Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Holden Commodore electric: first taste review

  • By Craig Duff
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    An electric version of the Holden Commdore is being built ... Photo Gallery

Craig Duff gets a quick taste of the electric Holden Commdore.

A car that could resurrect large family sedan sales and help safeguard Australian automotive jobs is being built in a tin shed in Melbourne. It's a Holden Commodore, but not as we know it.

That is evident as the car "beeps" as it reverses back to the laneway Carsguide will use as a "launch pad" for our first behind-the-wheel experience with a large, rear-wheel drive electric vehicle. Forward propulsion is silent ... tyre squeak on the painted floor and the hiss of the hydraulic power steering are the only sounds emanating from the car.

Outside, we're restrained to from-rest bursts up to 40km/h. That's more to do with the fact this car isn't registered than any worries over its driveability ... its stablemate is undergoing validation trials at the Anglesea proving ground on the same day.

Acceleration is steady, with a faint turbine whine as the Commodore picks up speed. Flicking the automatic transmission lever into Sport releases more charge from the batteries and the pace lifts noticeably.

It's not quite as quick as a regular combustion engined car but I suspect that has more to do with the way the car was programmed for Carsguide's visit and the developers' desire to keep it intact for further testing.

This Commodore has ditched the V6 engine for 300kg of lithium-ion battery cells. The battery pack is built in-house to fit in the engine bay and drivetrain tunnel, with the control electronics mounted where the fuel tank used to be.

There's still a gaping hole where the exhausts once exited, but EV Engineering - the non-profit company building the cars with the help of local auto component suppliers a $3.55 million government grant - plans to fit an aerodynamic undertray to cover the void.

The first generation car we're driving is powered by a 145kW/400Nm electric motor matched to a Borg-Warner electric single-ratio gearbox and differential.

EV Engineering's chief engineer Tim Olding says it is good for at least 140km/h and the seven "proof of concept" vehicles the company will by July will have a range of around 160km. They'll also be at least 40kg lighter than the first-gen cars.

The development has already led to the company filing several patents.

"We can buy a standard energy cell and then we have to adapt them to make it into a battery for us. So the first thing we have to do is attach a set of terminals to it. As a high-volume production cell they actually weld all the cells together. That's not a good idea for a small-scale battery because if something goes wrong we have to throw the entire battery away. So essentially, this (the terminal construction) is our technology we've had to develop. You lay a sheet of copper on the ground, lay a sheet of aluminium on top of it and then you put 50 grams of ammonium nitrate on that and explode it."

"Apparently the history is after the Battle of the Somme (World War I) they noticed bits of tanks were fused to other bits of tanks and initially couldn't work out what had happened. It's now used in armour plating ... when you want a ductile material and a hard material joined together, that's how you do it."

The resultant bond drives the impurities out and the dual-metal plate is then machined down into the square terminal posts that are screwed onto each cell and linked to create a 210-cell battery that weighs around 300kg.

Senior powertrain engineer Robert Dingli is just as convinced of the export potential of the software used to run the EV Comodore.

"We're written the code from scratch and I expect the proof of concept cars to be more "driveable" than an internal combustion Commodore," he says. "In terms of integrating the various functions on car we don't have the complexity regular engines have to contend with. The ABS and stability control systems in a conventional car have to deal with air-fuel mixtures, transmission shifts and a whole host of other parameters. We don't, and this will be a better driver's car for that."

The pair of electric Commodores already built by EV Engineering aren't the first Commodores to pack a motor.

Holden and the CSIRO built a petrol-electric ECOmmodore concept based on the VT model that was used at the Sydney Olympics Torch Relay in 2000. It was powered by a 2.0-litre four-cylinder engine sourced from the Vectra, along with a 50kW electric motor, backed up lead-acid batteries and super-capacitors. Holden announced at the time there were no plans for production ... but it obviously gave someone ideas.

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 13 comments

  • Would all the geniuses who are advocating hydrogen please explain how they are going to produce it without electricity. Regarding T Corby living 300 k from his capital city; is this relevant? How often does he make that drive? How far is his daily commute? If this car were to be produced, a range extender generator as used in the Volt would overcome most objections.
    Even with increasing electricity costs, it would still be much cheaper to recharge than paying for petrol.

    Gerry of Wishart of Wishart, Qld. Posted on 01 March 2012 6:31pm
  • With electricity prices going throught the roof why is having to buy electricity to charge up my car so much more attractive than LPG or diesel?  Besides, generating electricity means burning coall or gas in this county because we’re suddenly all scared that wind turbines are bad for our health and we don’t have the local skill base to be able to build a nuclear power lpant even if we wanted one.  Sorry but I still can’t see the point of electric cars.

    Con Fused of Port Fairy Posted on 24 February 2012 4:07am
  • great is what i say…i would like to know if it will get into the..showrooms and when…
    could you send me your comments

    richard lawrence of mandurah west aust Posted on 24 December 2011 8:52am
  • I’m probably considered as being one of the older generations (baby boomer) that still gets the wow factor when such an innovation comes along. Better still it is all Australian. To think that these types of technologies have started now shows me that there are individuals and companies willing to back these ideas. The problem with the world today particularly with the west is that we see things now and see the long term benefits of these types of technologies. It gives great joy in that these people are so creative that benefits will be here long after I’m gone. My kids and generations lives will be affected by what we do now. Remember Ford’s model T wasn’t the most efficient economic motor vehicle when it first started out. Look at it now, cars are getting are now getting 800-1000km to the tank. If we look at this objectively and take comparisons we would see the electric car is doing extremely well. At 160km range it is more than what is required for an average suburban drive. Together with battery replacement centres such as Better Place, the future looks more promising than relying on oil. It’s only the value of our dollar that’s keeping petrol cheaper at this time. Good work.

    Eric Van Der Burgt of Dandenong Posted on 16 December 2011 2:44pm
  • 160klms range I live 300klms from my nearest capital city, time to get real or hydrogen is the way to go.

    T.Corby of Wodonga Posted on 15 December 2011 11:01pm
  • For Kez. The amount of energy required to produce Hydrogen is exponentially more than that of just plugging into the grid. The amount of energy needed to split the hydrogen component from the oxegen, liquify and compress it in to storage that is why it is still on trial in the united states.It is far more than plugging in especially when you consider in European nations that a percentage of electricity is derived from green sources. I could tell you how to do it from the cars own electrical system but why do something for free. It is great to see that we don’t have to be reliant on just digging dirt out of the ground and forwarding it off to have no real benifit for the population of the country. We loose the Auto industry in Australia we loose our biggest manufacturing export.

    burningchook84 of Melbourne Posted on 15 December 2011 7:33pm
  • An electric Cruze would make more sense , still seats 5 people lighter, more agile and fleet ready! Could use 90kw electric power with a backup small diesel (900cc) engine capable of adding power if needed. Why not?

    Max W. of Aldinga Beach SA Posted on 15 December 2011 7:11pm
  • Fuel Cell powered Electric is the way to go.

    Ollygt of Brisbane Posted on 15 December 2011 6:02pm
  • With the price of Electricity going up and up, electric cars are not the way to go,  If they can produce & run Hydrogen cars in LA, why not hear in Australia?

    Kez of Sydney Posted on 15 December 2011 1:08pm
  • Finally, a ‘green’ car you’d actually want to drive. Big, roomie, powerful that doesn’t look retarded (Nissan leaf for instance).

    alex Posted on 14 December 2011 12:49pm
  • I’m not!

    g of Melb Posted on 14 December 2011 7:18am
  • What about hydrogen? Still the engine specs are pretty decent.

    MikiG Posted on 13 December 2011 6:41pm
  • I’M EXCITED !

    DOG WHO KNOWS NO FEAR of ADELAIDE Posted on 12 December 2011 7:00pm
Read all 13 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links