Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Hoon crusade a fake?

  • By Carsguide team
  • Carsguide
  • image

    Original YouTube video.

A row has erupted over a Channel Nine TV segment on Tuesday night...

... in which A Current Affair appealed to the public to help them catch a hoon ‘before he kills somebody’.

Wednesday night's A Current Affair appeared to backpeddle from their Tuesday night story that they were seeking the public's help to identify a young man in alleged hoon footage.

After the Tuesday night story, claims surfaced that the so-called ‘exclusive’ hoon footage had in fact been edited down from a clip on Youtube, which was one of the 2007 audition tapes for Australian Top Gear.  Channel Nine secured the rights to Top Gear last last year – around the same time the footage was posted on Youtube by somebody calling themselves ‘Mr Anonymous234’. It is the only video Mr Anon has posted.

Despite ACA reporter Tom Steinfort asking the public to help find the driver he referred to as ‘Crazy Carlo’, the Youtube footage shows the young driver introducing himself with: "Hi everybody at Freehand (the producers of Top Gear Australia), my name is Carlo Arena and I would like to be your Stig."

Comments running through online car forums cast doubt on the validity of the video – while still condemning the driving  “It is stupid and irresponsible … even stupider to video this act and paste it on the internet, now that’s exactly what I SHOULD be saying if this guy pasted the video up! After finding the FULL video that was NOT edited by ACA, it does appear that the guy was doing the video for Top Gear Australia Auditions to become the next Stig. He actually introduces himself so where is the mystery,” asked Beau Jones on DriftKulture.com.

“Does sound plausable (sic) that tabloid journalists would of got hold of it, "leaked it onto youtube" then put it on ACA instead of admitting they got it through their Top Gear deal,” Sicarius123 wrote on performanceforums.com  “If they have his Plate number and full name wouldn’t the police be able to track him,” evilvids commented on youtube.com.

ACA spotlighted the vehicle’s number plate as part of their ‘hoon hunt’ but comments on the forums suggested the car was sold shortly after the audition tape was shot, and has since been deregistered for use as a race car.

In the follow-up story on Wednesday night, A Current Affair admitted they knew the driver's identity and also knew that the footage ... far from being an exclusive ... was an audition tape.

“We thoguht it would have been unfair to splash the driver's full name ... with that in mind, we withheld a portion of the video in which he does indeed name himself and claims he wants to be a stunt driver on SBS's local version of Top Gear,” Steinfort said in Wednesday's follow-up piece.

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 37 comments

  • Again it was 'reported' on ACA and TT so who stupid enough to be watching it an believe whatever they are saying were true. Bogans!

    phuong Posted on 18 March 2010 4:14pm
  • Tania of Melbourne - I think you need to come back to reality. Fancy saying that drivers should learn to drift and that it is an extremely worthwhile skill. Far better that they learn to use their brains on the road. I have been driving for over 40 years, and have never needed to drift to get out of a dangerous situation. Fortunately I learnt to drive in a way that I don't get into such a situation. Throw the book at him!

    Gordon of Adelaide Posted on 10 February 2010 9:05am
  • The same story was on Today Tonight, and i just felt absolutely disgusted that both current affairs shows, could be so stupid in presenting the story. As Tony of Nul, has said Channel 7 got in an expert to say how stupid it is, but to then insinuate that Clarkson and the boys are irresponsible. Their not at any fault, when top gear road tests a car, the road is closed off, and the better driving is down at the airport location that BBC UK own. And as for this guy, he chose to do his audition tape, he could have done something smarter, but didn't. Both a current affairs need to some actual "research" and both hosts and reporters need to confirm the story.

    Anthony Byth of Lidcombe Posted on 09 February 2010 2:41pm
  • Hello Iam sure some people are missing the point!Get him off our public roads It could be you who he wipes out. Why does he not go through the right channels to do this on a race track? Wave the little pinky finger at him.

    M holland Posted on 09 February 2010 1:15pm
  • I agree with Alan of Logan. Drivers should learn to drift as the purpose of this training is to teach drivers to control their vehicle. It's a very difficult yet extremely worthwhile skill to learn. In fact, any extra driver training is what ALL drivers need!

    Tania of Melbourne Posted on 09 February 2010 1:15pm
  • Interesting...We had this shown on Ch7's Today tonight, with them and their "expert" blaming Top Gear for promoting "hoon" behaviour...especially the Stig, even though all his driving is done on a closed track...go figure.

    Tony of Nul Posted on 09 February 2010 12:47pm
  • Ho Hum Hoon Stories are really so yesterday, these slack journos need another bombing attack (preferably in their office) to give them something new to sensationalise.

    Bored of Hoon Heaven Posted on 09 February 2010 11:34am
  • ACA is an entertainment show with ratings to maintain. As an entertainment show rather than a news program, they will do, show and say whatever it takes to maintain the ratings with great indifference to the truth. Why do the media regulators not go after ACA they way ACA goes after its targets. Then we would have a news/entertainment story worth watching. ACA does on occasion fill us in on stories we want to know more about, and tackles corruption at times. But when all is quite they will edit, and run what it thinks will grab our attention, to entertain us, rather than what is newsworthy, or even at times accurate.

    Ken Meyers Posted on 09 February 2010 11:26am
  • Drivers who drift - are drivers who have learned control of a vehicle. Drifting should be taught to ALL new drivers, BEFORE being allowed on the road, or put into the hands of a commercial so-called "Driving Instructor". And, no, I'm not a young hoon, I'm elderly, but know that's how I learned car control.

    Alan of Logan Posted on 09 February 2010 11:14am
  • get something new to report on, hoons are getting boring now.....

    jay Posted on 08 February 2010 11:53am
  • drifters are wankers anyway. They should all be shot before they kill someone else

    me Posted on 07 February 2010 10:02pm
  • Cars should be banned and our cities turned into vast pedestrian plazas and I should be quoted more often. In fact, why am I not quoted in this story? Honestly! You set yourself up as a Council, con every lazy journalist in the country to call you whenever anyone does 5km/h over the limit, and what happens? Everyone with brains ignores you ..

    Harold Screwball of Partisan Bay Posted on 06 February 2010 12:58pm
  • ACA must have been truly desperate for a story. At least find something plausible next time.

    Kam of Sydney Posted on 05 February 2010 3:20pm
  • wet or dry. stupid or not. ya gotta admit he's got some skills

    JR88 of Adelaide, SA Posted on 05 February 2010 1:55pm
  • at least he knew what he was doing. 10/10 for some awesome drifting !!

    drift freak of MELBOURNE, Hoon Capital Posted on 04 February 2010 9:41pm
  • The journalist is less responsible then the driver. I'm sick of Channel 9 making up stories to 'sell papers'. Lots of people are affected by negative press. And Channel 9 irresponsibly never let the facts get in the way of a good story. They promote their own personnel to celebrity status through poor quality 'reality programs' and create stories on them too, mostly at their expense... no such thing as bad publicity just ratings...it's fraudulent and un-Australian!

    THOMAS GIBSON of Bribie Island Posted on 04 February 2010 8:39pm
  • Thats not proving anything drifting some curves in the wet. If he did that stuff on dry roads it would be a lot better.

    kaygas of melbourne Posted on 04 February 2010 8:37pm
  • We've got the idiots drifting on norton summit rd in the Adelaide hills. The road is dangerous enough as it is, let alone these idiots doing stuff like that anyway. I say, Catch them, Fine them, Disquallify them, and then crush them, the cars that is.

    Wazza of SA Posted on 04 February 2010 7:28pm
  • "Sicarius123 actually works for TodayTonight, so no surprise he's trying to put down the ACA story" - Ted Armstrong sounds like something a ACA representative would say

    pluto fernado of Sydney NSW Posted on 04 February 2010 2:24pm
  • got to give him credit he got skillz and i bet they closed the road off

    drift hoon of australia Posted on 04 February 2010 1:27pm
  • LOL ... another one for Sherlock ... I mean Jonno Holmes. What I don't get is, why do some journos knowingly lie and still get away scott free?

    Amup Posted on 04 February 2010 12:52pm
  • This guy is an idiot and a danger to other road users. It is NOT obvious that it is a private road (certainly not the suburban sequence). The police need to catch this fool and take his licence away from him until he grows up!

    sensible driver Posted on 04 February 2010 12:40pm
  • Another convoluted story smeared across the afternoon news - I wonder if this was a ploy to make it seem like the police are "all over the hoons" - does Australia feel safe now.

    Zareen of Sydney Posted on 04 February 2010 10:20am
  • Good Driver!! Love the Video!! Why is he a hoon..The streets dont look that busy.

    Scott of Sydney Posted on 04 February 2010 9:37am
  • iT WAS CHANNEL SEVEN THAT AIRED THIS NOT I REPEAT NOT CHANNEL NINE.. TOP GEAR IS GOING TO BE ON NINE, SO WHY WOULD THEY BAG IT??????????????? TOP GEAR HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HOONS PERIOD.. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hi Mark, No, the story we're referring to was definitely on Channel Nine's A Current Affair. However, Channel Seven has certainly done similar stories. regards, Editor

    Mark of Melbourne Posted on 04 February 2010 7:37am
  • Interesting comment "Packer runs a loose ship". Packer has not had a controlling interest in channel 9 for years...I agree with your sentiment that it is rubbish tabloid journalism.

    Luke Wilson of Sydney Posted on 04 February 2010 12:37am
  • They see me rollin They hatin Patrolling they tryin to catch me ridin dirty

    Kaiser of PF - Teh Pool Room Posted on 03 February 2010 9:49pm
  • The guy clearly states, and it is obvious that this was done on a closed road. If we all developed our skills to this level, then there would be no deaths due to cars hitting trees on wet roads

    Supporter Posted on 03 February 2010 9:20pm
  • WTF 11tybillionz BBQ PF in On juan

    PF Screwdriver Posted on 03 February 2010 7:34pm
  • A Current Trailer Trash Affair.....nuff said Never watch it as it's the worst Journalism/Reporting/Investigation ever to appear on Australian Television typical Ch9 trash. Packer runs a loose ship and is where it is because of it.

    Seriously of the world. Posted on 03 February 2010 7:20pm
  • ACA/TT, the story is as valid as their claims of being journalists... Take a video given to your network for another show, wait for a slow week in what you interpret as journalism and rehash. Sorry most didn't feel the knee jerk expected.

    Tracey Slackjaw of Sydney Posted on 03 February 2010 6:54pm
  • he's running bit rich with the fuel to air ratio, h should get that sorted he could get better performance out of the car

    The Tuner Stig of Your Backstreets Posted on 03 February 2010 6:12pm
  • Doesnt everyone know by now the golden rule of Journalism....Never spoil a good story by telling the truth!!!! Ivan Port Maacquarie

    Ivan Daniel of Port Macquarie Posted on 03 February 2010 5:50pm
  • Sicarius123 actually works for TodayTonight, so no surprise he's trying to put down the ACA story.

    Ted Armstrong of Canberra Posted on 03 February 2010 5:45pm
  • drop a gearbox in the ACA lobby. Guns would have solved this.

    Rorge of PF HQ Posted on 03 February 2010 5:44pm
  • Just as bad as CLIMATE GATE, another step into trying to get rid of the car.

    john of Melbourne Posted on 03 February 2010 5:29pm
  • Hoon hunt? More like witch hunt. OK fine, name and shame, but get the facts right and don't claim exclusivity when none exists.

    Bryce of Sydney Posted on 03 February 2010 5:17pm
Read all 37 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links