Skip navigation

How you get screwed on petrol

  • By Frank Zumbo
  • image

    Have you ever thought that you were being taken for a ride on petrol prices? Well, you have!

Coles or Woolworths: you get screwed either way on petrol.

Have you ever thought that you were being taken for a ride on petrol prices? Well, you have!

So how are you being ripped off? It’s simple really – once, of course, you know the games that can be played by the big oil companies and Coles and Woolworths.

Let’s begin at the retail level.

Here the rip off can occur in two basic ways. First, there is the practice of geographic price discrimination. This is where, for example, the same oil company charges one price for unleaded petrol at location A and a higher price for the same petrol at location B.

Why the higher price at some locations and lower prices at other locations?

Quite simply because the oil company can get away with the higher prices at those locations where there is little or no competition. At these higher priced locations there is simply no incentive for the oil company to lower its prices. Motorists simply pay a higher price than they would have if there had been independents in the local market.

Clearly, geographic price discrimination serves two purposes. To begin with, it allows the oil companies and Coles and Woolworths to gouge motorists in those locations where there is no competition from independents.

This gouging is nothing more than profiteering as the failure of competition in the local market means that consumers are being forced to pay much more than they would have if the local market had been vigorously competitive.

The profiteering gets larger as local competition fails in more and more areas.

Conveniently for the oil companies and Coles and Woolworths the geographic price discrimination can facilitate the destruction of local competition as the practice allows independents to be ambushed.

This can occur as the lower prices charged by the oil companies and Coles and Woolworths where there are independents can be subsidised by the higher prices in those areas where the big players don’t face any competition from independents.

In this way geographic price discrimination can be used in a predatory manner to target independents through at times below cost pricing with the clear aim of driving those independents out of business. The big players can sustain this below cost pricing against the independents through their higher prices in those areas where independents have been driven out of the local market.

Sadly for motorists the below cost pricing only lasts as long as the independents do, because once the independents are forced out of the local market prices will go up.

Read the full article on The Punch

Find the cheapest petrol near you

 

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 15 comments

  • Here’s a little secret for you youngins’. Have you ever wondered why Newcastles’ petrol is sometimes more expensive than Sydneys, they ??? keep telling us its because of transport costs, what they ???? not telling you is that ALL of Newcastles petrol is pumped up from Meadowbank to Broadmeadow through a pipeline, doesn’t matter which brand, petrols petrol, of course, they are both BP terminals. The only time the pipe is exposed is crossing the Hawksbury River, it is the longest underground pipe in Australia. If this is not true, then where are the 1000 petrol tankers needed to supply Newcastle every day, 7 days a week, 24 hrs a day,
    The ACCC keeps telling us that the Petrol Companies are playing on a level playing field, if this was the case, then Newcastles petrol should be selling at Sydneys prices. How come Bulahdelah, NSW can sell petrol at $1.36, whilst Taree sells at $1.44 and Newcastle $1.46 as of 23-12-11 How is it that this town can sell for less than its supplier at Newcastle, something is rotten in Denmark and its the ACCC in colusion with the Petroleum Companies

    CarlMc of Taree Hinterland Posted on 26 January 2012 10:46pm
  • This story has a 2009 date on it ???

    Peter Hemming of canberra Posted on 09 April 2011 5:30am
  • In New Zealand this weekend you can pay $1.79 for 91 octane, $1.89 for 95 octane and $1.93 at our local BP
    Diesel is $1.23 but it also a mileage tax in NZ that is collected separately

    Malcolm Craig of Aotearoa Posted on 02 July 2010 6:21pm
  • i got charged $1.39 per/L woolworths caltex in willoughby nsw on 8/5/2010 and then the same night in Eastwood the price was $1.25 per/L woolworths caltex!!!

    gus keen of sydney Posted on 11 May 2010 11:17am
  • Paula, no we should not be looking out for independents, because in most cases they can not provide us with cheaper petrol. Laws of free trade, larger company can always provide lower prices.
    what we should be doing (and no, its not “READING THE CONSTITUTION” lol) is looking out for more fuel efficient technologies, such as diesel and hybrid, lower displacement engines and stop buying V10 SUVs and V8 monsters.

    D4Diesel of Sydney West Posted on 07 August 2009 6:01pm
  • can anybody tell me why in this country diesel costs as much as unleaded petrol? most other places diesel is cheaper and current diesel engines are just as efficient and in some cases more powerful than hybrids! would be a no-brainer for most people if diesel in Australia cost 30-40% cheaper, as it does in most other countries.

    D4Diesel of Sydney West Posted on 07 August 2009 5:54pm
  • Hey !! The other fuel price government aided fuel scam is quite simple and been going on for years. Business people don’t give two hoots about price as it all copmes off tax as an expense. However Pensioners (most do not pay tax) used to all get paid on the one fortnight usually around Thursday so they usually had to “last” for a fiortnight and then “fill her up” so why not jack up the pricea day or so before hand. That way the government gets lots of the pension back via GST and excise. Then came paying Veterans and breeder on the alternate week so why not use the same “in between” cycle to catch all “those cash guaranteed pensioner mugs” as well? Government gets return of additional excise and GST from that “lot” as well. The next predictable “smart” stunt whereby the marketers profit, the government profits and the “mug motorists miss out again’ should be the lowering of fuel prices before long weekends/public holidays etc encouraging “cheap travel” and then ultra-jackup the prices after the event catching “all the mugs with near empty tanks”!! Any bets as to such happening any time after they’ve almost succeeded in “eliminating” all of the independents ???

    Terry of Logan of Logan City QLD Posted on 29 July 2009 2:09am
  • Just convert to LPG and 1/2 your fuel bill!

    Colin P of South Coast NSW Posted on 28 July 2009 9:18pm
  • You’re going to get ripped off for fuel, probably forever. Governments might make some noise but it’s never backed up with any action because they reap higher revenue with higher prices. Best thing is buy a car that uses less of it, or go to LPG

    Razor Posted on 28 July 2009 6:57pm
  • I dont think anyone is surprised or cares. Why have this as news. Maybe were getting screwed but it wont stop me driving a big V8 even if petrol soared over $2 a litre.

    kaygas of melb Posted on 28 July 2009 5:37pm
  • O.K.  Then why not DO something about it?  People need to agitate the issue STRONGLY to government etc and DEMAND such rorts be immediately outlawed.  Very simple to bring in laws to STOP the rorting - so why don’t they do it?? (rhetorical question, of course - they don’t want to do it because of the usual ugly $$$/deals they might lose - what I want to know is, why don’t we people HOLD them to govern as the PEOPLE want government?  That is our RIGHT under the Constitution (NOno wonder they want to CHANGE the CONSTITUTION - and not regarding this issue alone! - yes, this is perhaps another, bigger issue, but every small action in this country is supposed to be governed by it.  My point is the same:  we are being ripped off to keep governments and politicians and their buddies happy:  WE the people should be demanding fair trade, honest practices, LAWS to prevent otherwise - we once had them and acted on them, and we have that RIGHT.  God forbid that we ever become a Republic, as this will eventually mean ultimate control by whatever ugly power is sitting in government.  We just don’t know our Constitution as we should, nor that we can legally require many things under it, and we do not realise just how powerful standing for what the people truly want regarding a fair deal and just business practices, can be.

    Diane of anonymous Posted on 28 July 2009 2:20pm
  • Didn’t I hear a distant echo, that theres a petrol alternatives on the horizons? Oh it’s only echoes, well if authorities and companies get their gear together and speed up with the alternate solutions already, we wouldn’t be paying through our noses would we. Of course oil companies will continue to rip us off, no competition really. The consumers getting ripped off news is so yesterday, we are very aware of it. But what are the authorities going to do about it!? No use reporting it and letting us know, and nothing will be done about it? Pointless.

    Homer Posted on 28 July 2009 1:40pm
  • Is this news? It’s basic economics.

    Bob Posted on 28 July 2009 11:57am
  • I fuelled up in Kempsey on Sat 25/7/09 at a woolworths outlet on my way to Port-macquarie and the discounted price was $1.16,at Port-Macquarie 40 klms apart the discounted price was $1.24 at the woolworths outlet, thats 8c difference, its criminal, they hung Ned Kelly for less.
      Norm Hodge

    norm hodge of mid north coast Posted on 28 July 2009 11:37am
  • Shouldnt we be looking for the independents not Find the cheapest petrol near you?

    Paula of WA Posted on 28 July 2009 11:02am
Read all 15 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Feedback Form
Feedback Analytics