Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Sorry, there are no cars that match your search


Nissan X-Trail 2014: Shuddering when accelerating.

We purchased and ex fleet Nissan X-Trail ST 2014 18 months ago. It has only done 90,000kms and had been great. Recently it has been shuddering when accelerating. Initially only occasionally, but now so frequent we took it straight to mechanic, even though it had just had a service.

He has concluded it requires a new automatic transmission at $7000. This seems outrageous. We are not the original owners as we purchased it second-hand, but has a full service history with Hertz and had a full RACV check done before purchasing.

Do you have any advice on what to do? Should we sell it and cut our losses, or approach Nissan even though the car is no longer in warranty.

I would always approach a car’s manufacturer in a case like this, if only because 90,000km is not, in my estimation, an acceptable distance for a transmission to last before it needs total replacement. That said, I wouldn’t hold my breath in this case because the vehicle is well and truly out of warranty.

The other people I’d be talking to would be the RACV. The club will be very concerned to hear that a car it inspected has had such a major malfunction and may have some consumer advice of its own. Then again, if the inspection was a full 18 months ago, then again, I don’t like your chances. But it’s got to be worth a shot.

The other thing that bothers me is that the vehicle is an ex-fleet car, probably a rental car, so despite a full service history, that has to rate as a chequered past. The other part of the problem is that the mechanical layout of the X-Trail makes some repairs very time-consuming, and that’s a great way to jack up the price of any repair work. If it does turn out that you’re on your own, a second-hand gearbox from a wrecked X-Trail might be a better bet than a brand-new one.