Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Subaru Liberty Problems

Are you having problems with your Subaru Liberty? Let our team of motoring experts keep you up to date with all of the latest Subaru Liberty issues & faults. We have gathered all of the most frequently asked questions and problems relating to the Subaru Liberty in one spot to help you decide if it's a smart buy.

Ask Smithy Xtra squeaky Subaru Liberty Sport

The only thing you can do is put pressure on the dealer and Subaru to sort the problem out. Perhaps other owners can let us know if they have the same issue with their cars, and what they were told by their dealers.

Steering Shudder in Subaru Liberty RX

If you haven't had the brakes checked, do so, as it could be the brake rotors causing your steering shudder. I wouldn't be expecting to rebuild the suspension as such, although you could have a suspension specialist check the shock absorbers for you. Likewise, I wouldn't be expecting the auto to pack up just because it's racked up 100,000km, particularly if it's driving normally without a sign of a problem.

Whirring noise in 89 Subaru Liberty

When new the Liberty would get around 12 L/100 km on average. If the whirring noise is heard when you depress the clutch pedal it is most likely a clutch throw-out bearing, if the clutch is worn it will be taking up near the floor and you might experience some crunching of the gears. The clicking noise you hear when turning is probably the CV joints, which probably need replacing.

Weighty Question

THE 2006 Liberty 2.5 has a towing capacity of 1400kg with a towball weight of 90kg, or 140kg with a load distribution hitch. I would think it's probably OK, but to determine its capacity to tow your camper trailer, you have to know how much the trailer weighs when loaded to the gunnels with all the camping gear you plan to take with you. If you want to know how much it weighs in that condition, load it up and take it to your nearest weighbridge.

Six of the best

I'D GO for the later model with the lower kilometres. Five years from now the Liberty will be 10 years old and probably have 125,000km on it, but the Mazda will be six years old with about 110,000km on its odometer. The Mazda will look much more attractive to buyers.

Used Subaru Liberty review: 1991-1994

All-wheel drive is all about safety in all weather conditions on all road types, but almost as soon as those wonderful attributes were identified some rally tuner realised it also had enormous potential for rallying. It was about then that the all-wheel car went from a nice safe family car to a hotter-than-hell performance machine and we had some of the hottest special edition models, like the Subaru Liberty RS Turbo, appearing in our showrooms.

At first it was a limited edition model available to rally competitors by way of special order, but such was the demand for it that Subaru released it for general consumption. Before the WRX with which the company is so closely identified, the RS Turbo was already attracting the attention of rally enthusiasts.

MODEL WATCH

Subaru was in a period of transition in the early 1990s. Apart from its all-wheel drive models Subaru was producing cars that were struggling to stand apart from the small Japanese crowd, but in a moment of marketing genius the company decided to become an all-wheel drive only company. It was a masterstroke, one from which the company hasn’t looked back.

In late 1991 when the RS Liberty Turbo sedan was launched it looked much like its more mainstream cousin. If it wasn’t for the alloy wheels, sports rubber and modest rear wing you wouldn’t know you were looking at anything but a regular Liberty sedan. It’s not until you drove the RS Turbo that it became clear, instantly clear, that this wasn’t a family shopping trolley.

If you dared bury the right foot in the carpet the RS Turbo’s blown 2.0-litre quad-cam flat four responded with nearly 50 per cent more power and almost 40 per cent more torque than the naturally aspirated 2.2-litre engine that lurked under the standard Liberty’s bonnet. Peak power was 147 kW at 6000 revs while the torque curve reached its maximum of 260 Nm at 3600 revs.

To achieve the increased output Subaru beefed up the cylinder block, added four-coil ignition and added a liquid-cooled turbocharger and liquid/air intercooler. It then fed it through a five-speed manual gearbox and centre and rear differentials to all four wheels for a thrilling drive well beyond its modest looks suggest it’s capable of.

Given its head the RS Turbo Liberty would run hard and fast. It was capable of reaching 100 km/h in seven seconds, the standing 400-metre sprint was dismissed in 15 seconds, and it would reach 215 km/h if pressed all the way in fifth gear. As you might expect with its rally credentials, the RS Turbo LIberty was a delight on the road. It handled fast and slow corners well, was very precise and could change direction easily. The ride, while firm, wasn’t uncomfortable and soaked up bumps and potholes without being upset.

The brakes were perhaps an area for criticism. While discs were employed at all corners it lacked the added safety of ABS anti-skid electronics, which would definitely have been a bonus on a car of such high performance.

Inside, the RS Turbo LIberty offered the full accommodation of a regular four-door with quite good headroom, good legroom and foot space, even for tall occupants. The cloth-trimmed seats were both supportive and comfortable, there was a footrest for the driver’s left foot and an adjustable steering column.

Standard equipment included air-conditioning, power windows, mirrors and antenna, central locking, cruise, and there was an optional sunroof. The sound system was an AM/FM radio cassette with four speakers. A wagon version was released in 1992.

IN THE SHOP

The RS Liberty Turbo is at least 12 years old now, the last leaving dealerships in 1994, which means they will have racked up plenty of kays, some of which could well have been very hard ones. On average an early car will have done over 200,000 km, a later one around 170,000 km, but Subaru reliability is such that high kay cars can still be worth taking on.

Some early cars had rattling valve lifters that were fixed on complaint by Subaru, but some might have slipped through the system and owners have to try and find a solution themselves.

The body is fairly sturdy and stands the test of time well. Look for the usual car park dings, which are inevitable if the car has been driven daily.

Many have been modified for more performance or handling so look carefully for mods and make sure they have been well done by professionals who know what they’re doing. Also make sure those modifications don’t adversely affect the things that matter to you.

Fitting aftermarket springs and shocks, for instance, can make the ride hard and uncomfortable which diminishes its appeal as a family tourer. Look carefully for engine modifications, which might have boosted performance, but cut the reliability. Again seek expert help before buying a heavily modified car. Before you take on a car that has been modified check to ensure the modifications are legal rather than risk getting stuck with a car that doesn’t comply with the law.

IN A CRASH

Primary safety is the all-wheel drive RS Turbo Liberty’s great suit. Its handling in all conditions, boosted by its rally suspension is the perfect recipe for extracting yourself from a dicey situation. Airbags weren’t offered, but secondary safety comes down to its sturdy body construction.

OWNERS SAY

Dave Shephard has owned two RS Turbo wagons. The first was written off a few weeks after he bought it, but the second now has 260,000 km on it. When he bought them he was looking for a car with performance, but could still swallow his kite surfing gear. He says it’s a perfect compromise, a mix of power and performance with Subaru reliability.

Oliver Lever says the RS Turbo Liberty is a fantastic car for the young enthusiast or the family. Like all cars, he says, they have their shortfalls, which in the case of the RS Turbo Liberty is the gearbox. He says there’s plenty of information on them, parts are readily available, and their modest looks means they don’t come in for regular attention from the police.

Matthew Pyman has owned a 1991 RS Turbo for a year and says he has never been happier with any previous car. It is, he says, a dream to drive. He loves the handling, the rumble of the boxer engine, and the overall thrill of the drive.

Jarrod Power has owned his RS Turbo Liberty for three years. The great thing about them, he says, is that while they are quite attractive, and can be improved upon easily by lowering them and fitting a set of alloy wheels, they don't attract the attention of the police, which allows you to enjoy the driving experience. The RS Turbo Liberty gets tick in every box with its looks, performance and cost.

LOOK FOR
• Rattling valve lifters
• Illegal modifications
• Great all-wheel drive handling
• Roomy interior for family
• Combination of performance and practicality
• Good build quality

THE BOTTOM LINE
Its all-wheel drive safety makes it a great learning car for young drivers to gain experience.

RATING
75/100

Read the article
Change for the better

Subaru says the factory-recommended interval is 100,000km or 48 months, whichever comes first. So after nine years the belt should have been replaced twice. Wear depends not only on distance travelled but also time, because rubber deteriorates and wear is accentuated by short-distance driving below normal operating temperatures. There is some tolerance for extending the interval at low kilometres, but Subaru makes no specified allowance for this. You are strongly advised, in the interests of engine durability, to change the belt now. By not doing so you're gambling against a failure, and that's not wise.

Under control

THE old practice was to avoid maintaining the engine at a constant speed during the run-in period, but it's not needed with modern engines. We asked Subaru for an opinion and they agreed the advice you received was misguided. You can use cruise control without damaging your engine.

Used Subaru Liberty review: 1994-1998

There wasn’t much hoopla surrounding the launch of the second generation Subaru Liberty in 1994. The previous model was safe and solid without being particularly exciting, and there was no reason to believe the new one would be anything but a competent follow-up with the same attributes. It was all of that, but it was also much better, and cheaper to boot. By the time the year ended the Liberty was widely regarded as the best new car of the year.

By the mid-1990s Subaru was facing extinction. Its cars were sound, but it was a minnow in the car making world and really didn’t have the wherewithal to survive in a highly competitive industry that thrived on volume.

A switch to all-wheel drive exclusively across all models in the mid-1990s, the runaway popularity of the hot rally-bred WRX, and an alliance with General Motors which will see an evolution of the Subaru all-wheel drive system under the Commodore later this year, kept the bankers at bay and the company thriving.

MODEL WATCH

The second generation (2GEN) Liberty was new from the floorpan up. The chassis and floorpan were refined and improved, but essentially they were carried over from the previous model. The major changes to the underpinnings came from the increased wheelbase, which was 50 mm longer than the first generation model.

While the LIberty was attractive it wasn’t leading edge in styling terms, but that was what helped make it appealing to so many. It was inoffensive to everyone, while at the same time it looked sturdy and reliable.

The front-wheel drive LX opened the eight-model range which was topped by the all-wheel drive Heritage 4WD. Available body styles were a sedan and wagon.

The added 50 mm of wheelbase was put to good use with all of the stretch going to increase the rear seat room, which was generous to say the least. There was also a benefit for front seat occupants as Subaru fitted longer front seat runners that allowed the driver and front seat passenger to slide the front seats back further. That way it was possible for taller occupants to find a comfortable seating position.

Loads of space in the rear of the wagon, and a large boot in the sedan added to the Liberty’s attraction as a family car.

The stiffer body contributed to the Liberty’s praised ride and handling, which was enhanced by a package of well tuned springs and shocks for improved wheel control. Along with well weighted, precise power steering, the chassis package had road testers putting the Liberty near the top of its class.

An unusual exhaust note signalled that the Liberty had something different under the bonnet. On inspection you found it was a flat-four mounted at the front.

With a capacity of 2.2 litres the ‘boxer’ four produced 94 kW at 5200 revs and 190 Nm at 4400 revs, giving it quite reasonable performance. Performance was improved in 1996 when a larger 2.5-litre version of the flat-four became available.

Liberty buyers could choose between a five-speed manual gearbox and a four-speed auto, both of which were highly rated, and there was the choice of all-wheel drive.

The LX was equipped with standard air-conditioning, body coloured bumpers, power door mirrors, power steering and radio/cassette sound. Airbags and ABS were optional. The mid-range GX also had alloy wheels, central locking, cruise control, power antenna and power windows. The range-topping Heritage was only available with the auto trans, but also had standard ABS, dual airbags, CD player, remote central/keyless locking, leather trim and woodgrain. The sporty Rallye came with a body kit and fog lamps.

IN THE SHOP

Subaru build quality is rated highly, with tight body construction and even body gaps, so they develop few squeaks and rattles in service.

Owners and mechanics alike report few problems with Subarus in general, and the Liberty in particular, with most visits to the workshops being for regular scheduled service.

Tyre life is generally good, with owners reporting up to 75,000 km before tyres need to be replaced. Likewise brake life is reported as good.

Engines, transmissions and drive lines are all regarded as robust and reliable with few problems reported from the trade.

While the 4WD system is highly respected for its safe handling it should be understood that it is an added complication that can lead to greater repair costs if something does go wrong. Before rushing in and buying a 4WD think about your reasons for buying it.

A 4WD system will be a safer proposition in everyday driving, giving better grip and handling on slippery surfaces, it may well get you out of a dangerous system that a normal two-wheel drive system won’t. But don’t buy it expecting to be able to go off road, because that’s not what the Liberty is all about. Use the 4WD system for added on-road security, but don’t be tempted to go bouncing down rough bush tracks.

OWNERS SAY

Pete Minahan has done 60,000 km in the ’96 Liberty Wagon he bought in 2001, bringing it to 150,000 km in total, and he’s very happy with it. He praises its road manners, ride, and handling, and likes the all-wheel drive, but criticises its road noise and inadequate adjustment of the driver’s seat. He’s had to do nothing except the scheduled servicing.

Mitch Miller bought a manual Liberty GX in 1998 and says he hasn’t looked back. He reports that he regularly gets 8.1 L/100 km/h on country trips, with a low of 7.7 when using PULP.

Graham Stewart has had his 1995 Liberty one year and he’s very pleased with it. Now with got 270,000 km on the clock he says it’s quiet and smooth with plenty of pickup when needed.

Ron Co has owned a ’96 Liberty GX auto wagon since new. It’s only done 75,000 km, and apart from regular servicing there has only been a couple of minor problems with the windscreen washers and the air-conditioning. He praises its AWD and says he experienced its value when he was forced off the road while overtaking a truck. “All four wheels were off the road, but we drove through it and back on to the road without a drama. It really hit me just how lucky we were to have been in the AWD Sub and not a 2WD of any sort.”

Merve McKnight’s ’98 LIberty RX came after a series of Nissan Patrols. He says he grins every time he drives it, and has travelled far and wide in the 114,000 km he’s done in it. He runs mostly on regular ULP because it’s cheaper, but says it’s more responsive on PULP. Merve describes his Liberty as an orgasm on wheels.

LOOK FOR

• safe handling from all-wheel drive models

• solid body construction stands up well in service

• good build quality

• ‘flat’ exhaust note from flat four

• roomy interior

Read the article
Disclaimer: You acknowledge and agree that all answers are provided as a general guide only and should not be relied upon as bespoke advice. Carsguide is not liable for the accuracy of any information provided in the answers.
Have a new question for the CarsGuide team?
More than 9,000 questions asked and answered.
Complete guide to Subaru Liberty
Complete guide to Subaru Liberty CarsGuide Logo
Reviews, price, specs and more