Best Small Car Starting Under $80K announced! 2026 CarsGuide Car of the Year: Audi Q3, BMW X1 and Renault Megane E-Tech face off

The premium small car category (starting under $80K) is an interesting one because there are many cars that might not necessarily be cross-shopped, but in one way or another they end up being compared to one another.

Our 2026 CarsGuide Car of the Year awards category shortlist saw entrants from Audi, BMW, Cupra, Renault, Smart, Subaru and Volvo. The vehicles range from small petrol hatches all the way to small electric SUVs.

Now we’re at the pointy end and it’s time to whittle it down to a winner. First up are the two runners up in alphabetical order, then the category winner.

Add CarsGuide as a preferred source in Google Search

Runner up: Audi Q3

This small SUV from Audi is an oldie but a goodie and that’s how it has ended up as a runner up for CarsGuide’s best small premium car.

CarsGuide reviewers love how the Q3, despite its age, still presents well with a stunning exterior design, while the driving experience is elegant, yet fun.

“I think it’s such a neatly executed package, it’s hard to pick faults in that car,” said CarsGuide Deputy Editor James Cleary.

However there is a new-generation model set to launch locally in early 2026 that could potentially become the new benchmark for the segment.

Audi Q3 2025 review: Sportback S line 40 TFSI quattro

Runner up: Renault Megane E-Tech

While this French small electric SUV hasn’t stormed up the sales charts like some of its competitors, it’s a dark horse with charming driving dynamics and a stunning interior design.

CarsGuide Deputy News Editor Tom White, who had one for a three-month long-term loan early in 2025, noted it’s a car that moves the Renault brand forward in Australia.

In fact, he said that everyone who sat in this tester asked if it was a Kia, which he believes is a massive compliment to the Megane E-Tech.

The few things holding this car back are the mediocre AC charging rate, plus the Australian-specification car does miss out on things like connected services, which are offered overseas. Thankfully Renault has committed to addressing the latter with an update in 2026.

Winner: BMW X1

Although it’s been a couple of years now since the current-generation X1 launched in Australia, it still stands out as a segment benchmark, therefore making it a clear choice for CarsGuide’s best premium small car of 2026.

“Previously the Q3 was my favourite in that category, [but] I think the X1 does move the game forward,” said CarsGuide Deputy News Editor Tom White.

BMW X1 (Image: Laura Berry)

It not only offers class-leading petrol-powered variants, but the availability of electric powertrains in the same body style. All of them have stellar driving dynamics and high-tech interiors.

Additionally, besides its compact exterior dimensions, the X1’s clever interior packaging and available storage space makes it almost feel like a mid-sized SUV. You can see why this is now the best-selling BMW in Australia.

Category	Announcement #1	Winner & finalists
Sub-$50K Small Car	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$80K Small Car	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$60K Medium SUV	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$130K Medium SUV	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$100K Large SUV	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$220K Large SUV	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists
Sub-$85K Ute	Top 10 shortlist	Winner & finalists