Are you having problems with your Holden? Let our team of motoring experts keep you up to date with all of the latest Holden issues & faults. We have gathered all of the most frequently asked questions and problems relating to the Holden in one spot to help you decide if it's a smart buy.
Show all
Reliability and resale should be the key factors in your decision, given you're doing about 30,000km a year. That's considerably more than the average, and in three years you'd be clocking up close to 100,000km. With that in mind I suggest you go for a Japanese brand with a reputation for quality and reliability. That way you are more likely to have a trouble-free run and have a car that will be highly valued on the used-car market when you come to sell it. The Lanos and Accent are both built in Korea by companies whose credo was cheap, cheap, cheap. While the reliability of their products wasn't necessarily poor, their cars weren't built as well as their more expensive Japanese-made rivals. The Korean makes don't hold their values as well as the cars from Toyota, Mazda, Honda and Nissan. I'd consider a Nissan Pulsar, a Mazda 121, Honda Civic or Toyota Corolla, all of which are good, robust cars with good resale potential.
The change took place with the VX in 2000. The increase in power is predominantly due to a more powerful electronic control module that could process more data more quickly, and a new smoother intake manifold that improved the V6's gas flow and volumetric efficiency.
I assume the VH Commodore is a six, which was a new updated XT6 version of the venerable pushrod Holden six. While it was improved over the previous versions of the engine it was still quite inefficient even by 1982 standards. The Trimatic three-speed should have plenty of life left in it, but check the oil and make sure it's nice and red. Also make sure the shifts are smooth and precise with no sign of flaring on part or full throttle. Check the body for rust, particularly in the lower sections of the front guards, the lower sections of the doors, around the rear side windows and around the tail gate and rear window. The Camry has lots of life left in it, but it is near the mileage where major servicing could be needed. The Camry is most likely to be in better condition overall than the Commodore, which can be expected to be riddled with squeaks and rattles in the body.
The supercharged version of the ECOTEC V6 is an option in the Commodore S and produces 171kW compared with 147kW produced by the normally aspirated V6, which is the standard engine. One thing you might want to consider is that the supercharged engine is only available with the four-speed auto transmission where there is a choice of manual or auto with the standard V6. The auto tends to dull the driving experience of the supercharged V6, but it is still a lively engine and fun to drive. The VT Series II saw the introduction of the 5.7-litre Gen III Chev V8 which is a relatively high-revving V8 compared with the old Holden V8 it replaced, but it is also a fun engine to drive and comes with a choice of auto or six-speed manual. There is no significant difference in servicing or parts costs with either the S or the SS, but we are aware that some Gen III V8s have had problems with piston rattle and high oil consumption and you should carefully check for any sign of these problems with any car you are considering buying.
Early Commodores with independent rear suspension suffered from high tyre wear because of geometry changes they went through as they worked. Anything that made the rear lower, such as putting the weight of a trailer on it, made it worse. So the advice you received was correct and you would have to replace tyres more often on a Commodore built before the VX Series II. The VX Series II saw the independent rear suspension improved with additional links to particularly control the changes in toe-in as the wheels moved up and down. This meant Holden could change the suspension settings which reaped benefits in tyre wear, as well as worthwhile improvement in ride, handling and stability. If you are looking to buy, then I would recommend the VX Series II, but if you have a car you want to improve, then take it to a suspension specialist who will be able to suggest ways to solve the problem.
This is not unusual with the Astra which, like all European cars, chews through brakes, both pads and discs, quickly. It seems unusual that both front and rear discs should need replacing at such low kilometres, and at the same time. You'd normally expect the front discs to wear faster than the rears, but I have heard of similar cases with the Astra. You could try taking it up with Holden as a warranty claim, but I think you'd find they consider disc rotors as consumable items not covered by the warranty.
Since you have covered the basics of fitting new spark plugs and leads, I'd look deeper. It sounds as if you might have a burnt valve so I'd suggest you get a mechanic to do a compression test on the engine and look for a cylinder that is not holding compression.
Some AM stations don't have a very strong signal and that, in combination with the tiny roof-mounted antenna on the Barina, leads to problems. The longer the antenna the better the reception, but modern cars don't have long antennas that would solve your problem. It would be worth checking the antenna connections and mountings again to make sure water hasn't got in. And check the signal amplifier at the base of the antenna. Finally, unscrew the antenna, insert a coat hanger in its place and check the reception with that. If it improves the problem is with the antenna, so see if you can find a longer antenna.
It's certainly worth upgrading your brakes to the later VT set-up. You will improve your braking performance. As far as the shocks go, it's worth fitting new ones. Shocks are a most important safety item in your suspension, and there could be ride benefits as well. I would suggest either Koni or Bilstein shocks, though they are more expensive than the Monroes.