What's the difference?
When it comes to buying a people mover, the category leader is Kia's Carnival, with Honda’s Odyssey a distant second, and daylight coming in third and fourth.
The third generation – known as the PE - was released in 2015, and has subsequently proven a hit, particularly with buyers looking for space and a bit of luxury as well.
Kia has added the running changes recently made to the identical US market Sedona, and has included a few touches to make it specific for Australian audiences.
So, you’re married with children. Energetic children, with lots of friends who love their weekend sport, picnics with Gran and Pop, and heading off on a break, camping or just road-tripping to a favourite family-friendly destination.
You might be eyeing off a three-row SUV with all the rugged, outdoorsy neighbourhood cred that goes with it. But face facts, you’re in the people-mover zone. Or at least you should be.
The reputational discomfort that once went with ownership of a ‘one box’ family truckster has been all but eliminated, thanks largely to the vehicle you see here, Kia’s third-generation Carnival.
Launched in 2015, the current Carnival somehow combines day-to-day practicality with handsome design, a people-mover holy grail many though impossible.
Substantially upgraded with new safety tech and cosmetic tweaks in mid-2018, the Cleary family spent a week on board the second-from-the-top SLi Diesel, covering roughly 800km from Sydney down the beautiful NSW South Coast and back to see how the big eight-seater handled a holiday stress test.
Kia's Carnival has the people mover market all sewn up, but perhaps it should be looking at claiming some scalps within the larger SUV segment as well. It has a more comfortable, quieter ride than many of its rivals at similar price points, as well as a great deal more flexibility when it comes to people and cargo.
The Kia Carnival definitely should be added to the shopping lists of people who are looking for a vehicle that can suit many lifestyles and is flexible enough to deal with towing, cargo carrying, and the occasional full load of excited soccer kids.
It is perhaps a bit expensive for some family units, although the base model S now offers extra value, thanks to the additional safety inclusions.
The pick of the range for us is the SLi. It offers most of the inclusions of the top-spec Platinum - though it does miss out on items like rear cross-traffic alert - and the 18-inch rims are the perfect balance of looks and ride comfort. The diesel is the pick if you cover any sort of distance regularly, while the thirstier petrol will be cheaper to maintain for urban duties.
The Kia Carnival SLi Diesel delivers comfortable and relaxed family transport, handling the rigors of the Cleary family’s Griswold holiday tribute without raising a single bead of perspiration. It’s hugely practical, well equipped, surprisingly economical and backed by a market-leading warranty package.
If you take a good hard look at yourself in the mirror, and see a large family crowding in behind you, it could be the high-capacity hauler you really need.