Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Options plummet in value

  • By Paul Gover
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    According to Chris D'Sousa of Glass's Information Services, a $15,000 Hyundai Getz should not be tweaked at all. Photo Gallery

Many new-car buyers are wasting thousands of dollars on high-priced extra equipment which is worth nothing at resale time.

A lot of optional equipment depreciates far faster than the car it is fitted to, and rapid changes in standard equipment can overtake impressive showroom choices in as little as three years.  Extra safety equipment is hit among the hardest by depreciation, as used-car buyers are reluctant to pay extra for additional airbags or ESP stability control.

Yet a sunroof or leather trim or flashy alloy wheels could get a payback at trade-in or resale time as upmarket additions can add extra appeal.  Even the right colour choice can make a difference to a car's secondhand value, as trendy colours become unpopular quickly while staples such as white, silver and black tend to be timeless.

"You have to be very careful. If you start by spending $3000 on options it might all be worthless in a few years," the spokesman for car-price authority, Glass's Information services, says.  "If the car depreciates at 40 per cent, some of these options can depreciate at twice that, or more," says Chris D'Sousa.

He says flashy extra gear, including sunroofs and leather trim, might not put extra cash in the wallet but could make it easier to get a sale.  "They don't really add resale value. They add resale appeal," D'Sousa says.

Glass's tracks values for more than 40 items of optional equipment, currently tracking it backwards to cars sold in 2000. The list includes everything from extra airbags to CD players, body kits, bullbars and Xenon headlamps.  A range of extras is rated with zero value after 10 years, including anti-skid brakes, cruise control (which hits zero at seven years), and a six-stack CD player.

Glass's believes the best approach to new-car shopping is to choose a car that is already well equipped, only adding optional essentials such as a towbar.  "If you take a basic car, it's better to take a higher-spec model because options deprectiate a lot more than the car itself. Some, like towbars, will be value for about four years," he says.  "A good option will add value for up to 10 years. Then it becomes irrelevant.

"It is better to buy the higher-spec car because resale will be better."  Digging into specifics, D'Sousa says buyers need to be careful what they add to a car.  "There are certain options, like the visual touch-and-feel stuff _ that's sunroofs, alloy wheels and leather trim - that will always enhance a car. Then there are hidden options that are more in tune with today's market needs, like ESP and curtain airbags, that have no perceived value.

"Turn the clock forward, and this stuff is standard. It adds no value.  "We believe side airbags will have some value now for about six years.  Then it will be an expectation.  Satnav might have an average new price of $5000, but after a year we believe the value falls to only $2000. Then at 10 years it falls to $300.  A body kit will depreciate less than a rear cargo barrier."

Glass's tracks the whole car market and D'Sousa says there are different rules in different price classes. A $15,000 Hyundai Getz should not be tweaked, a Commodore or Falcon only deserves dressing if it is already a premium model, while BMW and Benz buyers should avoid going overboard.

"If you take a Hyundai Getz and spend a lot of money dressing up, people buying it secondhand don't perceive it as premium," he says.  "If you were looking at a base-model Falcon or Commodore I would suggest no options beyond a towbar. But if you look at a G-Series Falcon then a sunroof and leather trim will add some value.

"Even with a BMW, there are some options that add a lot more, and luxury brands have options' lists that run to small books. You can take a car and add 50 per cent to the purchase price, but does that add value?"

On car colours, D'Sousa warns about going for fashion colours that change rapidly. Holden is famous for using 'hero' colours on its V8- powered SS Commodore, switching rapidly from gold to light blue, green and even purple in recent years.  "These days everyone wants a black or silver car. A few years ago everyone wanted a green car, but these days no-one wants a green car,"  he says.

There are also regional differences between what sells and what sits on the lot.  "Convertibles don't sell well in Queensland, but they are popular in Sydney or Melbourne. White cars are not so popular in Melbourne," D'Sousa says."A fuddy-duddy car like a Mercedes-Benz sells well in Melbourne. 

People in Darwin will travel to Adelaide to get a secondhand four- wheel drive because they know it has had an easier life. It's the same for people in Perth, who will go to Adelaide for an SUV because they don't like the red-dust staining you get in WA."

Item                           new price     value after 10 years
Satellite navigation       $5000        $300
In-car television            $2800         $200
Electric sunroof             $2300         $200
Dual airbag package     $1400         $0
Alloy wheels                  $1000           $0

Source: Glass's Information Systems

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 7 comments

  • I just wonder about the purpose of the article. Why would you consider extra's if all you care about is resale value? Buying a new car is a great waste of money anyway, by the moment you roll over the sidewalk at the dealership you have lost about 8 grand anyway. That being said, I bought a new car a few years back, and I added about 7 grand worth of extra's, not because of predicted resale, but because this was things I wanted to be useful and happy for the car for the time to come. Don't sad things like resale value bother your choice of extra's, its not worth it, rather spend whatever YOU need to be happy, or buy a used car with the options already there..

    Brian of Melbourne Posted on 30 March 2010 1:23pm
  • Good story...especially at a time when i am looking at a new car with some extras.

    JE of ACT Posted on 05 December 2009 5:24pm
  • Definitely to be filed under the heading of "Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhh". Is this the best you can do?

    Hank Ford IV Posted on 02 December 2009 1:28pm
  • @Mark...sounds like you are having a dig, let me assure you that I am not bored at work but browsing websites like this is work. smile isn't it disapointing to read an article which should come as common sense to most people?

    C Posted on 02 December 2009 9:49am
  • Good general advice for non-car people who may just look at this site when they want to buy a car, not when they are bored at work.

    Mark Posted on 01 December 2009 3:04pm
  • frustrating read, why does it take a so called 'professional' from Glass's Information service to take this long to release such findings? Hardly a revelation, two thumbs down.

    C Posted on 30 November 2009 11:45am
  • Of course after ten years these things would be worth bugger all. Is a plasma TV worth any thing after 10 years, what a complete waste of time this story is.

    David of Buderim Posted on 27 November 2009 10:54pm
Read all 7 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links