Skip navigation

New Subaru XV: first drive review

  • By Mark Hinchliffe
  • Photos

    image

    The XV has the same high ground clearance as the Forester but a lower body height than most compact SUVs. Photo Gallery

  • Video

    ...

Mark Hinchliffe road tests and reviews the Subaru XV.

Looking into our crystal ball we can already declare this the year of the compact SUV. In fact, it is the year of the sub-compact SUV as car companies realise customers are downsizing. 

Just after VW has launched the Yeti, now comes the new Subaru XV delayed from last year because of the tsunami effects, with Mazda's much-lauded CX-5 arriving soon after.

Subaru has owned this class with its classy and versatile Forester for years now and this smaller version, based on the Impreza RX wagon, is bound to help it retain that class dominance. But the XV is up against stiff opposition and competitive pricing.

VALUE

This is the first hurdle and it's complicated by the fact that all Subarus only come with four-wheel drive, so the XV instantly cedes the price advantage to competitor models with front-wheel drive options. Prices start at $28,490 for the six-speed manual which is several thousand more than the entry price of two-wheel drives from Nissan, Mitsubishi and Hyundai.

The Lineartronic continuously variable transmission (CVT) adds $2500, which is also a bit steep compared with other brands. While emphasizing that Subaru will never deviate from all-wheel drive, Subaru Australia boss Nick Senior points out that the XV with CVT has lower fuel consumption and emissions than its front-wheel drive competitors. 

"All-wheel drive sets it apart from many faux SUVs," the former rally driver says. "It's an SUV in a traditional sense with clearance more than 200mm (220mm) and all-wheel drive. It's not confined to the suburbs. The horizon is your limit."

It's also better equipped than its cheaper rivals. Even the base 2.0i model comes with Bluetooth, cruise control, seven airbags, reversing camera and is the first in its class with stop-start engine technology across the range. Marketing general manager Andrew Caie says it will make customers "question the value of getting a front-wheel drive".

The L model adds satnav, dual-zone airconditioning, sunroof, privacy glass, leather gear shift and steering wheel, and sliding centre armrest, while the S gets leather trim seats, electric driver's seat, HID headlights with washers, alloy pedals, heated front seats, wing mirror indicators, chrome door handles and silver roof rails.

Senior admits the XV is not bargain-priced, but points out the whole-of-life costs are low because of high retained values. "Whole-of-life costs are becoming increasingly important in today's cost-sensitive society," he says. Subaru is also one of the few car companies that does not charge extra for metallic or pearlescent paint.

TECHNOLOGY

XV product manager Akihide Takeuchi claims the stop-start function can save as much as 5 per cent on fuel. Together with a lighter body, longer-stoked boxer engine tuned for economy and high-geared manual and CVT transmissions, fuel savings are up as much as 20 per cent on 90RON unleaded petrol. The CVT is actually better than the manual sipping only 7 litres of fuel per 100km. "It will debunk the theory that all-wheel-drive cars aren't fuel-efficient,'' says Takeuchi.

Stop-start automatically switches off the engine in 0.5 seconds when the car is stopped and restarts in 0.35 seconds when the brake pedal is released in the CVT or clutch is engaged in the manual. The new 2.0-litre engine has the same power and torque as before but now has a longer stroke for more torque at lower revs, which translates to better acceleration. 

The manual now has six speeds, with a taller top gear that reduces engine revs from 3000rpm at 100km/h to less than 2500rpm, which is not only more economical but also quieter. The inadequate and outdated four-speed auto has been replaced by CVT with paddle shifters and six presets. 

There are screens in the centre of the instruments, in the centre stack and a third on the dashboard. The larger multi-function display has up to eight displays, which can be personalised to show a range of useful information and can even send you a happy birthday message. The upgraded audio has USB, MP3 and iPhone connectivity and there is a new satnav system with voice control and predictive text when entering an address. It will even read out your text messages.

DESIGN

The XV is based on the new Impreza due next month with a 25mm longer wheelbase, better aerodynamics, a slightly fastback look, sharper headlights and a reserved attitude to style. No pompous macho posing here. The guards aren't flared and there are few chunky bits. Perhaps that is due to the high proportion of female buyers Subaru is hoping to attract.

The XV has the same high ground clearance as the Forester but a lower body height than most compact SUVs for a rakish, sporty crossover look. The longer wheelbase translates to greater interior legroom with scalloped backs to the front seats providing more rear knee room.

Rear passengers will also welcome the move from anchoring the centre lap-sash in the ceiling to the C pillar. Child seat tether anchor points are now integrated into the back of the seats, not the cargo floor. Head room remains limited, especially in models with a sunroof. 

The doors are light and a little flimsy, but they open out very wide for easy access. Forward visibility is aided by the A pillar being narrower and further forward providing the cabin with an open, airy feel.

Storage bins and cup holders are seemingly everywhere while the door pockets will take a water bottle and an A4 folder or laptop. The centre console has a handy clip-holder for a notebook and a pen. The boot is flat with a low-loading lip and flat-folding rear seats. However, cargo space is limited because the floor is raised to accommodate a space-saver spare tyre wide enough to still permit towing for a short distance. 

SAFETY

Subaru regains its perfect record for five-star ANCAP safety ratings with the XV which has seven airbags, including full-length curtain airbags and a kneebag for the driver. They also come with a reversing camera as standard, AWD and a brake override system that is biased to the brakes if the driver hits the brake pedal and accelerator at the same time.

Driver vision is improved not only by a slimmer A pillar, but also higher front seats and 20 per cent bigger sing mirrors. The body and chassis are 20kg lighter but also 10 per cent stiffer.

DRIVING

There are more Subarus sold in Tasmania per head of population than any other state, so the company chose north-west Tassie to launch the XV this week. The route included city streets, highway, lumpy back roads, gravel forest tracks and the scarily but spectacular ascent to Ben Lomond. It's called Jacob's Ladder and it is highlighted by sheer drops and dangerous hairpins with names such as Hanging Corner.

XV came through the acid test with full marks for its road handling, grip and predictable manners. At the same time, ride and cabin noise have not been compromised. However, the wheel arches could do with more sound dampening if you are traveling over gravel frequently.

The steering doesn't have a lot of feedback, but there is no kickback either and on the lumpy country roads of this route, that was a blessing. Technical manager Derek Ashby claims the XV performs the standard obstacle avoidance test or "elk test" at 72km/h which is the same speed as the BMW X1. Brakes have a fair bit of initial bite which makes the car twitchy on gravel, but confidence-inspiring on Tassie tar.

Inside, there are simply too many screens. You don't know where to look. There is just too much information available including a graphic representation of all four wheels and what they are doing. It's distracting for the driver when they are flashing orange while the driver's hands are crossed up and the vehicle is heading for the shrubbery on a tight forest fire trail. Thankfully, the stability control keeps it all on track and you can't even turn it off; only the traction control. 

The manual transmission is disappointing with a wide spread of gears designed for fuel economy, but not performance. Second is too high and there is a huge gap from fifth to the too-tall sixth which won't accelerate and dies on hills. Senior confirmed that the gearing was high to maximize fuel economy "in line with customer expectations".

The shifter also feels notchy and you can easily grab third instead of fifth on the way down and fifth instead of third on the way up. The CVT doesn't scream like most, but it does whine a bit and to keep momentum in a slippery corner you need to use left-foot braking which is somewhat overruled by the brake override system.

Cabin comfort is good with supportive seats although the leather trim in the S model is slippery when taking hairpins. There are plenty of soft-touch rubbery surfaces inside providing a feeling of quality while the controls and door handles feel firm and assured. The overall feeling of quality is broadsided by the flimsy doors, usually your first point of contact with any car. However, some people may like the equally lightweight tailgate.

VERDICT

Subaru is boxing with one hand tied behind its back thanks to its dogged commitment to all-wheel drive only. It is also hampered by the lack of a diesel option and too-tall manual transmission. Advantages are the quiet and well-mannered ride, high safety standards, features galore and impressive fuel economy. Caie expects to sell 500 a month to younger buyers and empty nesters alike, and claims it will not cannabilise Forester which he says is a bigger car.

RATING

4 stars

Subaru XV Crossroad Sport 

Price: from about $28,490
Warranty: 3yrs/unlimited km
Service: 6 months/12,500km
Engine: 2.0-litre, 4-cyl petrol boxer, 110kW/196Nm
Transmissions: 6-speed manual, CVT; AWD
Economy: 7L/100km (man) 7.3L/100km (CVT) CO2 168g/km (man) 168g/km (CVT)
Safety: 7 airbags, stability control, ABS
Dimensions: 4450mm (L), 1780mm (W), 1615mm (H), 2635mm (W)
Fuel: 60L tank, 90RON
Turning Circle: 10.6m
Suspension: independent McPherson struts (front), independent double wishbone (rear)
Tyres: 225/55 R17 97V Yokohama Geolander
Towing: 1400kg (brakes), 750kg (unbraked)

OTHERS TO CONSIDER

Mitsubishi ASX

3.5 stars

Price: $25,990-$36,990
Engine: 2L 4cyl petrol, 110kW/197Nm; 1.8L 4cyl turbo-diesel, 110kW/300Nm
Trans: 5- & 6-speed manual, CVT; FWD, AWD
Body: 5-door, 5-seater wagon
Thirst: 5.9-8.1L/100km

Nissan Dualis

3.5 stars

Price: $24,990-$36,890
Engine: 2L, 4cyl petrol, 102kW/198Nm
Trans: 6-speed manual & CVT; FWD, AWD
Body: 5-door, 5-seater wagon
Thirst: 8.1-8.6L/100km

Mazda CX-5

4 stars

Price: XV 2.0i manual from $28,490; XV 2.0i CVT $30,990; XV 2.0i L manual $31,990; XV 2.0i L CVT $34,490; XV 2.0i S manual $34,490; XV 2.0i S CVT $36,990
Engines: 2L 4cyl petrol, 121kW/210Nm; 2.2L twin-turbo diesel, 129kW/420Nm
Trans: 6-speed manual, 6-speed auto; FWD, AWD
Thirst: 6.0L/100km (diesel, est)
Body: 5-door, 5-seat wagon

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 18 comments

  • Can you fit three kid seats in the back?

    Raymond of Denmark Posted on 08 August 2012 6:10pm
  • My wife and I looked at the XV and were impressed with equipment levels especially for the base model. We are a family of 5 and we’re looking for an alternative to are larger vehical the KIA grand carnival but when we expressed our concerns about boot space in the XV the sales man suggested that were were best to look at the forester. So I guess if you are a small family or a couple with 1 or 2 children perhaps the XV is for you. Anyhow in the end we purchased a 2011 Nissan X-Trail ST-L wagon which gave us the space we needed and equipment levels.

    Nathan Smith of Hobart Posted on 26 May 2012 9:53am
  • 2.0L Diesel available in the UK as Manual only has a combined consumption of 6.5L/100km- not much of a saving!

    Russell of Winmalee Posted on 04 April 2012 6:32am
  • Puzzled as to why LED lights to light up the cargo area have to be a $598 option.

    joso of Greythorn Posted on 30 March 2012 7:12pm
  • As long as Subaru insists on a prospective buyer handing over private details just to download a brochure, Subaru is not a car anyone should consider.This is what you are in for- no option to opt out in advance: “...We may share your personal information with our authorised Retailers, related companies and/or other third parties associated with us, which may be outside Australia. We may communicate with you via E-mail, regular mail, telephone and/or SMS….”

    peter of Balwyn Posted on 30 March 2012 6:53pm
  • I do not like the hand brake on left hand passengers side of car.

    paul reynolds of Sydney Posted on 12 February 2012 1:26pm
  • I agree with Andrew, there needs to be a comparison of like cars- the Suzuki Sx4 is the one the XV needs to be compared to, not some of the others as previously mentioned. I am in the market for a new car at present and the Sx4 is on my list.

    Chris Timms of Geelong Posted on 06 February 2012 12:48pm
  • “It’s not confined to the suburbs. The horizon is your limit.” And then you show it in the TVC, struggling on a very mild incline. More confected PR puffery.

    Patrick Bateman! Posted on 02 February 2012 7:09am
  • Rob , Thanks for doing all that leg work and posing your findings for us.

    Wayne Watson of Goulburn NSW Posted on 26 January 2012 8:11pm
  • Why whinge about the AWD being dearer than 2WD rivals??  Of course it is.  Might as well complain about gravity or something.  How does it stack up against AWD rivals?

    Adam of Tas Posted on 26 January 2012 6:38pm
  • @Jerry Atrick, no I think it means Rob drove the Golf and the Tiguan. Bringing his grand total to 8 cars! I don’t think i will need to drive 8 cars to appreciate 1, especially when they range from a Hyundai to a BMW. What a waste of time, at least the Subaru salesperson got something out of it. That’s why we have the internet so we can narrow it down before you go to drive a Great Wall X240 or a BMW X5 for a comparison, please….....

    kommen Cents of Qld Posted on 25 January 2012 4:54pm
  • Rob, what is the ‘Golf Tiguan’? You mean VW Tiguan?

    Jerry Atrick of Bulamakanka Posted on 25 January 2012 8:52am
  • To Buddah,I agree the SX4 is an older design but thats not a reason to exclude it.Its still a good design.The other point you mention about it being closer to the Impreza I disagree.The Impreza was designed as a car with AWD,the SX4 as a 4X4 thats good in the city.In other words an SUV.It has more ground clearance but not as much as the XV. Its an Impreza with more ground clearance.

    Andrew Willis of Brisbane Posted on 25 January 2012 8:04am
  • Over the past week I have test driven the Mitsubishi ASX, Nissan Dualis, Jeep Compass, Golf Tiguan, BMW X1, Hyundai IX 35 and the Subaru XV. All of these vehicles have some very good points as well as some bad; however, I would encourage those in the market to drive all of the vehicles in the class; however, drive the XV last and I think potential buyers will see what the additional cost gets them. The difference in quality and performance was clearly evident and I was happy to pay the extra couple of thousand dollars for, what is in my mind, the complete package. I pick up my XV this Friday.

    Rob Young Posted on 24 January 2012 10:32pm
  • No interior photos? Does that mean its ugly inside?

    Rob Posted on 24 January 2012 7:36pm
  • “The horizon is your limit”...*sigh*...fail…

    alex Posted on 24 January 2012 1:19pm
  • There’s two reasons the SX4 has not been noted ... it’s a very old design now, having been around long before any of the other cars mentioned.  The other thing is its not an SUV like the XV, its an AWD hatch, more like the regular Impreza hatch.

    Buddha of Brisbane Posted on 24 January 2012 1:06pm
  • And yet another XV review ignoring the cars direct rival in size,spec,price,the Suzuki SX4. It’s not just Cars Guide its all the car sites. I’m not saying the SX4 is better as I havnt driven the XV yet. I actually really like the look of the XV and it will be on the list for next time, it just annoys me that the experts dont seem to have any knowledge of the competition out there. If the SX4 isn’t a worthy comparison then tell me why. To my eyes they are both a small 4X4, both made in Japan, 2lt, CVT or 6sp man, under $30000 for the 4X4s, not like the other cars which were compared to and are over $30000 for their 4X4 versions. By the way another site quoted $28990 as the price, a lot more than the “about”$22000 mentioned in this article, and that makes it about $5000 more than the Suzuki. Is it that much better, don’t know but Cars Guide would you please do a 2 car comparison.

    Andrew Willis of Brisbane Posted on 24 January 2012 7:52am
Read all 18 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Feedback Form
Feedback Analytics