CarsGuide uses an eight-segment review format, marked out of 10, to ensure consistent testing by our 16 Car of the Year judges with 250+ years of combined experience. Every model is evaluated against its segment rivals.
While the standardised format drives consistency, each review is compiled by a single journalist, bringing an inevitable level of subjectivity. So, the lead judges for each category evaluated its reviews to create a shortlist of the top-10 models, which the full judging panel then refined to three finalists and a winner in the CarsGuide 'War Room'.
The CarsGuide Car of the Year overall winner was selected from the category winners, with all of these decisions justified, where applicable. Note all eligible models had to be on sale and reviewed by January 1, 2026.