Volkswagen Tayron vs MG ZS EV

What's the difference?

So, does the new Volkswagen Tayron 195TSI R-Line sink or swim? It's definitely swimming as it delivers a solid blend of features and comforts for families seeking a 'sometime' seven-seater. It's not yet on the podium as it doesn’t hit every mark. Purchase price and servicing costs may put some buyers off but it packs in a number of thoughtful, family-oriented features. Whether it will go on to become Volkswagen’s standout seven-seat offering remains to be seen, but it’s a capable, well-rounded option in the segment.

The MG ZS EV Long Range is a practical small SUV that's easy to drive and the 440km it can travel on a full charge makes it the better choice over the standard range ZS EV. The extra 120km offered by the Long Range version reduces anxiety and is truly useful in covering more ground between charging.

The asking price may seem expensive but electric vehicle batteries are extremely costly to produce and will remain so for years to come.

Remember, too, that the MG4 electric car has an even great range for the same money - the only catch is, it's a hatch and not an SUV.

The Tayron has a robust silhouette but avoids tipping into boxy territory. Its long wheelbase is balanced well by the overall shape and the large 20-inch alloy wheels give it a planted, purposeful stance. It’s a pleasant-looking family SUV, though it stops short of being particularly distinctive. Beyond the illuminated Volkswagen badges (which are a genuine highlight and lend the Tayron some subtle Tron-like flair) the design is fairly unassuming.

Inside, the Tayron makes its strongest impression after dark. Multiple illuminated panels with galaxy-like patterns add depth and visual interest, giving the cabin a sense of atmosphere that’s largely absent in daylight. There’s a reassuring mix of soft-touch surfaces and materials throughout. Suede-like microfleece and leather elements are used generously, contributing to a cabin that feels well made.

The black headliner is a win when you have kids but interestingly for a top-spec grade, there is no sunroof. The R-Line leather steering wheel looks the part and feels good in hand but aside from the expansive digital displays, the cabin lacks a clear focal point. A little more personality would have gone a long way toward elevating the cabin space.

The ZS EV Long Range has a traditional SUV shape but with a very futuristic looking face thanks to its grille-less nose. That’s because with no radiator needed to cool a combustion engine there’s no need for an open vent or grille for air flow.

MG has used a textured plastic to subtly imitate an old-school grille to lessen the visual impact of a sheet of plastic between the headlights.

I think the effect works although the obvious charging flap could have been cleverly and seamlessly integrated into the nose, in the same way Genesis has done with the GV80 Electric. But the attempt has failed.

The ZS EV Long Range’s cabin looks premium with the sporty seats and red stitching, the landscape screen and digital driver display.

But, while the interior looks great, it feels a little low quality in places such as the vinyl upholstered seats. 

There are some ergonomic issues with the high centre armrest and the raised seating position, too.

The Tayron’s cabin hits most of the right notes for a three-row family SUV. Space is strongest in the front and middle rows, with generous head and legroom accommodating taller passengers without issue. That said, the narrow centre armrest means the driver and front passenger end up quietly competing for elbow room on longer drives.

The electrically-adjustable front seats are the most comfortable place to be, particularly over distance. With heating, ventilation, massage and strong lumbar and under-thigh support, they reinforce the sense that this is the flagship grade.

Storage up front is more mixed. The door bins and glove box are on the larger side, but the centre console leans more towards tray than box. While the ‘hideaway’ dual wireless charging pads are a clever idea, accessing them means clearing whatever you’ve placed on the shelf above. A small drawer to the right of the steering wheel is a useful touch, though, and works well for a garage remote or wallet.

The second row is firmer and more bench-like, with seat backs that don’t offer much support in corners. Heated outboard seats are a welcome inclusion, but, much like the Tiguan Allspace, there are noticeable gaps of around 12cm between the seats and the doors. While the Tayron offers three top-tether anchor points across this row, fitting three child seats side by side would be challenging.

That said, amenities in the second row are plentiful. The transmission tunnel is relatively low, foot space is generous, and there’s no shortage of features to keep younger passengers comfortable. Map and device pockets, dedicated climate controls, two USB-C ports, retractable cupholders and manual sunblinds all feature. The sunblinds, in particular, are a road-trip essential when travelling with kids or a sleeping baby. The only frustration is that the climate and seat heating controls can occasionally lock, requiring access via the front touchscreen.

The third row is kid-coded because of the access and available legroom. There’s no footwell as the seat base sits fairly close to the floor, so knees are up. There are also no amenities aside from a single cupholder, so any novelty will quickly wear off even for younger kids.

Much of the Tayron’s functionality runs through the large 15-inch multimedia display, including climate control. The screen offers clear graphics and is mostly responsive, though some lag can occur on start-up. Built-in navigation is standard, along with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. CarPlay maintained a consistent connection and pairing was straightforward.

Practicality is rounded out by a well-shaped boot. With all seats in use, there’s 345L of cargo space which is enough for school bags and a grocery run. Fold the third row and capacity expands to 850L, which is better than several key rivals. The squared-off load area makes it easy to stack gear, and it comfortably swallowed a nine-year-old’s BMX bike and scooter without needing to fold the second row, which benefits from a versatile 40/20/40 split.

All grades come with a space-saver spare tyre, which is far preferable to a repair kit, and the R-Line adds a hands-free powered tailgate. Deep side pockets flanking the height-adjustable boot floor and a 12-volt socket round out a cargo area that feels genuinely family-friendly.

The ZS EV Long Range is a practical small SUV and it fit my little family of four, although my kids are both under 10 years old and not at the lanky teenager point yet.

Space on board is good, offering ample legroom for even me (at 188cm) in the second row and adequate headroom back there, too.

I like the large door pockets, the wireless phone charger, and there are two USB ports for the back seats and another two up front.

The second row also has directional air vents and dark-tinted windows. I liked the panoramic sunroof's retractable shade, too. 

SUVS like the MG ZS offer easier access than sedans and hatches thanks to the elevated ride height which means people of my height don’t need to crawl in and out on their knees.

Boot capacity is decent at 359 litres, but not enormous.  

The MG ZS EV Long Range lists for $55,990 which is about $11,000 more than the standard range ZS in the Essence grade.

The features on this Long Range are almost identical to the Essence, too.

Coming standard are LED headlights and running lights, then there are those 17-inch alloy wheels (which have aerodynamic covers on them), proximity unlocking, roof rails, the rear spoiler and a panoramic sunroof with a retractable cover.

Inside, the seats are a combination of polyurethane and PVC, plus there’s a 10.1-inch media display with sat nav, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.

You can see the battery status from the screen as well along with the energy efficiency. 

Climate, phone and media are all accessed through the screen, but fortunately there are physical buttons for volume, temperature and fan speed.

There’s single-zone climate control and tinted rear windows.

A 360-degree camera view is also standard, but the quality of the picture is pretty murky.

How does that cost compare to rivals? Well, you could buy an MG4 electric vehicle for about the same price with 530km of range, but it’s not an SUV. 

You can even get a Tesla Model 3 for about $61K, but again, that’s not an SUV. The Tesla Model Y is an SUV and lists for $69,300 and has 455km of range.

The closest competitor would be the BYD Atto 3 Extended Range which can travel 420km and lists for $51,011.

There are more affordable EVs coming from brands like BYD and GWM, too, and they’re all competing for your money. 

Compared to the MG ZS EV Essence the Long Range has exactly the same features, apart from the tinted rear windows, but you’re paying $11,000 more. What you’re paying for is a bigger battery which will allow you to drive 120km further.

The MG4 Long Range offers more distance and represents better value, but it’s not an SUV and therefore not as practical as the ZS EV.  

For now, the R-Line sits at the top of the Tayron range and is the most powerful version available. It’s powered by a 2.0-litre, four-cylinder, turbo-petrol engine producing 195kW of power and 400Nm of torque, paired with a seven-speed auto transmission and all-wheel drive.

In isolation, and particularly against its key petrol-powered rivals, those figures stack up well. For everyday family duties, the combination feels suitably polished.

With a 2500kg braked trailer towing capacity, it's competitive for this segment and will be sufficient for many families towing medium-sized toys. That said, buyers coming from, or expecting, a Touareg replacement may notice the difference. The Tayron doesn’t match the larger SUV’s 3.5-tonne towing capability. And the larger capacity will be missed.

The MG ZS EV has one electric motor driving the front wheels and it makes 115kW of power and 280Nm or torque.

That’s the same power as the petrol MG ZS, but more torque, so it accelerates faster. We’re talking 0-100km/h in 8.5 seconds. 

Sure, that’s not Tesla quick, but being an electric car the acceleration is instantaneous with none of the lag petrol cars have due to turbos or changing gears.

How much can the ZS EV tow? Not much. The braked towing capacity of the ZS EV Long Range is 500kg. But think of it like this: a box trailer can weigh about 250kg and a fully grown Sumatran tiger can also weigh up to 250kg.

So an ZS EV Long range can tow a box trailer carrying a fully grown tiger. That sounds impressive.

For more on what the ZS EV Long Range is like to drive, keep reading.

Some of the Tayron’s key rivals lean on mild-hybrid assistance to improve fuel efficiency, and on paper they offer an advantage in this area. By comparison, the Tayron 195TSI R-Line sticks with a conventional petrol powertrain, so its efficiency figures are largely in line with what you’d expect given its size, weight and performance.

Volkswagen claims a combined (urban/extra-urban) fuel cycle figure of 8.6L/100km for this grade. With a 58-litre fuel tank, that translates to a theoretical driving range of up to 698km. In real-world use, after a mix of longer highway driving and some urban running, I recorded an average of 9.3L/100km, which feels reasonable rather than surprising.

Efficiency is an important consideration for families, particularly in this segment and it will be interesting to see how the upcoming hybrid powertrain performs once it arrives. For now, the R-Line’s fuel consumption feels broadly consistent with its output, even if it doesn’t lead the class.

The ZS EV Long Range has a larger battery than the standard range ZS EV and this gives it the ability to travel further on a full charge. 

The regular version is fitted with a 51.1kWh battery and the Long Range has a 72.6kWh battery which is pretty big - and that gives this an official range of 440km. 

The standard range ZS EV has a range of 320km. So the Long Range will get you 120km further which could make all the difference in whether you make it to your destination or not.

So, is 440km a lot compared to other electric cars? Well, it’s more range than the Nissan Leaf (385km) or Mini Electric (233km), but not as much as the Kia Niro (460km) and 50km less than the entry-grade Tesla Model 3 (491km).

Put it this way, the 320km offered by the standard ZS EV falls short of what I think is enough. But anything with more than 400km is truly useful and I find anything less than this can bring on range anxiety pretty quickly.

The ZS EV Long Range is fully electric and that means you’ll have to plug it in to charge it. 

You can charge up using a household power point, but it’ll take more than 24 hours to get to 100 per cent. So, a much better idea is to use a fast public charger.

A 50kW charger will take the battery from empty to 80 percent in 63 minutes using a CCS Type 2 port/plug.

As for energy efficiency, MG says that after a combination of open and urban roads the ZS EV Long Range will use 17.7kWh/100km.

I drove our ZS EV Long Range every day and used it for school drop offs, city commutes and some motorway running. And while most of the 156km I travelled was urban-based the trip computer was reporting an average of 20.0kWh/100km.

The R-Line’s engine is the standout in the Tayron range. It delivers solid, usable power with enough in reserve to make overtaking straightforward, particularly at highway speeds. While it doesn’t have the same effortless surge as the larger Touareg, it performs where it matters for everyday driving.

There is an occasional shudder through the front suspension and steering when entering a roundabout or turning off on a hill. It’s brief when it occurs, but noticeable and not something you expect to feel regularly in this class.

Suspension tuning is on the firmer side, though overall ride comfort remains acceptable. The Tayron provides decent road feedback without feeling unsettled or harsh. At higher speeds the cabin can sound slightly tinny, but around town it remains quiet and composed.

Steering response is direct without being heavy. The Tayron corners confidently for a vehicle of this size, but there is some body roll, which is most apparent for passengers in the back rows.

Forward and side visibility are strong, helped by a high seating position and unobtrusive pillars. Rearward visibility becomes more limited when the third row is in use, and a digital rear-view mirror would be a worthwhile addition.

With a 12.1m turning circle, the Tayron can feel large in tighter car parks, though it’s otherwise easy enough to park. The 'Park Assist' function and 360-degree camera system helps, even if image clarity falls short of what you’d expect from a flagship grade.

At first, the driver’s seat felt overly high and the lack of reach adjustment in the steering wheel made finding a good driving position harder.

But, the ZS EV Long Range is comfortable and easy to drive, while its size and ‘electric zippiness’ makes this little SUV perfect for narrow city streets and tight car spaces. 

Some EVs have break-neck acceleration and minimalist cabin controls which can feel weird, but the ZS EV Long Range’s cabin looks just like a regular combustion engine car’s and the motor has the same power as a petrol ZS’s engine.

That said, the instant acceleration of their ZS EV Long Range is fun and great for moving quickly out of car space, merging and overtaking when needed.

As with all EVs, passengers who are prone to motion sickness might find the acceleration and heavy deceleration a bit much. My family didn’t complain but the photographer who filmed the video above found it a bit much while looking down at his screen.

The ZS EV Long Range has yet to be given an ANCAP rating, but it is equipped with AEB, rear cross-traffic alert, lane keeping assistance and blind-spot warning. There are front and rear parking sensors and six airbags.

For child seats there are two ISOFIX points and three top tether anchor mounts across the second row.

The Tayron is covered by Volkswagen's five-year/unlimited km warranty which is a shorter term than a lot of its rivals.

You can pre-purchase a three- or five-year servicing plan at $2207 or $4098, respectively, which isn’t as affordable as some rivals but does include roadside assistance. However, at the time of writing, the five-year price was set at $3550.

Servicing intervals are well spaced at every 12 months or 15,000km, whichever occurs first, with servicing available at any of VW's 118 official service centres nationwide.

The Tayron only accepts a minimum 95 RON unleaded petrol, which might sting a little with regular fill-ups.

The ZS EV Long Range is covered by MG’s seven-year/unlimited kilometre warranty. The battery is covered by a seven-year unlimited kilometre warranty, too. 

Servicing is recommended by MG at 40,000km/24 month intervals.

According to MG the first service costs $295, then the next is $810, then $295 for the third, $810 for the next and so on. That’s about $233 a year over six years which is excellent value.