Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Toyota Prado: business-class comfort

  • The Sunday Telegraph
image

The Prado is taken on a wild trek into the Simpson Desert and proves itself off-road worthy aside from the frail shock absorbers.

The Toyota Prado, which won the Overlander magazine's 2006 4WD Of The Year award, travels well as an urban warrior. But we wanted to see how it would fare on a longer outback journey, so we took it to the Simpson Desert in August/September.

Our test Prado GXL D4D was equipped with a genuine Toyota cargo barrier and an alloy front bullbar; two essential safety items, in our opinion. It also had the well-engineered RhinoRack roof rack installed.

The cargo barrier allowed us to pack all our supplies, equipment, camping gear and an Engel fridge safely in the Prado's large luggage area, which had the standard extra row of seats removed. Our personal gear was stacked on theback seat.

The only change to factory Toyota spec was the fitment of a set of Goodyear Wrangler tyres, which are proven tough performers in the outback.

The Prado with diesel and auto is a comfortable, quiet and relaxed highway cruiser. Some 4WD tyres can be noisy, but despite their chunky tread and square shoulders, the custom-fitted Goodyears were very quiet, too.

The Prado's 180-litre fuel capacity allows big distances (more than 1500km) between stops.

Its economy was mid-12s, which is more than the government-tested ADR figures, but there was a calculated six per cent odo/speedo error with the taller tyres, and the roof rack; with its greater wind resistance; and higher speed saddled to the Prado's thirst.

In previous testing, we've proved the Prado's good economy compared to others.

The dirt begins north of Broken Hill, with sections of smooth, fast gravel interspersed with stretches of bitumen over the hills and creeks towards Tibooburra.

The next few days took us through Innamincka and Cordillo Downs station to Birdsville. Some sections were littered with sharp, tyre-destroying rocks; others were on graded gravel that allowed 100km/h-plus cruising. Regardless of surface, the Prado simply wafted along.

Calibration of the Prado's ABS (standard on the GXL and above, optional on the base model) is spot-on. The steering seems slow at first acquaintance, but you soon learn to appreciate its slightly stand-offish character on dirt.

In the rough, the Prado is almost as quiet and refined as on-road, with hardly a murmur through the body or a squeak or sizzle from the interior trim. Its dustproofing, too, is impressive.

After a couple of days' R&R at Birdsville, we were into the Simpson Desert, one of the most fascinating 4WD adventures on the planet.

Our convoy 'aired down' (reduced tyre pressures) at the famous Big Red sand dune and, after the obligatory photos, we were off.

The soft sand proved challenging for some 4WDs in our convoy, but it was soon obvious that the momentum provided by a 30km/h approach to a dune is far more successful than a slower approach.

For three days and half the journey, the Prado didn't put a foot wrong. With no evidence of any wheel spin thanks to its full-time 4WD system, we didn't even lock the Prado's centre diff, such was its competence.

Another three or four hundred dunes; until we emerged from the Simpson's dunes just east of Purnie Bore, in South Australia.

Although the Simpson crossing was complete, we were still half a country; about 2500km from home via Dalhousie, Oodnadatta and Cooper Pedy, then bitumen to Sydney via Port Augusta, Hay and Wagga.

The Prado felt good on smooth gravel, but we were reminded of the frailty of the shock absorbers' long-stroke valving through some creek crossings and jump-ups.

I've become conditioned to this softness, but it's obvious to others who drive the Prado that the shocks are past their prime.

Anyone contemplating such an arduous trek would be wise to install specialist off-road dampers. Most 4WDs you see in the outback have this simple, relatively inexpensive modification.

Did the Prado do the job? Absolutely.

It carried the two of us in business-class comfort for 6592km, and its diesel and five- speed automatic driveline didn't miss a beat.

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 9 comments

  • The diesel injector problems are a direct cause of the poor diesel fuel quality in Australia unfortunately.  The newer diesel engines are engineered to suit European quality diesel which is 50 Cetane or higher.  Australian diesel has between 43 and 49 Cetane which is chewing out injectors. Good luck with your new diesel engines in Australia folks.

    Andrew of Cairns Posted on 14 November 2011 1:41am
  • We purchased a Sept 07 build Prado D4D VX and took delivery of it on the 01Nov 07. The car ran beautifully for the first 10,000 km but then came the dreaded injector problem. Took ages to get this sorted out and a new injector fited in the D4D. Until that time our Prado sounded like a Panza tank coming down the street. Since then we have had more than our share of faults which have included a failed main rear engine oil seal, failed transfer case pinion seal, and it still has a oil leak internal to the turbo that needs to be fixed.

    Now on top of that we have the injector problem again and it will need another one replaced.

    The D4D is a great engine when it is running normally and very economical but it has its problems with the injectors.

    We have taken our Prado off road a lot and have ditch the OEM suspension for a much better aftermarket kit which also raised it 50 mm.

    The Grandtrek AT20’s are purely road tyres and if you are seriously going to do offroad work then get some decent rubber, we are opting for Mickey Thompson ATZ 4 Rib tyres for our next set of tyres.

    Paul Svensen of Alice Springs Posted on 30 January 2009 3:12pm
  • Just a quick note on the abillity of the 2008 playdo that some people may refer to it as we have just completed over 18k trouble free klms with plenty off road adventures with a recent run up to wedge island north of perth along the main beach run to the shack which was completed easily in the crd auto. Previous visits in a grand cherokee limited 160 kw crd 2006 and the previous cherokee 128kw was always remembered with snatching and winching to get out though always still having fun there abilities were let down by there constant mechanical breakdowns with limited workshop knowledge by jeep of the new german motors.Once bitten twice shy twice bitten TOYOTA TIME .

    james wilson of perth wa Posted on 26 January 2009 4:55pm
  • This a great car ive been in it on fraiser island with joel yes it was awsome never got bogged!

    aj of gp Posted on 05 March 2008 9:53am
  • Took the 5sp auto diesel GXL Prado for a three corner and round trip from Birdsville to Poepple (Sept 2007).  Counted 1133 sand hills each way.  The 5 sp auto and common rail diesel worked great, standard Dunlop tyres at half street pressure on the sand - should have dropped to a third, used the centre diff lock (so the track does not get damaged), used about 12 litres per 100ks of diesel, best speed was between 25-35ks, just crawled over the top of the dunes for safety, took the family (4), roof rack (55kgs), lots of gear in the back. 

    Was disappointed with the amount of white paper in every photo, we took a chemical toilet, didn’t leave any tell tail trails and took our rubbish home.  Thanks to Mal for spoiling out photo of the plate at Poepple. 

    Got caught in the dust storm and rain along the K1 but the Playdo didn’t miss a beat.  For those interested we travelled the three corners, bore track, walkers track, Innamincka (Diesel was 158.9, phones out so had to pay cash), Lake Coongie, Warburton Track, QAA & French Line, etc.  Ran road pressure in the tyres on the dirt but kept our speed down, 75kph max on the dirt highways and 20kph on the rocks in the Sturt Stony Desert.  Three big rigs towing off road trailers travelled at about 80 kph passed us and had to replace all their tyres in Birdsville.  We did not get any punctures or damage the vehicle.  Paul’s set of Coopers on his Rover had 11 punctures and a new set of tyres due to chuncks, knobs missing and that was half way.  Only problem I had was the after market new Century dual battery collapsed in the Prado and was replaced in Birdsville. 

    I was surprised how easy it was, my 17y daughter drove up big red on L plates, Prado kept the dust out (except when we closed the back door with a blanket hanging out).  Prado was great on the road, dirt and sand but could smell some dust when a truck went the other way over some bull dust.  Some red dust over the jack but none inside the cabin. 

    Just be careful after the tag-a-long tours.  Had 12 cards coming the other way, let them go but they chewed up the track a bit, felt like a camel going down a few of the sand dues. 

    Prado aircon easily kept up with the outside temp which went to 46.

    Car lovers at Birdsville was fantastic, the warm water and high pressure got all the sand / dirt / dust off the car & under body.  Vacuumed the interior of the car when we got home and to my surprise there was no dust smell in the car at all. 

    Still no rattles or squeaks, so we are heading back during the winter to do a double crossing.

    Highly recommend the trip but do your homework.  The GPS only had the main highways but we used it to check distances to way points pre-entered before we left home. 

    Nifty

    nev of Brisbane Posted on 11 January 2008 8:41pm
  • We are on our second Prado, this time the manual D4D. Our first was a 2000 V6 auto. We thought the first one was impressive around town and a lot of fun in the sand.  We traded that for a 2.4 Lancer and life got grim for a while. The new model is such a pleasure to drive. Our only gripe is poor air conditioning behind the front seats on our GXL.  I hear that Toyota is rectifying this for the lower spec models soon? One more thing - old habits die hard… with the new Prado it took me 4 months to stop reaching under rego plate downlight cover in an effort to open the rear door - the handle is now up a bit higher, dopey !!

    Brett Cowan Posted on 21 November 2007 10:46am
  • I have had many Falcons and a Commodore for Company cars and the latest being an '05 Prado GXL V6 4lt.5sp.auto which is the best by far. In 29 months I have travelled 203,000 kilometres without missing a beat. Brilliant is the best way to describe it. The 180 fuel tank is a bonus and gives me 1400 kilometres between fills. The drivers seat is the most comfortable too. I can recommend this vehicle to anyone for versatility and good old driving pleasure. I love it. With kind regards, PD

    Paul Daniell Posted on 07 November 2007 11:23am
  • Glenn Torrens’ decision not to lock the Prado’s centre diff while driving off-road shows his ignorance of essential off-road driving techniques.

    Any off-road driving instructor or tag-along tour guide will tell you that it’s common sense to use every available traction aid rather than wait until it’s too late.

    Does Torrens leave his seatbelt undone when he doesn’t need it?

    He also fails to point out the comparative weakness of alloy bull bars compared to a steel one. Anyone who doubts the effectiveness of a steel bullbar should watch ARB’s excellent video comparing steel and alloy bullbars (and an even less effective ‘nudge’ bar) in an animal-strike simulation.

    Also, what route across the Simpson did this ‘test’ take? There’s a huge difference in difficulty between the most direct and harsh ‘French Line’ and the more circuitous but smoother QAA and Rig Road routes.

    Finally, the Simpson Desert has around 1100 dunes and not 600-800 according to Torrens’ reckoning.

    'Morris Dancer' (freelance 4WD journalist) Posted on 06 November 2007 5:43pm
  • We own a Toyota Prado 2005 model - auto, petrol, bullbar, spoiler and dvd player…They are a fantastic car to have whether your on road or off road…but the only problem is the suspension is a bit hard and we have trouble fitting 8 kids in the car, but we only have 5 people in the car most of the time. Its great offroad, its been to Fraser Island and it tackled that easily. In 2 we have done 43,962 kms and its been a great car….
    NB: IF YOU ARE VERY INTERESTED IN BUYING A PRADO, BE SURE TO BUY A BULLBAR AS WE HAVE HAD 3 CAR ACCIDENTS AND THERE IS NO DAMAGE!! If You are looking at a bigger car, i suggest a Mercedes-Benz GL320 cdi or the new Toyota Landcruiser 200 Series and both cars start from the $100000 mark
    Thanks and good Luck,
    Joel

    Joel Northcott Posted on 06 November 2007 9:48am
Read all 9 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links