Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Subaru Forester S-Edition: review

  • By Mark Hinchliffe
  • The Courier-Mail
  • image

    The new flagship ?performance? model includes a range of WRX STI components and is the most powerful model in the compact SUV range in Australia. Photo Gallery

Mark Hinchcliffe road-tests and reviews the Subaru Forester S-Edition at it's Australian launch.

THE Bathurst 12-Hour race this weekend was to be the launch event for the new “performance” model in the Subaru Forester range.  However, Subaru boss Nick Senior says there was not a suitable category in the event for the turbocharged S-Edition. 

Instead, the S-Edition, which had its world debut at the Australian International Motor Show in Sydney last October, was launched on the dusty roads west of Canberra this week.

The new flagship “performance” model includes a range of WRX STI components and is the most powerful model in the compact SUV range in Australia.

It arrives along with a host of changes to the Forester line-up including a standard reversing camera in most models, more connectivity for iPods and Bluetooth mobile phones and the first new boxer engine since 1989.

PRICE

The S-Edition is listed at $50,990, which is $3500 more than the XT model, but it has 24kW more power, 27Nm more torque, leather upholstery and STI 17-inch wheels, turbocharger, intercooler and suspension.

Prices for the base Forester X and diesel remain unchanged despite the upgrade in standard features while the price rise in most other models has been kept to $500.

Senior also announced that Subaru and Datadot were now offering a refund of customers’ insurance excess if their vehicle is stolen and not recovered in 45 days during the first year.

TECHNOLOGY

The S-Edition 2.5 litre boxer engine generates 193kW of power, 347Nm of torque and sprints to 100km/h in 6.5 seconds compared with the XT’s 7.9.  It comes with a paddleshift five-speed automatic gearbox and Variable Torque Distribution (VTD) all-wheel drive.

The base model petrol Foresters get the new FB naturally aspirated horizontally opposed boxer engine, replacing the EJ unit introduced in 1989.  The longer stroke and smaller bore lift low and mid-range torque, decrease emissions and retain the same economy of 9.3 litres per 100km.

It also gets a maintenance-free chain drive system replacing the belts.  Senior says the engine will be introduced throughout the Subaru range over the next few years.

The new FB engine also required changes to the four-speed automatic transmission in the Forester X and XS, while the S-Edition comes in five-speed auto only. It’s a specially tuned version of the paddleshift transmission from the automatic WRX STI.

S-Edition gets the STI suspension with softer spring and damping rates and stiffer bushes, while the rest of the range just get the stiffer bushes to reduce pitch and roll.

DESIGN

Only Subaru anoraks will notice the exterior changes.  The grille is slightly different, the indicators are now in the door mirrors in all but the X and diesel models and there are two new shades of blue paint available.

Forester X, XS and XT have black-finish roof rails, while S-Edition gets silver.  Inside, the dashboard has a darker finish, a soft feel coating for the instrument panels and new colours.  S-Edition gets some extra badging, black and blue alcantara seats, drilled alloy pedals, luminescent instruments and STI wheels.

SAFETY

All Subarus have DataDot security and five-star crashworthiness ratings.  Now the Forester adds a reversing camera in all but the X and diesel models, regardless of the audio system.  However, parking sensors are an optional extra.

DRIVING

The new S-Edition is certainly quicker and more nimble, but it’s not really a performance car.  Acceleration is prompt without being electrifying and it’s accompanied by a quite sombre exhaust note.

And don’t be put off by the STI suspension componentry because this is not a bone-shaking, kidney-punching ride like the WRX STI.

Ride and handling are just about ideal for a dual-purpose vehicle with enough compliance to sort out the lumps and bumps, while keeping the car flat through corners.  It is a great improvement on the standard suspension.  Models with the new FB engine were not available for test on launch.

VERDICT

While the S-Edition is no STI, you can feel the extra oomph and the ride and handling are greatly improved.This should appeal to a slightly younger audience, although the biggest barrier will be the price tag.  Other changes should ensure the range remains at the top of the compact SUV category.

PRICES

Forester X manual             $30,990
Forester X auto               $32,990
Forester XS manual            $34,990
Forester XS auto              $36,990
Forester XS Premium manual    $38,490. With SatNav option: $40,490
Forester XS Premium auto      $40,490. With SatNav option: $42,490
Forester 2.0D manual          $35,990
Forester 2.0D Premium manual  $40,490. With SatNav option: $42,490
Forester XT manual            $39,990
Forester XT auto              $41,990
Forester XT Premium manual    $45,490
Forester XT Premium auto      $47,490
Forester S-Edition auto       $50,990

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 14 comments

  • Would it be better to buy a 2008 BMW X3 6cyl D or a Forrester S edition? Both are the same money but would a used BMW be worth it even though it has more age?

    Anthony Grasso Posted on 13 January 2012 5:28pm
  • I was actually doing the sums with a dealer for the 2011 XT Auto when I asked about the new 5 speed auto - Sorry he says it’s only available in the S - for $50+  Given that my 2009 Nissan Murano’s lease is ending and it’s a 6 speed CVT - I began wondering what I was doing at a Subaru dealer. Yes why isn’t the 5 speed available across the range?  This was truly a deal breaker!

    David of Epping NSW. Posted on 07 December 2011 10:19pm
  • I would LIKE to purchase a Forester with auto, but as long as they continue with the 4 speed auto I will be looking @ CR-V, Tiguan, Golf wagon. I see this transmission as a deal breaker and thats a shame as I have previously owned a Forester that proved to be reliable/economical/nice to drive etc.

    And I have expounded these virtues to all my friends and relatives, some have purchased WRX’s and XT’s.

    gary of melb Posted on 24 March 2011 11:36am
  • The Forester is a nice car and Subaru’s on the money with their new FB engine but there is still room for improvement in areas such as exterior styling, choice of interior material and what’s with the conventional 5 speed auto gearbox in a performance SUV or 4 speed auto for that matter in their NA models. Like some leading brands, why don’t they have one DSG like transmission across all their models! Also, for avid enthusiasts, bring on a proper STi variant not a derivative and they’ll be on the money.

    DC of Perth Posted on 25 February 2011 10:29am
  • Mat F - it’s here to stay (this year anyway). The number of 500 refers to the WR Blue colour S-Editions.

    stav of sydney Posted on 11 February 2011 8:19am
  • Can anybody confirm if this model is here to stay or limited edition only? Zupps said 500 only. City Subaru said here to stay.

    Mat F of Brisbane Posted on 08 February 2011 9:12pm
  • Sorry Rusty. Nobody in their right mind would buy an X3… Well just because… The V6 Rav? Another sexless and uninspiring vehicle from Toyota. The Tiguan? Well the jury is still out on that one.

    Mat F of Brisbane Posted on 08 February 2011 8:53pm
  • I certainly hope they have changed the air con grill on the drivers side,as on the 2010 model. It reflects into the rear vision mirror, when the sun shines through the windscreen! Very off putting and distracting. Maybe even a different colour paint “Might”  fix the problem.

    Doug Ellacott of Bundaberg Qld. 4670 Posted on 08 February 2011 12:33pm
  • I agree with Mat F the XT is such a great all rounder, no other vehicle has anywhere near the capabilities for the money. Our XT also returns similar economy and performance is only bettered by full on sports cars. If the new S-edition was available in manual we would be ordering one now.

    Lee S of Tasmania Posted on 08 February 2011 11:16am
  • At about $55,000 driveaway, you’ve got to compare it with the 147kw 7sp DSG auto leather trimmed Tiguan, amongst others, like the V6 Rav 4 Cruiser fully loaded.  Even the BMW X3 is in the ball park price wise.

    Rusty Posted on 08 February 2011 1:07am
  • subarus are like the collingwood magpies, you either love em or you hate em.hope my s edition has black and white stripes when it arrives

    KD of Gippsland Vic Posted on 07 February 2011 10:22am
  • Jim & Roger - Have you guys lost the plot?  You’re male, reading car reviews and you make those comparisons? Seriously guys, not cool.
    I have a Forester XT and no Falcon, Commodore, Golf or Megane can do all the things that I need it to do. My Forester has been through snow, ice, sand, knee deep water, mud, etc, etc. Ok its not as capable as a Wrangler or as fast as a Ferrari… but I don’t need it to be.
    It can take 4 adults fully laden with ski gear from Brisbane to Hotham and back and the best part is - when the guy in front s**ts me off, all I gotta do is plant my foot down and a surge of happiness flows through my body.
    Not to mention that I can take 4 adults and 2 huskies to the beach without it feeling cramped.
    And to top it off I average 10.54 l/100km for the last 1 year (Yes I log all my fuel and kms).
    I challenge you to name me 1 car that can do all that and cost less than $60k

    Mat F of Brisbane, QLD Posted on 06 February 2011 9:08pm
  • 51k and Subaru only equips the Forester S with a 5 speed auto?? Even the most base model Falcon / Commodore / Aurion comes with a 6 Speed auto. Someone ought to tell Subaru this is the 21st century.

    Jim C of Sydney Posted on 03 February 2011 2:09pm
  • I just don’t get it, $50K+ for a ‘performance’ compact SUV?? If you want performance, you buy a Golf Gti/R/Megane RS250 which handle better and don’t have high centre of gravity, boxy styling or cheap interior plastics… if you want practicality (eg boot space) and performance then get a Skoda octavia RS wagon, much nicer interior, more compliant ride, vastly superior gear box and fuel efficiency and still fun to punt plus all for $10K less! I just don’t get this Forester S-Edition’s appeal.

    Roger McLenny of Lane Cove Posted on 03 February 2011 9:59am
Read all 14 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links