2025 Subaru Forester Reviews

The hooligan of the SUV class has gone to finishing school. The turbocharged version of the fourth generation Subaru Forester has grown a little older, a little wiser and a lot more refined.It’s still an athlete at heart but it’s not wearing a tracksuit and runners anymore. It’s gone smart casual. The gawdy styling and big bonnet scoop have been replaced by a more subdued appearance, one that you could take home to meet the parents.For every customer that doesn’t like the new model because it’s too understated, Subaru reckons there will be several more who prefer it. The new Forester XT released this week has more power and performance than before, despite putting on 104kg in its middle-aged spread.Subaru has gone to great lengths to hide the air-cooled plumbing that helps give the car its huff and puff. (For the technically-minded, the cooling tract to the intercooler, still on top of the engine, is ducted out of view behind the grille). The only downside to the bigger, better, faster Forester is that the price has risen by about 10 per cent on both models. Ouch.VALUEThe previous Subaru Forester XT could be had for less than $40,000 but the starting price of the new model is $43,490 plus on-road costs. The price hike is due in part to the lack of a manual transmission this time around.The Forester XT is only available with an eight-speed CVT auto (replacing the old five-speed manual and four-speed auto). The starting price buys a sunroof, cruise control, remote entry, a rear view camera, Bluetooth phone control and audio streaming, dual-zone air-conditioning, privacy glass, roof rails and 18-inch alloy wheels.The top-line XT model trips over the $50,000 mark at $50,490 plus on-road costs (up $5000 from $45,490). The extra dough buys a remote-opening tail-gate, navigation, Subaru’s “eye-sight” crash avoidance system, leather trim (with electric adjustment for the driver) and an eight-speaker Harman Kardon sound system.There is no question Subaru has added a lot more equipment and technology to the new Forester XT but on first impressions the prices seem a little steep. With such fierce competition in the SUV market I wonder how long Subaru will hold these RRPs.At least Subaru doesn’t gouge, sorry charge, for metallic paint like most other manufacturers do (Mazda is another notable exception).TECHNOLOGYAll models come with an “Si drive” mode that enables the driver to switch between “eco”, “normal” or “sport” settings. The first slows throttle response (for snow), the second acts normally (for the daily grind) and the third reacts sharply and unlocks a manual gear selection mode (for those with a plane to catch), unleashing all available power with a dab of your right foot.For the adventurous types, a crawl function called “X-mode” will help negotiate steep climbs or descents off-road below 20km/h. The top-line XT model comes with a second pair of eyes – tiny cameras either side of the rear view mirror detect cars, pedestrians and cyclists. If it thinks you’re about to hit someone or something it will slam on the brakes in the nick of time.Radar cruise control is standard on the top-whack model, too. It has three pre-determined distance settings between you and the car in front, which thankfully can be disabled for those who find it leaves gaps for others to drive into.Another cool trick: the automatic tail-gate can be programmed to open to a certain height, so it doesn’t bang on the garage roof or bump the kayak.ACCOMODATIONThe new Forester XT has grown up and out, just like the regular models on which it is based. But here’s a boring fact you might like to know (but may never admit to knowing): the cargo area of the top-line model with the automatic tail-gate has 17 litres less cargo space than the standard model, because the electronic gizzards take up room behind the panels.But (drum-roll please) it still has a bigger boot than the last one: XT 422 litres, XT Premium (with auto lift gate) 405 litres, and 1457 with the seats down. . With five seats (with five adjustable head rests) there is plenty of room for heads, shoulders, knees and toes.Other good news: the quality of interior materials has stepped up a notch, although the dash (which you hardly ever touch) is softer than the elbow pad area on the doors. It would be better the other way around.The only serious blots on an otherwise impressive report card: the front and back seats are too flat and unsupportive, the steering wheel is a bit Plain Jane for a car with sporting intent, and there is no digital speed display to help keep your licence intact.Oh, and despite seeing itself as a rival to German car-maker Volkswagen, it doesn’t have auto-up power windows on all four doors, only the driver gets this luxury in the Subaru. Picky, I know, but people comment on this stuff!SAFETYSeven airbags (including one for the driver’s knee) give the Forester XT a five-star safety rating from independent auditors ANCAP. A rear camera is standard across the range, too, although the lines that guide you into a parking space don’t turn with the steering wheel, as some of the fancier ones do.I’m also going to include Subaru’s commendable decision to include a full-size spare tyre (in an era of space-savers) as a safety plus. Do you really want to be driving home precariously with one skinny wheel after a long weekend away? Didn’t think so.DRIVINGSubaru appears to have addressed most concerns with the previous model. The new Forester XT is quieter, more refined, better balanced and smoother to drive. Performance is about the same even though the car has put on 104kg. It now weighs up to 1647kg, which is almost as heavy as a Holden Commodore.The 0 to 100km/h times tell the story. The old model with manual transmission did the dash in 7.1 seconds, or in 7.9 with the archaic four-speed auto. The new Forester XT with its eight-speed CVT splits the difference, with a claimed time of 7.5 seconds.It still feels brisk enough, and the CVT (with small levers behind the steering wheel) is one of the better installations we’ve sampled. The Si Drive (which adjusts throttle sensitivity) may seem a bit gimmicky, but it has a purpose from time to time.I really like the new Forester XT; my only beef is the price, which is too high, and the cruise control, which is counter-intuitive until you’re tutored on how to use it. If you tap up or down, it adjusts speed in 5km/h increments (not 1 or 2km/h as in other cars). To creep up 1km/h at a time you need to hold the button. It’s easier just to tap the brakes and reset it.The air-conditioning also cuts in and out quite a lot, presumably as it flickers between trying to save energy and keeping you cool. Not the most controlled climate conditions.VERDICTOverall, though, the new Forester XT is a welcome change for the SUV class ruffian. But before you sign on the dotted line it is worth knowing that, contrary to what Subaru says, there are a number of compact SUVs that offer similar performance for the same or less money.Subaru Forester XTPrice: from $43,490 plus on-road costsSafety rating: Five starsWarranty: Three years/unlimited kmBody: Five-seat wagonDimensions (L/WB/W/H): 4595/2640/1795/1735Weight: 1629 to 1647kgEngine: 2.0-litre direct-injection horizontally-opposed four-cylinder petrol: 177kW/350NmTransmission: Eight-speed CVT automaticPerformance (0 to 100km/h): 7.5 secondsConsumption: 8.5L/100km

Subaru has been in the ‘compact SUV’ market since before that term even existed. The engineering-oriented Japanese marque pioneered all-wheel-drive passenger cars and station wagons over 40 years ago and remains a major player today.This early work by Subaru is paying big dividends today, because compact SUVs compete in one of the fastest growing of all market segments. Interestingly, this doesn’t just apply to Australia; buyers in many other countries are discovering how much sense it makes to own affordable, driver friendly compact SUVs.Which brings us to Subaru’s Forester, the midsize model in the extensive Subaru all-wheel-drive wagon range. So important is the Forester that Subaru Australia imported several pre-production generation-four Foresters to Australia to permit a select group of journalists to drive them on- and off-road this week. The new model won’t reach us downunder till February 2013.In an interesting move, all models in the Subaru Forester range have satellite navigation as standard. However, it’s a rather basic system with maps that look more like kid’s drawings than the real thing.New Forester can be specified with a 2.0 or 2.5-litre flat-four petrol engine, and a 2.0-litre turbo-diesel. However, only the 2.5 petrol can be specified with an automatic transmission, the others have a six-speed manual gearbox. The automatic is a CVT unit and Subaru’s engineers have done an excellent job of minimising the sometimes irritating ‘slipping-clutch’ sound and feel. Once that transmission is designed to sit behind all engines in the Forester range we are sure it will be a big winner.The fourth-generation Subaru Forester is marginally smaller on the outside but clever design means the interior is slightly larger in most dimensions. Rear seat passengers are the biggest beneficiaries and I found my six-foot frame could sit easily behind itself, if you know what I mean.As is the way with most latest generation cars the Subaru Forester is quieter and smoother than ever before, with cabin noise levels diminished to the sort of levels that used to require an expensive sedan to achieve. Luggage space is lost due to the installation of a full-size spare wheel in an area obviously designed for a space-saver. But given the number of Australian drivers who may take their Forester off road this is probably an acceptable sacrifice.We road tested the EyeSight system fitted to the topline Forester. Unlike other crash avoidance and mitigation systems, Subaru's uses cameras, rather than radar, in its operation. Anything that can be seen by the human eye will create an image behind the cameras’ lenses, whereas radar only works when its beams are reflected back from metallic or similar surfaces, so may not ‘see’ pedestrians, cyclists or animals.Though we never needed Eyesight for crash prevention we did witness the warnings it gave when we deliberately let our Forester wander out of its traffic lane. It was even able to see very vague lines at the edge of country roads, lines that had been all but worn away by age, harsh sunshine and vehicle tyres. Impressive, and a potential life saver in situations that may result in crashes typically classified as ‘unexplained single vehicle accidents’.We did some reasonably serious driving in hills near Canberra as part of the press launch of the Forester. Its ground clearance of 220 mm is greater than that of all its competitors, even of some dedicated 4WDs. So deep ruts and large rocks will seldom cause hassles. The electronic traction controls, tagged X-Mode by Subaru, are arguably the best we have yet experienced; sophisticated, non-intrusive and simple to use. However, X-Mode is only fitted to Foresters with automatic transmission, not on manuals.Downhill and uphill assist are controlled by the throttle and brake pedals, making them significantly more intuitive than the hand controls generally fitted. Even first time off-road users of a gen-four Forester will feel they are experts in the way the wagon responds. Having said that, it may be best that these people have some professional instruction before they become too brave and get themselves stuck.On sealed roads, the added ground clearance of the Forester isn’t a problem unless pushed far harder than is ever likely to be attempted by the typical owner. Even then the electronics will do their best to keep you safe.To say we are impressed by the latest Forester is an understatement. While competing vehicles in this class are becoming softer by the day, Subaru has stuck to its guns and produced a genuine off-road wagon. Even better, Forester’s on-road behaviour has been further refined despite the upgrading of its allroad abilities.Though the new gen-four Forester won’t reach us downunder till February 2013 it may be an idea to contact your Subaru dealer well before then as there is likely to be an initial rush by existing owners wishing to update. However, they won’t have prices at this time.

The original SUV polishes its credentials in the face of mounting opposition. Cheaper running costs and a superior automatic open the door to Subaru's fightback in Australia's toughest new-vehicle segment.Prices are kept low - thanks to a new entry-level model with a smaller engine - while the feature list expands. Even Subaru's safety-sharp and affordable EyeSight driver assistance package is standard on the top model. But Subaru is aware that rivals have been busy. Honda punched out a new CR-V last month, Toyota will show its new RAV4 in February, there's a new Mitsubishi Outlander and a bigger-engine for Mazda's CX-5.But Subaru has an ace up its sleeve. Subaru Australia boss Nick Senior says it’s no pretender and is "the perfect city car for dirty weekends." While rivals trend away from getting dirty, Subaru ups the Forester's off-road ability.True, it has dropped the low-range feature from the manual gearbox models but there's a new electronic program - called X-Mode - that prepares the wagon for more adventurous dirt duty.VALUE Forester hits showrooms in February starting at about $31,000 - around the same as the outgoing model. But the spec is different. The new base model has the two-litre petrol engine from the smaller XV (and Impreza) models and comes only as a six-speed manual. Subaru Australia boss Nick Senior says a 2-litre CVT auto is on the cards, just not yet.The 2.5-litre version will come in at about $35,000 (prices aren’t known until January) and that’s the same engine as the current car. But though there’s been a bit of a price rise, the feature list is far bigger and the wagon is a much better ride.DESIGNThe platform is basically the same as the outgoing wagon, crimped here and there to flatten the central tunnel bump and stretched to add 25mm to the wheelbase and 35mm to the length. It's also 35mm higher, sits on a track that's up to 20mm wider and while body width remains the same, the doors are less bowed and the door trim is less obtrusive.Add in the windscreen pillars that are punched 200mm forward - the "cab forward'' design sprouted in the 1990s - and Subaru claims a much bigger, more airy interior and more room for rear seat passengers. The cabin gets soft-touch plastics and improved material quality and the look of the interior is now much more upmarket and better reflects the Subaru quality standard. There is an electric tail gate option on some models.TECHNOLOGYTwo problems, one solution. Forester previously has a reputation for a high fuel thirst without delivering much in the way of performance. The old four-speed auto is now out and replaced with the continuously-variable transmission used also on the Impreza sedan on which the Forester is based. Fuel savings are quite dramatic.The 2.5-litre manual version has a 8.1 L/100km thirst, a big improvement on the current wagon's 9.3 L/100km average. There's no power change to the 126kW/235Nm 2.5-litre four-cylinder petrol engine or 108kW/350Nm two-litre turbo-diesel, but there is a new entry-level two-litre petrol four - borrowed from the XV and Impreza - promising 110kW/198Nm.But, like the turbo-diesel model, it comes only with a manual gearbox. At least, for now. The X-Mode is an off-road package available on the CVT models. It cleverly juggles power individually to any of the four wheels with traction, incorporates downhill assist and adjusts ESC and traction control. Stop-start is standard on all petrol Foresters and is one of the reasons for the improved fuel economy.SAFETYSubaru is trumpeting a five-star rating and brings in the big gun with its brilliant EyeSight camera-based forward vision aid. First seen last year on upmarket Liberty models and similar to the Volvo City Safety, the Subaru program is standard on the ultimate Forester 2.5i-S model and optional on the penultimate 2.5i-L.It uses stereo cameras with 3D imaging to scan, identify and communicate with the vehicle's brake system to avoid frontal collisions, lane drifting and low-speed crashes. Used with the adaptive cruise control, it will lock onto the vehicle ahead and autonomously slow, stop and accelerate to maintain a safe distance.It also incorporates pre-collision braking, brake assist (enhances brake pressure), throttle management (stops accidental acceleration when an obstacle is ahead), lane departure warning, fatigue warning and start alert (warns when the car ahead has moved away). All new Foresters get seven airbags, more high-tensile steel in the passenger cell construction, aluminium bonnet, paddle shifters for the automatic versions and six-speaker audio with iPod/USB connectivity and Bluetooth.DRIVINGFirst up, the diesel. Train spotters will note that when it comes to the 2013 engine line-up, not much has changed. So the diesel remains punchy - but only in a relatively narrow opening between 2000rpm and 4000rpm. It can stumble below 2000rpm and is weak under 1500rpm.That brings to the surface the second problem - there’s still only a manual gearbox. Senior says a CVT auto diesel “is coming" but there’s no arrival date. The diesel is also still noisy, but mainly for people on the outside of the car. Inside it’s audible at idle but diminishes to silence at cruising. Compared to the outgoing model, the gearbox feels crisper. Compared with others in its class, it needs an auto but still drives with commendable ride comfort and on-road surety.The 2.5-litre petrol has been tweaked but only slightly. It’s the best choice. Previously, it was a thirsty beast that - in  automatic - was also a tired drive. Now it’s perky thanks to the smooth CVT box. It’s also quietened down the ride and brought it well within parameters set by decent mid-size passenger cars - an admirable boost to ride appeal and one that will further swing sedan buyers into the SUV sector.The 2.5 isn’t particularly revvy but has linear acceleration. It cruises particularly well and is quite adept at dismissing the effects of rough bitumen roads. On the gravel it is even more surprising, with excellent stability that defies the wagon’s height.VERDICTVery smooth and very surefooted manners mean this SUV is now almost in the upper-market mid-size sedan bracket for ride and handling.Subaru Forester Price: from about $31,000Onsale: February 2013Warranty: 3 years/unlimited kmResale: 58%Service interval: 6 months/10,000kmSafety: 7 airbags, ABS, EBD, EBA, TCCrash rating: 5-starEngines: 2.0-litre 4-cyl petrol, 110kW/198Nm, 2.5-litre 4-cyl petrol, 126kW/235Nm, 2.0-litre 4-cyl turbo-diesel, 108kW/350NmTransmission: 6-speed manual or CVT auto; AWDThirst: 7.2L/100km; 168g/km CO2 (2.0 petrol); 8.1L/100km; 187g/km CO2 (2.5); 5.9L/100km; 156g/km CO2 (diesel)Dimensions: 4.6m (L), 1.8m (W), 1.7m (H)Weight: 1498-1600kgSpare: Full size

Canny motorists are facing a shopping bonanza as car makers start slashing prices to make way for new models. But it's not only outgoing models going cheap - look out for end-of-year sales as well.Any time a carmaker trumpets a new model, these shoppers are there ready to make a financial killing by buying up the old model. Look for sales at particular times of the year. June is traditionally a strong month for squeezing extra savings out of a dealer though, with a buoyant car market and fierce competition, anytime towards the end of any month can deliver a bonus.End of year sales are popular. Dealers always want to sell but the months of November and December provide a chance to discount cars built in the current year. Fighting this are car buyers who want a car built in the new year to preserve resale value. Here's some deals but be prepared for more as the calendar year draws to a close.HOLDENDeep Purple is no longer a rock band - it's Holden's new colour that is available on a range of cut-price “Z-Series” Commodore sedans, utes and wagons. The new colour is the same as Holden's iconic show car, the Efijy. Different models in the Z-Series line-up get different equipment levels but, as an example, the base Omega automatic is $41,990 but the Z-Series edition costs $39,990.The bonus is that the Z includes a heap of extras within that price, including leather upholstery, 18-inch wheels, rear camera and sensors, leather steering wheel and chrome door frames. The SV6 ute adds 19-inch alloys, carpet mats and leather seats for $38,490, down $1000 on the plane-Jane SV6.The discounts on the VE Holden Commodore range precede the launch early next year of the VF Commodore models. Holden is also running out the Barina five-door manual hatch at $16,490, a saving of $500.TOYOTAYou'll have to do some legwork here. The new Corolla is on sale and some dealers still have stocks of the old model. Officially, there's no discount on the outgoing model though some dealers - predominantly NSW and Victoria - have extra stock and have advertised a $18,990 price, $1000 off the list price. Note that the cheapest 2013 Corolla is also $19,990. Toyota WA says customers should discuss pricing direct with their dealer.It's not only the Corolla that may offer savings. The RAV4 gets updated early next year and though there's no official price, dealers will consider offers. On top of that, Toyota has zero per cent finance on Camry, Camry Hybrid and Aurion until the end of the year.HYUNDAIThere's a lot of previous-model stock available from Hyundai and buyers can make big savings if they're not chasing the latest car. These include old-stock i30 hatchbacks with $2000 off the normal price and previous Santa Fe SUVs for up to $3000 off.But there are also current models. The big one is the $13,990 drive-away price on the i20 three door which saves $2500. A similar discount is on the five-door i20. The i40 wagon is now from $29,990 driveaway, a saving of about $3000, and the sedan model with automatic transmission is also from $29,990, saving about $2500.Hyundai's popular baby SUV, the ix35, is now from $27,990 driveaway for the Active version, a saving of $1120, while other ix35 variants have been reduced by $500.MITSUBISHIThe new Outlander SUV arrives November 18 so Mitsubishi is sweeping out current stock. The "Enhancement Pack" model is an LS version with leather seats, heated front seats and an electric-adjust driver's seat. It has Bluetooth, 18-inch alloys with a full-size alloy spare, six airbags for the front-wheel drive version (up from two) and a cabin styling pack with bright trim to the door handles, console panel and rear door trim.Prices start at $28,990 drive away for the LS front-wheel drive model with five-speed manual transmission. The normal price is $29,340 plus on-road costs so the saving is about $4500. But for buyers who want the new model, register on Mitsubishi's website and there's the chance to win a $1000 Westfield shopping voucher and 15 per cent off accessories for the new Outlander. If that's not tempting, Mitsubishi also has 0.9 per cent finance until the end of this month.SUBARUThe 2012 run out has just started for Subaru which has chopped up to $5000 off three models. It replaces its Liberty and Outback in early 2013 as a mid-life makeover that includes upgrades to trim specifications. There is an all-new Forester also due about February. So the deals are now on the table.The Outback 2.5i manual is usually $37,490 plus on-road costs (say, $5000) but is being rolled out the showroom door for $35,990 including all on-road costs. The same axe has lobbed on the Forester X which is now $32,990 drive-away including leather-faced seats, alloy wheels and fog lights.The normal retail price is $30,990 without the extras and without on-road costs. Subaru is selling the Liberty 2.5i sedan manual for $31,990 drive away with leather seats, electric driver's seat and reverse camera. The car normally sells for $32,990 plus on-road costs.FORDKuga Trend $35,490 drive away (normally $38,990 plus on-road costs) and the upmarket Titanium is now $41,490 drive away, previously $44,990 plus all on the road charges. The Kuga is to be replaced with a new model in early 2013.Focus Ambiente hatch now $19,990 drive away (normally $20,290 plus costs). The Mondeo Zetec hatch is $33,990 with all costs (usually $37,740 plus on-road fees) and Falcon's XR6 Turbo is down from $46,235 plus costs, to $43,490 drive away.KIAThere's a new Sorento SUV so the outgoing model has a $2000 gift voucher attached to its normal retail price.VOLKSWAGENIs running out stocks of the current Golf VI to make way for the Golf VII due early next year. Volkswagen Australia has set the price of the current Golf 77TSI manual at $20,990 including metallic paint and all drive-away costs. This is a saving of about $5000.The Golf Wagon 90TSI with DSG auto, metallic paint and all drive-away costs is now $29,990, saving about $3500. Note that for small-car wagon buyers, Volkswagen has not confirmed a wagon version of the new Golf. If you want this shape, this could be your last chance.VOLVOThe Swede is clearing out its 2012 stock by adding value rather than chopping the price tag. The S60 and V60 entry-level models now come with the upmarket Teknik pack valued at about $4500. But if you specify the Teknik model, Volvo will automatically give you the R-Design pack (valued at $3000) for free.The same deal applies to the XC60 SUV. There's also a deal on S60 or V60 from the dealer's existing stock. Volvo will include free scheduled servicing for three years or 100,000km.

Love them or despise them, the birth of all SUVs have their DNA in Subaru's Forester. It is the originator of the street-smart wagon that put on high heels and minced into the bush, creating a dual-use machine that Australians embraced like cold beer. In fact, Australians probably lit the fire that raged into the

Subaru chose to mimic its rivals when it revamped the Forester in 2008. It did so by making it bigger and taller while at the same time making it look more like an SUV.NEWIn doing so it made its SUV roomier inside, more refined and better equipped. The final result was that it was 75 mm longer, 60 mm wider, 110 mm taller and rode on a wheelbase that was 90 mm longer than the previous model.All of that meant it was roomier inside and had more space in the boot. The looks also changed, the new model boasting a smoother, more curved shape than the older, boxier model, and it rode 20 mm higher, which helped it fit in with the preconceived ideas of what an SUV should look like.What it didn't change was the boxer engine it used and the use of constant all-wheel drive, the latter in contrast to most of the Forester's rivals that continued to be front-wheel drive, except when the going gets slippery and the drive is then sent to the rear wheels as well.The 2.5-litre naturally-breathing horizontally-opposed 'boxer' engine was tweaked to give 5kW more power and 3Nm more power and torque respectively, not much it has to be said, but for more there was also the choice of a turbocharged version that gave quite a decent boost in performance for those who feel they need more.Subaru offered a choice of 5-speed manual or 4-speed automatic transmissions, the latter with the ability to be shifted by the driver. Subaru claimed the new model was more fuel-efficient, which was fine, although the numbers they quoted weren't all that great.But it was right on the money in terms of safety with a maximum 5-star ANCAP rating on the back of front, side and curtain airbags, ABS braking and stability control across all models. The model line-up began with the X and climbed to the turbocharged XT Premium at the top of the tree.NOWSubarus are generally well regarded by owners and that's certainly the message we get at Carsguide where few are moved to complain about their cars. The trade similarly gives them a tick of approval for their reliability and durability.About the only thing that crops up when we ask about Subarus in general, including the Forester is their tendency to consume oil. It's not something that is likely to cause a problem, but it is something that owners need to be conscious of and make sure they check the engine oil regularly, and top it up when needed.Forgetting to do it, or simply ignoring it, can lead to expensive repairs. When test driving an auto Forester observe for clean shifting and engagement of gears. It's a regular automatic and in many respects nicer to drive than the CVT transmissions most of its rivals now use. Check for a service record, nothing kills a car faster than a lack of servicing, and the Forster is no different to any other car in that respect.SMITHY SAYSBigger and better than the previous model, it ticks the family boxes.Subaru Forester 2008-2010Price new: $30,490 to $44,990Engine: 2.5-litre 4-cylinder, 126 kW/229 Nm; 2.5-litre turbocharged 4-  cylinder, 169 kW/320 Nm.Transmission: 5-speed manual, 4-speed auto, AWDEconomy: 9.3 L/100 km (2.5), 10.5 L/100 kmBody: 4-door wagonVariants: X, XS, XS Premium, XT, XT PremiumSafety: 5-star ANCAPCOMING UPDo you own a Toyota Yaris? If so tell us what you think of it by sending your comments to Graham Smith at grah.smith@bigpond.com or Carsguide, PO Box 4245, Sydney, NSW, 2010. 

Nissan X-Trail and Subaru Forester go head-to-head in this comparative review.

Ewan Kennedy reviews the 1997, 1998, 2002, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 and 2010 Subaru Forester as a used buy.

Living in a consumer-driven nation is Nirvana for those who are stress-free enough to dream and actually have the money to afford the dream.It has created an industry of dream makers - manufacturers who will, at a price, make you anything you want. And if you've ever yearned for more power for Subaru's perpetual Forester, you can stop dreaming.The S-Edition is the offspring that resulted after a one-night stand between a Forester and Subaru's performance arm, STI. It gets a massaged turbocharged engine and STI-inspired extras inside and out but retains the practicality and spacious cabin that have fortified Forester through a barrage of attacks by newcomers.VALUESleeping with STI isn't cheap. The Forester S-Edition is based on the XT Premium model but costs $5500 more because of the more highly-tuned engine, the five-speed automatic transmission (why don't all Subaru Imprezas get this?), a leather and Alcantara mix for the upholstery and a few other bits and bobs.Pretty much everything else is from the XT Premium's goody list, such as the huge sunroof, leather trim and top-notch radio/sat-nav system. But while it's comparative in price to similarly equipped rivals, the Forester doesn't look as stylish and the $50,990 doesn't translate into metal.DESIGNThis is where it all goes a bit wonky. The Forester is a very practical wagon that isn't made in Germany only because Subaru created the shape first. It's based on the time-old line drawing of two boxes - one big, one small - backed into each other and while some of us admire the pragmatic sketch, it's not stylish.It's also been around for a while. Against the Volkswagen Tiguan, Kia Sportage and Hyundai ix35 for example, it's dated. Effective, but dated. That aside, it has a lot of clever family-friendly features.I love the flexibility of the cabin - there's flip-up cupholders in the rear seat cushion, remote levers for lowering the back seat, and the back seats are higher than the front so kids have a clear view out the side windows.TECHNOLOGYSTI has either breathed more mumbo into the 2.5-litre turbo-petrol from the XT Premium or detuned the WRX engine. Regardless, it's the hottest box on the Subaru block with 193kW/347Nm, a jump from the XT's 169kW/320Nm. Yet fuel consumption is identical at 10.5 litres/100km average.Best news is the five-speed automatic from the Liberty. This is the only Forester with this box and Subaru goes the extra distance by equipping the S-Edition with paddle shifters on the steering wheel column. Cool.The rest is constant all-wheel drive, MacPherson struts at the front and double wishbones at the back. The S-Edition tightens up the screws in the suspension for flatter cornering and this means it misses out on the self-levelling rear end that's a feature of its sisters.SAFETYFive-star crash rating, electronic stability control, six airbags and lots more little nanny aids in the electronics all make this one safe little truck. The high seat height is arguably a potential safety feature, as is the full-size spare tyre.DRIVINGThis was driven back to back with the normally-aspirated 2.5-litre XS model with the four-speed auto. Pointless me talking about which I prefer. The S-Edition has a delightful linear bottom end that gets a kick about 3200rpm as the turbo becomes fully awake. It is, in fact, two engines.Drive it smooth and you'll get decent economy and no ugly photographs in the mail of you in the car. Give it a boot and it raises its head and really gets going. The bonus here is for overtaking, as in the country when passing a truck, for example. Not on the freeway.It's a nice drive but it's no WRX. Part of the problem is it feels like it's on stilts - which it is in comparison to the WRX - and there's some nervous jiggling and hints of some vagueness in the suspension and steering when the power is up.Personally, I'm not confident about pushing this anywhere near as fast into a corner as a WRX. That's not the aim. It's just a quick wagon in the same mold as the Mazda CX-7 turbo and some much more expensive Euro-wagons.VERDICTNo doubting this is a lot of fun. The auto is superb and really makes it an easy drive in the city. It's roomy, comfortable and well equipped but you have to ask yourself if there's value here particularly when there's the less powerful and (only) four-cog auto version in the XT Premium.Perhaps the S-Edition is for the WRX owners who just wants a bit of comfort. Or room for the kids.SUBARU FORESTER S-EDITION Price: $50,990Engine: 193kW/347Nm 2.5-litre turbo-petrolTransmission: Five-speed automatic, AWD Warranty: 3 years, unlimited kmResale: 54%Service Interval: 10,000km or 6 monthsEconomy: 10.5 l/100km; 248g/km CO2Safety: six airbags, ESC, ABS, EBD, EBA, TCCrash rating: 5 starBody: 5-door, 5 seatsDimensions: 4560 (L); 1795mm (W); 1700mm (H); 2615mm (WB)Weight: 1585kgTyre size: 225/55R17Spare tyre: Full-size alloyRivalsSKODA OCTAVIA RS 147TSI-compare this carPrice: $39,490Engine: 2-litre, 4-cyl turbo-petrol, 147kW/280NmTransmission: 6-spd DSG automatic, front-driveBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 7.7L/100km, 95 RON, CO2 179g/km MAZDA CX-7 LUXURY SPORTS Price: $45,990Engine: 2.3-litre, 4-cyl turbo-petrol, 175kW/350NmTransmission: 6-spd automatic, AWDBody: 5-door hatchThirst: 11.5L/100km, 95 RON, CO2 273g/km VOLKSWAGEN TIGUAN 147TSI - compare this carPrice: $42,990Engine: 2-litre, 4-cyl turbo-petrol, 147kW/280NmTransmission: 7-spd DSG automatic, AWDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 8.8L/100km, 95 RON, CO2 205g/km

AUSTRALIAN motorists love compact SUVs which have taken over as the new family vehicle. The segment is one of the few experiencing growth and it's no wonder with 25 models available with a range of variants with diesel power, manual and automatic transmissions, plenty of cargo space and room for a family of five and even their pooch.Today every maker needs a compact SUV in their range. Over at Volkswagen Australia managing director Anke Koeckler says:. "The Tiguan is one of the volume sellers in our plan to become a significant player in Australia."The current Tiguan's about to be replaced by a second-generation model and is in short supply as is the Toyota RAV4 so they couldn't make this comparison of five compact petrol-powered automatic SUVs that includes top sellers, a European and the two emerging Korean models.We asked the Tranter family - Ross and Julie and their children, Joshua, 7, and Samantha, 5 - to come with us for a drive through city traffic, highway touring, rural roads and a picnic in the country in our full-day comparison test. They own a Mazda2 and admit that in a couple of years they will look at an upgrade, possibly to a compact SUV.VALUEPricing and feature fit-out is keen in this highly competitive category. Our five vehicles are mid to high spec, according to what was available from the manufacturer, but they only vary in price by $5000 from the Hyundai ix35 at $35,490 to the Subaru Forester at $40,490 which comes with a comprehensive info/navigation/entertainment system with reversing camera.The Renault Koleos is listed at $36,990, but our test vehicle was fitted with a leather package ($2500) that includes black leather seats, electric driver's seat, heated front seats and quick-release rear folding seats. It also comes standard with a built-in Tom Tom navigation system, auto wipers, front and rear parking sensors, and a chilled glovebox.The top-spec Kia Sportage Platinum is fitted out at similar levels to the Hyundai. It costs an extra $1230 but adds rain-sensing wipers. Both have rear parking sensors, sunroof, rearview camera, auto headlights, fog lamps (front only on Kia) and heated side mirrors.In the middle is the X-Trail at $38,490 with roof rails, auto climate control and cooled/heated cup holders.All come with what are considered essentials in a family car these days - remote locking, cruise control, comprehensive stereo connectivity for Bluetooth phones and iPods, fog lights and climate airconditioning.Resale values are similar, but slightly better for the Renault and Subaru at 54 per cent and the lowest was the X-trail at 50 per cent.TECHNOLOGYAt the heart of all these models are four-cylinder petrol engines of similar capacity. Even though the Hyundai and Kia share a 2.4-litre engine compared with the 2.5-litre units in the others, power and torque are almost the same across the group.Power varies only 5kW from 125kW in the X-Trail to 130kW in the Koreans and torque 9Nm from 226Nm in the Koleos and X-Trail to 235Nm in the Forester. All models also offer a diesel variant which are worth considering for economy if you're doing long distances and for their driveability. The Forester transmission is an old-fashioned four-speed auto, while the Koreans have six-speed torque-converter automatics; the X-Trail and Koleos have continuously variable transmissions with six selectable steps.Most are front-wheel drive switching to all-wheel drive when they sense rear-wheel slip, while the Subaru is permanent all-wheel drive. All have hill descent control and hill-start assist, but only the Renault, X-Trail and the Koreans have a locking diff function.Economy is fairly close across the group but interestingly the X-trail is the best at 9.1 litres per 100km compared with 9.5L/100km in the Koleos which runs the same engine, but weighs about 80kg more. The Koleos also requires 95Ron fuel.If towing is important, the X-Trail and Koleos have 2000kg capacity compared with 1600kg in the Koreans and 1400kg for the Subaru.DESIGNThe group can be split into two on styling - the boxy Nissan and Subaru versus the more curvaceous Hyundai, Renault and Kia. It comes down to taste, but the Tranters liked the "modern" look of the ix35."I like a car with a lot of curves," says Julie.To us the X-Trail and Subaru are starting to look a little old-fashioned, even though both have had major makeovers only a couple of years ago. Of the "rounded" models the Kia has a little more pizzazz with LED daytime running lights and coupe-like rear roofline.Statistics for cargo space never give a real-world indication of how much luggage can be fitted, but with picnic baskets, esky and our photographer's kit bags loaded, all seemed to hold a fair bit of gear. The Renault is the only model with a split rear tailgate which Ross liked, but Julie thought it would make it more difficult to reach luggage items at the back of the cargo area. However she liked the underfloor storage area with slide-out tray in the Nissan."I'd probably use it as a permanent storage area for sunscreen, the kids' hats and snacks," she says.The X-Trail's cargo floor was the only one in the group not carpeted, a virtue according to Nissan for outdoor types. In the cabin, the Nissan again looked a little tired, while the others appeared modern and fresh, although the Renault is a little quirky and difficult to get used to all those knobs and controls. The Tranters found cabin space good in all but praised the Subaru for having the best legroom space in the rear for the kids in their booster chairs.SAFETYAs a fire and rescue officer, Ross Tranter places a strong emphasis on safety."There are things I've seen at crash scenes that I'd rather forget," he says.The Tranters own a Mazda2 and bought the top spec just for the extra airbags in the back, so they were impressed that all models, except the XTrail, get a five-star safety rating with full-length curtain airbags and stability control.They also commended all for their good forward visibility and praised the Kia and Hyundai for their reversing camera conveniently located in the centre mirror. There was high praise, too, for the high driving position of all, which at least gave them a feeling of safety.All vehicles come with three anchor points in the rear, but the Tranters found the Subaru was the only vehicle that was easy to fit the seats as the belt clasps were not spaced wide enough in the others. On the theft safety front, the Subaru also has Data Dot protection.DRIVINGIt was the Tranters' ninth wedding anniversary but they enjoyed our test loop through Brisbane city and out into the country for a picnic, then later McDonalds for the kids. Stepping up from their Mazda2 to the compact SUVs was easy for the Tranters who commented that they liked the high seating position and good forward visibility of all models.They liked the Subaru: easy to drive, plenty of room in the back for the kids, a big boot and a quiet and comfortable ride. They found the Hyundai a bit noisy on some surfaces, comfortable with a lot of extras they enjoyed but they didn't feel it was as stable as the Nissan in the dirt. Praise came for the Renault's handling and steering feedback."I didn't feel like I wasn't in total control at any time. It's not wanting for power either. I could put my foot down and it was there when I wanted it," Ross commented. Julie found the Renault's quirky controls a bit confusing to start with. And Ross didn't like the Kia's seat. "It has good support down low but not up high."We found the Koreans' automatic gearboxes had to work hard to keep things humming along, while the Forester, Koleos and X-Trail felt more lively and responsive, even the Subaru with its four-speed box. We're no great fans of continuously variable transmissions, but the CVT boxes in the Renault and Nissan are among the best we have driven and kept the revs in the sweet spot for difficult terrain.Most of these will tackle a rough bush track and even a beach, but be aware they are not meant for heavy duty off-roading. Subaru is fitted with Yokohama Geolanders which we have found the best compromise between highway and track. The Forester also has the best ground clearance at 220mm while the Koreans have the lowest at 170mm (Hyundai) and 172mm (Kia), but you should take into account a load and passengers will reduce these clearances.VERDICTIf rough country roads were on our agenda, we'd pick the Subaru or X-Trail as both vehicles not only handled the terrain with poise but also gave a feeling of being solidly built and reliable. The Renault has the same X-Trail underpinnings and urges you to have a go at the rough stuff thanks to a pretty slick engine/transmission combination and slightly more compliant suspension. It is a much under-rated vehicle with only 310 sold fo far this year.Most of the vehicles in this class are suburban run-arounds doing the grocery, school and sports ground circuit. Here, the modern styling of the French and Korean models look the part. For the record, the Tranters liked the style of the Hyundai but when it came to family practicalities their vote unanimously went for the Subaru for its space, comfort and quiet ride.SUBARU FORESTER 2.5 XS PREMIUMPrice: $40,490Engine: 126kW/235Nm 2.5L 4-cyl petrolTransmission: 4-speed auto, AWDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 9.3L/100km  CO2: 220g/kmSafety: 5 stars, 6 airbagsTowing: 1400 (braked), 750kg (unbraked)Warranty: 3-yr, unlimited kmService: 12,500 or 6 mnthsResale: 54%NISSAN X-TRAIL ST-LPrice: $38,490Engine: 125Kw/226nM 2.5L 4-cyl petrolTransmisson: CVT, 4WDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 9.1L/100km  CO2: 214g/kmSafety: 4-stars, 6 airbagsTowing: 2000 (braked), 750kg (unbraked)Warranty: 3-yr/100,000km, roadside ass.Service: 6 mnths/10,000kmResale: 50%HYUNDAI ix35 2.4 HIGHLANDERPrice: $35,490Engine: 130W/227Nm 2.4L 4-cyl petrolTransmission: 6-speed auto, AWDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 9.2L/100km  CO2: 219g/kmSafety: 5 stars, 6 airbagsTowing: 1600 (braked), 750kg (unbraked)Warranty: 5-yr, unltd kmService: annual or 15,000kmResale: 52%KIA SPORTAGE 2.4 PLATINUMPrice: $36,720Engine: 130kW/227Nm 2.4L 4-cyl petrolTransmission: 6-speed auto, AWDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 9.2L/100km  CO2: 221g/kmSafety: 5-stars, 6-airbagsTowing: 1600 (braked), 750kg (unbraked)Warranty: 5-yr/unltd kmService: 1-yr or 15,000kmResale: 52%RENAULT KOLEOS DYNAMIQUEPrice: $36,990 ($40,290 as tested)Engine: 126kW/226Nm 2.5L 4-cyl petrolTransmission: CVT, AWDBody: 5-door wagonThirst: 9.5L/100km  CO2: 228g/kmSafety: 5 stars, 6 airbagsTowing: 2000 (braked), 750kg (unbraked)Warranty: 5-yr/unltd km, roadside assistService: 1-yr or 10,000kmResale: 54%SHOWROOM SUCCESSSALES success in the highly competitive compact SUV category is fickle, changing every month. Nissan X-Trail was the leader in June, Hyundai ix35 in May, Subaru Forester in February, April and July, Toyota RAV4 in January and March.So far this year Subaru Forester is the top seller with 7574, even though sales are down 13.1 per cent on last year. This repeats its top-selling success in the category since 2008. The new Hyundai ix35 was second with 6806, RAV4 third (6472), X-Trail fourth (6430) and Dualis fifth (5156). Despite the Renault Koleos being a Nissan X-Trail with French dressing, it has sold only 310 so far this year to rank 20th out of 25 models in the category.The compact SUV segment is one of the few recording growth with an increase of 2.1 per cent so far this year while the SUV category is down 2.9 per cent and the total new vehicle market is down 5.9 per cent. The only faster-growing categories are luxury SUVs (317.4 per cent) and utes (6.2 per cent).SAFE AND GREENOWNERS of any of our tested vehicles can rest assured they are safe and green. They all have six airbags, stability control and anti-skid brakes as a minimum, while some have more driver aids such as Hyundai's Vehicle Stability Management which adds steering assistance in low-traction situations. All get a five-star crash rating from the Australian New Car Assessment Program, except the X-Trail which was last tested in 2007 and scored four stars.The Australian Green Vehicle Guide gives all vehicles better than average scores for greenhouse air pollution and economy. The Kia and Hyundai score closely because they basically have the same drivetrain. The Hyundai scores 6 greenhouse rating out of 10 and 8.5 for air pollution gaining four stars. The Kia scores a 5.5 greenhouse rating because its CO2 levels are 2g/km higher. Next is the Subaru with 6 for greenhouse emissions, 6.5 for air pollution for 3.5 stars and Koleos with 5.5, 6.5 and 3.5 stars. There are no results listed for the X-Trail.Most of these models have been around for a while in some shape or form and are good buying second-hand. Subaru Forester and Honda CR-V are the only used compact SUVs rated as a "safe pick" by the Automobile clubs of Australia. In their recent annual buyer's guide to used car safety ratings, they gave five stars to the Forester (02-08) and CR-V (02-06). Four stars were awarded to the Kia Sportage (98-03), Toyota RAV4 (06-09), Ford/Mazda Escape/Tribute (01-06), CR-V (97-01), Forester (97-02), Suzuki Grand Vitara (99-05) and RAV4 (01-06).