Articles by Neil McDonald

Neil McDonald
Contributing Journalist

Neil McDonald is an automotive expert who formerly contributed to CarsGuide from News Limited. McDonald is now a senior automotive PR operative.

Maserati GranCabrio first photos
By Neil McDonald · 25 Aug 2009
Chop the roof off. The Modena-based thoroughbred carmaker has done just that with its slinky GranTurismo, delivering the GranCabrio, the company’s first four-seater convertible. The sleek newcomer makes its world debut at next month's Frankfurt Motor Show and will be available here in the third quarter of next year. A spokesman for Maserati importer, Ateco Automotive Ltd, Edward Rowe, says customers are already queueing for the car. “We have a list of people who have seen the spyshots and they have expressed an interest,” he says. Cost? Rowe says the price is yet to be confirmed but says “it will have a margin above the GranTurismo”. That means somewhere north of $300,000. In true Italian fashion, Maserati has gone against current thinking by making the GranCabrio a canvas soft-top instead of an electrically folding tin-top design favoured by the Germans. The company says this allows for a full four-seater capacity and also helps emphasis a link with past Maserati convertibles. The GranCabrio is continuing a long tradition in open-top Maseratis. It joins models that have played such an important part in the Modena carmaker's history such as the 1950 A6G Frua Spyder, 1960 3500GT Vignale Spyder, 1964 Mistral Spyder, 1968 Ghibli Spyder and 2001 Spyder designed by Giorgetto Giugiaro.
Read the article
Contaminated fuel cost thousands
By Neil McDonald · 20 Aug 2009
Carsguide understands some drivers are being quoted between $3000 and $5000 to repair damaged engines in their late-model cars after filling up with bad fuel in the city's northern and north eastern suburbs. But as costs mount, Consumers Affairs Victoria has stepped in to take up the cases of affected motorists. So far it has received one official complaint and 146 inquiries about the contaminated regular unleaded fuel. The problem has been linked to six outlets, none of them mainstream fuel companies. Samples taken by the RACV and Victorian Automobile Chamber of Commerce have revealed that a silicone oil was the contaminant. CAV spokesperson, Sam Parkinson, says an investigating is continuing to establish if the contamination occurred at the retailers or from the delivery tankers. Parkinson says consumers have several avenues to chase compensation if their vehicles are affected but they must act quickly. "We're advising people to contact the retailer directly and make a formal complaint," she says. "It would also be advisable to obtained as much evidence as they can that contaminated fuel has been purchased." Motorists should keep fuel receipts or bank statements that show fuel was purchased from an affected retailer, get a sample of fuel from their vehicles as well as get a quote from their mechanic for the repairs, she says. "If possible get the mechanic to provide written advice that it's their opinion that the vehicle has been damaged as a result of the contaminated fuel," she says. "If they are not able to negotiate with the retailer then that's when they should lodge a complaint with the CAV." She says several affected retailers have been contacted to make sure they are aware of their legal responsibilities to motorists. If consumers are still worried, the RACV is recommending motorists use premium unleaded with either a 95 or 98 octane rating until the problem is resolved. The RACV's chief engineer, Michael Case, says no contaminants had been found in the higher octane petrol. Case says engines that run rough, misfire or are hard to start could be contaminated. Other signs to look for include white powder or film in the exhaust pipe, if the engine check light comes on, or if there is a sickly sweet smell from the fuel and exhaust gas or white powder on the spark plugs. "If vehicles show any of these signs, motorists should stop driving immediately," Case says. "Continuing to drive may result in further extensive engine damage." Any motorists who are experiencing problems should contact Consumer Affairs Victoria on 1300 55 81 81.  
Read the article
Citroen C5 2009 Review
By Neil McDonald · 20 Aug 2009
Like many things French, we have mixed emotions about the Citroen C5 Tourer. Love the looks, space, equipment, technology, six-speed automatic and effortless cruising pace of the 2.0-litre turbo-diesel but the driving experience leaves us indifferent.It all comes down to the car's hi-tech Hydractive III suspension. It is sensational when the roads are billiard-ball smooth and when you do happen to encounter some gravel roads, the Roll-Royce-like plushness and refinement is something you don't get for the price of a European family wagon.However, sharp bumps like bridge expansion joints will catch it out regardless of whether you're in normal or sports mode. And speaking of sports mode, it doesn't feel particularly sporty, just harsher.Perhaps it’s about taste. It takes a while to get used to the culinary delights of snails and frogs’ legs, so we suspect driving the C5 falls into the same category. There's is plenty to like about the big French wagon though. The cabin is plush, with heated front seats that have good support and the ambient lighting at night is a real touch of class.The door pockets have motion sensor lights that turn on when you're rummaging around for gear and the luggage bay light that doubles as a torch is a neat touch.An acoustic windscreen and laminated side windows do a great job of isolating the cabin from road and wind noise and the rear side window blinds are handy for keeping the sun off small children.The 100kW/320Nm 2.0-litre diesel is quiet, smooth and reasonably frugal but feels a bit underdone in this cavernous wagon. Citroen quotes 7.2 l/100km and we came close to bettering that in a mix of highway and city driving.Apart from the spongy ride, the C5's fixed-hub steering wheel - like the C4 - takes a while to get use to. Some of the minor switchgear and radio controls are not intuitive and storage space around the cabin is plentiful but practically useless because the nooks and crannies are so small.But that's the French for you. You should not expect a country that gives you great food, architecture, fashion and style to execute cars with the same caustic efficiency as the Germans.At $60,990 the C5 wagon is for those confident folk who embrace individuality and French flare.As the name says, it's Exclusive. 
Read the article
Mercedes Benz van gets 5 stars
By Neil McDonald · 18 Aug 2009
The $39,490 Mercedes-Benz Vito van was tested last month at Autoliv in Melbourne's northern suburbs as part of the Australian New Car Assessment Program.ANCAP chair, Mr Lauchlan McIntosh, said the result was encouraging but given the number of work vehicles on the road, he wanted other manufacturers to build five-star vans and utes.There are more than 250,000 vans and on Australian roads and few have the safety features of the Vito, he said. “It's great news for trades people and fleet buyers,” he said.McIntosh described the Vito result as a milestone for crash safety. “They are the workhorses in so many applications,” he said. “I look forward to other companies taking up the challenge to build five-star commercial vehicles.”McIntosh said commercial vans should be as safe as cars. ANCAP will focus future testing on other utes and commercial vehicles. The Vito was tested in a 64km/h frontal-offset collision, a 50km/h side impact crash and 29km/h pole crash test.The car was fitted with the optional side curtain airbags, which cost $800.Mercedes-Benz Australia managing director of commercial vehicles, Ken Matthews, said the company would now consider making curtain airbags standard on the Vito.“It's something we will consider,” he said. “It would give Mercedes an edge in the market.”Sample of ANCAP ratings for other vehicles Mercedes-Benz compares to the Vito and VianoVehicle Stars Score out of 37MITSUBUISHI EXPRESS * 8.49NISSAN PATROL *** 22.17FORD TRANSIT *** 22.53TOYOTA HI-ACE *** 23.5HYUNDAI i-Load **** 25.81MITSUBISHI PAJERO **** 25.88TOYOTA HI-LUX **** 26.86VOLKSWAGEN TRANSPORTER **** 26.93VOLKSWAGEN CADDY **** 28.46TOYOTA PRADO **** 29.53AUDI Q7 **** 29.82TOYOTA TARAGO **** 30.45LAND ROVER DISCOVERY **** 31.39FORD TERRITORY TS **** 31.57HOLDEN CAPTIVA **** 31.23NISSAN PATHFINDER **** 32.17FORD FOCUS 2007 ON **** 32.46MERCEDES-BENZ VITO ***** 32.66 (was 30.66)MERCEDES-BENZ VIANO ***** 32.66 
Read the article
Porsche 911 Turbo first look
By Neil McDonald · 14 Aug 2009
But the global financial crisis has caused heartache of a different kind for German carmaker Porsche.
Read the article
Chrysler Neon rates well in crash
By Neil McDonald · 13 Aug 2009
The 1996 Chrysler Neon was one of 118 vehicles to score strongly in the Monash University Accident Research Centre crash rankings survey. "It shows that secondhand car buyers do not have to limit their options when it comes to buying a safe car," MUARC researcher, Dr Stuart Newstead, said. The study assessed 239 cars, commercial vehicles, vans, people movers and four-wheel drives from 1982 onwards. The data was compiled from 3.6 million vehicles and 740,000 injured road users involved in crashes from 1992-2007. Dr Newstead said the results show that buyers can choose safer cars across most market segments. "There is a safer choice for every driver, from small cars to larger cars and commercial vans," he said. Apart from the Neon, the Ford Focus, Volkswagen Golf, Mazda MX5 and Peugeot 307 rated well among small cars. Not surprisingly, vehicles built before 1995 dominated the worst performers. "These vehicles generally do not have the safety features of some of the more modern cars, like airbags and stronger bodies," Dr Newstead said. "Generally, the newer the car, the better the protection for driver and passengers." Among the worst performers were pre-1995 versions of the Hyundai Excel, Mitsubishi Lancer and Nissan NX. Some pre-1995 micro cars, commercial vehicles and four-wheel drives also rated poorly. The MUARC study ranked older versions of the Daihatsu Mira, Subaru Sherpa, Suzuki Alto, Suzuki Carry van and Daihatsu Rocky as very poor. Other models that scored poorly or very poorly included the Daihatsu Mira built between 1990 and 1996 and the Nissan Pintara built between 1989 and 1992. Many late-model Australian-made cars scored above average but European and Japanese cars dominated the best performers. Ford Falcons and Holden Commodores from 2002 to 2007 achieved good rankings but older Saabs, Mercedes-Benzes, Audis and BMWs have excellent crash protection. The ratings are in their 17th year and vehicles have been rated by both their occupant protection and impact on other road users, including cyclists and pedestrians. Dr Newstead urged car buyers to make safety a high priority when choosing a second-hand vehicle, regardless of budget. The RACV's Used Car Safety Ratings can be found at www.racv.com.au BEST PERFORMING VEHICLES Small cars Chrysler Neon (1996-09) Ford Focus (2005-07) Mazda MX5 (1998-2005) Peugeot 307 (2001-2007) Volkswagen Golf (2004-2007) WORST PERFORMING VEHICLES Small cars Hyundai Excel (1990-1994) Hyundai Accent (1995-2000) Mitsubishi Lancer/Mirage (1991-1992) Nissan NX/NX-R (1991-1996) Subaru Impreza (1993-2000)
Read the article
Commodore shuns four-cylinder path
By Neil McDonald · 12 Aug 2009
The abject failure of the last four-cylinder Commodore - nick-named the ‘backfire’ - has convinced GM Holden not to do it again. Despite the appeal of a four-cylinder economy drive, and the chance to go head-to-head with the frugal new 2.0-litre Falcon in 2011, Holden says it is not even considering a baby engine for its family favourite.Rather than downsize its Commodore engine, GM-Holden chairman, Mark Reuss, says the company plans to ‘out-engineer the competition’. "Dropping cylinders would be the last result because people still like the power and the towing, all the things that we get with this engine and with this car."Ford and Holden are adopting different strategies to deliver improved fuel consumption and lower emissions. Reuss says the Commodore can achieve four-cylinder-like economy from its new engines and promises further technology gains to lift economy.At the launch of the company's greener direct-injection V6s last week, Reuss says the company was committed to achieving ‘further fuel efficiencies’ out of its new 3.0-litre and 3.6-litre engines. Apart from hi-tech engine management solutions, Reuss says shedding weight is also a priority for future Commodores.The company does have another smaller capacity V6 in the wings though. GM-Holden builds a smaller capacity 2.8-litre V6 for its export markets and Reuss has not ruled such an engine joining the lineup."I'm not saying we would never go below 3.0; but 3.0 is the sweet spot for the architecture, the car and the fuel economy and performance," Reuss says. "We look at all of those things and the displacement it would have. You don't rule out any of that stuff.""Our Port Melbourne plant is the most flexible engine plant in General Motors so we can always do that and relatively quickly if we need too. Right now we think this is the answer that we're looking for and the customers really asking for. But this is a journey and we will react to the market."Versions of Holden's new direct injection V6s will be exported to GM plants globally and will appear in several different brands, including some Saab and Alfa Romeo models. GM's Mexico plant will receive engines for the new Cadillac SRX and other markets in Europe are lining up for the new V6.GM-Holden's incoming new chairman, Alan Batey, says he was surprised by Ford's decision not to build the Focus four-cylinder. The Ford decision ‘creates an even bigger opportunity for us’ with the Cruze, he says. "I was a little bit surprised that Ford did make that announcement based on where we think our program is," he says. "Having said that they started with a European starting point.""We started from a global perspective where ours is a global platform that will be used around the world. From where I sit today I'm absolutely sure we can do really well with our car."GM-Holden's Elizabeth plant in Adelaide is gearing up for the local Cruze, which will start production next year and include a hatchback version of the small sedan.
Read the article
Audi A4 2009 review
By Neil McDonald · 12 Aug 2009
Pedigrees do not come much better than Audi's 2.0-litre TFSI engine. It won its category at this year's engine ‘Oscars’, having been voted best-in-class in the 1.8 to 2.0-litre category. But what does all that mean for consumers?Unlatch the bonnet and they will find this turbocharged engine in the engine bay of many Audi models. It is available in various tunes from 125kW to 188kW in the A3 Sportback, A3 cabrio, S3, A4, A5, A6 and Q5.In its most potent form it develops 200kW in the TTS coupe with S-tronic. The award cited the turbo's match of power and economy. There's no doubt that combined with Audi's seven-speed S-tronic gearbox, the engine is a blast to drive in the newest $73,900 A4 sedan 2.0 TFSI.After a week pedalling the A4 quattro fitted with the 155kW/350Nm turbo four; buyers looking for performance but with an eye on the hip-pocket at the petrol pump will appreciate this modest drinker.Audi quotes a combined fuel economy figure of 7.4 litres/100km. That seems achievable but when you use the available low-down performance as we did, economy takes a back seat. With the 350Nm available from just 1500 revs the A4 will slingshot away from traffic lights with the single mindedness of a racing greyhound.There are no real surprises with A4's S-tronic gearbox, essentially Audi's version of a dual-clutch transmission. The S-tronic is well matched to the turbo four and reacts quickly and seamlessly once under way. But like many of the newer dual-clutch gearboxes, it still has momentary lapses in concentration at idle, a bit like a seniors' moment.The well equipped A4-2.0 TFSI combo is at the top end of Audi's mid-size lineup. Like most of the German brands though, the sting is with the options, the most outrageous being $1695 extra for metallic paint.Adding some spice with the $1695 18-inch alloys, $3390 for the navigation package, Audi's $3390 drive select with adaptive dampers, $1324 for side assist and $318 for high beam assist catapaults the price to more than $85,000. But even at this price the 2.0 TFSI is a worthy thoroughbred.
Read the article
Tax break bolsters sales
By Neil McDonald · 12 Aug 2009
Although the market was still down 10 per cent last month compared to July 2008, small cars and off-roaders showed sales gains. The Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries credits the sales gains on a flow-on effect of the Federal Government's small business tax break on new equipment.Even sportscars were up, thanks to newer entrants arriving into the market. In all 75,333 vehicles were sold last month compared to 83,976 in July last year. Small car sales were up almost 3 per cent while the medium and luxury off-roader segments were up 4 per cent and 7 per cent.Some brands like Mitsubishi are reporting stock shortages of key vehicles like the Triton because of demand created by the tax break. FCAI chief executive, Andrew McKellar, says the tax break for small business has been a successful stimulus measure. "And small businesses remain eligible for a 50 per cent tax break until the end of the year," he says.The humble Toyota Corolla again knocked the country's favourite family sedan off the best-seller list - the fourth time in 18 months it has turned the tables on Holden's locally built six. The Toyota four-cylinder eclipsed the Holden Commodore by just 35 cars to become the biggest seller. The Japanese carmaker sold 3856 Corollas versus 3891 Commodores last month.Some surprises were the new Toyota Prius, which had is best sales month ever on the back of the launch of the third-generation car with 446 government and private sales. The Holden Cruze also leaped out of dealers, with 1982 sales while Hyundai's popular Getz and i30 continue to sell well, along with the Mazda3. Chinese brand Great Wall Motors got off to a modest start, selling 274 utilities.Sportscars experienced a sales lift of 10 per cent last month on the back of new entrants among the luxury imports. Premium brands like Alfa Romeo, Audi, BMW, Lexus, Porsche, Volvo and Volkswagen all recorded slight July sales gains over the same month last year. Overall, 530,556 new vehicles have been sold so far this year, down 15 per cent or 96,115 vehicles, compared to the same period last year.Toyota has extended its overall sales lead with 110,897 vehicles, giving it a 24 per cent overall market share. Its lead is almost double that of its nearest rival, Holden with 66,418 sales with Ford in third spot with 54,239 sales. Mazda and Hyundai fill out fourth and fifth spots with 44,627 and 36,161 sales.Top Ten sellers (July) 1 Toyota Corolla 38912 Holden Commodore 38563 Ford Falcon 28374. Mazda3 27855 Toyota HiLux 25636 Hyundai Getz 21477 Mitsubishi Lancer 21298 Hyundai i30 20459 Holden Cruze 198210 Toyota Camry 1717Top Ten brands (July) 1 Toyota 16,6642 Holden 10,2663 Ford 77834 Hyundai 62265 Mazda 60246 Mitsubishi 41667 Nissan 37568 Subaru 28079 Honda 265710 Volkswagen 2361
Read the article
My 1970s Mini and Moke
By Neil McDonald · 11 Aug 2009
"Even 30 years down the track there is hardly anything that handles as well, except perhaps the new Mini,"he says. Apart from being a Mini historian, Watson is a publisher of a quarterly magazine called The Mini Experience, which he started in 2004. Watson's magazine is the country's primary resource for all Mini enthusiasts and it has an eager following with more than 1200 subscribers. Fittingly his daily driver is a 1976 Mini van, which shares his garage with a 1972 Mini Moke. "They are a barrel of fun to drive," he says. "It's got the grin-factor. Every time I get behind the wheels I break out in a grin. As long as its well maintained there are very few cars on the road today that can compare." Watson's was one of several hundred Mini owners who attended a birthday bash for the car last weekend organised by the Victorian Mini Club. Of the more than 5.3 million Minis sold, 200,000 buyers were in Australia, with production here ending in 1978. The car was the brainchild of engineer and designer, Sir Alec Issigonis, who famously drew the prototype on a tablecloth. The project was initially called the Austin Design Office Project 15 (ADO 15) .When he sketched out his ideas, Issigonis made sure the car had a wheel at each corner to free up interior space, micro 10-inch tyres and east-west engine with a gearbox design that shared engine oil. The original design was also about 300mm narrower than the final production car. It is said that when the final prototype was build, Issigonis was not happy with its proportions and suggested it be cut in half longitudinally and widened. The extra width ultimately helped its proportions and gave the car a better on-road stance and its famous sporty handling characteristics. He also wanted 80 per cent of the 3m car to be for passengers, a task he achieved. Although front-wheel drive cars were already on roads, Issigonis took the concept further. He mounted the engine transversely to drive the front wheels, with the radiator at the side and then placed the transmission underneath. The British Motor Corporation started Mini production on August 26, 1959. It was launched in two versions, the Morris Mini Minor and the Austin Seven and cost less than 500 pounds. Australian versions followed at BMC's Zetland plant in Sydney in 1961. The Mini was initially sold as a bare-basics car with few luxuries. To help trim costs the original had sliding windows, external body welds and minimal creature comforts. Issigonis, who was a smoker, put an ashtray into the car but there was no radio and a heater was not available until the 1961 model arrived. Despite being a smash hit, the first European examples had a few problems that would spell an instant consumer backlash and recall today. Ventilation was initially a problem as the rear hinged windows would not stay open, exhausts were fracturing because they lacked flexibility and if it rained the cabin could be flooded. All this did not matter though. People were crying out for low-cost motoring and as soon as the Mini arrived in showrooms it was a sellout. It started a craze and became the car to own for people from pop stars to British royalty and appeared in cameo roles in various films, including The Italian Job. It also spawn a range of models including a van, wagon, ute and the hotter Cooper series. The Mini's compact rubber-cone independent suspension and a wide track allowed safe, responsive handling that later won races, including a swag of Monte Carlo rally wins. Of the locally built Minis about 26,000 were Mokes, a quirky open-air car that defied description and initially started life to be a British military vehicle. Watson says despite the fact that the Mini has been around in Australia for just as long as the UK versions, little has been written about it. "There's lots of information available about the English cars," he says. "But I'm still finding out stuff about the locally built cars." For example, the Moke was originally designed and built in the UK but it was never popular. Only 10,000 were built in the UK and about 90 per cent were exported to countries including Australia. BMC's Australian operations grabbed the opportunity to assemble the cars here and in 1968 Australia became the sole builder and supplier. The Moke was something of a success locally and was subsequently exported to 80 countries. Watson also says there is some myth about whether the Mini was a profitable car. "It was always said that the Mini was a low profit, or no profit car," he says. "Ford apparently stripped one down and said that if it had built the Mini it would have lost 30 pounds on each car." Watson believes that it's possible the entry bread-and-butter model would have lost money. "But very few people bought the base car," he says. "The Deluxe and premium models like the Coopers were very popular and profitable." Watson says little is known about the first six Minis brought to Australia in 1960, except that they were not pre-production cars. "They were all early production cars, built in February 1960 and arriving in Australia in June or July," he says. "Assembly of Australian Mini's began in January 1961, which is why many people believe these first six cars were pre-production models. Although they were pre-production Australian cars (our Minis differed in numerous ways from the UK Mini, from the outset) I believe that none of those cars still exist." Watson has tracked down one of these cars, which has been restored and is now owned by a private collector in Queensland. It is generally accepted that the original Mini is one of just a handful of cars that have reach such an iconic status. It joins the original VW Beetle, Citroen 2CV and Model T Ford as having introduced low-cost mobility for millions of people. The original ranks number four as the world's biggest selling car and was Britain's best selling car ever. The VW Beetle managed 21 million, the Ford Model T 15 million and the Renault R4 eight million. Today's Mini may be light years away in cost and equipment, but the original is credited with starting a small car revolution. Low mileage originals in the UK are still sought by many and can fetch from $15,000 up to $30,000 for some of the limited edition and original Cooper S models.
Read the article