Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Volkswagen Scirocco manual 2012 review

EXPERT RATING
7.5

The new Golf-based Scirocco isn't actually very new. As a nameplate, Scirocco has been around since the 1970s and pre-dates even the Golf. But Australian buyers have spent decades lusting after the small coupe in vain.

Until now. This model has been on sale in Europe since 2008 but arrives here, mid-lifecycle, for the first time. In the past, Volkswagen was concerned that the Scirocco would hit three-door Golf sales - or vice versa. The Scirocco is a Golf coupe, in effect, and the two models share engineering.

So it has compromised. Only the top-spec Scirocco R is offered and the three-door Golf R has been deleted to make room. The Golf GTI still comes as a three-door or five.

VALUE

The Scirocco R sits between those two go-fast Golfs on price and performance. It has the same 188kW turbocharged four-cylinder as the R but lacks its all-wheel drive, instead directing power to the front wheels only, like the GTI. It costs about $5000 more than a GTI but is $2500 more affordable than a Golf R.

Aside from other Volkswagens, European performance three-doors under $50,000 are thin on the ground. Its closest rivals are a Mini Cooper S or a Renault Megane RS250. Both are desirable and slightly cheaper.

DESIGN

There's less flamboyance about the Scirocco, although it's impossible to dislike its cultured Teutonic curves. Inside, it's as dark and sober a cabin as we've come to expect from Volkswagen, enlivened here and there by pleasing details, including a great wheel. The upholstery disdains the leather usually offered at this level for two-tone micro-fibre sports seats.

The fronts tilt-slide for access to the back, where there's enough room for two adults although they sit a bit skewed because the rear seats are set inboard. The headrests need cut-outs to avoid obstructing rear vision. It's adequate, but forward sight is compromised through corners by extremely thick A-pillars.

DRIVE

There were corners aplenty on the drive this week into the Victorian Alps, which turned on torrential rain and thick fog. It was an unwelcome test, but showed the car would be a podium chance at the winter Olympics. It lapped up the wet roads without missing a beat, holding its line through corners with unexpected levels of sureness. Against the odds, given the conditions, it was an enjoyable drive.

The accurate steering makes it easy to place on the road and even though it isn't the most tactile relationship with the front wheels, you get a sense of what they're doing. I was left wondering whether the all-wheel drive in the Golf R was worth the extra cost. Removing the all-wheel-drive components mean the Scirocco is 125kg lighter than the Golf R and it felt lighter and more agile.

This is partly thanks to a differential that works with the electronic stability control to selectively brake the inside wheel during hard cornering. The Scirocco also gets an adaptive suspension system as standard, with three modes from comfort to sport. Its wider track and larger 19-inch standard wheels also help, but I had doubts about what they would do for the ride quality. Even on the surprisingly good surfaces in Victoria's High Country, the ride could get fidgety. And noisy, with too much tyre roar.

On pure straight line pace, the Golf R still has an edge. They share the same direct-injection turbocharged 2.0-litre with identical power and torque figures except for a slightly broader torque band in the hatchback. The Golf R's superior all-wheel drive traction allows it to overcome its weight disadvantage and sprint more quickly to 100km/h, by 0.3 seconds. In practice, they both feel respectably quick and the Scirocco DSG -- at 6.0s to the limit -- is almost a second quicker than the Golf GTI.

This unit has an addictive mid-range that seems to go for ever and it's very flexible, so third gear is often low enough even for slow-speed corners. It pulls strongly uphill and doesn't even sound too bad for a turbocharged four, which can be a bit industrial on the ear.

What it loses in pace, the Scirocco gains in efficiency with an idle-stop system making it easier on fuel. Unusually these days the manual, at 8.1 litres per 100km, slightly outperforms the six-speed double-clutch automatic. Since this engine requires 98RON, any margin is worthwhile and the gearbox has a neat action.

VERDICT

Of course, coupes mean compromise. You won't be able to load up at Ikea quite like you can in a Golf. It's a small price to pay. With the Scirocco, Volkswagen has a winner.

Pricing guides

$21,490
Based on 11 cars listed for sale in the last 6 months
Lowest Price
$16,999
Highest Price
$23,888

Range and Specs

VehicleSpecsPrice*
R 2.0L, PULP, 6 SP MAN $18,810 – 23,870 2012 Volkswagen Scirocco 2012 R Pricing and Specs
EXPERT RATING
7.5
Philip King
Contributing Journalist

Share

Disclaimer: The pricing information shown in the editorial content (Review Prices) is to be used as a guide only and is based on information provided to Carsguide Autotrader Media Solutions Pty Ltd (Carsguide) both by third party sources and the car manufacturer at the time of publication. The Review Prices were correct at the time of publication.  Carsguide does not warrant or represent that the information is accurate, reliable, complete, current or suitable for any particular purpose. You should not use or rely upon this information without conducting an independent assessment and valuation of the vehicle.