Solid state batteries are not the game-changing future of mass production electric cars, according to Audi powertrain engineers

Audi Q6 e-tron quattro battery production
Chris Thompson

Senior Journalist

4 min read

If you’re even slightly interested in electric cars, chances are you’ve heard that solid state batteries are the future, coming to save us from range anxiety and the slow decline in power retention that current lithium-ion batteries face.

But that might not be what really happens if senior drivetrain and battery engineers from Audi are correct in their predictions.

While it seems like some brands are holding back releasing a stable of EVs before the advent of mass production solid state batteries, senior engineers at the launch of the new Audi Q6 e-tron say it’s unlikely solid state batteries will be feasible as the basis of an electric car future.

Read more about solid state batteries

But rather than canning the idea of solid state batteries altogether, it seems that Audi is taking the approach that it’s too early to write off any one method of battery tech development.

As a brief refresher, most electric cars in Australia feature a lithium nickel manganese and cobalt (Li-NMC, or alternatively NCM) battery chemistry, which perform well in terms of charging and efficiency, but are relatively expensive and can slowly lose their ability to hold charge over time.

There is also a rise in the use of lithium-iron-phosphate (LFP) batteries, which are cheaper and don’t degrade as much over time, though they’re also heavier and less efficient. This tech is most commonly found in BYD's Blade batteries and entry-level Teslas.

Solid state batteries are lighter, use fewer materials, provide a longer range and are less dangerous, though their development is proving slow and they’re certainly not going to be cheap.

According to Audi battery development engineer Johannes Gehrmann, the physical precision required to manufacture solid state batteries means it’s unlikely they’re going to become the prevailing force in providing power to electric vehicles for at least the foreseeable future.

While he said it’s becoming increasingly difficult to find the next ‘breakthrough’ in battery tech, Audi isn’t putting all its eggs into the solid state basket.

While the tech, when employed perfectly, does provide plenty of advantages, it’s incredibly expensive and difficult to achieve on a large scale. One reason Gehrmann provided is that a solid state battery has the potential to expand very slightly with repeated high energy [use?] - not something that’s really acceptable when even a millimetre makes a difference in engineering.

It’s not that Audi doesn’t believe in a future for solid state, Gehrmann said the costs of proper engineering make sense for high-end models, and Audi has plenty of those. But the wider Volkswagen Group and rivals like Toyota or Hyundai Motor Group may end up going with another tech for their mass production models.

Despite VW currently running a program with its battery company PowerCo to determine the viability of solid state, Audi is apparently looking into ways to use LFP batteries in a more efficient way.

LFP batteries are currently used in some of the cheaper EVs on the market, and are particularly popular with Chinese brands, but if Audi is looking into the tech, it’s possible there’s more to be found in terms of their development.

Chris Thompson

Senior Journalist

CarsGuide’s Senior Journalist Chris Thompson has never had a ‘real job’ outside being a motoring journalist, which makes him the perfect candidate to inform you about everything happening in the world of new cars. Even as a teenager, while studying journalism at university and stacking shelves at a Brisbane bottle shop, he became a contributor to Unique Cars Magazine in 2014. There he specialised in covering classic car events and writing stories of his own and others’ car ownership. Shortly after packing up his 1992 VW Golf GTI and moving to Melbourne, he worked stints as Deputy Editor at industry titles Australasian Bus and Coach Magazine, and Farms & Farm Machinery Magazine under then Bauer Media’s umbrella, but being a full-time motoring journalist remained his goal. After a few months in Melbourne, he became the first digital journalist at performance car title MOTOR Magazine in 2017. He soon got to grips with the new car industry, becoming probably the youngest full-time journalist and road-tester in Australia at the time, at just 22 years old. A few years at MOTOR saw him become a seasoned reviewer with a particular skill for on-road assessment, as well as becoming adept at video presenting and finding and writing left-of-field motoring stories, sometimes at a rate of several a day. He traded track days and supercharged V8s for family SUVs and fuel efficiency tests when he transferred across the office to Australia’s longest-running motoring publication, Wheels Magazine. There he continued to hone his skills as a reviewer driving mass-market cars with more seats and less power. He also ran Wheels’ news section for a high-intensity period during Melbourne’s infamous lockdowns. Now, Chris brings more than a decade of motoring journalism experience to the team at CarsGuide as a Senior Journalist. He joined in 2022 and works across areas ranging from the news desk and road tests to international new car launches. He also leads the editorial side of CarsGuide’s social media content. He doesn’t get nearly as much time in his 1989 Mazda MX-5 as he would like, as he’s usually behind the wheel of a new car, constantly familiarising himself with the increasingly fast pace the new car industry is changing. When he’s not working, he’s probably playing Australian Rules football, seeing live music, or answering everyone’s car questions at the pub. You can find Chris on LinkedIn and Instagram. Expertise Road testing New car news Performance cars Video presenting and broadcasting Social media content Education Bachelor of Journalism | Queensland University of Technology | 2013-2015 Featured Publications Unique Cars Magazine | 2014-2017 Australasian Bus and Coach | 2016 Farms & Farm Machinery | 2016-2017 MOTOR Magazine | 2017-2020 WhichCar | 2018-2022 Wheels Magazine | 2020-2022 CarsGuide | 2022-present
About Author

Comments