Skip navigation

Cheap tyres are risking lives

  • By Neil McDonald
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    Beaurepaires marketing manager Melinda Wood, says a tyre's quality, as well as its inflation, tread depth and condition, greatly influence its ability to stop a vehicle in an emergency.

Spending more on tyres could save your life.

Most people regard tyres as a grudge purchase, to be done as cheaply as possible, but a new national survey confirms the expert view that quality tyres are worth the extra.  Really cheap buys - such as no-name Chinese imports - have been exposed through the research.

A Beaurepaires survey found that better tyres can also reduce stopping distances by up to 7m compared to cheaper ones.  Beaurepaires marketing manager Melinda Wood, says a tyre's quality, as well as its inflation, tread depth and condition, greatly influence its ability to stop a vehicle in an emergency.

Good tyres can mean the difference between having and avoiding a collision, she says.  With the Christmas holiday season about to start, motoring organisations like the RACV are recommending that drivers check their tyres for the correct inflation pressure, any defects and the whether they are roadworthy. Brakes should also be checked.

A Victorian Automobile Chamber of Commerce survey recently found that 25 per cent of Victorian vehicles would fail a five-point safety check involving tyres, steering, seatbelts, headlights and brakes.

RACV research has found that more than 20 per cent of all vehicles on Melbourne's roads are driving on at least one unroadworthy tyre and that one in five vehicles have under-inflated tyres.  An unroadworthy tyre is one with a tread worn below 1.5mm or has been physically damaged.

The RACV's chief engineer, Michael Case, says cheaper tyres are often a false economy.  "In general you get what you pay for," he says.
"Cheaper tyres are not necessarily a bargain because they don't last as long."

Case says that the economic downturn has forced many motorists to neglect vehicle maintenance or resort to budget imported tyres.  "Anecdotally there is a connection between the economy and vehicle maintenance," he says.

The RACV's own tests have shown that a car travelling at 60km/h on worn tyres will need an extra 3.9m to stop.  The Beaurepaires survey found that just one in eight drivers (12 per cent) understand that premium tyres are safer.

"More worryingly, many drivers think there is little difference in stopping distances between premium and cheap tyres - 33 per cent think this stopping advantage is less than 6m," Wood says.  Women are more likely than men to underestimate the stopping distance advantage of premium tyres.

Almost two in five women (38 per cent) consider the difference in stopping distance advantages between premium and cheap tyres to be less than 6m, compared to 28 per cent of men.

Beaurepaires tyre experts tested 16 different sets of tyres, from many leading brands, in both wet and dry conditions.  Dunlop and Goodyear - distributed by Beaurepaires - were the best performers, stopping up to 7m earlier in the wet than the other tyres.

These same tyres also led the way in dry conditions, with almost 2m on their competitors.  Stopping distance depends on several factors like reaction times, speed, driving conditions, and the condition of the tyres and brakes.

Under-inflated tyres will also significantly affect a vehicle's handling and ability to stop in an emergency.  Drivers unsure about the condition of their tyres should have them checked by an expert.  Most reputable dealers have free safety inspections.

Recommended Stopping Distances:

Speed/Stopping Distance

40 km/h/37m
60 km/h/55m
80 km/h/82m
100 km/h/116m


Tyre Tips

1. Check tyre pressures regularly
2. Replace any worn or defective tyres
3. Have tyres balanced and steering alignment checked 4. Check your spare tyre is correctly inflated and roadworthy 5. Practice how to change a tyre

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 21 comments

  • So the tyre brands that beaurepaires sells and make most profit on are the best… what a coincidence.

    Shane of Sydney Posted on 12 December 2012 12:01pm
  • Especially for Michael Farrell. Some information you may like to hear for your next set - worth a try, and I bet you won’t regret it. You have obviously never had a set of Michelin tyres. Not only do they grip in all conditions, they outlast anything also. You can definitely have your cake and eat it too if you want long life and safety. I was going to write more, but I can’t be bothered, other than, most tyre sales people know as much about tyres as the public, and that is they are black and round (mostly) and if it has a ‘name’ it must be good, but very few will ever be able to explain why. So, the public are left in the dark and have to rely on the ads and names they think they can trust, and the best salesman with the gift of the gab to buy from. I’ll give you an example of a brand name tyre people continue to buy simply because it has a brand name they trust. The RE92 by Bridgestone. First made in Late 1991. Tyre technology has had serious advancements in the last 20 years. Would you buy a VP Commodore new today for today’s Commodore price? I’ve said more than I meant to. (note: I am not associated with any tyre company or the industry). Cheers, use the info as you see fit.

    PM of Australia Posted on 14 September 2011 12:08am
  • Tyre life is directly related to tyre grip in dry weather. The longer the life the worse the grip. The shorter the life, the better the grip (based on same tread depth obviously). Very simple, you can’t have your cake and eat it too.

    Michael Farrell of WA Australia Posted on 27 July 2011 1:47pm
  • I have been driving Honda vehicles - all types - since 1960 and have only used Michelin tyres.  They have been absolutely brilliant and have long wearing capability.  Any new or used vehicle is instantly fitted with Michelin tyres for safety and long use.

    M Thomas of HOWLONG, NSW Posted on 14 July 2011 3:02pm
  • On a personal basis I am a fan of Yokohama and have driven on nothing else since 1985 with several diferent vehicles.  I would have to say that the S-Drive is by far the best tyre I have ever driven on.  Having recently updated my wife’s car, it was fitted with Bridgestone RE050a tyres.  Certainly not cheap at $380 each.  They are excellent roadholding tyres, but appear to be wearing already.
    On my 4WD I changed from the original Yokohamas to Mickey Thompson ATZ.  Again, not cheap at $280 each, but I am extremely happy after 20K.

    Peter Paynting of Emu Plains Posted on 18 April 2010 8:39pm
  • I am a fan of Yokohama C Drives, though the price can vary a lot depending on where you go. They are one of the best I have ever used in the wet, but aren’t quite as good as their old A539s in my opinion. A car racing friend of mine suggested I try them, and since I won’t look at much else apert from Michelin’s, which I also am keen on

    Paul0075r of NSW South Coast Posted on 13 April 2010 11:26am
  • I have 2 full set of wheels, one for daily drives, and the other for club sport events.  The club sport tyres are *R Spec* and wear very quickly.  I will get about 8000 Klm from these, yep eight thousand, and until you have driven on competition tyres you have not experienced Grip, stopping, handling, direction change and unfortunately road noise. While these tyres are road legal, they do wear very quickly, and I drive a small mid engined car that is just under 1000Kgms. The tyres are about $350 a corner! Are they worth it? Oh yes, my stopping distances have changed by nearly 50%, my lap times are 4 seconds quicker. My daily drive tyres are also at the expensive, soft end at $230 a corner, and both sets are only 205/50/15’s. Here is a comparison, my *R Specs* are one second faster in the wet per lap than my high performance tyres on the same track in the dry.  That is true performance!

    Peter or Brisbane of Australia Posted on 10 April 2010 12:27pm
  • I have a very limited choice for my cooper S, but i changed from the horrible run flats, to Pirelli dragons, and now P6’s - these are very good, maintain around 80% of dry grip in the wet, are quieter than run-flats (or even the dragons) and were only $130 each.  My wife’s Santa-Fe now runs on Pirelli Scorpion zeros - a hell of an improvement on the Kuhmo’s - and - I got them for $60 cheaper ! - so i guess I’m running “cheapies”

    cmos of Brisvegas Posted on 06 April 2010 6:25pm
  • Beaurepaires would be more impartial than some as they sell a
    number of different brands. Having said that, keep an eye on the magazine stands. Wheels Magazine do an annual wheel and tyre guide where they test a wide variety of brands comprehensively and scientifically.
    Personally I like Yokohama A Drives. They go some way towards taming my evil tail happy commodore ute in wet weather.

    Brenton of Canberra Posted on 04 April 2010 10:49am
  • I own a VZ Monaro & the original Bridgestone Potenzas srubbed out at around 30,000kms. I was shocked at the price of replacements & settled for Maxxis MA-V1 instead at around half the comparable price. Am very satisfied with their current wear rate but have noticed less grip than the Bridgestones in the dry & the wet. To overcome this I simply reduce my speed in wet conditions & leave a longer gap with the vehicles in front of mine.
    Long live the cheaper brands!

    Robert of Turrella Posted on 04 April 2010 9:45am
  • I normally get the factory Bridgestone RE92s for my Commodore until the last time I got a new set, I got Pirelli P6’s for $115 each. And they are infinitely better than the Bridgestones in the wet. I thought the tyres would wear out faster but they have lasted MUCH longer than the Bridgestones. Better value all around on the P6’s. Safety is a main concern, but I too refuse to pay for tyres that dont last (Yokohama S760 etc).

    Cuddy of Bendigo Posted on 31 March 2010 10:43am
  • I’ve heard good of Nexan tyres, but never tried them myself. I’ve had great experiences with Bridgestone RE070 and RE050, both have won many individual tests in europe, and some year after year. I’ve had some very bad experiences with Falken tires. I had some Z spec (high speed) and they completely melted when having to emergency brake on the freeway. After I had them replaced, I saw the block had actually lifted themselves. I’m currently running Pirelli Scorpion ATR’s on my 4x4, and they are very good.

    I also agree with other people here making comments about how “performance tires are softer and wear more” Soft=Grip=Wear. Its always a matter of finding a good compromise between your economy and performance. One thing should be mentioned though, a normal generic car would not show a big difference in braking distance, between a performance or standard tire, simply because the brakes are average too, and fade easy.

    Brian of Melbourne Posted on 30 March 2010 10:08pm
  • How can a Beaurepaires (what business are they in again??) survey be taken as credible, impartial evidence of the quality of said Chinese “no-name” imports? Can they substantiate that Chinese tyres are somehow worse than their ‘branded’ tyres that are made in Thailand or the Phillipines? How about reporting on a proper unbiased study with some real data and clear methods of analysis rather than hype, conjecture and unsubstatiated claims.

    Jeremy Ngoh of Wheelers Hill Posted on 29 March 2010 3:04pm
  • Theo of Sydney. How can a harder compound that supposed to last longer be safer. I always use expensive brand name and it last. Why not make tyre out of concrete for it to last longer than. I rather have more grib than skid of the road into a tree any day.

    phuong of canberra Posted on 18 March 2010 2:53pm
  • The sadest thing about tyres in my opinion is, after Bridgestone closes it’s factory, no one here would know how to make a tyre. We’ll be left with nothing else but imports, from good quality to rubbish.

    B of Endeavour Hills Posted on 12 March 2010 9:19pm
  • Actually, in general more expensive tyres which tend to be performance-oriented tyres do not last as long as cheaper ones. This is because expensive performance tyres are designed first of all for grip, and tend to use softer compounds. So it is in fact the other way round - cheaper tyres tend to last longer than the most expensive ones.

    Theo T of Sydney Posted on 11 March 2010 8:41pm
  • I never really considered this, what a great article considering that I will need new tyres soon. This has really changed my mind about putting the Kmart cheapies on…

    Mike Posted on 06 March 2010 3:10pm
  • “Cheaper tyres are not necessarily a bargain because they don’t last as long.”


    Who ever said that obviously never driven on a set of expensive performance tyres e.g Pirelli’s P-Zero Corsa or Advan Neova’s which will last around 10,000ks at best.

    I have also driven on well known rather expensive tyres and they have been horrible in both the wet and dry and haven’t lasted as long as they should.

    Andrew of Canberra Posted on 01 March 2010 2:13pm
  • Thought it was common sense to buy the best tyres you can afford.  Got me some Maxxis Victra z4’s (235/50/19) on my calais which grip like a cat on carpet wet or dry and are 10 times better than the bridgestones I had before.

    kato of Canberra Posted on 01 March 2010 1:02pm
  • Even allowing for bias in tests such as the above one briefly mentioned ie,'Dunlop and Goodyear-distributed by Beaurepairs-were the best performers' i have never seen a test/comparison where the cheap tyres have come out any good. Usually it's the stopping and the wet that is particually bad. Have you been sold a pup? Woof woof!

    Graham Adamson Posted on 10 December 2009 8:17pm
  • To-Day, I puchased 4 new tyres for my Ford fairlane 245/35/17 and the brand Nexan,the owner of the tyre shop said he has them on his xr6 turbo and said they are great in the wet and he recommended 40psi have Ibeen sold a pup? regards Peter

    Peter Franklin of Gold Coast Posted on 07 December 2009 4:12pm
Read all 21 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Feedback Form
Feedback Analytics