Alfa Romeo reliability "better" than rivals

Andrew Chesterton

Contributing Journalist

3 min read

Alfa Romeo says its quality and reliability on the Tonale small SUV is "far ahead" of its German rivals in BMW, Mercedes-Benz and Audi, saying it has access to top-secret shared warranty-claim data in which the Italian brand says it "scores so much better".

It's little secret that Alfa Romeo has faced issues with perceived reliability from the buying public, but the brand says a host of factory improvements – from laser-guided paint checking called 'Eagle Eye' to human quality control – has seen it rise above its competition, at least based on its data.

"So we saw in the warranty period, the issues, if you want to call it this way, on Tonale. We have also OEM shared information, the ones that we cannot disclose because otherwise we would be kicked out from this group of information sharing," says Alessandro Corgnati, Alfa Romeo Tonale Global Product Manager.

Read more about

"Comparing all this data, we understood that our 2024 production was at the level of the best competitors. And what I can tell you is that with the improvements that we mentioned, those are just very little improvements, we have many others that are also technical and are even maybe not clearly understandable for a customer.

"We brought down this level of warranty issues, if you call it this way. And now we have, let's say, a level that we feel is best in class, comparing all the information possible."

Pressed for detail on the data, Mr Corgnati said the information was "very sensitive", but said it was based on warranty claims.

"It's a tough one because since this is internal data, either I don't want them to know where we are, and all the information is very, very sensitive. What I can tell you is that the information I was giving is based on warranty period," he says.

Alfa Romeo is banking on the Tonale small SUV to fuel a brand resurgence, both in Australia and around the world. The just-launched Junior crossover will remain the brand's best-seller, but the Tonale is expected to slot into second position, ahead of the now-ageing Giulia sedan and Stelvio mid-size SUV.

"What I want to underline is that we don't aim to do what the Germans do. As our CEO always repeats, we don't have the ambition to sell millions of cars as the Germans are doing," Mr Corgnati says.

"We clearly know what is the role of Alfa Romeo, and we want to go in a very clear way in that direction because we know our customers, we know them very well, we know what they want, and we want to keep delivering this in a very clear way."

Andrew Chesterton

Contributing Journalist

CarsGuide contributing journalist Andrew Chesterton is an award-winning Australian automotive reporter with more than 20 years of experience across newspapers, magazines, digital publishing and automotive corporate communications. Andrew began his journalism career at Sydney’s The Daily Telegraph and The Sunday Telegraph, reporting across business, courts, crime, property and state politics before moving into automotive journalism. He joined Top Gear Australia as its online editor in 2008, later being appointed editor of Top Gear New Zealand. He subsequently worked as an assistant editor during the Australian launch of the Daily Mail Australia, and as communications manager at FCA Australia, now Stellantis. His experience on both sides of the media industry gives him an unrivalled understanding of the automotive industry, and the relationship between car manufacturers, the media, and Australian consumers. Andrew’s work has appeared across leading automotive, news, business, luxury, travel and lifestyle publications, including CarsGuide, EV Central, DMARGE, The Sydney Morning Herald, Marie Claire, Top Gear, GQ Australia, The Australian, WISH Magazine, Boss Hunting, The West Australian, The Nightly, Women’s Day Australia, Carsales, NRMA, Men’s Health, CEO Magazine, Australian Financial Review and more.   Andrew specialises in industry news, vehicle reviews, policy,  performance and luxury cars, electric vehicles, automotive technology, EVs hybrid and plug-in hybrids, and the broader Australian new-car marketplace. In 2025, Andrew was named Newspress Australia News Journalist of the Year and was a finalist for the overall Journalist of the Year award. Earlier honours include Website of the Year wins at the Australian Magazine Awards and ACP Awards, the ACP Rising Star Award and recognition in the Bauer Media and News Ltd journalism awards. Expertise Electric, hybrid and plug-in hybrid vehicles Performance, luxury and supercars New-car reviews and road testing Australian automotive industry and new-car sales Chinese automotive brands and emerging manufacturers Utes, SUVs and family vehicles Automotive technology Policy Awards 2025 Newspress Australia News Journalist of the Year Featured Publications CarsGuide EV Central DMARGE The Sydney Morning Herald Marie Claire Top Gear GQ Australia The Australian WISH Magazine Boss Hunting The West Australian The Nightly Women’s Day Australia Carsales NRMA Men’s Health CEO Magazine Australian Financial Review The Daily Telegraph The Sunday Telegraph Note: The author, Andrew Chesterton, is a co-owner of Smart As Media, a content agency and media distribution service with a number automotive brands among its clients. When producing content for CarsGuide, he does so in accordance with the CarsGuide Editorial Guidelines and Code of Ethics, and the views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author.
About Author

Comments