Porsche Cayman S 2009 review

Traditionally a car company will build a hard top sports car and then leverage that by knocking off the top and charging a lump extra for the privilege of having the convertible version of whatever that car may be.

Porsche — as is their wont — did it differently. Not only did they build the soft-top version first but when they stuck the roof on they charged a lump extra for that. Also, true to form, Porsche did a damn fine job of building that hard-top car.

Starting with the Boxster's sweet chassis and mid-engine layout Porsche's stylists went to work to produce a car that was different enough to look at that some casual observers still believe it to be a model in its own right, and took it to the market as the Cayman.

Pricing

For the privilege of having a solid roof the Cayman S — the upper tier of the range — starts some $15,000 above the equivalent Boxster and at $155,300 there is some debate over whether this two-door sporty is any sort of bargain at all. The popular defence to that is that while it may be more expensive than the drop-top Boxster it is far less so than the hard-top 911 against which it has claims for handling and performance. Not sure where I stand on that debate, I just know that if the readies weren't a problem there would be a Cayman S in the garage.

Drivetrain

The 3.4-litre engine has the distinctive busy sound of the flat-six. There is no gentle rumbling of a big-bore engine waiting to be ignited but rather an impression of noise that quickly becomes a crackling howl when the whips are produced.

Punch the throttle and the Cayman comes to life, happy to put the horizon behind at a rapidly increasing rate or throw itself at the next corner with an inspiring surety. The Cayman is not a selfish car, happy to share its dynamism with drivers of many and varied abilities.

The test car came with Porsche's sublime 7-speed PDK double-clutch automatic, a $5500 option. So sharp are the changes and so intelligent the programming that you are going to quickly forget how deeply you were gouged to have this gearbox. The beauty of the PDK is that it really is a set-and-forget performance hero. The shifts are razor sharp and there is rarely a time when urge is not in the meat of the 370Nm available across a very usable rev range.

Vary the throttle agression and vary the shift agression ... it's that simple. If all you want to do is shift quietly through traffic then the PDK is there make it as seamless as possible. Attack the road and there is a whole new character to the box as it skips gears to get to the most effect ratio for maximum torque — and then holds hard like a hungry dog to a bone.

If you really must you can self-select the changes but its is going to be a happier relationship if you sooner rather than later come to terms with the fact that left to its own devices the PDK in full auto can do a better job than you can.

Driving

It is a masterclass in automotive engineering. Packaging feel, balance, excitement, a goodly degree of refinement and within the bounds of what it is a surprising amount of space and comfort into a low-slung two-door sportscar is no small feat.

Whether trundling through city traffic or attacking the open road the Cayman cabin is a lovely place to be. Around town the Cayman is docile, with the light yet precise steering seemingly immune from tramlining over road imperfections and a ride compliant enough to take the very worst out of Sydney's awful road surfaces.

The cargo space — split front to rear — is not generous but there is enough to get away for a weekend or get the (small) family shopping in. Still, load carrying and domestic duties are not what the Cayman S is about. This is a thoroughbred sportscar and given the chance it will behave as such. Accelerate strongly, stop positively and turn in with the balance of a dancer. What more can you ask of a car.

Bottom line: Yes please!

Porsche Cayman S
Price: as tested $174,250 ($155,300 base)
Engine: 3.4L/flat 6, 235kW/370Nm
Transmission: 7-speed PDK auto, rear-wheel drive
Economy: 9.2L/100km (supplied), 9.8L/100km (as tested)
Rating: 92/100
Rivals
BMW Z4 35i from $116,900 87/100
Nissan 370Z from $67,990 82/100
Mercedes-Benz SLK 350 from $115,637 86/100
Audi S5 from $138,600 88/100