Holden Acadia vs Range Rover Sport

What's the difference?

The Holden Acadia is a proper seven-seater SUV in that it will fit adults in the third row without turning your friends into enemies. It’s also practical and well fitted out with storage places and utilities such as USB ports.

I was particularly impressed with the advanced safety equipment on-board even at this entry LT level. Yes, it’s a V6 petrol and it’s not the most fuel-efficient SUV, but our time with it showed that with cylinder deactivation and the stop-start system it might not be as thirsty as you’d think.

The Range Rover Sport P460e Dynamic HSE is a cool and classy premium five-seat SUV. It’s comfortable, refined, powerful and efficient with excellent safety and thoughtful practicality.

If you’re in the market for a luxurious SUV and your budget sits just under $200K this car should be on your shopping list but we’d recommend careful assessment of its value proposition across standard features and cost-of-ownership relative to its highly credentialled rivals. 

To fully understand the look of the Acadia, take a peek at the GMC website - but make sure you shield your eyes in the same way you would during a solar eclipse, or when welding, or in an atomic blast.

You’ll understand when you get there but suffice it to say contained within the site are some pretty confronting trucks and SUVs. Once you’ve recovered, you’ll realise the Acadia is the supermodel of the GMC family.

Yep, it has a big, blocky, truck-like look but it’s a refreshingly tough styling alternative to more elegant looking SUVs such as the Mazda CX-9.

The Acadia is also one of the smallest members of the GMC family, yet its dimensions position it as a large SUV in Australia. Even then it’s not huge compared to other large SUVs here, so you won’t have an issue piloting it in Aussie car parks or fitting into spaces.

The Acadia measures 4979mm end-to-end, 2139mm across (with the mirrors out) and 1762mm tall.

Along with the Mazda CX-9 the Acadia would also consider the Kia Sorento and Nissan Pathfinder to be among its rivals.

Inside, the Acadia is a modern and stylish looking place, although it’s a bit unrefined. Still, as one YouTube commenter reminded me parents will like the wipe clean surfaces.

Well her comment wasn’t written that politely but being a parent, I concur that the hard plastics have that advantage.

The interior is not all unrefined. The seats, even in the entry grade LT we tested, while cloth (and only available in Jet Black) are sculptured with bolsters and finished with a textured pattern that looks and feels great.

Gerry McGovern may have left his role as Jaguar Land Rover Chief Creative Officer (under mysterious circumstances) late last year but his design fingerprints are all over the current Range Rover Sport.

A clean, confident and tightly wrapped exterior reflects his focus for SUVs on large, relatively unadorned surfaces, a high waistline and a curved, sloping nose. 

A coefficient of drag (Cd) of just 0.29 also supports his team’s consistent focus on aero efficiency.

The interior treatment gives off a clearly discernible echo of Land Rovers and Range Rovers past with a compact angular hood sitting over the compact digital instrument display and the flat lower dash section enhancing a feeling of simplicity.

Perforated semi-analine leather seat trim (in Ebony on our test car) dials up the luxury feel, as does the sleek 13.1-inch media screen and soft-touch materials across the dashtop as well as in and around the doors.

Worth noting piano black surfaces across the front centre console might look slick in the showroom but in day-to-day life they attract fingerprints like Chopper Read before a police interview.

The Acadia’s practicality game is strong. It boasts seven seats with third row positions actually able to fit adults, five USB ports sprinkled through the cabin, and a cargo capacity of 1042 litres with the third-row seats folded flat and 292 litres with them in place. If you have three kids, even teenagers, the Acadia could be the perfect family personnel carrier for you.

All three rows are spacious and even at 191cm tall I had good shoulder and elbow room up front, and in the second and third rows I had enough legroom to sit in each seat behind my seating position without feeling cramped.

Feeling a bit down because you might not be able to stretch the budget to get the LTZ-V? Well, cheer up – the LT has more headroom and that’s because it doesn’t get the sunroof which eats into the ceiling height.

Cabin storage is excellent. There’s a wide and deep centre console bin, a hidey hole in front of the shifter, a tray for second row passengers, six cup holders (two in each row) and decent-sized door pockets.

Directional air vents for everybody on board, three-zone climate control, two 12-volt power outlets, privacy glass and proximity unlocking complete a great practicality package.

At just shy of 5.0m long, more than 2.2m wide and a bit over 1.8m tall with a 2997mm wheelbase the current Range Rover Sport is a large five-seater. 

Its wide-track, high-roof stance and the dash’s away slope means there’s lots of room up front  and storage aplenty.

A deep box between the seats is covered by a padded lid and a dual cupholder unit in front of it is able to slide away to reveal another handy space. A wireless charging pad sits in front of the gearshifter.

The top of the centre console forms a flying buttress which leaves another useful storage area underneath.

Generous bins in the doors (neatly outlined by bright metal trims) are big enough to hold large bottles and there are two (upper and lower) glove boxes on the passenger side.

There are also individual front centre armrests swinging down from the inner edge of the front seats, their angle adjusted via a twisting rotary dial.

We’re not convinced by the multimedia package with a relatively complex line-up of screens and functions proving at times a struggle to navigate. 

Physical controls for the ventilation system, rather than in-screen adjustment would be a good start.

But what we loved was the heated windscreen which is part of the Cold Climate Pack fitted to the test car. A cold winter morning’s foggy windscreen cleared in an instant is a huge safety plus.

Move to the back, as you’d expect for a car measuring close to three metres between its axles, there’s lots of room.

Sitting behind the driver’s seat set to my 183cm position I have plenty of head, leg and shoulder room. 

The rear seat’s breadth means three adults can slide in there quite easily. But the centre position isn’t sculpted and padded like the outer two and a driveline hump in the centre of the floor limits footroom, however power recline functionality (with controls in the doors) adds extra flexibility.

The reason for the non-sculpting in the centre spot is a hefty fold-down centre console housing a lidded storage compartment and a pair of flip-out cupholders.

The door bins are generous, there are hard-shell map pockets on the front seatbacks and adjustable ventilation control at the back of the front centre console sits above the seat heating dials. Nice. 

The boot swallows no less than 647 litres with the 40/20/40 split-folding rear seat upright which grows to a healthy 1491L with it folded and there are numerous helpful additions back there including hooks, lighting, a netted pocket, storage cubby and 12-volt power socket. Boot-mounted buttons to release the rear seats are handy, too.

The same control panel contains a height adjustment feature for the electronic air suspension to make loading and unloading easier and Land Rover also deserves a medal for including a full-size spare wheel rather than a space-saver or inflator kit.

In this case that means a monster 23-inch alloy rim shod with the same tyres as the rubber doing the work under the car. Bravo!   

Power and connectivity options include two USB-C sockets, a 12-volt outlet and a wireless phone charging pad in the front, another two USB-Cs in the back and a second 12V plug in the boot. So no problems with charging capacity for phones and other devices.

Braked trailer capacity is 3.0 tonnes (750kg unbraked) and one of the Range Rover’s party tricks is the ability to swing the tow bar into place or back out of the way at the touch of a (you guessed it) boot-mounted button. Exposed shins everywhere are grateful.

Our test car’s Dynamic HSE grade is one rung up the Range Rover Sport ladder with a single grade below and four above. 

Then its P460e petrol plug-in hybrid powertrain is one of four choices which also include petrol and diesel mild hybrids.

The combination of the two adds up to $181,018 (a model year update coming in quarter four sees that increase to $188,500), before on-road costs, which puts it in the same size and price league as the Audi SQ7 4.0 TFSI V8 quattro ($174,815), BMW X5 M60i ($177,900), Mercedes-AMG GLE53 AMG 4Matic+ ($179,900) and Porsche Cayenne S E-Hybrid AWD ($187,800) - all prices before on-road costs.

Quite the shopping list of large performance luxury SUVs and you have to be packing in the standard features to keep your head above water in this company.

Aside from the performance and safety tech we’ll get to shortly this Range Rover Sport steps up with 20-way heated and ventilated, electric memory front seats, electrically reclining and heated rear seats, perforated semi-analine leather seat trim, a leather-trimmed steering wheel, illuminated alloy treadplates (with Range Rover script), Satin Chrome gearshift paddles and ‘bright metal’ pedal covers.

There’s also a 12.3-inch digital driver’s display, dual-zone climate control, an electrically adjustable steering column, a 13.1-inch central multimedia touchscreen, high-end Meridian audio (with Android Auto, Apple CarPlay and digital radio), a head-up display, built-in nav, voice recognition and wireless device charging.

To split hairs, I’d expect three- or four-zone climate at this price point but things like the heated power rear seats are a nice inclusion.

All up, a solid standard equipment list but not enough to blow the competition away.

For reference, our test car had been treated to some options in the shape of the Enhanced Black Pack for $8720 (black brake calipers, 23-inch gloss black wheels, privacy glass, Black Exterior Pack and black contrast roof), a sliding panoramic sunroof ($4641), Cold Climate Pack for $1980 (heated steering wheel, heated windscreen and heated washer jets) and adaptive off-road cruise control ($483). Total as-tested price is $196,482, before on-road costs.  

All Acadias come with a 3.6-litre V6 petrol engine which makes big dollops of power and torque or 231kW (at 6600rpm) and 367Nm (at 5000rpm).

A nine-speed automatic swaps gears, and in the case of our two-wheel drive LT test car the drive went to the front wheels only.

The V6 gets the thumbs up for its stop-start fuel saving system and cylinder deactivation, plus good acceleration and the smooth power delivery you’d associate with a naturally aspirated engine, but a thumbs down for needing to rev hard to make that mumbo.

The Range Rover Sport Dynamic HSE P460e is powered by a 3.0-litre, turbo-petrol, inline six-cylinder engine sending drive to all four wheels via an eight-speed automatic transmission and four-wheel-drive system including a two-speed transfer box for high- and low-range running off-road.

A permanent magnet synchronous electric motor, positioned between the engine and transmission, is powered by a 38.2kWh lithium-ion battery located under the rear floor.

The motor’s roughly 160kW of peak power contributes to overall outputs of 338kW and 660Nm, the 2.7-tonne SUV claimed to sprint from 0-100km/h in a spritely 5.5 seconds.

We were surprised by the Acadia’s fuel efficiency. After filling up the tank I drove for 136.9km on a combination of hilly country roads and peak hour evening city traffic and then filled up again – only 13.98 litres were used. That’s a mileage of 10.2L/100km. The official combined consumption figure is 8.9L/100km.

So, while the engine is big and not particularly new (it’s an evolution of the V6 built by Holden in Australia for the Commodore) it does have fuel-saving tech like cylinder deactivation and a stop-start system – which you can’t switch off.

Still, not the most fuel-efficient seven-seater – those with turbos and smaller capacity engines such as Mazda CX-9 are truly amazing in the way they can deliver grunt without getting thirsty.

Claimed combined cycle (urban/extra-urban) fuel economy for the Range Rover Sport Dynamic HSE P460e is a miserly 1.6L/100km, the 3.0L inline six emitting just 38g/km of CO2 in the process.

It’s important to note that the official number is predicated on the car’s battery being charged consistently.   

Land Rover says pure-EV range on the combined WLTP cycle is 118km, noting a real world number of “up to 96km” is more realistic. Maximum electric-only speed is a lofty 140km/h.

Maximum DC charge rate is 50kW which Land Rover says will deliver an 80 per cent charge in 40 minutes. A 7.0kW AC wallbox will take you to 100 per cent in five hours and a 2.3kW domestic socket will have you waiting 15 hours for a full charge. Home and public charging cables are included.

We recharged at a 150kW pylon and as expected the peak rate went to around 45 kW and it took 30 minutes to half fill the battery. Using the supplied home charging cable on a three-pin outlet for a roughly nine-hour stint delivered a 50 per cent battery top-up. 

Over around 300km of city, suburban and highway running we spent most of the time in Hybrid mode which leaves it to the powertrain’s brain to switch between pure-electric and internal combustion power, rather than the dedicated EV setting. 

Overall result was 6.1L/100km, which is pretty great for a full-size, 2.7-tonne SUV.

A 71.5-litre fuel tank (which requires a minimum 95 RON premium unleaded inside it) equates to a real-world range of around 1170km using our on-test consumption figure.

I drove the Holden Acadia back-to-back with the Nissan Pathfinder – you can watch the model comparison in the video above, but the upshot of that experience was important.

See, while I wasn’t a major fan of the Acadia driving experience when I first met the SUV at its Australian launch in 2018, when I drove it straight after the Pathfinder the difference was like night and day.

The Acadia is comfortable, from the big seats to the smooth ride. If you’re covering a stack of territory the Acadia makes a great highways cruiser and will chomp up big distances  effortlessly.

That V6 does need to rev hard, but it’s powerful and acceleration is swift, while the nine-speed automatic shifts pretty seamlessly. Noise cancelling tech keeps the cabin fairly serene, too.

Look, it’s not the most dynamic of SUVs and there was a bit of tyre chirp in the corners when pushed, but this isn’t a performance car and nor is it trying to be.

Small windows mean a cooler, tough look, but the downside is a dark cabin and occasionally visibility is limited by the A-pillars or out the rear windows.

A 2000kg braked towing capacity will rule the Acadia out for many thinking of pulling a large caravan or big boat. The Pathfinder’s 2700kg braked towing capacity is a strength of that SUV.

Do you need all-wheel drive? Nope, but it’s handy for dirt and gravel roads. Still the 198mm ground clearance with only front-wheel drive should see you get down bumpy roads that regular sedans couldn’t handle.

Applying a Sport badge to a 5.0-metre long, roughly 2.7-tonne SUV is a brave call. But there’s no doubt the Range Rover Sport Dynamic HSE P460e is rapid in a straight line. 

Zero to 100km/h in 5.5 seconds is quick for a car of this size, and just so you know, it has the ability to storm on to a maximum velocity of 225km/h. It will even hit 140km/h in EV-only mode.

The 3.0-litre, turbo-petrol six feels and sounds suitably brawny without upsetting what is an impressively refined drive.

Throttle response is as smooth as it is urgent, the eight-speed auto is slick as butter and the option of manual shifts via wheel-mounted paddles is welcome when you want to get more involved.

The front seats manage to combine long-distance comfort with firm location and the continuously variable adaptive suspension smooths out imperfections with uncanny ease.

The layout is double wishbones at the front with multi-links at the rear and the Sport’s calibration keeps in planted and balanced in corners despite its high-riding SUV form.

Noise from the enormous 23-inch rims, shod with 285/40 Pirelli Scorpion MS rubber is minimal and we didn’t come close to challenging their grip strength. Road feel through the steering is pretty good, too.  

Brakes are big ventilated discs all around (400mm fr / 370mm rr) and they’re well up to the task with regen braking in support at slower speeds.

This test was on-road only, but for the record this car’s approach angle is a maximum 33 degrees, breakover is 24.5 and departure is 30, with a handy wading depth of 900mm.

Despite its substantial footprint the Range Rover Sport is surprisingly easy to park, with sensors, multiple cameras and screens helping to keep things low-stress.

And it's worth noting none of the Range Rover’s advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) functions intrude beyond their intended purpose in day-to-day driving, which is always welcome. 

The Range Rover Sport has a maximum five-star ANCAP rating from assessment in 2022 although it’s worth noting that rating is based on the performance of its slightly larger Range Rover sibling.

Active (crash avoidance) tech includes auto emergency braking (AEB) with pedestrian and cyclist detection, junction assist and backover detection, all operational from 5.0 to 80km/h, adaptive cruise (with stop & go), lane departure warning and lane keep assist, blind spot monitoring, traffic sign recognition, a 360-degree camera view, rear cross-traffic alert, forward collision warning, driver fatigue monitoring and tyre pressure monitoring as well as front and rear parking sensors.

If a crash is unavoidable there are six airbags onboard - front, front side and side curtain - but no front centre bag or knee airbags for the driver or front passenger. 

No active bonnet to help protect impacted pedestrians from striking hard engine parts under the bonnet but standard multi-collision brake minimises the chances of subsequent impacts after an initial crash. 

There’s also an event data recorder and for child seats there are three top tether points across the second row with ISOFIX anchors in the outer positions.

The Acadia is covered by Holden’s five year/unlimited kilometre warranty.

Servicing is recommended every 12 months or 12,000km. Expect to pay $259 for the first service, $299 for the second, $259 for the third, $359 for the fourth and $359 again for the fifth.

Land Rover covers the Range Rover Sport with a five-year/unlimited kilometre warranty, which is in line with premium competitors like Audi, BMW, Lexus and Mercedes but lags the mainstream market with an increasing number of brands at seven, eight and up to 10 years conditional. The warranty for the hybrid battery is six years/100,000km.

Roadside assistance is included for five years, service is recommended every 12 months/20,000km and a five-year service plan will set you back $3900.

That’s a solid average of $780 per workshop visit, which is marginally more expensive than a BMW X5 M60i ($714) over the same period, but substantially cheaper than the Audi SQ7 ($920) or Porsche Cayenne S ($1135) and less than half the cost of the Merc-AMG GLE53 ($1684).

Land Rover has a long-standing network of 74 dealers across the country including all state and territory capitals as well as key rural and regional centres.