Volkswagen Problems

The Tiguan is getting old and the Qashqai is brand-spanking, the latter also with much better warranty and service back-up. Neither is my favourite in the class but I'd go for the Qashqai.

The Golf is a better, classier car, but the latest Golf does not have the sharp edge of the previous GTI. So I agree the Focus is the smart choice.

There was a recall in 2012 to check for a fractured fuel pipe on the diesels, which could cause a leak and fire, but yours should have been checked and presumably cleared by the dealer at a service. The concerns about the DSG gearbox in VWs doesn't apply to your vehicle, as the problem only affects the six-speed 'box and not the 7-speed that's in your car. I wouldn't be concerned about anything with your car, it's hardly done any miles and should have plenty of life left in it.

Like us, it seems you like the idea of the Golf, the quality and driving, but not some of the niggles.

What's happening is that the car's computer is detecting a problem and putting it into limp home mode. The idea is that you are then able to drive on at a reduced speed to get it to a dealer for repairs. What's not happening is that the dealer is not identifying a problem when they get to see the car and check it on their diagnostic equipment. It's difficult to find the cause of a problem when it is not evident when the mechanic is doing the check. There is likely to be a problem with a sensor or a wiring connection issue. The only way to find the problem when the diagnostic gear isn't telling what is causing it is to do a thorough manual check. I would be taking the car back to the dealer and telling them that you won't be taking it back until the car is fixed.

VW spokesman Karl Gehling replies: "For the MY15 Golf the bi-xenon lights are available as part of a luxury pack. Unfortunately this pack is not available in conjunction with the R-Line package." So it's a win-lose for you.

You might just be able to buy a 2010 Subaru Liberty wagon for $15,000, more likely you would have to settle for a 2009 model. The Liberty is a good choice. I would be wary of suggesting the Golf wagon, servicing is relatively expensive and you need to be careful when choosing your car to ensure there are no hidden bugs that might prove expensive down the track. The Kia Sportage is certainly worth a look and should fit within your budget.

We're passing your message to all the other Golf people.

The Mazda6 is very good and great for the price but the Mercedes C-Class wagon is a couple of steps further up the ladder and an excellent car if you have the money.