Lotus Eletre vs Polestar 5

What's the difference?

So, how does this radically different Lotus measure up to the brand’s reputation and stack up against its would-be competitors in the final summation? It doesn’t reset the benchmark in any area or stand out head and shoulders above its competition, but crucially for Lotus (and its overlords at Geely) it doesn’t feel behind its rivals. 

For the Lotus diehards this is an unrecognisable addition to the brand’s legacy of great sports cars. But this new version of the brand is looking to reach fresh customers and the Eletre will likely grab their eye with its dramatic looks.

It’s a highly competitive luxury, performance SUV that should have anyone considering a similar sized Bentley, BMW, Mercedes, or even the Lamborghini taking it for a test drive. It has both elements - luxury and performance - that will appeal to those looking for something special.

The Polestar 5 is utterly gorgeous. It's essentially a concept car come to life.

It perfectly balances sportiness and comfort, like a GT should, though the screen-heavy minimalism might not be everyone’s cup of tea.

If you’re after something faster and with more physical switchgear, there’s the Porsche Taycan, but it’s considerably more expensive.

Note: CarsGuide attended this event as a guest of the manufacturer with travel, accommodation and meals provided.

The design of an electric SUV is, by its very existence, interesting as it’s something a Lotus has never been before. This is the brand’s new flagship SUV, designed to take on the likes of everything from the Bentley Bentayga to the BMW iX and even the Lamborghini Urus, so it needs to make a statement.

The design is influenced by the Evija electric hypercar, which Lotus built to kick-start its Geely era, but goes a step further with its angular design. It certainly looks more closely related to the Lamborghini SUV than any Lotus you’ve seen before.

It’s different, it looks special and will likely turn heads, but to be blunt, if you’re a Lotus lover who has an affection for the Elise, Exige and the like then this really isn’t for you.

This is a modern evolution for Lotus, created to appeal to new customers with its edgy exterior design, utterly modern interior look and premium finish.

One disappointment is the way the plethora of safety sensors and cameras can disturb the lines of the car, making it look like an unfinished prototype from some angles.

There’s no way around it. The exterior of this car is exquisite. It truly is a concept car that has come to life.

The front end is particularly fascinating as the split LED headlight set-up emphasises just how low-slung and wide this grand-tourer is.

Something surprising about the Polestar 5 is while it’s less than 1.5-metres tall, it’s more than five metres long, which makes it longer than a Toyota LandCruiser, for example.

While the tail-light set-up is stunning and angular, the rear section of the Polestar 5 is its most awkward.

Like the Polestar 4 Coupe, this car doesn’t have a rear window and that means there is a big slab of body coloured panel instead. It makes the overall silhouette rather back-heavy, especially when finished in lighter colours.

Inside, the design is virtually identical to a series of other existing Polestar models. It’s intentionally minimal with a major focus put on the large central touchscreen.

While the interior looks and feels premium, like other Polestars, it doesn’t make this flagship offering feel as special.

It doesn’t help that there are large sections of glossy piano black on the steering wheel, centre console and rear-seat armrest section. These are all areas that get used a lot, meaning fingerprints and grime will show quickly.

The modern and premium design carries over into the cabin, with the model we were testing finished in grey leather and Alcantra with gold highlights. Which, along with the fact there’s leather and carpet inside, makes this feel more polished and luxurious than any previous Lotus.

But once you look beyond that you notice it’s not quite as practical as such a large SUV could be. Yes, there are a couple of cupholders in the centre console, but one is quite small and not practical for most cups/bottles.

There’s a small shelf for the wireless smartphone charging pad and the centre console box, but aside from that, there’s no other significant storage space in the front.

On the plus side the seats are comfortable and supportive, which is also true of those in the rear. The space in the rear is excellent, with plenty of head and knee room that will allow four adults to travel in comfort (adding a fifth to the middle seat would be a squeeze).

Those in the back also get access to the small screen that allows them to adjust not only the climate control but also the front seats. The rear seats also recline and there’s a pair of cupholders and USB-C ports.

The Lotus Eletre has a generous 688-litre boot, which is wide and deep. However, it comes at the expense of a spare tyre, with only a puncture repair kit provided.

The Polestar 5’s front seats are supremely comfortable and almost limitlessly adjustable, meaning they’re perfect for long-distance driving. Even if you do get a sore back, there’s a great massage function.

While the steering wheel is a lovely unit to hold and twirl, the buttons on it just aren’t intuitive, unless you’re shown what they do. They are touch-sensitive pads that are blank and don’t have any iconography on them.

Instead, the button's purpose is shown on the digital instrument cluster when you hover on them. There’s a considerable amount that can be adjusted from the steering wheel, but failing this you’re forced to use the touchscreen as physical switchgear is few and far between.

Sure the prominent, portrait-oriented 14.5-inch touchscreen multimedia system runs Google Built-in and has Google Gemini, but clicking through menus, especially while driving, for key functions isn’t intuitive. I’d love more physical buttons.

In terms of storage up front, there isn’t as much as you’d expect. There are two cupholders, a small centre console slot with a wireless charger, as well as a tiny centre armrest storage slot. There’s no glovebox.

As standard the Polestar 5 comes with a 4+1 seating configuration, meaning that while there is a small centre rear seat, the emphasis is put on the two outer seats. They’re almost like separate bucket seats and offer electric adjustment.

At a leggy 182cm tall, there’s adequate legroom for a car that’s more than five metres long. Headroom isn’t bad either, especially given there’s a panoramic glass sunroof and the fact the car is only 1.5-metres tall.

Many of the second-row controls are on the fold-down centre armrest. They’re touch-sensitive and rather finicky to operate.

Despite this car’s length, there’s only 365 litres of boot space, which is tiny for a car of this size. Thankfully there’s a sizeable underfloor section in lieu of a spare wheel.

At the front there’s a 62-litre storage compartment that’s big enough for charging cables among other odds and ends.

For the first year of production, two Launch Edition versions of the Polestar 5 are being offered. Pricing is as follows:

• Polestar 5 Dual motor Launch Edition: $171,000
• Polestar 5 Performance Launch Edition: $193,100

All prices are before on-road costs

While it’s safe to say the Polestar 5 isn’t an affordable offering, it’s still considerably less than a Porsche Taycan, for example. For a similar 0-100km/h sprint time as the Performance, you’ll need to dish out at least $65,000 more.

As a flagship offering, it’s expected that all versions of the Polestar 5 come fully loaded. The following is standard across the line-up:

• 4+1 seating configuration
• Matrix LED headlights
• Brembo brakes
• Panoramic glass sunroof
• 9.0-inch digital instrument cluster
• 14.5-inch touchscreen multimedia system
• Google Built-in and Google Gemini
• Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
• Head-up display
• 10-speaker sound system
• Digital rear-view mirror
• 'MicroTech' upholstery made from recycled materials
• 12-way power-adjustable front seats
• Heated front seats
• Heated rear seats
• Heated steering wheel

While this is already a fair bit, the additional standard features the Performance receives are alluring. They include:

• Gold exterior and interior highlights
• 21-inch forged alloy wheels
• MagneRide adaptive dampers
• 21-speaker Bowers & Wilkins sound system
• Microsuede headliner

Even though this is a lot of standard equipment, if you want Nappa leather, you’ll need to fork out an additional $12,000. Like many luxury cars, there are a series of other cosmetic optional extras which further inflate the price.

As mentioned earlier, there are three Eletre models, with the base model and S sharing the same powertrain, while the R gets a unique set-up.

The Eletre and Eletre S punch out a very healthy 450kW/710Nm from the dual motors that provide all-wheel drive traction. Despite being a full-size SUV, the two 450kW models are able to run 0-100km/h in only 4.5 seconds.

The Eletre R gets more powerful motors that make a staggering 675kW/985Nm, and crucially also get a two-speed transmission, which helps with acceleration. Lotus claims it has enough performance for the Eletre R to launch from 0-100km/h in just 2.9 seconds, a hugely impressive time for such a big and luxurious vehicle.

All Launch Edition versions of the Polestar 5 come with a dual-motor all-wheel-drive set-up.

The entry-level Dual motor has total system outputs of 550kW and 812Nm, which aren’t small numbers. It’s enough to send this car from 0-100km/h in 3.9 seconds.

However, stepping up to the Performance boosts the total system outputs to an outlandish 650kW and 1015Nm. The 0-100km/h sprint is claimed to take just 3.2 seconds.

If you’re after raw speed though, the Porsche Taycan is quicker again, but it’s considerably pricier.

Despite the different powertrains, all three Eletre models have the same 111kWh battery but the driving range varies across each one. 

The entry-grade model has a claimed WLTP range of between 535-600km, the Eletre S drops to 490-535km and the Eletre R can travel between 410-450km on a single charge.

On test we found those claims to be optimistic, certainly on the higher end, and especially if you head out of the urban environment and don’t maximise the regenerative braking to keep the battery topping up.

Every Polestar 5 Launch Edition comes with a sizeable 112kWh lithium-ion battery pack.

Thanks to this, the Dual motor is claimed to offer up to 670km of WLTP range, whereas the Performance offers up to 565km. Real-world range will likely be much less, especially if you lean into this car's performance potential.

An 800V electrical architecture allows the Polestar 5 to DC fast charge at rates up to 350kW. A 10-80 per cent charge is claimed to take 22 minutes.

AC charging, however, is capped at 11kW, which is surprisingly low given more an more cars are capable of 22kW. A 0-100 per cent charge is claimed to take 11 hours.

The challenge for Lotus, and its competitors, is to make its cars stand out from the pack despite the increasing similarities in performance brought on by electric powertrains.

Whereas in the past we could have assessed the difference between a Lotus-built V8 compared to a BMW manufactured V8 or even a Mercedes-Benz V12, these days all the electric models produce the same quiet, effortless punch.

So, it creates a generic driving experience in some regards, when what you’re hoping for at this end of the market is something special and different. And it’s important to note I don’t use the term ‘generic’ in a negative sense, but simply the Eletre has similar driving characteristics to the electric models from BMW, Mercedes-AMG and others.

Where it does give a hint to Lotus’ heritage is in its handling, where the combination of the air suspension with adaptive dampers, torque vectoring (by braking) and the British brand’s decades of experience combine to create a surprisingly direct and responsive SUV.

You won’t mistake it for an Emira, Exige or Elise, but the Eletre does have dynamic ability a cut above your average luxury SUV.

During the Australian media launch of the Polestar 5 we only got to experience the flagship Performance grade. We’ll have to wait for another time to sample the entry-level Dual motor.

In terms of electric-motor power, there’s plenty of it. In fact, there’s probably too much. I only went full throttle once while driving and it was enough to terrify my passenger.

The amount of power on offer is the kind you’d tap into every now and then when you have new passengers onboard.

Unlike many EVs, the acceleration in the Polestar 5 Performance is linear and builds, rather than snapping your neck backwards.

There are three regenerative braking modes to select from, including two that are versions of one-pedal driving. My preference is the standard mode as it feels more natural to use both the accelerator and brake pedals in a GT.

The suspension set-up in the Performance trim is unique as there’s MagneRide adaptive dampers. The Dual motor, on the other hand, has a passive damper set-up.

There are a series of modes to select from and in practice the adaptive dampers help keep this 2.5-tonne beast in check. It’s surprising how comfortable this car can feel with the large 21-inch alloy wheels.

Adding to this, the steering wheel, even its firmest setting, is surprisingly easy to twirl. As a result, this makes the Polestar 5 a great balance of sportiness and comfort, just as a GT should.

While many of this car’s driving attributes defy its weight and heft, its turning circle does not. There’s no rear-axle steering and the fact it’s more than five metres long doesn't do it any favours. Prepare for many three-point turns.

In terms of noise, vibration and harshness (NVH), the Polestar 5 is naturally a quiet car given it’s an EV. However, with the Bowers & Wilkins sound system, there’s noise cancelling which makes the car even quieter, especially on the move.

The Polestar 5 hasn’t been crash tested by ANCAP or EuroNCAP yet and is therefore unrated.

However, a full suite of safety kit comes as standard across the line-up. This includes the following:

• Eight airbags
• Autonomous emergency braking (AEB)
• Blind-spot monitoring
• Rear cross-traffic alert
• Lane-keep assist
• Lane change assist
• Adaptive cruise control
• Driver attention monitoring
• Intelligent speed limit assist
• Front, side and rear parking sensors
• Surround-view camera

While it’s great to have all the above safety features, some of them are annoying in practice. The lane-keep assist, for example, struggles on narrower roads with faded lane markings and can tug on the wheel.

Then there’s the intelligent speed limit assist which chimes when you go above the posted speed limit. This is usually fine, but it can read the signs incorrectly and you need to turn this off using the touchscreen every single time you drive.

As for its ownership credentials, Lotus doesn’t offer capped price servicing, so you’ll need to discuss the on-going maintenance costs for your Eletre.

On the plus side, the new model is covered by a five-year/150,000km warranty for the car, with an eight-year/200,000km warranty for the battery.

The Polestar 5 is covered by a five-year, unlimited-kilometre warranty, whereas the high-voltage battery is covered for eight years or 160,00km. This is fairly standard for premium brands.

Every Polestar 5 comes with five years of roadside assistance and logbook servicing is required every 24 months or 30,000km.

At this stage Polestar hasn’t announced service pricing for the Polestar 5.