Neil Dowling
Contributing Journalist
29 Aug 2011
4 min read

Porsche Cayman S and Lotus Evora S go head-to-head in this comparative review.

value

Porsche Cayman S

from $147,500

Clearly, it's not cheap. You don't buy really good stuff on the cheap. Be aware that if you're new to Porsche, there's no gloss and baubles - the car is simple in appearance yet there's a lot of clever engineering underneath. The standard kit includes Porsche stability management, rear park sensors, sat-nav with nine-speaker audio, cruise control and 18-inch alloys. The options list contains 103 items.

Lotus Evora S

from $149,990

New Lotus importers Ateco have reduced prices so the Evora range is significantly cheaper. The "S" - for supercharged - is new. It's also loaded with gear - previous option list contents have been tipped in to become standard fare - which makes it better value than the Cayman. Standard stuff includes deep-pile carpet, heated seats, 125mm touch screen with sat-nav, front and rear park sensors, and leather upholstery.

design

Porsche Cayman S

Pretty hard to mistake this as a Porsche. Mid-engine placement lets the wheelbase stretch out and minimise overhangs - contrary to the tail of the 911 - and puts all the weight at the centre of the car and down low. Perfect handling is the result. Cabin room is reasonable but personal storage is poor. Front boot has a deep area to accommodate some hard luggage while rear boot - above the transmission - is suitable for smaller, more flexible cargo. Like cash.

Lotus Evora S

The Coca-Cola hipline, deeply recessed radiator outlets and sloping tail scream sports car. It looks great and that extends to the inside where everything is kept simple and cleanly styled - similar to the fuss-free design of the Cayman. But the shape creates poor rear and side visibility for the driver and the race-car bonnet vents take away prospective luggage room.

technology

Porsche Cayman S

Legendary and technically enlightened Porsche flat-six engine delivers 235kW/370Nm for a 0-100km/h time of 5.2 seconds and a fuel economy average of 9.6 L/100km. Dual-clutch (called PDK) version is a tad quicker but some of the fun is missing. The steel -bodied coupe is only 1350kg with weight saving achieved by forged and cast alloys in the drivetrain and suspension.

Lotus Evora S

Even Lotus boss Dany Bahar isn't happy with his current flagship using a Toyota Aurion engine. Truth is, a sports - oriented engine would befit the Lotus badge but the 3.5-litre V6 - with its Australian supercharger on top - is smooth, flexible, sufficiently engaging and even fuel efficient. Pity you can't see the beautifully made cast-alloy suspension arms. The remote ignition/entry system never works properly and is rubbish.

safety

Porsche Cayman S

Six airbags plus electronic chassis and brake systems indicate passenger safety is up there with the best, though the car has not been ANCAP crash tested.

Lotus Evora S

Exotica doesn't get crash tested so, like the Cayman, there's no ANCAP rating on this. However, it has all the brake and chassis aids and gets four airbags.

driving

Porsche Cayman S

Cayman S is beautifully simple and always feels totally composed and so easy to drive. Ride is firm, as you'd expect, and potholes will hurt you. But anything above a reasonable road surface - particularly one on a winding route - is sheer joy. Few cars can keep up with it over a tight course. It's one of those rare cars that bonds with the driver, making the relationship as one. The more powerful "S" Cayman rewards with extra oomph but you'll still crack a smile in the base Cayman.

Lotus Evora S

Despite the Toyota drivetrain, this is a die-hard sports car that only makes a few compromises when it picks up a registration plate. It's quicker than it first appears, has a very rigid chassis and has excellent roadholding with a flat-as-a-tack body through the corners. You feel all the stones in the road surface through the magnesium steering wheel and vibrations through your body and feet. Easy to drive but demanding to drive quickly. Possibly you'll love it but your partner may not get the attraction.

Verdict

Porsche Cayman S

Lotus Evora S

Basically, you'd be more than happy with either. But while the Porsche is undoubtedly easier to live with, probably more reliable and certainly better built, it isn't exactly rare. Anyone with money can park it in their driveway. The Lotus requires more skill to drive, more risk to own, can be a pain to live with and yet rewards with a rawness and simplicity that really is the soul of a sports-car.

Neil Dowling
Contributing Journalist
GoAutoMedia Cars have been the corner stone to Neil’s passion, beginning at pre-school age, through school but then pushed sideways while he studied accounting. It was rekindled when he started contributing to magazines including Bushdriver and then when he started a motoring section in Perth’s The Western Mail. He was then appointed as a finance writer for the evening Daily News, supplemented by writing its motoring column. He moved to The Sunday Times as finance editor and after a nine-year term, finally drove back into motoring when in 1998 he was asked to rebrand and restyle the newspaper’s motoring section, expanding it over 12 years from a two-page section to a 36-page lift-out. In 2010 he was selected to join News Ltd’s national motoring group Carsguide and covered national and international events, launches, news conferences and Car of the Year awards until November 2014 when he moved into freelancing, working for GoAuto, The West Australian, Western 4WDriver magazine, Bauer Media and as an online content writer for one of Australia’s biggest car groups. He has involved himself in all aspects including motorsport where he has competed in everything from motocross to motorkhanas and rallies including Targa West and the ARC Forest Rally. He loves all facets of the car industry, from design, manufacture, testing, marketing and even business structures and believes cars are one of the few high-volume consumables to combine a very high degree of engineering enlivened with an even higher degree of emotion from its consumers.
About Author
Disclaimer: The pricing information shown in the editorial content (Review Prices) is to be used as a guide only and is based on information provided to Carsguide Autotrader Media Solutions Pty Ltd (Carsguide) both by third party sources and the car manufacturer at the time of publication. The Review Prices were correct at the time of publication. Carsguide does not warrant or represent that the information is accurate, reliable, complete, current or suitable for any particular purpose. You should not use or rely upon this information without conducting an independent assessment and valuation of the vehicle.