Skip navigation
Sell your car on Carsguide for free

Oil proves to be green

  • By Mark Hinchliffe
  • The Courier-Mail
  • Share
  • Email
  • Print
  • Text size
Hyundai i30 Hybrids appear to be the better purchase but in reality, the public prefer diesels to hybrids.

What is greener — a hybrid or a diesel?

Hybrids have won the PR war with everyone from Hollywood stars to politicians clamouring to be seen driving them. Meanwhile, diesels still suffer from poor PR as dirty, noisy oil-burners.

Governments offer hybrids substantial subsidies and concessions overseas and even in Queensland they stay at 2 per cent stamp duty while duty on all other vehicles has as much as doubled.

Yet the public isn't all that keen on hybrids, or LPG for that matter.

Hybrid private passenger car sales are up 16.3 per cent from 1292 in 2006 to 1503 in '07 and LPG sales are down 44.5 per cent from 607 to 337.

Meanwhile, diesel private sales are up 62.9 per cent from 10,566 to 17,215.

It seems only government departments and corporations who wish to be seen to be green are buying hybrids with non-private passenger car sales up 60.8 per cent from 1694 to 2725.

While petrol-electric hybrids have been embraced as green icons by politicians and the media, the results speak for themselves.

For example, Hyundai i30 diesel won the Greenfleet technology class of the World Solar Car Challenge in October, beating the Toyota Prius hybrid. It used just 3.2litres/100km while producing 97g/km of emissions, while the Prius hybrid averaged 5.6litres/100km with emissions of 146g/km.

The i30 CRDi costs $21,490, while the Prius costs $37,400.

Comments on this story

Displaying 2 of 2 comments

  • Excuse me, but your info is misleading. You said i30 uses 3.2l/100km and Prius 5.6l/km. Where do you get those figures from? From hyundai website, i30 uses 4.7l/100km for a manual and 6l/100km for an auto. Both are for 1.6 CRDi diesel car. The official figure from Toyota is 4.4l/100km for the Prius and this has been confirmed in real life. So which one is more economical, in terms of fuel? I think 4.4 < 4.7 (or if you prefer, 4.4 < 6.0) Get the record straight, mate.

    sean Posted on 18 February 2008 1:07pm
  • Diesel these days is cleaner than petrol because the manufacturers put in sophisticated systems to defeat polution AND because the engines run at much higher temperatures.

    Tomas of Brisbane Posted on 15 January 2008 2:24pm

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links

Feedback Form
Feedback Analytics