BMW 2 Series vs Subaru Liberty

What's the difference?

It may be expensive for a small coupe. And EVs have reframed performance standards to the detriment of most internal combustion engine sports cars like this – at least for acceleration times. But the M240i xDrive Coupe is far more than just about numbers, imbuing the soul and spirit of what makes this brand’s vehicles so enjoyable and memorable to drive.

A unique and most-welcome survivor today, the MY25 makeover takes all that, and improves the interior, to be at the heart of what BMW has traditionally done best (styling aside). We found parting with it at the end of our term very difficult.

The Liberty has a lot going for it - a great reputation for reliability, it isn't terribly priced (although servicing is a little steep) and has that signature all-wheel drive. While I've complained about the ride and handling, apart from STi and RS-badged versions, that has never been the Liberty's strong suit.

While it might be a shrinking part of the market - and Subaru is a founding architect of the modern SUV cult - Subaru and its competitors still care. The Liberty, like Forester and Outback, remains a stand-out in the sector with a boxer 2.5 and all-wheel drive. Sometimes that kind of individuality is enough.

BMW has iconic form when it comes to coupe, err, form.

Consider the timeless E9 Coupe of 1968, its elegant E24 6 Series successor of 1976 and the chiselled E31 8 Series of 1990.

Even the sinewy E82 1 Series Coupe of 2007 still resonates.

But, despite boasting long-nose/short-tail proportions, today’s G42 looks awkward from some angles, like a Lego version of the preceding F22 of 2014, complete with cartoonishly aggressive detailing that don’t sit happily on the car.

Not Munich’s finest moment. Still, as one of the last surviving small coupes, we’re still very glad it exists. And, in a rare case of more being more, this M240i’s body kit disguises some of the heavy-handedness.

So, what’s new here? Barely earning the facelift tag outside, the MY25 2 Series Coupe gains extra colours, restyled alloys and revised exterior trim, with more body paint in the lower parts and rear apron, as well as high-gloss black for the M240i’s mirror caps.

Inside, the modifications are more profound, updating to BMW’s 'Operating System 8.5', offering improved functionality and all housed within a fetching, single-piece rectangular display screen that also takes in the instrumentation.

Along with a flat-bottomed steering wheel, redesigned air vent knobs, fewer buttons, revised trim and different ambient lighting, they refresh what was a dated-looking cabin.

Here's a thing - this week I regularly parked my car in the same street as a fourth-generation Liberty. I kept heading for it at the end of each day because that design feels a lot more contemporary than the current car.

I came to my senses every time before trying to get in, but it does tell you that today's machine is a little on the dowdy side. While not the horror of the lines-everywhere-slab-sided fifth-generation model, I don't think the styling has escaped unscathed from the mess of the car it replaced.

This one won't scare small children or start pub arguments, though, and is a more cohesive, gracefully-ageing design. The LED daytime running lights and, in the case of the Premium, LED headlights, give it a modern feel and its less imposing headlight design is rather more pleasing. 

Little has happened as part of the refresh, with just the requisite number of visual tweaks. The front and rear bumpers (now with subtle diffuser) are a bit sharper and new wing mirrors and grille all add a little extra - but not much - to the 2014 original.

Inside is pretty much the same as before. The touchscreen has a flat, glare-prone screen but the rest of the cabin is well thought through, if entirely conventional. The flashy alloy pedals are a fun touch, though, and the materials choices are solid if uninspiring.

You could be forgiven for thinking you’ve stepped into a mid-sized rather than small coupe, with today’s G42 being larger in every area except wheelbase than an E46 3 Series Coupe of about 25 years ago.

Length, width, height and wheelbase dimensions are 4548mm, 1838mm, 1404mm and 2741mm, respectively, which make for a surprisingly easy-to-access and spacious cabin – at least for adults up front.

In fact, if nobody is sat behind, even a 200cm-plus individual can stretch out. German cars are great at accommodating the 99-percentile people. And head room’s not bad either, even with the standard sunroof.

BMW’s are about driving, so no shocks to learn that the M240i’s driving position is first class. Sat low and snug, this is a suitably sporty yet incredibly comfortable and high-quality environment, aided by nicely bolstered M Sport seats, a lovely steering wheel and a beautifully presented dashboard. Everything fits like a glove.

If the notion of reducing the number of buttons in the newly-extended electronic interface raises red flags (how many times have we moaned about this in most software-based Chinese vehicles?), rest assured: the M240i’s ergonomics are spot-on.

There are still plenty of switches alongside the iDrive controller and gearshifter for all major vehicle functions, Porsche-style, as well as big old physical buttons for the (soaring) audio, to back up the screen shortcuts for more-detailed functions. It only takes a few moments to learn how easy and intuitive the whole set-up is. BMW leads the way here.

Crisp, clear and colourful digital graphics almost make up for the fact that the gorgeous old analogue dials of old are extinct. Instead, the company serves up unremarkable angular instrument displays and electronic readouts. Very comprehensive and informative, they do the job, but are utterly bereft of character or style. It’s as if Munich’s designers have forgotten how to make things look pretty nowadays. Hang on, do we see a pattern emerging here?

More solid Teutonic sensibility – this time far-more artfully served up – can be found in the excellent ventilation system, ample console-sited storage and pleasingly deep door pockets, highlighting how easy the M240i is to live with.

Crash regulations demand central posts, so no pillarless sides unfortunately in this modern coupe, but frameless door glass is nice (and assists in entry/egress when retracted), enhancing that sporty sensation.

The flipside is poor side and rear vision for the driver, but – frankly – it is otherwise difficult to fault the M240i’s interior layout and presentation.

Even the back-seat area tries hard.

The seats whirr forward and back (slowly) to increase/decrease the narrow aperture as required (using a shoulder-height lever within easy reach), though you’ll need to be pretty flexible accessing the two-person buckets that await. Once ensconced there, there’s sufficient space, padding and support for most folk of up to about 180cm to travel in reasonable comfort, as long as the front-seat occupants aren’t in maximum chaise longue mode and journeys aren’t too long. The quite-upright backrest angle can’t be adjusted.

Just ensure the climate control is on. Things can become pretty stuffy, quickly. And be thankful for the air vents, extended glass area, middle armrest with cupholders and reading lights.

Further back, there is a large-ish, 390-litre boot with a low, wide and flat floor, that can be extended by tugging on a handle to drop the 40/20/40 split/fold backrests as required.

The usual tie-down hooks, lighting and power outlets are present, but you’ll search in vain for a space-saver wheel. Just the dreaded 'tyre mobility kit' that – once deployed – will likely ruin your tyre and cost hundreds to replace. No thanks.

A gashed tyre. No phone coverage. What a way to ruin a great drive day out on your favourite rural roads and in such an immensely enjoyable car. Australia demands a spare tyre.

The Liberty has a terrifically spacious interior. Rear seat passengers have a huge amount of legroom, with a ton of room behind my driving position (I'm 178cm) for long-legged teenagers. There's also plenty of legroom and even air vents.

The cabin has four cupholders in total and four USB ports, two up front and two in the back.

If you found a way to fill the boot with water you'd get 493 litres aboard and you can drop the 60/40 split fold seats for yet more space.

The Liberty's sixth-generation has arrived at middle age and Subaru took the opportunity to tweak the specification as well as the looks. Second in the three car range is the 2.5i Premium, which sits between the 2.5i entry-level and the 3.6R, and carries a $36,640 price tag.

Standard on the Premium are 18-inch alloys, a six speaker stereo with Bluetooth and USB, dual-zone climate control, keyless entry and start, active cruise control, powered and heated front seats, sat nav, auto high beam, active LED headlights, a very impressive safety package, partial leather seats, leather steering wheel, power everything, sunroof and a full-size spare.

The 7.0-inch touchscreen now not only features sat nav and a half-decent media system but also has Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, which is still a rarity in this class. Also a rarity is the standard all-wheel drive system (good) and the CVT auto (maybe not so good).

As before, the M240i employs a 3.0-litre direct-injection turbo-charged in-line six-cylinder petrol engine, making a heady 285kW of power at 6500rpm and 500Nm of torque between 1900rpm and 5000rpm.

A ZF-supplied eight-speed torque-converter automatic transmission is fitted (and, sadly, no manual is available), driving all four wheels via an AWD system with an M Sport-tuned differential.

Like the overall specification, the drivetrain has received some attention. While power outputs are the same as before - 129kW/235Nm - the CVT auto with which Subaru's 2.5-litre boxer engine is paired is slightly improved. Even in the quiet of the cabin you hear that 'flat' four-cylinder's trademark gravelly growl.

Being a Subaru, all four wheels receive their share of power. The Liberty's published towing capacity is 1500kg for braked trailers and 750kg unbraked. If you need a bit more, the six-cylinder 3.6R can handle another 300kg.

Rated as a Euro 6d-compliant vehicle, the M240i’s average combined fuel consumption figure is 8.0 litres per 100km, for a carbon dioxide emissions average of 185 grams/km.

With a 52-litre tank brimmed with premium unleaded petrol (98 RON minimum is recommended), that should result in about 650km between refills on average.

Over a mix of urban and highway driving, we managed 8.9L/100km, which is better than the pre-facelift version’s 9.6L/100km. That’s impressive stuff for a performance-orientated sports coupe.

Subaru says the combined cycle fuel figure is 7.3L/100km and I got 9.3L/100km with a mix of suburban and 80km/h running.

The fuel tank is a generous 61 litres.

The M240i xDrive’s specification reads like it’s straight out of BMW fan fiction.

Nestled within a shrunken 3 Series-derived 'CLAR' platform brandishing near-50:50 weight distribution, stuffed between beefed-up struts up front, is a strident in-line six, driving the rear or all four wheels via an M Sport differential and held up by a multi-link rear axle.

The promise here is an athletic driving machine on one hand and a cosseting grand tourer on the other, but whether the M240i can walk that fickle red line as effortlessly four years on… well, that’s what we’re here to find out. As we said earlier, sub-3.5s Teslas and the like have really messed with the bang-for-your-buck playbook since 2021.

Luckily, the reality only reiterates the 2 Series Coupe’s place in the sun. Rather than the anodyne (or artificial) whine of an electric motor, here instead is one of the greatest modern engines in the world, mated to arguably the best auto transmission ever in existence.

That’s a terrific start. And, once the button is pressed, the M240i’s performance bandwidth is deeply moving and immensely satisfying.

With a kerb weight of 1690kg, the M240i’s power to weight ratio is an impressive 168.6kW/tonne, helping it to scoot from standstill to 100km/h in 4.3 seconds, on the way to an electronically-limited top speed of 250km/h. Note that the M2 flagship is just 0.3s quicker to 100.

Pottering about town in its most benign ('Eco Pro') setting, the B58-hearted Bimmer slinks about gingerly, purring like a content tabby while skimming along over all sorts of urban roads like a luxury car costing a lot more should, taking everything in its stride. Given this is what driving is like for most people most of the time, the BMW nails it.

More throttle unleashes a surging snarl as the BMW’s speed steps up, with varying degrees of urgency according to the driver’s will and desire. Racing up through the gears, the German straight six feels like it has barely stirred; like things are just warming up.

In conjunction with Sport mode, here is where the M240i really starts to take off, leaping into action, engine roaring as speeds soar as if every road is a stretch of derestricted autobahn. The pace of this coupe is quite remarkable. Planted yet precise, the steering firms up as the chassis hunkers down, and you’re left in awe of how calm and composed the car constantly feels. Even in pouring rain.

As the roads start to snake and twist, the BMW glides through the chosen line with startling grip and confidence, without ever feeling nervous or twitchy in standard traction settings, regardless of surface or weather conditions. That’s the AWD doing its thing.

The M240i is all about nuance and control, whether you’re talking steering, handling, roadholding, braking or electronic intervention. It is refreshing to feel so connected to the driving experience so intimately.

As we said back in 2022, plonking for Sport Plus mode, with the stability and traction nannies neutered, is an easy street to big old oversteer spills and thrills, if so desired.

And then, you’re back in Eco Pro, crawling along in cocooned comfort and relying on the ADAS tech to waft you along, before being back in 'Individual' mode as the road ahead clears, with powertrain in 'Sport' but the suspension in 'Comfort'; just right for times when you just want to streak ahead of slower traffic without pummelling your spine. It’s all there for you. The M240i can do it all.

Inevitably, in Sport mode the ride’s firmness can be fatiguing on bad urban roads. Likewise, the tyre noise over coarse bitumen is tiring over longer drives. And it is all too easy to exceed the speed limit.

Earlier, we said we prefer this over the extroverted, track-focused M2, despite the latter’s astounding speed, thunderous soundtrack and tremendous dynamic capabilities, and that’s because of the M240i’s ability to deliver pleasure with everyday user-friendliness. Plus, the performance flagship is only 0.3s quicker to 100.

Maybe the latest base manual M2 might change our minds.

As it stands, on the move, the M240i is BMW in full flight, staying true to brand values but without frying your nerves or depleting your bank account too much. We love it and you should too.

Subaru says the Liberty has undergone some changes to improve the driving experience. To my backside, that hasn't worked out perhaps as intended. At least I hope so, because the results aren't terrific. The ride is particularly odd - in the corners there is noticeable body roll but it bangs and crashes over bumps, the rear passengers suffering worse than those up front.

In the cruise it's perfectly reasonable and the car is very quiet, indeed it's pleasant at speed. At lower speeds, there is a lack of feel contributing to the feeling that the wheel lacks accuracy. Nothing dramatic, but I felt like I was constantly correcting it the way Parisians correct my high school Francais.

Cheeringly, what I expected to be my least favourite part of the car was quite good. I am monotonously on record dissing CVTs because generally, they're pretty terrible. After six months with one in the Forester, I was never comfortable with it. 

Here in the Liberty, it seems better integrated with the engine, with much better control of the trademark flaring and it's only when you really get the accelerator up against the firewall that you're reminded you're driving a rubber band. When you switch from I (Intelligent) to S (Sport) mode, it also responds accordingly, but there's never going to be fireworks.

The brake pedal is a bit on the mushy side, too, but its stopping ability was never in doubt. I guess the final verdict is that some parts of the experience are dreamily isolating while others are not as good as you might expect.

The Liberty ships with seven airbags (including driver's knee), lane-keep assist, adaptive cruise with brake light recognition, ABS, traction and stability controls, reversing camera, forward and side view cameras, reverse cross traffic alert and blind spot monitoring. 

Bafflingly, there are no parking sensors at all on any Liberty. I know that sounds churlish, but I don't park watching a camera and like the beepers so I can watch somewhere else. Give me a beeper and a dipping left-hand mirror any day.

On top of all that, the 'EyeSight' system is also fitted. EyeSight is a pair of cameras pointing forward that not only powers the lane keep assist, but lets you know if you're drifting or approaching an obstacle too quickly. It also detects pedestrians and in this latest iteration will work up to 50km/h rather than 30km/h as before.

As you might expect, the Liberty scored five ANCAP stars in December 2014.

BMW offers a five-year/unlimited kilometre warranty, matching all of its German rivals, as well as three years of roadside assistance.

As always, servicing frequency is condition-based, depending on how they’re driven, amongst other factors, with an indicator on the instrument panel to alert the driver/owner. That said, our advice is to always visit your BMW dealer annually or at every 10,000km, just to be certain.

Capped-price servicing is not offered.

However, the ‘BMW Service Inclusive Basic package’ is available at extra cost, covering scheduled servicing for five years/80,000km, as long as the scheme is subscribed to before the end of the first 12 months of first registration. A 2 Series should cost from $2380.

At three years/unlimited kilometres, the Subaru warranty is now starting to look a bit thin compared to, say, Korean rivals. Over the three years of the capped-price servicing you'll wear $2281.66 for up to 75,000km of servicing. 

Subaru expects to see you every six months or 12,500km, so that averages out to $380 per service.

Hyundai's Sonata will cost you just $795 over the same period (for fewer visits), a Mazda6 will only hit you for between $308 and $336 per service, and a Camry will cost just over half what Subaru charges every year.