Mazda CX-5 vs Tesla Model Y

What's the difference?

The Mazda CX-5 Evolve kicks some goals and with its comfortable on-road handling, robust safety equipment and practical interior, it’s still a solid choice for families looking for a mid-sized SUV. The only thing it’s missing is a hybrid powertrain, which would make this already well-rounded package even more compelling.

If you like the five-seat Model Y, then you'll like the six-seat L version even more. I think this the best example of Tesla's electric SUV to date, and the cabin layout just makes a lot of sense, and would suit plenty of families who don't need to squeeze someone into a compromised middle seat.

Note: The author, Andrew Chesterton, is a co-owner of Smart As Media, a content agency and media distribution service with a number of automotive brands among its clients. When producing content for CarsGuide, he does so in accordance with the CarsGuide Editorial Guidelines and Code of Ethics, and the views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author.

The next-generation Mazda CX-5 is bigger than before, but it retains the sleek body lines and understated styling that have made it such a handsome SUV. The wider front end and repositioned grille give it a more purposeful look than the outgoing model, while the 17-inch alloy wheels keep things suitably restrained.

Inside, the cabin doesn’t feel too basic despite the cloth upholstery. There are plenty of soft-touch materials, a pleasant dashboard and some new technology, including the 12.9-inch multimedia display. You lose most of the physical buttons, though, so there’s a little less of that traditional Mazda tactility.

The fabric seats are cosy and the extra interior space is definitely noticeable. Overall, there is still an understated elegance to the CX-5’s cabin.

Spoiler alert - it looks a lot like a five-seat Model Y, doesn’t it, albeit a slightly bigger one. And you’d have to be a bigger Tesla head than me to immediately spot the differences at a glance.

The wheelbase is longer, the rear doors are bigger as are the rear 3/4 panels and the roof line is higher, helping with headroom in the third row.

Still, safe to say if you like the look of the five-seat Model Y, you’ll like this one. And if you hate it, well, good luck.

The alloys are 19-inch and shaded by the aerodynamic caps and there are light bars front and rear which debuted on the updated five-seat Model Y when it arrived mid-last year.

The bigger changes are inside, of course. I promise we’ll get to the second and third rows in the Practicality section, but let’s talk about the look and feel first.

There’s a love/hate relationship with Tesla’s stripped-back aesthetics, and I’m probably somewhere in the middle. I like the airiness of the space in the cabin, and I think it feels nicely put together, and I really dig the contrasting fabric used on the doors and dash which add a little visual interest to the cabin.

But I hate using the central screen to select a gear and I hate not being able to see how fast I’m going without turning my head. A head-up display would work wonders in the Model Y L cabin.

The front seats are a particularly comfortable place to spend time, with wide seat bases and plenty of elbow room. Getting in and out is easy thanks to the wide door apertures and 205mm of ground clearance and there’s enough space to settle in for a longer journey.

There’s also plenty of useful storage up front, including a large glove box, dual-opening centre console, cupholders and bottle holders, plus a dedicated phone tray with wireless charging. You get a 12-volt socket and two USB-C ports for keeping everything else topped up.

The 12.9-inch multimedia screen replaces Mazda’s familiar rotary selector with touchscreen operation, which I find easier to use. The updated operating system takes a little while to get your head around and there’s no native sat nav, but otherwise it feels functional and fresh for the new-generation model. Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are standard, with CarPlay maintaining a solid connection throughout my week.

The extra size of this next-generation model is more noticeable in the back, where improved leg- and headroom is good news for taller adults on longer trips. The rear doors open to almost 90 degrees, making it easier to access the ISOFIX child-seat mounts and three top-tether anchor points.

There’s not a huge amount of extra family-focused kit back in the rear row, but you do get directional air vents, storage bins in each door and a centre armrest with cupholders. My nine-year-old was comfortable, although he did point out the lack of a charging port during a road trip.

And, as a parent, I had one other gripe: keeping the fabric seats clean from my kid’s shoes in rainy weather. Let’s just say some seat covers might be a worthwhile investment.

The boot offers up to 466L with all seats in use. That’s not the largest capacity in the class, but it was more than enough for my little family of three this week. I like the level loading floor, although the boot itself is quite tall, which can make lifting heavier items in and out a little awkward.

I’m also pleased to see a spare tyre, even if it is only a space-saver. And while a powered tailgate would be handy, at this price point I don’t think you’ll really miss it... until you’re standing there with your hands full!

Captain’s chairs are simply a more luxurious version of second-row seating. With that there is no argument and the heated and cooled chairs that occupy the second row of the Model Y L are pretty good examples of them.

Space, both knee and headroom, is ample, and you can adjust each seat individually if you want to grant a bit more space to any third row occupants. Armrests deploy at the push of a button — as do the two hidden cupholders — and it really is easy to settle in and get comfy.

The third row is a bit more hit and miss. I’m 175cm and found I had enough legroom and headroom, but the big plastic mouldings that emerge from each side of the Model Y (which house a cupholder) are a miss. They end up pushing you into the seat next to you, and I can foresee a lot of arm rubbing with anything like two adults back there.

Also confusing is how to actually get out of it. You can fold the seat in front of you flat, but then you have to climb over it. I found it easier to just walk out between the seats.

There are another two USB-C ports in the rear row and you get air vents but no temperature controls. 

The Model Y L stretches 4969mm in length, 1668mm in height and 2129mm in width, which is roughly 18cm longer and 4.5cm taller than the five-seat model. The extra space doesn’t sound like that much, but start dropping rows and you find a heap of storage space.

Both the second and third row stow electronically from the boot, but with them in place you’ll find 420 litres of storage in the double-layer boot. Drop the third row, and that number grows to 1076 litres. With the third row folded there is a massive 2423 litres of space. The frunk serves up another 116 litres.

There’s also room (and the ISOFIX attachment points) for four child seats.

The Model Y L sits smack bang between the $68,900 Long Range AWD and the $89,400 Performance, setting you back $74,900, before your on-road costs. It’s also the only three-row option in the Tesla family.

Aside from people movers, we’re not swimming with options in the three-row electric space, either. The Kia EV9 will get it done from $97,000, the Hyundai IONIQ 9 starts from around $120K and the Volvo EX90 is more expensive again (from $124,990).

Anyway, in Tesla land, the Model Y L rides on 19-inch alloy wheels, has a glass roof, automatic wipers and Tesla’s smartphone access key, as well as the little credit-card swipe.

Inside, there’s a 16.0-inch central screen that handles everything. And I mean everything. It's your gear selector, your speedometer, and everything else, too. There’s no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto, but you can access things like Spotify and podcasts through the in-built apps and the on-board navigation system is a good one, too.

All of that pairs with a 19-speaker sound system, and there are dual wireless charge pads. All three rows of seats are heated, while the first and second row get ventilation, too.

A second 8.0-inch touchscreen in the middle row then handles things like the seat heating or cooling, music and games to amuse the kids. And the Model Y L also debuts V2L, or Vehicle to Load, for Tesla in Australia, using a connector in the external charger.

The CX-5 is all-wheel drive and powered by a 2.5-litre four-cylinder petrol engine producing 132kW of power and 242Nm of torque. It has a braked towing capacity of up to 1800kg, giving you the option of some light towing on the weekends, while the six-speed automatic transmission shifts smoothly through its gears.

But there’s no escaping the fact that most of its key rivals now offer hybrid powertrains, and you can feel the absence of one here. The CX-5’s petrol engine is perfectly capable, but it doesn’t have the same efficiency advantage that many buyers in this segment are increasingly looking for.

The Model Y L gets Tesla’s dual-motor AWD powertrain, with two electric motors producing a total 378kW and 590Nm. That’s enough, Tesla says, to knock off the sprint to 100km/h in five seconds flat.

The CX-5 has a 58-litre fuel tank and claimed combined cycle (urban/extra-urban) fuel consumption of 7.4L/100km, giving it a theoretical driving range of up to 783km. That’s a solid range for a family-sized SUV and means you won’t be constantly thinking about your next fuel stop.

My real-world fuel use settled at 7.8L/100km after a week of longer highway stints and urban trawls, so it’s not too far off Mazda’s official number.

Still, this is where I’d like to see a hybrid powertrain join the CX-5 range. The fuel economy is reasonable, but with so many rivals now offering hybrid options, Mazda is starting to leave some efficiency gains on the table.

Tesla is always a little vague when it comes to the size of its batteries, but reports point to the Model Y L carrying a 84Wh (useable) NMC battery.

Whatever the specifics, the range is strong, with Tesla promising a 681km driving range on the WLTP combined (urban/extra-urban) cycle.

It’s also set up for 250kW DC fast charging, which should see you take on 288km in 15 minutes, according to Tesla.

The CX-5 feels composed around town, with power delivered smoothly for everyday driving. But when you need to punch it off the mark, there’s some noticeable lag, and you have to work the engine harder to find the power when tackling a steeper hill at higher speeds. It’s capable enough, but it can feel like you’re asking a little more of it than you should.

The suspension has a firm edge to it, but I like how responsive the steering feels. The CX-5 is genuinely enjoyable through corners, with a dynamic feel and very little body roll.

The cabin is also impressively quiet, with minimal road or wind noise creeping in at higher speeds. Visibility is good through the front and sides, although the A-pillar can get in the way at times.

The reversing camera provides a clear view, while front and rear parking sensors make manoeuvring easier. Overall, it’s not a difficult SUV to park, despite its larger dimensions.

Honestly, it feels like the Tesla Model Y has grown up. I didn’t love earlier iterations of this car and I found the Performance to be fast but lacking any emotional fizz.

This one, though, feels solid and composed, and the power on tap (of which there is ample) is more about effortless progress than it is attempting to offer sports car excitement.

The steering is now nicely weighted and feels direct enough without being too sharp, and the cabin is well insulated, with often the slightly off-putting sort of rubbing noise the steering wheel makes when you turn it the only intrusive sound.

One drawback is a ride that definitely errs on the side of firm. This Model Y L gets electronic damping designed to iron out some of the more jagged stuff, but it still feels brittle in places, and you can definitely feel some sharpness in the cabin. Now, to be fair, it’s not too firm for me, but it might be for you.

Another is a bizarre turning circle which constantly reminds you you’re driving a big bus, especially when you try to complete a tight three-point turn.

But despite its stretched dimensions, I found the Model Y L easy to drive and park in the city, and once you're up to speed with Tesla's operating system (there's no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto), then the screen is pretty easy to use, too.

The Model Y L gets the same maximum five-star ACNAP safety rating as the rest of the Model Y range, with nine airbags (up from seven in the five-seat model), and things like AEB (Auto Emergency Braking), lane-keeping assist, 'Forward Collision Warning' and blind-spot monitoring all along for the ride.

Interestingly, the curtain airbags from the five-seat version haven't been replaced, with coverage still only extending to the second row. New airbags have instead been added for third-row occupants.

One more analogue quirk of the Tesla Model Y L is the thick B-pillar, which does a good job of almost completely obscuring driver-side blind-spot checks (for those of us who still like to do those manually).

The CX-5 is covered by Mazda’s five-year, unlimited-kilometre warranty, which also includes five years of roadside assistance. It’s a solid offering, although longer warranty terms are becoming increasingly common in this segment.

Servicing is reasonably priced at around $440 per service over seven years, and the intervals are well spaced at every 12 months or 15,000km, whichever comes first. That should make ongoing ownership relatively straightforward for families.

Tesla warranty is a these-days-underwhelming five years and unlimited kilometres, while the high-voltage battery is covered for eight years or (a wildly specific) 192,000km.

There’s also five years' of roadside assistance, including puncture repair (a good thing, given the lack of a spare wheel). I also couldn’t find a puncture repair kit and later research suggests Tesla sells them, rather than provides them as standard.

Tesla servicing is condition-based, so there’s no fixed schedule, with a summary on the car’s touchscreen providing a record of when vehicle maintenance was last carried out and prompts for when they should be performed next.

In the absence of a combustion powertrain the emphasis is on things like wheel rotation, balancing and alignment, brake fluid testing, air-con servicing, camera precision, radiator cleaning and high-voltage battery maintenance.

Expecty a ‘Vehicle Health Check’ to come in under $300 with ‘General Diagnosis’ at around $270 per hour.