BMW I4 vs Mercedes-Benz CLA35

What's the difference?

The BMW i4 balances a solid, old-school feel with the beauty and stunning looks of high-end technology. It feels like the end of an era for the German brand before it leaps into the screen-heavy age of software-defined vehicles.

While BMW hasn’t publicly announced an end-date for i4 production just yet, the new i3 is bound to overshadow it once it arrives. It offers more than double the claimed range and will likely address a number of this car’s flaws.

In the meantime however, the i4 is definitely worth considering if you value driving dynamics and a quality feel in a car that you can drive daily.

Is the Mercedes-AMG CLA 35 the perfect choice in the sleek sedan’s line-up?

Well, if you are after outright performance, then the answer still clearly lies with the CLA 45. But for those that just want a little more pep compared to the standard CLA range, the 35 is undoubtedly the one to get.

It’s not without its flaws, though, commanding a $15,000 price premium over the CLA 250 and a tougher-than-we’d-like ride, but if you value a more engaging drive and a brisk 0-100km/h time, the CLA 35 should definitely be on your shopping list.

The BMW i4 is firmly at the end of its lifecycle, however its exterior design is ageing like fine wine. This is apt given our tester was finished in delicious-looking 'Fire Red' metallic paint.

The overall proportions of this car are gorgeous, especially towards the rear where the roofline is drawn out, accentuating the liftback look.

This latest update only brought minor tweaks to the design, including refreshed headlight and tail-light signatures. As mentioned above, the M Sport package is now also standard which does give this car a subtly sporty look.

Inside the design marries together the best of the old and new worlds. A major highlight is the curved display housing not only the 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster, but also a 14.9-inch touchscreen multimedia display. It’s a stunning setup that looks ultra modern.

On the flipside however, there is still a lot of physical switchgear on the centre console, including a rotary iDrive controller that allows you to control the content on the screen. It’s a great setup if you like to avoid getting fingerprints on the touchscreen.

While there are a few applications of glossy piano black around the cabin, it’s balanced nicely with other metallic and matt finishes. You’re able to choose from a few different trim inlays, including aluminium and open-pore wood, for no extra cost.

Lastly, the new M Sport steering wheel looks great in this car and adds a lovely sporty touch to the interior.

From the front, the CLA 35 exterior oozes style and luxury.

Up front, the sleek and slender headlights emphasise the width of the fascia, while the large Mercedes logo sits proudly front and centre of the CLA’s nose.

There are subtle hints to the CLA 35’s sportiness too, with a slightly bulging bonnet and chiselled lower chin.

The grille is also unique on the 35, with a dual-horizontal slat design instead of the non-AMG CLA’s diamond pattern or the CLA 45’s Panamericana grille.

To my eye, the front of the CLA 35 is actually a bit too tame in styling for an AMG model. I prefer the in-your-face aggression of the CLA 45’s widened track and front grille, while the CLA 35 opts for more subtle styling cues. To each their own, though.

The silver paintwork of our test car probably doesn’t help, and if it was my choice I'd pick 'Sun Yellow' or 'Denim Blue' to stand out a bit more from the sea of black, grey and white German cars out there.

Move to the rear of the car though, and a large rear diffuser, big dual-exhaust outlets and a bootlid spoiler are much more befitting an AMG model.

Step inside the CLA and you will see it adopts the same dashboard design as all new-generation Mercedes vehicles built on the MFA2 platform, with the 'MBUX' dual-screen layout, large air-vents and central touchpad.

Our car was specced out with red-leather interior, which is a bit too loud for my tastes, but a two-tone black leather/titanium grey combo can also be had at no extra cost.

Sitting inside the CLA 35, you can tell it’s a modern car thanks to the clean layout of all the controls, while the screen-heavy dashboard definitely makes it feel tech-focused.

Hopping into the i4, it’s clear you’re getting into a low-slung vehicle. If you’ve got poor mobility, it may be worth looking elsewhere.

Once you’re in though, the cockpit is a lovely space to spend time. The driver’s seat is beautifully comfortable and offers plenty of adjustment, including extendable thigh support.

Ahead of the driver the steering wheel is rather thick in classic BMW fashion. I appreciate the physical buttons and scroll wheels as they’re easy to understand and use on the fly.

The curved display not only looks stunning, but is functional and easy to use. The digital instrument cluster has a number of layouts you can choose from and it can be paired with the head-up display, which is great to refer to at a glance.

Moving across, there is a lot going on with the central multimedia system. It can feel overwhelming with the amount of content and information to begin with, but once you start poking around, things are logically sorted.

Thankfully there are also a series of shortcut buttons always at the bottom of the screen to take you to key menus.

Adding to this, there is the flexibility of having the iDrive controller. Reaching the far side of the screen from the driver’s seat can be a bit of a stretch and being able to use the rotary dial on the move is much easier.

There is wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto as standard. It takes up the full touchscreen display, which looks great.

Looking around the cabin, storage space is fine but not amazing. There are two cupholders plus a wireless charger tucked behind them on the centre console, plus a shallow centre storage area under the central armrest.

Hopping into the second row, it’s clear the focus for this car is on the occupants up front. The door aperture is rather narrow, making it tricky to get in and out gracefully.

In the second row space is nothing more than adequate. At a leggy 182cm tall, my legs almost touch the seat in front when it’s set to my driving position and my head almost brushes the roofliner. I’d struggle to spend a lot of time back here.

This is compounded by the massive hump in the centre that’s a carryover from the combustion platform this car is based on.

Second-row amenities include climate control with air vents mounted on the back of the centre console, two USB-C ports, as well as a fold-down armrest with cupholders.

At the back there is a large liftback that opens and closes electronically. With the rear seats upright there is 470L of boot space, which expands to 1290L when folded.

While this is not massive in terms of outright capacity over a similarly sized sedan, the envelope is much more open and usable.

There’s also a section under the boot floor that’s generously sized for power cables, among other odds and ends.

Measuring 4695mm long, 1834mm wide, 1399mm tall and with a 2729mm wheelbase, the CLA 35 is definitely a sizeable sedan in the metal.

This actually makes the CLA 35 slightly longer and wider than a non-AMG C-Class sedan that measures 4686 and 1810mm respectively, but don’t expect the same level of practical interior space.

With a heavily sloped roofline, rear-seat comfort takes a hit. My 183cm (6.0ft) frame could not sit upright behind my driving position without tilting my head, while legroom was also slightly lacking.

With such large C-pillars and a small rear window, the second-row can actually feel a little claustrophobic for full-sized adults, but will seat children quite comfortably.

Second-row amenities include air-vents, two USB-C ports, back-of-seat storage nets, bottle holders in the doors, and two cupholders in the fold-down arm rest.

Just like at a music concert though, the best seats in the CLA 35 are up front, with plenty of room for heads, shoulders and legs.

The cabin is also much more light-filled up front, making for a more pleasant experience.

The front seats are electronically adjustable, as is the steering column, but the headrests are fixed.

Storage options include sizeable door bins, a centre console cubby, glove box, two cupholders and a wireless smartphone charger.

Boot space is 460 litres, but can expand with the rear split-fold 40/20/40 rear seats stowed.

Though the boot looks small and shallow on the outside, the aperture is actually quite large, and can easily accommodate a large suitcase with plenty of room to spare.

Priced at $85,500 before on-road costs, the CLA 35 sits $15,300 upstream of the CLA 250 but is $25,700 cheaper than the $111,200 CLA 45.

Standard equipment includes leather interior, dual-zone climate control, electronically adjustable front seats with heating and memory function, keyless entry and push-button start, 64-colour ambient lighting, and a wireless smartphone charger.

AMG specific appointments include 19-inch wheels, a flat-bottomed steering wheel, sports exhaust, high-performance brakes with silver-painted calipers, blacked-out exterior highlights, sports suspension, a racy bodykit and speed-sensitive steering.

Instrumentation is displayed on a 10.25-inch screen, which can be customised and features AMG readouts.

The multimedia system, which includes satellite navigation, digital radio and Apple CarPlay/Android Auto connectivity, is also outputted to a 10.25-inch screen, with inputs including touch, voice commands, centre touch pad or steering wheel controls.

Our test car also came with a ‘Mojave Silver Metallic’ paint finish and 'Vision Package', adding $1190 and $990 to the bottom line each.

The Vision Package adds LED headlights with adaptive high beams, a panoramic glass sunroof and surround-view monitor.

Straddling the lines between a small- and mid-size sedan, the CLA 35 doesn’t really have any direct competitors, which is reflected in its pricing that slots it between the Audi S3 and S4 sedans.

Though the CLA 35 features a long list of equipment, it is still a sizeable chunk of coin, costing more than the C300 sedan and Volvo S60 T8 PHEV, the latter boasting higher engine outputs.

The i4 eDrive35 continues to be powered by a single, rear-mounted electric motor that produces an unchanged 210kW and 400Nm.

This is nothing revolutionary in terms of the powertrain, though it’s nice it retains a rear-wheel drive-layout like the discontinued 4 Series Gran Coupe this car is based on.

BMW claims the i4 eDrive35 can do the 0-100km/h sprint in 6.0 seconds and the top speed is 190km/h.

Powered by a 2.0-litre, turbo-petrol four-cylinder engine, the CLA 35 punches out 225kW/400Nm.

Drive is sent through a seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmissions to the road via Mercedes’ '4Matic' all-wheel-drive system, enabling a 0-100km/h sprint in the 1603kg sedan in just 4.7 seconds. Top speed is electronically limited to 250km/h.

Though I didn’t get a chance to test the latter, the former certainly feels accurate when taking off from a freeway on ramp, however, there is some hesitation from the turbo in getting on boost.

Peak power comes in at 5800rpm, while maximum torque is available from 3000-4000rpm.

The electric motor is fed by a 70kWh lithium-ion battery pack that allows for up to 448km of claimed range, according to ADR 81/02 testing.

This is 18km more than the pre-update car thanks to silicon carbide semiconductor components which are claimed to reduce energy consumption and increase range.

However, the Tesla Model 3 and Polestar 2 both still offer more range for less money.

BMW claims the i4 eDrive35 consumes an average of 16.3kWh/100km, according to ADR 81/02 testing. Over my 200km of urban testing I saw an average of 17.5kWh/100km, which isn’t fantastic as EVs are predominantly more efficient in the city.

Using my as-tested consumption, this means you have a theoretical range of 379km. That’s not great, though this range issue will be addressed with the forthcoming i3 electric sedan.

AC charging is available at rates up to 11kW, whereas DC fast-charging is offered at rates up to 180kW, allowing for a 10 to 80 per cent charge in 32 minutes.

Officially, the CLA 35 sips 7.5 litres per 100km on the combined cycle, but we managed a 9.9L/100km figure in our week with the car.

The majority of our driving was done in inner-city environments, with the two trips down the freeway to seek out twisty country rounds.

Minimum fuel grade in the CLA 35 is 98 RON.

BMW has positioned itself as creating vehicles that are the ‘ultimate driving machine’ for decades now and this i4 is no exception.

While it’s not an outright performance powerhouse, it doesn’t need to be in order to feel engaging to drive.

The rear-mounted electric motor produces a decent 210kW/400Nm and it’s enough to get moving in frenetic urban traffic with ease. You’ll rarely want any more out on the open road either as rolling acceleration is decent.

The regenerative braking system in this car feels natural and transitions to the friction brakes with no awkward lurching or inconsistencies.

I like how you can drive this car like a regular combustion car using both the accelerator and brake pedals, or with an extra flick of the gear selector you can activate one-pedal driving. During my loan I played around with both and didn’t have a favourite as both feel well tuned and easy to adapt to.

The steering is direct and on the lighter side, making the car feel agile and nimble on the move. However, in low-speed situations you realise the turning circle isn’t fantastic…

I appreciate that BMW opted for standard 18-inch alloy wheels that are paired with tyres that have chubby sidewalls as this keeps the ride from being harsh and jittery, especially over firmer bumps.

Don’t worry if 18 inches aren’t enough though, BMW offers alloy wheel options that go all the way up to 22 inches.

This is the type of car that suits a long-distance road trip as it’s such an easy and fun car to cruise around in. That's why it’s so unfortunate that the range limits how you can travel before recharges.

In terms of noise, vibration and harshness (NVH) in the cabin, the i4 is naturally quiet given it’s an EV. However, it feels like there’s extra insulation because even at high speeds tyre and wind noise are virtually nonexistent, creating a hushed and tranquil interior ambience.

The CLA 35 might not offer the outright thrills or breadth of capability of the CLA 45, but don’t think the cut-price AMG offers up a cut-rate driving experience.

From the driver’s seat, one of the cool things about the CLA 35 is that it doesn’t actually look any different from its more expensive sibling.

The drive-mode selector that is now embedded on the steering wheel is fantastic, a feature first seen on the Mercedes-AMG GT 4-door, and makes changing the driving dynamics on the fly an absolute breeze.

In fact, we think all cars where you can select drive modes should have a selector on the steering wheel like this, which lets you quickly and easily dial it up or down while keeping your hands on the wheel.

'Comfort', 'Sport', 'Sport+' and 'Individual' modes are available, while the transmission can also be put into manual mode independently for those that prefer to use the flappy paddles.

Suspension settings can also be tweaked regardless of which drive mode you are in, and it’s this level of customisability that we appreciate.

You want loud exhaust pops and the engine in full attack with manual shifting and the softest suspension? Sure, that’s doable here in the CLA 35. And toning it down to its most comfortable settings is just a flick of the wrist away.

The steering feels a little numb on centre and at slower speeds, though feedback picks right up with speed and is communicative enough when the road starts to get twisty.

Fitted with wide and sticky Michelin rubber, as well as the aforementioned all-wheel drive system, the CLA 35 is certainly not lacking in grip.

The suspension does an okay job of absorbing bumps, but uneven surfaces, like Melbourne’s tram tracks, can send uncomfortable jolts into the cabin if travelling quickly.

In fact, we think the ride comfort of the CLA 35 is probably its weakest aspect, offering not enough variability in its Comfort and Sport settings, and instead settling somewhere in between, regardless of drive mode.

The CLA 35 is ultimately still a fun and engaging sports sedan, though there are some sacrifices made to get it there.

The CLA 35 has not been tested by ANCAP or Euro NCAP, but the standard CLA range was awarded a five-star rating in September 2019.

Standard safety equipment in the CLA 35 includes autonomous emergency braking, automatic high beams, nine airbags, drive attention alert, blind-spot monitoring with exit warning, lane-keep assist, traffic sign recognition and tyre pressure monitoring.

The standard CLA also comes with these features, and was awarded 96 and 92 per cent respectively in ANCAP adult occupant and child occupant protection tests.

For the vulnerable road user and safety assist examinations, the standard CLA scored 91 and 76 per cent respectively.

ANCAP says the AEB system works from seven-200km/h.

Of note, adaptive cruise control is not standard in the CLA 35 like it is in the CLA 45. Instead, buyers will have to tick the 'Driving Assistance Package' box for the feature, which also comes bundled with cross-traffic alert and lane change assist.

Like all electric BMWs, the i4 is covered by a five-year, unlimited-kilometre warranty, whereas the high-voltage battery is covered for eight years or 160,000km.

A five-year warranty has been commonplace within the premium space for a few years now, whereas many mainstream brands have since moved up to seven years of coverage, or longer in some cases. It’s far from competitive.

Owners also receive three years of complimentary roadside assistance.

BMW offers a six-year pre-paid service package priced at $2420, which averages out to just over $400 per year.

As with all new Mercedes-Benz models, the CLA 35 comes with a five-year/unlimited kilometre warranty, which is one of the best assurance periods offered by a premium carmaker.

It also comes with five years of roadside assist.

Scheduled service intervals are every 25,000km or 12 months, whichever comes first.

A three-year service plan is available for $2150 for new CLA 35 buyers, saving $500 when priced individually.

Four- and five-year plans are also available, and are priced at $4200 and $4950 respectively.