Neil Dowling
Contributing Journalist
15 Nov 2013
3 min read
Land Rover Discovery and Jeep Grand Cherokee go head-to-head in this comparative review.
 

value

Land Rover Discovery

From $68,545

Looks good on paper, then there's its iron-fist-velvet-glove reputation. Clear accent on balancing city and hard-core off-road work but can't match Jeep luxury yet. Durable package, sensible equipment. No capped service but a long annual/26,000km service interval. Resale: 63 per cent.

Jeep Grand Cherokee

From $71,000

Excellent. Awesome standard gear starts with perforated heated and vented driver's seat, heated rear seats, nine-speaker audio and dual sunroof - Overland looks a $100,000-plus vehicle. Probably more for the city dweller. No capped-price servicing and intervals are short (six months/10,000km). Resale: 61 per cent.

technology

Land Rover Discovery

The 3.0-litre V6 bi-turbo diesel (155kW/520Nm) is a detuned version of that in other Disco models. But eight-speed auto, five-mode Terrain Response and height-adjustable electronic air suspension remain. Two-speed transfer box is aided by an electronic rear diff and centre diff. Disco is rated at 8.5L/100km from an 82-litre tank. Vented discs all-round, steering is hydraulic assist.

Jeep Grand Cherokee

Mercedes-inspired 3.0-litre V6 turbo diesel (184kW/570Nm) drives through an eight-speed auto and two-speed transfer case. Jeep has similar off-road aids to Disco - five-mode Selec-Trac for varying road conditions, air-adjustable suspension and electronic and mechanical diffs. Steering is electric assist to squeeze fuel use down to 7.5L/100km from a big 93-litre tank.

design

Land Rover Discovery

Good-looking, with comfortable cabin. Seven seats are a family lure. Horizontal split tailgate adds to versatility while luggage capacity is up to 1192L. Logical dash design and electric park brake appeal as does ample storage. Side and front vision are good but lack of rear camera is a handicap.

Jeep Grand Cherokee

Sweet. Top-spec Grand Cherokee looks good on 20-inch alloys. Leather and wood cabin with big touchscreen is upmarket but seats only five. Beats Disco for cargo space (but not personal space) and has an electric tailgate. Foot-operated park brake is awkward.

safety

Land Rover Discovery

No crash test result. For the 2014 model year, Disco gets six airbags, rear park sensor, heated mirrors, auto wipers and electronic assistance including trailer sway control, rollover stability, hill descent and hill holder, traction and stability control. Full-size spare.

Jeep Grand Cherokee

No crash test result but it bristles with standard gear: seven airbags, blind-spot monitor, adaptive cruise, rear cross-path detection, trailer sway and rollover control, reverse camera and front/rear sensors and bi-xenon headlights with washers. Spare is full-size.

driving

Land Rover Discovery

Feels as solid as a rock and inspires more confidence than Jeep. Despite two turbos, has annoying lag at low engine revs. Eight ratios a big boon. Ride is firm but controlled though seats aren't as comfortable as Jeep. Excels in dirt, as does Overland.

Jeep Grand Cherokee

Perky engine betrays few diesel traits. Responsive and fuel-efficient, it is a joy to drive, mainly because the eight-cog box - helped by paddle shifters - enhances the engine's output. It's also quiet and very comfortable in traffic, on the highway and especially in some rugged off-road conditions.

Verdict

Land Rover Discovery

Jeep Grand Cherokee

Neil Dowling
Contributing Journalist
GoAutoMedia Cars have been the corner stone to Neil’s passion, beginning at pre-school age, through school but then pushed sideways while he studied accounting. It was rekindled when he started contributing to magazines including Bushdriver and then when he started a motoring section in Perth’s The Western Mail. He was then appointed as a finance writer for the evening Daily News, supplemented by writing its motoring column. He moved to The Sunday Times as finance editor and after a nine-year term, finally drove back into motoring when in 1998 he was asked to rebrand and restyle the newspaper’s motoring section, expanding it over 12 years from a two-page section to a 36-page lift-out. In 2010 he was selected to join News Ltd’s national motoring group Carsguide and covered national and international events, launches, news conferences and Car of the Year awards until November 2014 when he moved into freelancing, working for GoAuto, The West Australian, Western 4WDriver magazine, Bauer Media and as an online content writer for one of Australia’s biggest car groups. He has involved himself in all aspects including motorsport where he has competed in everything from motocross to motorkhanas and rallies including Targa West and the ARC Forest Rally. He loves all facets of the car industry, from design, manufacture, testing, marketing and even business structures and believes cars are one of the few high-volume consumables to combine a very high degree of engineering enlivened with an even higher degree of emotion from its consumers.
About Author
Disclaimer: The pricing information shown in the editorial content (Review Prices) is to be used as a guide only and is based on information provided to Carsguide Autotrader Media Solutions Pty Ltd (Carsguide) both by third party sources and the car manufacturer at the time of publication. The Review Prices were correct at the time of publication. Carsguide does not warrant or represent that the information is accurate, reliable, complete, current or suitable for any particular purpose. You should not use or rely upon this information without conducting an independent assessment and valuation of the vehicle.