BMW I4 vs Mercedes-Benz Evito

What's the difference?

The BMW i4 balances a solid, old-school feel with the beauty and stunning looks of high-end technology. It feels like the end of an era for the German brand before it leaps into the screen-heavy age of software-defined vehicles.

While BMW hasn’t publicly announced an end-date for i4 production just yet, the new i3 is bound to overshadow it once it arrives. It offers more than double the claimed range and will likely address a number of this car’s flaws.

In the meantime however, the i4 is definitely worth considering if you value driving dynamics and a quality feel in a car that you can drive daily.

It’s arguably the best-looking mid-size van on the market, particularly with the optional enhancements fitted to our example. And its longer (km-based) service intervals and capped-price servicing costs offer substantial savings compared to a diesel Vito equivalent.

However, the eVito has a much higher purchase price, smaller payload, shorter driving range, can’t tow a trailer and feels a tad under-powered at low speeds. Plus filling its battery with fresh charge takes much longer than filling a tank with diesel, which may or may not be an issue depending on planned usage.

Therefore, a buyer would need to have not only a sizeable purchasing budget but also very specific and resolute criteria for this vehicle to shine in a commercial role.

The BMW i4 is firmly at the end of its lifecycle, however its exterior design is ageing like fine wine. This is apt given our tester was finished in delicious-looking 'Fire Red' metallic paint.

The overall proportions of this car are gorgeous, especially towards the rear where the roofline is drawn out, accentuating the liftback look.

This latest update only brought minor tweaks to the design, including refreshed headlight and tail-light signatures. As mentioned above, the M Sport package is now also standard which does give this car a subtly sporty look.

Inside the design marries together the best of the old and new worlds. A major highlight is the curved display housing not only the 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster, but also a 14.9-inch touchscreen multimedia display. It’s a stunning setup that looks ultra modern.

On the flipside however, there is still a lot of physical switchgear on the centre console, including a rotary iDrive controller that allows you to control the content on the screen. It’s a great setup if you like to avoid getting fingerprints on the touchscreen.

While there are a few applications of glossy piano black around the cabin, it’s balanced nicely with other metallic and matt finishes. You’re able to choose from a few different trim inlays, including aluminium and open-pore wood, for no extra cost.

Lastly, the new M Sport steering wheel looks great in this car and adds a lovely sporty touch to the interior.

The eVito’s front-mounted electric motor drives the front wheels. Its lithium-ion battery is located beneath the standard Vito floor to ensure load volume is not reduced. This substantial battery is as wide as the load floor and extends from just behind the front wheels to just ahead of the rears. Its charging port is located behind a spring-loaded body flap ahead of the left front wheel.

It rides on a 3200mm wheelbase with 5140mm overall length, 1928mm width and a kerb-to-kerb 13-metre turning circle, with 1916mm height allowing access to underground and multi-storey carparks. It’s equipped with strut-type front suspension, semi-trailing arm/coil spring rear suspension and four-wheel disc brakes.

Hopping into the i4, it’s clear you’re getting into a low-slung vehicle. If you’ve got poor mobility, it may be worth looking elsewhere.

Once you’re in though, the cockpit is a lovely space to spend time. The driver’s seat is beautifully comfortable and offers plenty of adjustment, including extendable thigh support.

Ahead of the driver the steering wheel is rather thick in classic BMW fashion. I appreciate the physical buttons and scroll wheels as they’re easy to understand and use on the fly.

The curved display not only looks stunning, but is functional and easy to use. The digital instrument cluster has a number of layouts you can choose from and it can be paired with the head-up display, which is great to refer to at a glance.

Moving across, there is a lot going on with the central multimedia system. It can feel overwhelming with the amount of content and information to begin with, but once you start poking around, things are logically sorted.

Thankfully there are also a series of shortcut buttons always at the bottom of the screen to take you to key menus.

Adding to this, there is the flexibility of having the iDrive controller. Reaching the far side of the screen from the driver’s seat can be a bit of a stretch and being able to use the rotary dial on the move is much easier.

There is wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto as standard. It takes up the full touchscreen display, which looks great.

Looking around the cabin, storage space is fine but not amazing. There are two cupholders plus a wireless charger tucked behind them on the centre console, plus a shallow centre storage area under the central armrest.

Hopping into the second row, it’s clear the focus for this car is on the occupants up front. The door aperture is rather narrow, making it tricky to get in and out gracefully.

In the second row space is nothing more than adequate. At a leggy 182cm tall, my legs almost touch the seat in front when it’s set to my driving position and my head almost brushes the roofliner. I’d struggle to spend a lot of time back here.

This is compounded by the massive hump in the centre that’s a carryover from the combustion platform this car is based on.

Second-row amenities include climate control with air vents mounted on the back of the centre console, two USB-C ports, as well as a fold-down armrest with cupholders.

At the back there is a large liftback that opens and closes electronically. With the rear seats upright there is 470L of boot space, which expands to 1290L when folded.

While this is not massive in terms of outright capacity over a similarly sized sedan, the envelope is much more open and usable.

There’s also a section under the boot floor that’s generously sized for power cables, among other odds and ends.

With its hefty 2318kg kerb weight and 3200kg GVM, the eVito has an 882kg payload rating. That is 183kg less than a diesel equivalent (119 Vito MWB RWD), given that the eVito is around 300kg heavier than the ICE version largely because of its battery.

And unlike the diesel alternative, which is legally rated to tow up to 2500kg of braked trailer, the eVito has no tow rating, which is consistent with other electric vans we’ve tested and a potential deal-breaker for tradies.

The cargo bay offers a competitive 6.0 cubic metres of load volume and is accessed through sliding doors on each side (822mm openings), with large internal assist-handles on the bulkhead. Rear cargo bay access is through a swing-up tailgate, which can limit the use of forklifts not fitted with extendable tynes. All doors and walls are internally lined.

The load area is 2678mm long, 1709mm wide and 1392mm high. With 1270mm between the rear-wheel housings, it can carry two 1165mm-square Aussie pallets or up to three 1200 x 800mm Euro pallets, secured by eight sturdy load-anchorage points.

The cabin bulkhead has a cavernous open storage area at its base which is handy for storing ropes, straps etc. The upper section of the bulkhead protrudes about 20cm into the openings of the side sliding doors which may obstruct loading of large items.

Cabin storage includes a large-bottle holder and bin in the base of each door, with smaller bins at mid-height. There’s also an overhead glasses holder, two cupholders and three open bins across the top of the dash, a single glovebox and a hidden compartment beneath the passenger seat which is handy for storing small items or valuables out of sight.

Our test vehicle is the eVito Panel Van MWB (Medium Wheel Base), which comes equipped with a single 85kW/360Nm electric motor and a 60kWh battery for an eyebrow-raising list price of $91,051 plus on-road costs.

Our sparkling example looks more upmarket than the standard offering, as it’s equipped with the optional $2779 Sport Package comprising metallic paint (Brilliant Silver on ours), body-coloured front and rear bumpers, black roof rails, fog lamps, black leatherette upholstery and a choice of 17-inch alloy wheels. These good-looking rims are fitted with 225/55R17C Dunlop Econodrive tyres and there’s a standard full-size steel spare.

Other options, including premium infotainment and electronic interface functions, cargo bay wood-flooring/LED lighting and more, raise the as-tested list price to $99,871 - which means you’re looking at six figures to drive away in this stylish two-seater.

So, what’s a $100K electric Mercedes-Benz van include as standard equipment? Let’s start with a conspicuously long (8.0 metres) charging cable stored in a vinyl bag. There’s also a chrome grille, tinted windows and heated door mirrors, but headlights/daytime running lights/tail-lights are halogen when you’d expect to see LEDs at this price.

Inside, there’s a full steel bulkhead (with large window) separating the cabin from the cargo bay, a leather-wrapped and two-way adjustable multi-function steering wheel, two USB ports, high-gloss black trim appointments in the upper central console, and a chrome interior package including air-vents, air-con dials, door-handles and surrounds.

Also standard are ‘Comfort’ bucket seats for driver and passenger with heating, base-cushion length adjustment, fold-down inboard armrests and powered adjustments including height/reach lumbar support. The infotainment system has a relatively small 7.0-inch touchscreen, but there’s digital radio, voice command and multiple connectivity including Apple/Android devices.

The i4 eDrive35 continues to be powered by a single, rear-mounted electric motor that produces an unchanged 210kW and 400Nm.

This is nothing revolutionary in terms of the powertrain, though it’s nice it retains a rear-wheel drive-layout like the discontinued 4 Series Gran Coupe this car is based on.

BMW claims the i4 eDrive35 can do the 0-100km/h sprint in 6.0 seconds and the top speed is 190km/h.

The eVito’s single electric motor drives the front wheels via a single-speed transmission. It produces 85kW of power and 360Nm of torque from the energy stored in its 60kWh battery.

Using the steering wheel paddles, drivers can switch between five energy-recuperation modes to optimise battery range and reduce manual brake use. These range from D- (strongest deceleration/recuperation) through D, D+ and D++ which progressively reduce these effects. DAuto uses a radar sensor to automatically adjust the recuperation level according to surrounding traffic.

There are also three switchable drive modes comprising E+, E and C, which allow drivers a choice of energy consumption/performance levels.

The electric motor is fed by a 70kWh lithium-ion battery pack that allows for up to 448km of claimed range, according to ADR 81/02 testing.

This is 18km more than the pre-update car thanks to silicon carbide semiconductor components which are claimed to reduce energy consumption and increase range.

However, the Tesla Model 3 and Polestar 2 both still offer more range for less money.

BMW claims the i4 eDrive35 consumes an average of 16.3kWh/100km, according to ADR 81/02 testing. Over my 200km of urban testing I saw an average of 17.5kWh/100km, which isn’t fantastic as EVs are predominantly more efficient in the city.

Using my as-tested consumption, this means you have a theoretical range of 379km. That’s not great, though this range issue will be addressed with the forthcoming i3 electric sedan.

AC charging is available at rates up to 11kW, whereas DC fast-charging is offered at rates up to 180kW, allowing for a 10 to 80 per cent charge in 32 minutes.

BMW has positioned itself as creating vehicles that are the ‘ultimate driving machine’ for decades now and this i4 is no exception.

While it’s not an outright performance powerhouse, it doesn’t need to be in order to feel engaging to drive.

The rear-mounted electric motor produces a decent 210kW/400Nm and it’s enough to get moving in frenetic urban traffic with ease. You’ll rarely want any more out on the open road either as rolling acceleration is decent.

The regenerative braking system in this car feels natural and transitions to the friction brakes with no awkward lurching or inconsistencies.

I like how you can drive this car like a regular combustion car using both the accelerator and brake pedals, or with an extra flick of the gear selector you can activate one-pedal driving. During my loan I played around with both and didn’t have a favourite as both feel well tuned and easy to adapt to.

The steering is direct and on the lighter side, making the car feel agile and nimble on the move. However, in low-speed situations you realise the turning circle isn’t fantastic…

I appreciate that BMW opted for standard 18-inch alloy wheels that are paired with tyres that have chubby sidewalls as this keeps the ride from being harsh and jittery, especially over firmer bumps.

Don’t worry if 18 inches aren’t enough though, BMW offers alloy wheel options that go all the way up to 22 inches.

This is the type of car that suits a long-distance road trip as it’s such an easy and fun car to cruise around in. That's why it’s so unfortunate that the range limits how you can travel before recharges.

In terms of noise, vibration and harshness (NVH) in the cabin, the i4 is naturally quiet given it’s an EV. However, it feels like there’s extra insulation because even at high speeds tyre and wind noise are virtually nonexistent, creating a hushed and tranquil interior ambience.

It’s easy to get comfortable given the height/reach adjustable leather-wrapped wheel and powered multiple seat adjustments, which include base cushion rake and height/reach lumbar support. The base cushion can also be manually extended for more under-thigh support by sliding the front section forward.

There’s good eyelines to the door mirrors and, thanks to the large window in the cabin bulkhead, the central rear-view mirror has an unobstructed view through the tailgate window. The passenger-side mirror’s wide-angle view, combined with active blind-spot monitoring, help to minimise the large blind-spot over the driver’s left shoulder that all solid-walled vans share.

Steering is nicely weighted and communicative, unladen ride quality is supple thanks to its four-coil suspension, and four-wheel disc brakes provided reassuringly strong braking response. However, there was also noticeable tyre noise intrusion at speeds above 60km/h on coarse bitumen surfaces.

Acceleration from standing starts feels leisurely at best, even when using full power. This is when the eVito’s 2.3-tonne kerb weight is noticeable, which is not surprising when you compare its weight-to-power and weight-to-torque ratios with a diesel Vito (MWB) equivalent.

For example, based on kerb weights, the 119 CDI Panel Van (140kW/440Nm) has to move 14.2kg/kW and 4.5kg/Nm compared to the eVito’s much heavier 27.3kg/kW and 6.4kg/Nm.

However, the power delivery is seamless and once up to cruising speeds the response noticeably improves, fortunately in the 60-80km/h range where much city and suburban travel occurs. The key to fluent progress in traffic is maintaining momentum.

To test its load-hauling ability, we inflated the tyres to the recommended pressures and forklifted 650kg into the cargo bay through the side doors. Combined with driver and equipment, this equalled a 750kg (three-quarter-tonne) payload which was about 130kg short of its maximum rating.

With the cargo bay load positioned well ahead of the rear wheels, the rear suspension only compressed 25mm with no risk of bottoming-out over bumps.

Our 50km test route comprised mostly city and suburban routes (for which this vehicle is tailored) plus some highway driving. There wasn’t a noticeable drop in handling, braking or ride quality with this payload, although standing-start acceleration felt more subdued as you'd expect.

There is currently no ANCAP rating. Even so, it comes with a suite of standard passive and active safety features including front, thorax and window airbags, AEB, blind-spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alert, lane-keeping, active parking assist, crosswind assist, front/rear parking sensors, DRLs, active cruise control, reversing camera and more. There’s no speed sign recognition, though.

Like all electric BMWs, the i4 is covered by a five-year, unlimited-kilometre warranty, whereas the high-voltage battery is covered for eight years or 160,000km.

A five-year warranty has been commonplace within the premium space for a few years now, whereas many mainstream brands have since moved up to seven years of coverage, or longer in some cases. It’s far from competitive.

Owners also receive three years of complimentary roadside assistance.

BMW offers a six-year pre-paid service package priced at $2420, which averages out to just over $400 per year.

The eVito has a five-year/250,000km vehicle warranty with an eight-year/160,000km battery warranty and a 24-hour roadside assist support package. Scheduled servicing is every 12 months/40,000km whichever occurs first. Capped pricing for first five scheduled services totals $2432 or an appealing average of $486 per service.