Club Campers Frontier vs Mini 3D Hatch

What's the difference?

All in all, the Frontier is the best forward-fold camper on the market, although it is also the most expensive. If you were making a buying decision purely based on features, you’d probably look elsewhere, but if you are prepared to pay a little more because this camper-trailer is Australian made, you get a very functional camper that’s easy to set up, reliable, strong and light. 

The Mini 60 Years is another classic special edition Mini and its definitely one for the fans. I'm not at all fussed by it and would quite happily save my money for a standard Cooper S. The Mini is still one of the most playful, interesting cars from a mainstream car maker and while it doesn't please everyone with its size and weight, it's tremendous fun to drive.

It's the kind of car I could own and I always feel comfortable in - it's the perfect size for urban environments but is just as much at home belting down a freeway on a long trip or scooting down a B-road just because.

The real appeal of a forward-fold camper-trailer is the internal configuration. Because the bed folds out over the front of the camper, the trailer body is configured with a wrap-around lounge and dinette area, that also converts into a bed. It brings a certain level of caravan comfort to a camper-trailer-sized package. Cub’s execution is quite good. The lounge is comfortable and the dinette table is highly adjustable up and down or around and around. It converts into a bed more simply than any other on the market I’ve seen. 

The downside of the forward-fold concept is the quantity and access of storage. Very little of the internal storage is easy to get to, and in truth there’s very little of it. That’s what happens when you put a couch in a trailer, sorry. There are hatches under the seats, but even they are limited by the slide-out kitchen and battery box across the back, plus, they’re not as easy to get to as a drawer. It’s the same in every manufacturers version, though. However, the Frontier has one unique features that makes it stand out – a series of pigeon holes under the foot of the bed which provide the only easy-to-access internal storage in any forward-fold I’ve come across so far.

Yep, it's a small car so expect things to be reasonably cosy. I fit in there fine but I am neither particularly tall nor broad. Taller folks will fit just fine in the front (but not too tall, don't be greedy) while larger people might find themselves uncomfortably close to their passengers.

The rear seat is bearable for children and patient adults on short trips. At least they'll be well hydrated because as well as the pair of cupholders up front there are a further three in the back for a total of five. The Mini joins the NC Mazda MX-5 as a car with a greater cup capacity than passenger capacity. Front seat passengers can keep the water topped up as there are also small bottle holders in the doors.

There are two USB ports in the front seat and a wireless charging pad that doesn't fit bigger phones under the armrest. If your iPhone is the smaller size, the combination of wireless CarPlay and charging pad is excellent.

The boot is surprisingly big for such a small car, beating many of its cheaper rivals with 211 litres with the seats in place and 731L with them folded down.

The Frontier is quite good under tow. Cub designed and manufactures its own coil-spring independent suspension and has paid quite close attention to the balance and dynamics of the trailer. 

As it’s not overly heavy, it’s not a handful, even on the beach, and behind the Mitsubishi Triton I tested it with, it was barely a struggle. On the road, the camper is well behaved, easy to see over and around and because it’s not very long, it’s not very daunting.

Driving a Mini is a unique experience. Almost no other car on sale today has the combination of that far-away, near-vertical windscreen and an A-pillar that is almost slim by today's standards. The side of the car is almost fifty percent glass, so vision is terrific. 

It had been a little while since I drove a Mini Cooper S so I was looking forward to the Mini bounce that I've always loved and my wife despised. Somewhere along the way, that bounce has faded somewhat, to the point where my wife says she doesn't mind it anymore. That must be a good thing, because while the ride is more refined, it's still a blast to drive, even if you're just getting around in traffic.

The Mini just loves point and squirt driving. The quick, well-weighted steering helps you swing the nose in and out of gaps and the handy slab of torque from the 2.0-litre ensures you stay out of trouble while doing it. The Mini also loves haring down a country road, the more secure-feeling ride belying its short wheelbase. The weight of the car probably helps keep things on the straight and narrow. It's pretty clever to make the car feel grown-up while also maintaining its sense of playfulness.

The driving mode switch doesn't make a huge amount of difference, with Sport mode adding a few apologetic pops from the exhaust.

Complaints are few, but there are too many buttons on the steering wheel and to my mind are all in the wrong place. By necessity, the controller for the media screen is practically on the floor and is crowded in by the cupholders and huge handbrake lever. But that doesn't mean Mini should take away the handbrake.

I have my reasons.