Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Test drive: Volkswagen Golf TDi

  • By Paul Gover
  • Herald Sun
image Volkswagen's latest Golf is available in 6 models with prices starting from $25,990. Photo Gallery

Golf is a game which never changes, yet is never quite the same.

It's a similar story with the car.

Anyone who knows the Golf knows exactly what to expect when Volkswagen starts a fresh round with a new model. It will look a certain way, drive a certain way and feel a certain way.

So the sixth-generation Golf is no surprise. And in a lot of ways it is just a mega-facelift update of the previous model, the super-good fifth generation that was great for owners but tough for Volkswagen to build at a reasonable profit.

A lot has changed for Golf 6 but the best news for buyers is the price line has been held at $25,990, with more value and a lot of tweaking of details as minor as the dash lamps and mirrors and even the quality of the optional leather trim. The engines are smaller but there is better efficiency and double-clutch gearboxes are available across the range.

Later this year, of course, there will be a new GTi.

Volkswagen is aiming high with the new Golf, and not just because it is the backbone of the brand in Australia — and globally.

It knows the competition is getting tougher as everyone from Ford and Holden to Peugeot and Renault and all the rest look to cash-in on global downsizing and a green movement which is providing a lot of power for compact cars.

Volkswagen also knows it must work harder in Australia because of the classy competition — particularly the Focus, Mitsubishi Lancer and upcoming Mazda3 — which are clustered much closer to the $20,000 price point than it can manage.

It is using the smoother new body, the powerplant choices, and an Audi- style emphasis on cabin quality to do the job.

There are six models in the new Golf range, with a choice of three engines and three transmissions. The $25,990 starter car comes with a 90kW turbo petrol engine and a six-speed manual gearbox while the $35,690 hero is a 103kW turbodiesel with a six-speed DSG manu-matic gearbox.

The one in the middle is the 118kW contender with the same engine package as the GT from the previous model, using a combination of supercharger and turbocharger on the same basic 1.4 litre engine as the base car.

At the bottom, the trim level is called Trendline and this jumps to Comfortline once you pass the $30,000 threshold.

But Volkswagen is following BMW with its optional equipment, which includes everything from the metallic paint and a sunroof to parking radar, satnav with 'Excite' sound, and adaptive chassis control with switchable settings to match the driver's mood.

Driving

The first time I drove the new Golf I was underwhelmed.

The car looked and felt far too much like the old Golf to justify an 'all new' tag. It didn't help that a lot of the major building blocks in the car, from the chassis to the roof panel, are carried over.

At the time I was convinced the Golf 6 was really, in computer-speak, the Golf 5.1.

But I used a fresh set of eyes when a Golf rolled into the garage for more than just the usual one-week evaluation. And I was able to get it onto familiar territory to test a lot of the subtle changes.

But a word of warning — the Golf in the garage is a $45,160 car, not a $25,990 base model, thanks to the 118 TSI engine, DSG gearbox, Comfortline trim and a long run of extras including a sports package, parking radar, satnav, premium sound and an alarm.

It's not the car I would have chosen, but it is nice. Actually, it's very very nice.

But the price means it goes up against cars like the Honda Accord Euro when most buyers will shop it against Mazd3 and Focus and Lancer.

So, let's get the basics out of the way.

Golf 6 looks a little cleaner and smoother, and will fit right in at the trendy schools and coffee shops.

The cabin feels a touch roomier, and the improvements to plastics and switches and even the colour monitor lift it to a new level. It looks and feels like a premium compact.

The super-turbo motor is a gem. No-one would know it is only a 1.4 because it kicks like a 2-litre when you ask the questions. It is also sipping at just 7 litres/100km, despite regular bursts of acceleration.

The DSG gearbox is equally good, sliding through gears or responding quickly to a manual call for a downshift.

But...

Some of the Carsguide test team both complained about the car's jerky response, particularly in stop-start traffic or when parking. And there were also grumbles about poor response on light throttle.

So the DSG takes some learning. And it's not perfect.

But the suspension in the test car is sublime. A smooth ride with good grip and all the cornering power you could want, unless you really want the GTi. The Golf just follows the wheel and soaks up bumps.

There seemed to be a lot of tyre noise at first, but that impression has faded. But it's something to consider.

As for the rest, the Golf has won me over.

It's a great little car and, despite the Euro-style price premium, looks good and good value. It's definitely a car to recommend to friends.

Now we have to wait and see how it goes against the Mazda3, which will be the new Japanese hero in the compact class.


Snapshot

Volkswagen Golf

Engine: 1.4 litre four cylinder with supercharger and turbocharger

Power: 118kW/5900revs

Torque: 240Nm/1750-4500revs

Transmission: Seven-speed DSG, front-wheel drive

Economy: Average on test 7.0 litres/100km

SCORE: 76/100

HOW IT COMPARES

Ford Focus (from $20,490): 74/100

Mazda3 (from $21,490): 72/100

Mitsubishi Lancer (from $21,490): 73/100

Peugeot 308 (from $25,990): 68/100

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 13 comments

  • I bought a Golf TDI 2.0 with Sports Pack in 2009. Loved the test-drive of this in comparison to anything else in the price-range at the time. My car arrived. Driving it home, it would lag and take off with a neck-jerking acceleration! One time entering fast moving traffic, it faltered and went into limp-home mode. To cut a long story short, on the third visit, VW Service finally hooked up the engine diagnostics to the main-frame system in Germany. It pointed to the turbo waste-gate. Upon removal, a bolt was missing from the waste-gate and the turbo was replaced. On pick-up, I finally found the car I test-drove. Bloody brillant cornering and acceleration that would give a Boxer a run for its money. My gripe wasn’t the service I got. It was the fact that none of their test drivers picked up the radical difference between my car and a properly working one. The other gripe was the driver’s seat-belt buckle with dinging that would drive you mad that took a few visits to be replaced.
    Other than this, VW Service has been great and the cost of running this car is half of what I was spending on a Commodore so for ten-times the fun.
    VW need to improve production tests & component quality.

    Michael of Sydney Posted on 30 March 2012 8:22pm
  • My 1997 Golf 1.9 TDi has suffered a few niggles whilst under warranty, trying to convince dealers that there was a problem has been frustrating. Now the car is just out of warranty but the problems have not gone away. The first problem was a faulty passenger door lock which meant that door was always locked and could not be opened from inside or outside the vehicle, the dealer said this was an intermittent fault and could not be repaired, I replaced the lock myself and hey presto problem fixed: the issue I have is that it should have repaired under warranty. The second problem is power loss, the engine has always been a bit smoky since new and the dealer stated that this was normal for a diesel, but upon investigation I found the turbo seal was leaking enough oil to cause the turbo to carbon up and seize. I have contacted VW Australia and VW in Germany and after several months I am still waiting for a response, they seem to have very poor response and after sales service with total disregard for keeping customers happy. My future consideration when buying a car will exclude VW.

    Tony T of Melbourne Posted on 17 March 2011 8:21am
  • The engine is great and mates wonderfully to the DSG. The car has plenty of torque and is responsive. I am very disappointed with the quality of the materials used. Car dealer service is very expensive.

    De Spear Posted on 27 October 2010 11:48am
  • I am not happy with the throttle operation on our 2010 118KW Golf. From a standing start is very vauge and unresponsive. The pedal has a lot of free movement so hard to know when car is going to move and then it is like driving an electric forklift. OK once car is moving. I cant beleive it is supposed to be like this but I have been to Haven Mazda twice and two mechanics have said it is OK. It is terrible and I am sure I am not the only person having problems. Surely VW have recognised the issue and made a retrofit part. I would go so far as to say it is potentially dangerous when pulling out into a line of traffic. There is a delay when nothing happens so you give more throttle and it shoots out into the traffic too fast. The throttle really is a problem even though VW tell me all this is normal and nobody else in NZ has had any problems.

    D Lyttle of Nelson NZ Posted on 03 July 2010 5:08pm
  • My 2005 MK5 Golf 2ltr. D.S.G. diesel,73,000klms.performed OK,(a few minor niggles under warranty) until 6 weeks ago, it started no problem,was driven to the shops,parked,then refused to start,the R.A,C.checked it out,said it needed a new battery,a new battery was fitted by them,but the car still refused to start.They then sent the car to a VW.specialist in Perth, they gave me 4 different reasons for the problem on 4 different days,after getting in touch with VW Australia, they said that because the car was not at an authorised agent they could not help,fair enough,I had the car transferred to a dealer,they could not sort it,the car has now been taken to another VW dealer and I am still waiting for their comments, apart from the worry of the cost of this fiasco,I have now been without a car for 6 weeks. LET THIS BE A WARNING TO THOSE WHO ARE CONSIDERING BUYING A EUROPEAN CAR.

    george hill of mandurah,western australia 6210 Posted on 25 April 2010 7:34pm
  • I have had a 2006 2.0 TDI CSG for 3 years, doing over 120000 km. Comments such as ‘shoddy build’ & ‘unreliable’ could not be father from the truth in my experience.  I would also suggest that you drive a Golf to compare it to an Astra - no contest, everything does just what it should. Only -ve is no MP3 jack or player on base model stereo.

    craig l of melbourne Posted on 12 January 2010 12:15pm
  • Hi all I have a MY09 TDI GT Sport just over 40000 kMs. One word Beautiful. No Brilliant, it only gets better with age just like a fine wine. If you have thought that they were built in South Africa so they must be flawed then please let me correct you they are not. I will never ever change from VW ever. The 125 kW Diesel GT sport engine is one to embarass most V6 and V8 varients to 100 kMp/h as seen in real life tests, I dare you to try. This vehicle will blow them out of the water. Anyway test drive one and see for your self, and no im not on the VW payroll.

    Osti of Sydney Posted on 18 December 2009 11:58pm
  • I have the Mk V Golf GT Sport. It is the best car I have ever owned. I have done 60,000 klms in 16 months and it has been cheap to run, reliable and cheap servicing (compared to my previous Chrysler). Suffice to say I wouldn’t buy anything other than a VW. It is sensational.

    Sue Mitt of Melbourne Posted on 14 June 2009 12:27pm
  • VW have a hard task ahead of them - a lot of people got scorched with reliabiliy issues in previous models. Its going to take a lot of marketing to convince people that the otherwise expensive golf has been re-born as a quality, reliable vehicle. It will be interesting to see what happens.

    Ashley Groome of Melbourne Posted on 27 March 2009 11:27am
  • I reckon the Holden Astra is another model which you may have overlooked as a golf contender - it’s a very similar European hatch… not to mention better value, cheaper parts and servicing and probably a more extensive dealer network in Australia.

    I have a late 2005 model, and at the time that gave me similar features, a similar ride, a more powerful engine than the base golf, at a few grand less! 114,000km later, it’s still great to drive! Wish I had the diesel version now, though!!

    So if a VW Golf is out of your budget, consider a new Astra.

    Ben of QLD Posted on 24 March 2009 8:35pm
  • I have a mate with a ‘99 Golf who says he’ll never buy another one, due to its shoddy build quality and expensive parts. Why buy a German import for big $$‘s, with huge maintenance costs as it gets older? - when you can buy a local or Jap built car for less $$‘s, with better build quality, and lower maintenance and parts costs? Oh, I see, you buy a Golf and sell it after a year, before anything goes wrong with it.

    Ron N of Perth, W.A. Posted on 24 March 2009 12:43pm
  • so much nicer than that car bought in the droves by tacky people called the Mazda Throiey…

    emily of melbourne Posted on 19 March 2009 10:47am
  • Yawn!

    anthony Posted on 18 March 2009 2:47pm
Read all 13 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links