Articles by Alison Ward

Alison Ward
Jaguar XF 2010 Review
By Paul Gover · 24 Dec 2009
The arrival of the XF was a seachange moment for Jaguar and every fan of the British brand.  Life has not been the same for anyone since the classy mid-sizer landed, bringing a new style of design and a new commitment to class and quality for customers.It's no surprise that the XF has been a global winner for Jaguar, even during the Global Financial Crisis, and has also lifted it onto shopping lists which would previously have been reserved for Benz, BMW and Audi. And maybe Lexus.The high point of the XF development is the go-fastest model, the XFR, which is intended to lure people away from some of the most charismatic performance cars in the world, led by the BMW M5 and Benz's latest E63 sledgehammer.The deal is done with a transplant that puts a supercharged and direct-injection 5-litre engine into the nose of the XF, with 375 kiloWatts and 625 Newton-metres for R-car duty. It's easy to pick the car by its 20-inch alloys, a punchier front end, bonnet louvres, four polished exhast tips and a bootlid spoiler.Mechanically, the upgrade to XFR brings everything from quicker steering and giant disc brakes to an active differential and adaptive dynamics in the suspension.  The idea is to make the car much quicker - the 0-100km/h run takes 4.9 seconds - but also easier to drive and more responsive for people who enjoy their driving.But no performance sedan can live on its speed alone in 2009, so the XF also comes with a full list of luxury equipment including leather seats, automatic aircon, a Bowers & Wilkins sound system unique to the XF, as well as safety gear including front-side-head airbags, anti-skid brakes and ESP, with an iPod connector for the sound system.The XFR arrives as part of an upgraded 2010 XF range that gets upgraded engines, all with more go and less emissions, and even an acoustic laminated windscreen.But the cost of the XFR is considerable, as it comes in at a rampaging $208,450. That's right on double the price of the basic V6 XF, although it undercuts the E63 and M5 but enough of a margin to make it look like a bargain.Driving - Paul GoverThe XFR is, no question, the best Jaguar I have driven. And I've driven a few.  What makes it so good is the combination of a tight body, good looks, real quality and the sort of get-up-and-go that makes you want to go driving.It's also modern on the inside and suitably chunky with the R-car additions to the external bodywork, including the lovely grille work in the nose.The supercharged V8 gives the XFR real thumping performance, but the electronics and suspension work keep it easily under control. It's nowhere near as hard to handle as some early go-faster XK coupes, but lacks the fully-brutal impact of the latest AMG Benz.Actually, it is a pretty sweet package. It is happy to trickle in traffic but if you flick the switches to sport and take control of the six-speed auto with the column paddles it becomes a real driver's car.You can brake late with the classy discs, the nose follows the wheel without complaint, and it puts all the power on the road without bucking or resistance.The car is quiet, apart from some roar from the low-profile tyres, easy to park and has good cabin and boot space. It's not ideal in the back, where it's a bit short of legroom against the new E-Class, but is fine for family work.The driving position is very good and I love the touch-screen infotainment package, which is just about the best in the business. The B&W sound system is a real thumper, even if the brand is barely known in Australia.But I find the speedometer really hard to read, particularly with blue lighting in daylight, and something as quick as the XFR needs a digital speedo readout for Australia.I still find the gearshift controller a gimmick, but it is easy to use and gives most people a laugh.  The XFR can be very heavy on fuel, which is no real surprise, but generally it's ok in the 11-12L/100km range.I currently rate the XFR a little ahead of the aging BMW M5, although it is no match for the E63, which is an impressive result. But I still find myself wondering how the car will wear over time and if Jaguar has translated Ian Callum's excellent design work and its R-car fast parts into long-term quality and reliability.She says - Alison WardI have to admit I'm not the biggest Jaguar fan, so I rolled my eyes when the XFR arrived.  Why? I cannot shake the feeling that Jags are a bit unreliable, and the earlier XF I drove was a disappointingly sluggish drive.  There, that's the bad part mostly done.The good news is that Jaguar has improved a lot with this car. For me it's a headier mix of stylish fittings and sportier grunt.  It looks great.  Both sleek and sophisticated, just as the Jaguar name suggests.   It drives beautifully and gets going at the slightest hint on the accelerator.The comfortable leather seats, sexy swede roof and easy-to-navigate touch-screen display are well refined but I didn't see anything really new.It does have plenty of legroom and boot space which is a surprising bonus on its sporty external appearance. The attention to detail with the interior and exterior design will rival its competitors and so will its cheaper pricetag.  But would I buy one?  Maybe, or maybe not. The unreliability reputation reared its head again when I heard the rear suspension rattle after just four days on test. I worry about what else would start to hum and squeak given enough time.The 'James Bond' styled dial called a Selector (that I would usually call a gear lever) rises out of the centre console. Most men will love this feature, however I think its over-the-top, as are the air vents that also open when you start the car.The glove compartment has a secret silver button that was temperamental to open as well.  I could see these useless items failing in the future and I would hate to think of the costs to fix them.   Overall, Jaguar has done a great job here but I would say this car is definitely one for the boys.BOTTOM LINE: The best Jaguar since . . . forever, really.SCORE: 82/100Jaguar XF-RPRICE $208,450ENGINE 5.0-litre Roots supercharged V8POWER  375kW at 6500 revsTORQUE 625Nm from 2200 revsTRANSMISSION Six-speed automatic, rear driveBODY Four-door sedanSEATS FiveDIMENSIONS  Length 4961mm, Width 2053mm, Height 1640mm, Wheelbase 2909mm, tracks front/rear 1559mm/1571mmSTEERING Servotronic ``fast ratio'' rack and pinion power steeringSUSPENSION Double wishbone front; multi-link rearFUEL TANK 69.5 litresFUEL TYPE Premium unleadedFUEL CONSUMPTION 12.5/100km combinedWEIGHT 1891kgSPARE TYRE Space-saver spareBRAKES Anti-skid all-round discsWHEELS 20-inch alloysTYRES Front 255/35 R20, Rear 285/30 R20SAFETY GEAR Dual front, side, curtain airbags, bi-xenon headlights, active damping, electronic stability control, traction control, brake assist, active differential controlCO2 EMISSIONS 292g/kmRivalsAudi S6: 78/100 (from $204,900)BMW M5: 80/100 (from $241,816)Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG: 84/100 (from $234,900)
Read the article
Nissan Dualis 2009 review
By Paul Gover · 01 Dec 2009
It put the soft-roader under the microscope, trimming prices and aggressively repositioning the starting-price ST and luxury Ti.  Most importantly, it introduced a front-wheel drive model of the Dualis and pitched it as a grown-up hatch.Has it worked?  Well, so far this year Nissan Australia has sold 1472 Dualises, against the running total last year — all-wheel drive only, remember — of 2396. That's a slump of 38 per centThat's not an encouraging figure, even taking into account the impact of the economic crisis.  The Dualis remains a hard sell for Nissan and Carsguide does not really understand why, given the fact that it is a huge seller in Europe.It is a competent and roomy performer and the lower-cost front-drive model priced from $24,990 means it should be selling a lot better.  We suspect it's all in the name. Some buyers, swamped with the better- known compact off-roaders like the Subaru Forester, Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4, probably still think the Dualis is some type of kitchen appliance. Even the respected X-Trail SUV, for a few thousand more, overshadows the smaller Nissan.When Nissan Australia launched the all-wheel drive Dualis last year prices started at $28,990. Today the all-wheel drive ST is $2000 cheaper and the sharply priced front driver is in Corolla territory.You now can get an entry six-speed manual front-drive ST for $24,990 with the CVT auto adding $2500.  The all-wheel drive ST will set you back $26,990 while the luxury Ti front driver starts at $27,990.  The savings are even better on the AWD Ti with prices trimmed by $4000 for the manual and $3500 for the CVT.At $29,990 for the AWD manual, the Ti now undercuts its luxury competition.  For this money you get a comprehensively equipped crossover hatch with a 2.0-litre engine, five-star crash rating and loads of space.Nissan Australia's chief executive officer, Dan Thompson, says adding a front-wheel drive into the mix will lure hatchback buyers who want space and practicality but who do not need an all-wheel drive.  He is right but Nissan's approach is not new.Hyundai, Kia, Renault and Mazda all now have front-wheel drive versions of their crossovers.  You can get a Tucson, Sportage, Koleos and CX-7 without the heavy and expensive all-wheel-drive package.So the compact SUV segment is a cut-throat segment where buyers take no prisoners and Nissan is discovering this with the Dualis.  Despite the price cut, equipment levels remain unchanged, as does the engine lineup.The wagon's all-aluminium four-cylinder 2.0-litre petrol engine generates 102kW and 198Nm with acceptable rather than exceptional performance. With 188mm of ground clearance you're also less likely to crunch the bumper on high kerbs or gutters when parking.  For families, there is plenty of space in the back.The load area swallows 410 litres of luggage and with the 60/40 rear seats folded flat space grows to 1513-litres.  As the bread and butter version, the ST comes with cloth seats. The Ti gains leather upholstery and steering wheel, heated seats and six- stacker in-dash CD stereo.The Ti also gets steering wheel audio controls, Bluetooth, automatic headlights, rain sensing wipers, foglights, trip computer, front passenger under seat storage drawer, rear armrest and sliding front console armrest. When I first drove the updated Dualis I was impressed. The price was good, the package seemed right, and the car drove well on a brief sprint around the beachside suburbs in Sydney.  But ...Now I have driven it on home ground, as a Ti with CVT transmission, and I'm far less impressed. The Dualis wobbles around corners, the performance is dowdy, and I wonder how Nissan expects it to compete with a Toyota RAV4 or a Honda CR-V or the class leading Subaru Forester.For a start, it still maintains that it is a hatchback. And a car.  It's not, it's an SUV wagon and that means it has to compete with the other SUV wagons. And they are a tough crew with a lot of history and a lot of strengths.Looking deeper into the Dualis, the cabin is very roomy and - as tested at a bit over $30,000 - it has all the stuff you need. Leather trim, a punchy sound system, a reasonable-sized back end and space for three teenagers in the back.  It is easy to park, visibility is excellent and the weighting of the power steering, power of the aircon and function of the minor controls is all good. Just as you would expect in a Nissan.But it is very dozy when you pull away from a stop sign and, with the constantly-variable automatic transmission, the 2-litre engine never gets to show its best. It needs to be revved to get going but the gearbox works against you, even for highway overtaking.  I remember the manual being much better on the preview drive and it would be my gearbox choice.As for the front-drive package, no-one who drives the Dualis is going to miss the all-paw grip. It's never remotely challenged in corners and few owners will take it to the beach.So, overall, the Dualis is a solid contender but not a standout. There is enough good stuff about it to win people to the car, so perhaps the relative failure is down to the styling and name. I'm a bit confused by this car. It's supposed to be a small car but lots of the time the Dualis feels quite big.  When you stand beside the Dualis it doesn't seem that big, but when you get inside it's really roomy. There is plenty of space for five, or a couple of youngsters in the back with all their toys.The leather seats are nicely designed, and comfortable. But you can feel the cheapness as soon as you open the boot, just looking at the finish and smelling the cabin.When you start driving, particularly in a tight corner, it feels really big and that's not something I like in a small car.  When go around a corner you feel like you're driving a tank. But it has a really good turning circle because it is only a little car.  And I felt like I was driving it with the handbrake on the whole time. Maybe the turbo wasn't cutting in - but it doesn't have one - so it could be the slightly-strange CVT transmission thing.  I hate that the locking for the doors is in the centre console and what's with the seat heaters in Australia? Wouldn't it be better to have an automatic boot release or a latch to let the seats fold down from the boot instead?For me, it is actually quite a good car for the starting price. And versatile too. But I don't think it's as good as some of its opposition, including the Subaru Outback.THE BOTTOM LINE: Not a bad car, but not a threat to the class champions.
Read the article