Are you having problems with your Holden? Let our team of motoring experts keep you up to date with all of the latest Holden issues & faults. We have gathered all of the most frequently asked questions and problems relating to the Holden in one spot to help you decide if it's a smart buy.
Show all
Ignition coil failures have been an often reported failure on Commodores going back a number of models; it's not necessarily something new. I couldn't say the others will fail any time soon, after all the two failed coils did 184,000 km before giving up.
The Captiva doesn’t actually have a four-wheel drive mode in the conventional sense. It employs an all-wheel drive system with all the drive going through the front wheels in normal conditions, but when conditions dictate the drive is redirected to the rear axle as required for maximum traction. I’m not sure what difference having a light on the dash would make, the system would still be working out the best distribution of the drive for best traction, all you would have is a light flashing on the dash. I would find that distracting.
On the basis of what you have described here it doesn’t sound as though the car is unsafe, and I wouldn’t be reluctant to drive it. I can, of course, understand that you feel frustrated at not being able to get a satisfactory explanation of the cause of the noise. I would suggest that you go back to the dealer and ask for a meeting with the service manager to discuss your concerns. Have the manager talk you through what they have found wrong with your car and what they have done to fix it, and ask them to justify to your satisfaction that it is indeed fixed. If you’re still not satisfied ask them to have a Holden factory technician assess the noise and give you a report on it. Further to that you could have an independent mechanic assess it for you.
Good to know that the problem can be fixed, but I would think such a rework is beyond all but the most enthusiastic owners.
It’s a bit like comparing a carburetor with fuel-injection. A carburetor is really a compromise and is very difficult to tune perfectly for all running conditions, so there is often a problem where the engine coughs, splutters, misfires, stalls or surges. Electronically-controlled fuel-injection can be more precisely tuned to all running conditions, whether it’s hot, cold, wet, windy, high speed, low speed, whatever. The end result is that the car performs better and gives better economy. It’s the same with the vapour-injection system; your car will run better, it won’t stall, stumble, surge, and the performance will be the same as it would be on petrol. Whether that makes it worth the extra $1900 or so it would cost is only a question you could answer. For me it is, I wouldn’t be bothered with an old air-valves system, which is the cheaper system you would be getting.
That's a brave move after all those years driving the HG, but you've chosen a car that should give you good service. It's not possible to say it won't breakdown at any time, and if it does you won't be able to fix it yourself as you would have done with the HG. The brakes won't wear out as fast as they might on other brands, the current car doesn't appear to have the issues with ignition coils that earlier models did, and I haven't heard of reports of brake hose failures on the VE. Overall it is generally reliable and shouldn't give you too many nightmares.
Phew, where to start! It's always a good idea to read the warranty before you buy a car so you understand what it covers and what it doesn't. The new car warranty is provided by Holden, the extended warranty is not, that is provided by an insurance company and sold to you by the dealer. Again you need to read it and understand what it covers and what it doesn't cover before you buy it. Personally I wouldn't buy one, I don't believe they are good value for money. Like every profession there are good mechanics and dud ones, ones that treat their customers well and others that don't. It's a good idea to find a mechanic you can trust, one that treats you with respect, and stick with them. Don't be afraid to ask questions, and don't be fobbed off. If you aren't satisfied persist until you are satisfied with the answers, it's not a bad idea to ask to see any parts that have been replaced and get an explanation of why they needed replacing. A good mechanic will be happy to take the time to explain to you what has gone wrong and what they have done to repair your car. With regard to Holdens breaking down shortly after the warranty runs out, I don't believe there is any evidence that they do, certainly none that says they breakdown more frequently than other makes. As for the extras charged during a service; you are perfectly entitled to get a quote before the car goes in, and Holden would be able to tell you how much each service will cost you; if there is anything else they find during the inspection they must get your approval before going ahead with the work. It is not uncommon to find faults during the service inspection; that is why they inspect cars when they come in for service, I don't think that's unreasonable. Cars do breakdown, that's a fact of life, and it's not restricted to Holdens.
The 186S motor was a sporty six introduced in the HR model and continued in the HK, HT and HG models. It replaced the X2 twin-carb motor in June 1967, and had revised inlet and exhaust manifolds and a modified air cleaner. Peak power was 108 kW at 4600 revs and maximum torque was 249 Nm at 2200 revs. It's not a super rare engine.
Sometimes, when a car sits for an extended period of time, the oil can drain back down into the sump from the top of the engine. If that happens it can take a few seconds for the oil to be pumped back up to the top again, and in that time the lifters can rattle. I would guess that’s what it is, but if you are concerned about it have a mechanic check it.
The guys at the LPG Warehouse have just fitted an EMER vapour-injection system to a similar car to yours and it’s working a treat for the owner. In that installation they used a toroidal LPG tank and removed the spare wheel; the owner was happy to keep his boot space and use a puncture repair kit should he encounter a flat tyre. They can also use a smaller cylindrical LPG tank if you wanted to retain your spare. Contact the LPG Warehouse on 03 9770 2287 for more info.