Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Nissan Maxima Ti: review

  • By Neil Dowling
  • The Sunday Times
  • image

    The latest Maxima is a step above its predecessor — particularly in its much-needed new look. Photo Gallery

Neil Dowling road tests and reviews the Nissan Maxima Ti and finds it's still for a mature buyer.

Will cardigans ever make a comeback now that the Mitsubishi 380 is gone? It's possible thanks to the existence of rival carmakers who indulge in the ordinary. Nissan is one. The Maxima has, since birth, been a smartly-engineered sedan whose potential appeal was shot because of bland styling.

The second generation model, the one that ended early this year, was marginally better and clearly appeased those buyers itching for the return of the wool cardigan. Now there's a new, bolder Maxima. One with a more aggressive snout and stylishly thin side glass. And yet, gauging from the cabin, it is still a cardigan car.

Interior and fit-out

The pleated leather seats suit the Maxima's conservative overtones, appealing to part-time lounge room retirees who like space, comfort and the slightly sanitised smell of fallen steers.

Indeed, this is a car that my father would like to drive and in which my mother would like to be driven. It's not a young man's car, despite marketing efforts that may imply it's the older brother of the 350Z coupe. They share an engine block, dearest, not a heart.

Against rivals such as the Holden Berlina V6 (which is in the throes of a major drivetrain upgrade), the Falcon 6GE (one of the best-value large cars around), the Honda Accord V6, Skoda Superb 1.8 (gasp! Truly, 1800cc) and the impressive Toyota Aurion Presara, the Maxima hits hard but the return punches are harder.

While this new Maxima is a step above its predecessor — particularly in its much-needed new look — it doesn't reflect value. I like the simplicity of the body style and the cabin but most people still think it's stark. It has all the features and more of its rivals, it just doesn't make a show of them.

Everything works perfectly, though I still can't see the benefit of foot-operated park brakes when there's room for a conventional handbrake in the centre console and even technology around for an electronic version that takes up the space of a postage stamp.

The keyless entry and start suits the car and, dare I say, the more mature motorist who is inclined to forget the keys. I speak from personal experience. The Maxima Ti version tested wants for nothing and, at $46,990, is good value for money.

Driving

Most of the attention will centre on the car's roominess — it's generous, especially the boot — and its comfort. There is much to praise about the ride comfort which gently absorbs life's irregularities and does the whole motoring thing in a quiet, unfussed manner. As I said, a cardigan.

The spark of life comes in the form of the engine which is a retuned version of the previous model's 3.5-litre V6 and not the 370Z's 3.7-litre unit. It feels sharper, more responsive and delivers its liveliness with a guttural tone. Though the continuously-variable transmission — an automatic gearbox without traditional cogs — is effective and smooth, it softens the engine's delivery and at times feels like the right pedal is being cushioned by a big marshmallow. Egg the Maxima along and it'll put up a good show — especially when you select the transmission's manual mode — but its preference is to cruise.

Verdict: 83/100


Nissan Maxima Ti
Price: from $46,990
Engine: 3.5-litre, V6
Power: 185kW @ 6000rpm
Torque: 326Nm @ 4400rpm
Economy (official): 10.2 litres/100km, (tested): 11.6 litres/100km
Emissions: 243g/km (Corolla: 175g/km)
Transmission: CVT; front-drive


Rivals
Falcon G6E ($48,490) — 86/100
Commodore Berlina V6 ($42,790) — 81/100
Honda Accord V6 ($48,990) — 85/100
Toyota Aurion Presara ($49,990) — 85/100
Skoda Superb 1.8 Eleg ($45,990) — 82/100

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 4 comments

  • Well Neil Dowling, you have got to be proud of yourself on this report.  What a load of biased rubbish.  I have the (luxury) of using both Commodores and a Maxima at work.  Give me the Maxima any day for drive, power, comfort and handling. 

    Perhaps you should try your hand at writing dog food reviews Neil.

    Adam of Sydney Posted on 05 September 2010 2:29pm
  • To Neil Dowling - no, the previous Maxima was not the 2nd generation - with respect to local sales, it was the 4th. The first generation was from around 1989 to 1995, the second to 2000, the 3rd to 2004, and the 4th preceding this current model. Get your facts straight.

    Bob Posted on 13 July 2010 7:04pm
  • Wow what a crap report. As D. Cauz says above: Does your local service technician drive your car more than you do? The simple answer is if its a Holden yes he does. I had the unfortunate experience of being given the Holden for a number of years and now I have the Maxima. The Holden simply can not compete with this car. If you’re thinking of either of these two cars dont waste your time (and your mechanics) and get the Maxima instead.

    Mark Posted on 22 June 2010 3:24pm
  • There is one major point that all these car experts don’t comment on, this being service and repairs (reliability).
    If this was considered I’m sure Ford and Holden would rate 40/100.
    Although all cars may offer different features and functionality, it does come down to “would you buy that make of car again?”.
    I would suggest they also rate each car against the number of NRMA breakdown callouts in a given time, or warrenty claims in the first 3 years.
    I’m sure this data would make interesting reading, as it’s facts not one persons opinion.
    A car may look good and perform well, but how many times do you visit the workshop. Does your local service technician drive your car more than you do?

    D.Cauz Posted on 21 December 2009 6:13am
Read all 4 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links