Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

A guide to small cars

  • By Paul Pottinger
  • The Sunday Telegraph
image The Mazda2 Maxx is a brilliant driving car.

A Commodore or a Falcon is about as appropriate to urban-dwelling DINKs as using an aircraft carrier to go fishing on a lake.

Australian car-makers have never quite grasped that many of us no longer live on quarter-acre blocks with white picket palisades in suburbs straight from Neighbours.

But style, luxury, comfort and even performance needn't be sacrificed at the altar of practicality or forsaken in the pursuit of greenness.

Only a decade ago, Volkswagen's Golf was considered a small car, but the current model is quite big enough for a family mobile.

Beneath that, there's an emerging class of diminutive but dynamically pleasing, usefully spacious and (of increasing importance) eco-friendly city cars.

It's the segment that shows less in terms of horsepower really can be more in terms of liveability and sustainability. In terms of luxury, too: you can downsize but up-spec - and cut quite a figure when you do.

When a car weighs not much more than a tonne, low fuel consumption and low emissions are pretty much guaranteed.

The Citroen C2 and C3 won't win any traffic-light derbies, but they do tick both those green boxes and the less tangible - but just as important - one marked “style”.

In terms of reliability, it's said there's no such thing as French without tears, but it's hard not to be enamoured of the chic siblings.

Our selections would be the C2 VTS with 1.6-litre petrol engine or the C3 Hdi with super-frugal, 1.6-litre turbo diesel (both from $23,990).

The latter variant would also be the overwhelmingly popular choice in Paris.

Italy gave the world the original city car, designed to provide affordable personal transport while being able to park on a postage stamp. It was the Fiat 500.

The reborn, and instantly iconic, Fiat 500 fulfils that brief as a chunk of retro chic that's also fun to drive.

Our choice is the top-spec Lounge variant, priced from $25,990 with a perky 1.4-litre petrol engine mated to a six-speed manual. If the 500 doesn't raise a smile, you probably don't like sunny days, either.

There's also the option of a robotised manual transmission with auto-drive mode. It dispenses with both a clutch pedal and the emission spikes that occur when you change ratios in a conventional gearbox.

And, with seven airbags, the ESP-equipped top models in the 500 range have better crash-safety credentials than a Falcodore.

The Honda Jazz has been around longer than any other car mentioned here but, in several respects, it remains the benchmark for city cars.

Honda's build quality is world-leading; the Jazz's space, practicality and economy are class-leading.

Although a small engine combines best with a manual gearbox, it's equally true that changing gears for yourself is a dying art.

So try the range-topping VTi-S with continuously variable transmission and 1.5-litre powerplant at $22,920.

In the next-size-up Civic range, Honda offers a petrol/electric model which has been submerged beneath the decidedly eco-unfriendly mountain of print devoted to Toyota's Prius.

The Civic Hybrid ($32,990) is massively cheaper than the Prius and at least looks like a car rather than a self-conscious eco-statement.

Anyone who equates Hyundai with its old $13,990 drive-away-then-chuck-it-away days is labouring under a mighty misapprehension.

The new Hyundai i30 has won car-of-the-year awards both here and in Europe (where this, the best car ever built in Korea, was designed).

The 1.6-litre diesel-powered models take it up to just about any supposedly more prestigious European equivalent you care to name.

The name of our preferred variant, the SX CRDi (from $21,490, plus $1500 for the safety pack) is the only clunky thing about it.

More Australians spent their own money on a Mazda3 last year than on any other car. It's the fourth-best seller overall but, unlike the top three, there are no fleet sales among them.

Sales-wise, the newer, next-size-down Mazda2 will run its bigger brother close this year. And so it should, being, if anything, an even more convincing package.

Diminutive in stance but capacious within, cute to the eye but perhaps the best-driving car here, tolerably rapid but easy on fuel and easy to park, the Mazda2 Maxx (from $18,710) is the ideal city car. Nor will it fall short when freeway trips are required.

Frankly, it's brilliant - and a cheaper, lighter, more efficient coupe version will arrive in Australia shortly.

Look out also for the Peugeot 107, due mid-year. It will slot under the 207's entry-level ask of $19,990.

If you remember the Top Gear episode in which a game of five-a-side football was played using Toyota Aygos, the 107 is the same car, made in the same factory, but with different badges.

Actually, it's cars like the 107 and the Fiat 500 that make us look askance at Smart's ForTwo (from $19,990).

Yes, it's very clever, but Sydney isn't yet Turin, despite the epic ineptitude of the RTA and our Roads Minister.

Besides, you've got an allocated parking space downstairs. So why go without a boot and back seats?

Toyota's Yaris shows how a small car can fit a family, although you really need to ignore the base models and go straight to the YRX (from $20,790).

Of course, it's the Prius that gets all the attention in Toyota's range; as such, it's the world's most successful automotive marketing exercise.

Granted, the hybrid-powered Prius uses staggeringly little petrol in the city, but on the open road we'd take a diesel such as Volkswagen's Polo Match TDI ($22,990).

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 8 comments

  • Interesting comment that changing gears for yourself is a dying art. Sadly an increasing number of people will never attain the ability or have the joy of driving a manual transmission car.

    Howard Posted on 22 April 2008 4:43pm
  • You haven't mentioned the delightful Suzuki Swift which I drove as a rental car while in New Zealand recently. I usually drive a 3-litre 6, so imagine my surprise when I covered most of the North Island and only had to refill the (smaller) fuel tank once. The little Suzuki was really deceptive as far as interior space was concerned but there wasn't enough room in the boot for my suitcase.

    Ted Price of Perth Posted on 22 April 2008 2:54pm
  • I recently downsized from a VX Commodore to an Astra diesel manual, and apart fom a drastic drop in my fuel bill (down ~200 per month) with both city and alot of country driving I havent looked back. I have more safety equipment in the Diesel Astra then I did in the Commodore, and the low end torque of the diesel is brilliant. For long haul trips the size of the Astra is fine, no issues in our household of 3 adults. We recently played with the idea of getting an SS VE, and the truth was we just simply dont need a car that uses that much fuel (albeit alot more grunt), the new VE has the extra safety equipment that stopped me from updating in 06 but I truly enjoy the Astra, its a fun grunty 6speed. Could I personally drop down to a Yaris or a Mazda2? No not really, and I once called a friends Smartcar a pregnant skateboard (smaller again then the Yaris or 2), which I now apologise for but still wouldnt take it on the westgate let alone the Hume, that is not to say that it cant but I wouldn't feel safe in one. Whats the biggest I would go in the future, I like the new Opel Insignia, if brought over I would trade in the oil burner for another, but going down already the midsize is the smallest I could personally go.

    Josh of Melbourne Posted on 22 April 2008 9:15am
  • The media can harp on all they like about down sizing - NO THANKS !!! Give me a safe, roomy, comfortable large car any day over a unsafe, cramped small car. There is nothing more relaxing and enjoyable than driving Australia's highways in an Australian built full-size family car. All these twats in their buzzy little roller-skates for cars look down right stupid and unsafe. Big trucks alone would blow half them off the road as they pass......HAHAHAHAHA

    Dean of Sydney Posted on 22 April 2008 12:56am
  • Sasha, as the owner of a Golf and having driven on country roads, I have no problem feeling safe at all. I have also previously driven a Corolla down numerous unsealed roads without any safety concerns (it actually went a lot better than I was expecting).

    elephino Posted on 21 April 2008 4:25pm
  • is this another coloumn asking us trade-in our australian made cars (designed for our roads and unique conditions) for an imported cramped shopping trolley? Space = Comfort, Compfort = safety

    dave Posted on 21 April 2008 1:43pm
  • I was a 5 Liter V8 Person for many years, and had a pleasant shock, when I down sized to a 1.6 twin cam, no it did not have the low down grunt, but the fuel needle did not drop from full, to empty when you started it up either. As a diesel Fitter, I tend to be bias to the Diesel engine, I think Australia is going through a major transport change, gone are the days, Dad, Mum and the kids all plied into the car and went away together for a weekend camp. Kids are now off on their own, Neither do you get many weekend self home builders as when I was a kid, and people took a door or window home on a Friday night in the boot, to fit over the weekend. People want an easy to park, multipurpose all round small car, with low service costs now, and those who do not provide them in the car industry will be left behind, the small SUV market boom is a good indicator to this.

    Dave Hayden of Tasmania Posted on 21 April 2008 1:26pm
  • You didn't mention the Ford Fiesta. I drive one and it is one of the most enjoyable small cars I have ever had. It has great build quality and has never ever missed a beat. Having said all that what do DINKS do when they want to venture outside their inner city cafe and laundromat lined streets to where roads are wider, huge semi trailers dominate and you have to deal with other road hazards such as Kangaroos and crazy hoon drivers. While small cars are certainly very practical inside the city, they are not all they are made out to be during most other driving conditions. We have a Falcon as well as a Fiesta and while I have sometimes driven the Fiesta out of the city the experience is never too great. We have family friends with a Commodore and a VW Golf as a second car and they feel the same, that the small car is not really suitable or safe when driving on country roads. My friend believes it has something to do with the way that our country roads are made with a huge camber and often unsealed edges. Another friend while driving his Toyota Corolla ran into a ditch by the side of the road when he attempted the maneuvre of slowing down and putting his left wheels onto the dirt to give way for oncoming traffic. Luckily he was unharmed and the car was only slightly bruised but it could have been much worse if he had been a bit faster or had hit a huge boulder the farmer had placed near the ditch. People would argue that this could happen to anyone driving any car. The point is however that driving in our countryside is quite hazardous and I am glad of every extra ounce of protection I can give myself and my family. When push comes to shove there is no substitute for mass, large crumple zones and a wide and long wheelbase (for stability).

    Sasha Posted on 21 April 2008 10:55am
Read all 8 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links