners. We bought a new 2007 X Trail ST ( latest shape) after owning two other faultless X TRAILS. We bought a new version mainly due to the reliability and overall usefullness of the old model but what a lemon we ended up with. In 3 years of ownership our car has had 2 complete gearbox replacements, 2 complete air conditioning units replaced and a hydro belt tensioner replaced. Thank god it was covered under warranty! The Xtrail is a good car but make sure you sell it before the warranty expires. It wont stop me looking at another XTrail as this is our 4th in the family but i gather now there are better alternatives out there. Nissan really needs to look at their competition as they are being left in their wake at the moment. Anyway, i am off to the local Nissan dealer to upgrade ....lets see what crappy trade in price they will give us.

    Alex Smith of twin waters Posted on 16 April 2010 9:23am
  • I tow a van weighing 1300kg with a T30 petrol no problems fitted auto trans cooler. On average 16L/100Km @ 90 to 100kmh.

    Peter Taylor of Perth WA Posted on 07 April 2010 11:29pm
  • I think the comment below needs to be re-quoted. I feel this guys pain…

    **
    BEFORE YOU INVEST IN AN XTRAIL, SUGGEST YOU INVEST 2 MINS TO READ THIS:

    I am writing this so that maybe one other person will avoid the disappointment and expense of owning an Xtrail that I have experienced. They are really, really poor off road - try doing anything more than a 30 second sprint through soft sand and you will find out why? first the 4wd warning light turns on, then 4wd disengages and then you are stuck up to the axle. This happened to me every time I went near the sand. Try Fraser Island or Double Island point ... you will see them regularly being towed out of very ?normal? conditions by REAL 4wd?s. Maybe all SUV?s in the price range are the same.. but believe me, buy a tow rope - you will need it. And don?t have any weight in the car - you will almost certainly get stuck.
    All that is something I could cope with and probably just live with, as I haven?t been on the beach for more than 1.5 years ....

    James Farr of Canarvon Posted on 30 November 2009 4:44pm
  • Jeff of Canberra, I have been looking for a new (used) car for some time and an Xtrail has been high on the list. I just checked out theJeep Patriot on redbook and it said that the 2007 Jeep Patriot MK My2007 Liited only has a braked tow capacity of 1500kg.

    Sick of car hunting Posted on 18 October 2009 6:59am
  • Has anyone done any towing with an x-trail diesel manual. I tow a van weighing, all up, 1300kg’s

    Peter Vincent of Adelaide Posted on 26 April 2009 6:15pm
  • I recently bought the Xtrail Ti petrol and it’s a pleasure to drive, especially the CVT gear box is so smooth. I disagree with people who think CVT is crap. If you know how to use it, then it’s quite quick. It won best compact SUV (out of 20 contenders) in 2007 when it first released in australia,voted by Drive, and it also won Australian Car of the year in the same year because of its offroad ability and the CVT gear box. People who judged these yearly events are professional test drivers so it can’t be wrong.

    xtrailist Posted on 18 April 2009 4:12am
  • Recently, our fleet cars were up graded from commodore wagons to xtrails based on the fact that they were a four cylinder and used less fuel. For some reason, petrols were bought and diesels were not considered. This aside, the xtrail petrol are ORDINARY. Averages 10.5 Lt/100 compared to my old wagon which was 9.4 lt/100. The CVT transimission is crap with the only way to get anywhere is put ur foot down, otherwise you crawl. Out of the 5 cars that were bought, one has already had a motor replaced at 7000km and another has a terrible squal coming from the gearbox. With this in mind, the Diesel would hopefully be better but for anyone looking at a petrol xtrail, DONT!! Stick to the commodore!

    Matthew Glennen Posted on 21 March 2009 6:51pm
  • lol - an auto commodore, falcon or even the 380 can tow more than this…

    the alex of brisbane Posted on 11 November 2008 8:58pm
  • Well, what can I say David, in your own words, pulled out by real 4WD’s, does this sentence give you a clue, X-Trails are not 4 WD, they are SUV’s, anything less than low range gears who go out sand-surfing really need a quick course in 4WD training. My wife and I have pulled out so many wannabees from sand, mud, snow in their pretend 4WD, in our ‘real 4WD’ it really beats us why they even try, is it some kind of macho thing, ” I conquered Frazer Island sand dunes” whoopee-doo.
    Did you let the air out of tyres to 18psi? Did you check the ground up-ahead by walking the distance, do you or anyone else check the depth of mud-puddles? If you sink in sand, what do you think one and half tonne going to do? Do all you WB’s ever see what salt-water does to a vehicle, and how many actually crawl under their vehicles to wash them. Anyone who thinks sand is normal conditions really have rocks for brains, I challenge any SUV to go over Big Red or Hells Mountain.

    This happened to me every time I went near the sand, see, like I said above, a wannabee, helloooooooo, mother nature is telling you something. Anyone who buys a vehicle because the crocodile rocks in the advert. really didn’t spend much time comparing all models in the same category, my wife and I spent over 6 months researching all reviews, comments, warranties, blogs, complaints, recalls, lemons, before we even come close to parting monies, and don’t ask the sales, can I pretty please do this, just do it, hell, if its 4WD, I wanna see it do 4WD, if they complain, just walk away yelling I’ll spend my money to your opposition. Let the sales rep know the oppositions prices and watch them beat each other down, just sit back and watch

    Carl & Cathy Mc of Taree Hinterland Posted on 06 November 2008 9:43pm
  • BEFORE YOU INVEST IN AN XTRAIL, SUGGEST YOU INVEST 2 MINS TO READ THIS:

    I am writing this so that maybe one other person will avoid the disappointment and expense of owning an Xtrail that I have experienced. They are really, really poor off road - try doing anything more than a 30 second sprint through soft sand and you will find out why… first the 4wd warning light turns on, then 4wd disengages and then you are stuck up to the axle. This happened to me every time I went near the sand. Try Fraser Island or Double Island point ... you will see them regularly being towed out of very “normal” conditions by REAL 4wd’s. Maybe all SUV’s in the price range are the same.. but believe me, buy a tow rope - you will need it. And don’t have any weight in the car - you will almost certainly get stuck.
    All that is something I could cope with and probably just live with, as I haven’t been on the beach for more than 1.5 years .... but my Xtrail has also recently required $3000 for a new clutch after just 66,000 km’s. I complained to Nissan - they sent two “fob” off letters, saying it was just out of the 3 year warranty period, therefore - bad luck, they basically didn’t give a toss. It was out of the time warranty, but 34% under the distance warranty,  which is surely the most relevant indicator of usage anyway? Also, a new clutch after that number of km’s? I have had 1980’s cars that did 3 times that without needing anything like that in repairs. And a new car, made in 2005, come on - this isn’t the 1970’s is it? Ironically, I was loyal enough to get it serviced by a Nissan dealer, even though it cost more to me. Amazingly, they even said to me in terms of the warranty we “give the customer the benefit of any reasonable doubt”. So, they may not of even fixed it anyway! “reasonable doubt” quoted to you by a multi-national car company - that’s hardly reassuring!
    Don’t be fooled by the type of marketing that puts crocodiles on top of cliffs in the advertisements like I was - in my experience - absolute LEMON. And it will cost you….
    If all you are doing is sealed road, then your test drive around the block is fine for you, and what they want you to do. See what they say when you ask to give it a test on the sand….
    MAYBE THE NEW MODEL IS DIFFERENT ... BUT THE APPLES NEVER FALLS TO FAR FROM THE TREE IF YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN ....

    Tell your friends!!

    David Elmer of kinscliff Posted on 22 October 2008 10:10pm
  • Just bought an X-trail TL diesel manual, and it’s a fantastic drive.  Has a lot of go, and the best ride in the class.  I testdrove most of the rivals, and only the Freelander 2 and Tiguan came close, and those are more expensive when you option them to the same level as the TL X-trail.  The Jeep Patriot is a pile of, well you know what, compared to the X-trail, the quality, fit and ride of these is far inferrior to the Nissan.  Plus, if I want a car that’s gonna breakdown and burn I’d buy a Captiva.  Santa Fes are ok, but I wouldn’t touch a Korean car… that’s just me.

    I would recommend this car, and I wouldn’t worry about the price of diesel, I use on average 7lt per 100km, and even at 20% more, diesel still comes out in front.  The diesel also drives a lot nicer than the petrol, we drove both back to back when we were deciding, and the tdi is much nicer with the extra torque.

    Nissan are doing some reasonable deals on these, we managed to get about 10% off the on road price, so they are great value.

    Throughly recommend this car.

    ChrisJH of Perth Posted on 20 September 2008 8:50pm
  • I have a 2004 xtrail, really great cars with 2 tonn towing capacity as we pull a caravan behind, was thinking to update it to the new deisel but with 1350 kg towing capacity I will be looking for another car, maybe a nissan pathfinder with 3 ton towing cap on deisel, Why make a xtrail wiuth such a low towing ability

    Mike G of Mandurah (WA) Posted on 17 September 2008 10:03pm
  • About time Nissan brough out a Diesel version of X-Trail however Too bad is the new T31 model. The new X-Trail is less of a improvement then the old T30 series purly due to the changed gearbox. Both Auto (CVT) and 6 Speed Man drives poorly compare to the old style Auto & 5 Speed Man. All Nissan model with CVT option lacks the GO. This is espically noticeble on the bigger vehicle like Murano & XTrail. Overall, I recommand many other makes/model out there compare to this new Diesel X-Tail. Nissan needs to stop reinventing the wheel with new models that just doesn’t cut it, and a example of this is replacing Pulsar with Tiida. They might as well start making cars with Square wheels!!

    R.Kelly of NSW Posted on 11 September 2008 1:54pm
  • Nearly bought X-trail this year but for two things - looks too like old model and no auto diesel. Just too boxy at the back. The old one looked better. Nissan were just too profit greedy to do a serious update or offer a diesel. Now they have lost the initiative and the plot. As people downsize they should offer diesel in the Qashqi immediately or give it a decent 4 cyl like o’seas markets get.
    Oh , and drop the stupid rubber band in the Auto, it is truly awful to drive !!
    Again too fixated with profits to do a real auto box.

    don of Brisvegas Posted on 23 August 2008 8:31pm
  • Forget the X-Trail peoples….the Jeep Patriot (diesel version) was out in Australia over a year ago, pulls 6.7l/100km of the gold stuff, (true, cause I got one and in fact it averages 6.5 on the open road and 7l in the city), has great towing capacity, 2t;  all the interior mod-cons (except the 6 drink-holders that x-trail has (why?)), and the best part of all of it, starts at 29,990.  That is 7,000 cheaper than the base model x-trail.  That’ll cover the extra price of diesel at the pump.

    Oh yeah, it even goes off-road…and does it really well…like a Jeep should.

    Geoff of Canberra Posted on 19 August 2008 4:03pm
  • Not much point in paying a premium for Diesel at the moment. The Govt needs to explain why we are being ripped off here.
    It seems no matter who we elect,,they have their OWN INTERESTS at heart..like
    Party Donations ect..and not the PUBLIC who elected them in.
    Looks like we need more INDEPENDENTS..to sort out this PARTY CORRUPTION
    DONATION business.

    cyril stevenson of coffs Posted on 16 August 2008 6:29pm
  • Q: Neville, how many Sante Fe’s have been sold in July 2008? A:179, which is 3% of the total medium SUV Market . The top selling SUV’s in July are the Subaru Forester 19% 1200 vehicles and the Kluger 23% 1400 vehilces. This is an interesteing fact, considering the Forester is not available in a diesel, and as many have indicated, why would you buy diesel at the moment? It would take about 7 years to repay the differnece in purchase price and diesel price on most diesel variants versus a pertol vehicle. I have also seen a lot more diesels on the back of tow-trucks, which indicates some reliability issues.

    Paul Gosford of Gosford Posted on 13 August 2008 11:20am
  • I heard that the high price of diesel is because of high tax from government. not the fault of petrol company.  I think X-trail is design not for towing but for sporty drive. Did anyone imagine how a Porsche looks like with a trailer towing at its back?  Its not matching its image.  More torque means faster acceleration from stand still with a trade off of top speed which already killed by the speed limit everywhere near the city. For diesel car, Australia is too late as compare with Europe but too early under the current high diesel tax and few pumps around the urban area. I feel very disappointed on X-trail is its look is not big difference from the first model which makes me feel I am driving a box. I would prefer a Hummer diesel if one day I like driving a diesel box on the road.

    Smurmsg of VIC Posted on 13 August 2008 12:53am
  • if you want diesel economy and 2-tonne tow capacity, why not a Hyundai santa fe? 5speed tiptronic auto & 343 Nm torque make towing easy, and 7 seats with A/C to all 3 rows, reclining rear seats, stability control, climate control are a bonus.  towing a one tonne trailer the other weekend i averaged 9 l/100 k’s.  (ADR rating 8.2) can’t complain.

    neville smith of brisbane Posted on 08 August 2008 8:48pm
  • Stephan Jelenic hit it on the head.  What’s the point with diesel being 30 cents a litre dearer than petrol and today in Redcliffe it is 40 cents a litre (26%) dearer. All diesel users will agree that the Government is fixated on petrol prices rather than fuel prices and diesel users appear to be the victims of fuel company price gouging. Also diesel buyers will find that they have to queue up for a go at the single diesel bowser at the local (lack of) servo and more often than not they have to wait for a petrol vehicle at the closely alongside petrol bowser to clear out of the way.
    What of the Nissan X Trail itself?  It seems to be a wonderfully torquey little engine, albeit $1000 dearer to buy and no doubt dearer to service.  What’s the use of that torque in the automatic model if it cannot tow 2 tonnes? I almost bought an X Trail petrol auto last year because of it’s 2 tonne towing capacity but decided to wait until the diesel model came out, thinking that it might be able to tow even more than 2 tonnes. At that time diesel was usually 10-15 cents/litre higher than discounted petrol, and much the same price when petrol discounting came off.  Small diesel engines use less fuel per 100 klm and in Europe and NZ where diesel is lower in cost, they make good economic sense. 
    In Australia the X Trail diesel automatic (why would you have a manual in typical Brisbane traffic crawls?) is seriously let down by 2 factors, it’s towing capacity, and Government inaction at overly high diesel prices.  If I buy an X-Trail in the near future, it will definitely be the petrol automatic which in my opinion is a better SUV towing and AWD option than a Toyota RAV 4 automatic.  I own a Nissan Navara STX 2.5 diesel auto which is a great towing vehicle and only uses 10 litres of diesel per 100 klm.  Despite this, I will not be buying another diesel vehicle in future unless the Government steps in and punishes the fuel companies for penalising me and my family for trying to tread lightly on the environment. and use less of our finite hydrocarbon resources. Nissan has done a good job with the diesel X Trail, but it does not make good economic or convenience sense in Australia.  Ditto for the increasing rash of light diesel vehicles that are now coming onto our market.  All they are going to do is cause even more frustration at the hard-to-get-to diesel bowsers at the lack-of -service centres and increase fuel rage when the new owners discover how they have been ripped off.

    Steve Mahoney of REDCLIFFE QLD Posted on 06 August 2008 2:33pm
  • I own an X-TRAIL (2003) great vehicle.  Enquired about diesel motor (2004) after finding out that they have been around for approx 2yrs (overseas).  Nissan said that we don’t need them in Australia.  Shame, my next car will not be an X-TRAIL.

    Robert Mullins of WISHART QLD Posted on 05 August 2008 8:22pm
  • the lack of towing ability of the auto is very disappointing.I was keen to seriously look at this diesel, but not any more. I wonder if an after market oil cooler would be an option?

    malcolm boyd Posted on 05 August 2008 1:05pm
  • with the price of diesel being 30 cents a litre dearer petrol whats the point !

    stephan.jelenic Posted on 03 August 2008 6:13pm
Read all 29 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links