Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Holden Berlina sportwagon: review

  • By Neil Dowling
  • The Sunday Times
  • image

    According to Hinchliffe, the wagon is still breathing.

Neil Dowling road tests and reviews the 2011 Holden Commodore VE Series II Berlina Sportwagon.

image image
  • Comfort
  • Features
  • Versatility.
image image
  • Cabin quality
  • No spare wheel
  • Harsh engine.

YOU wake up one morning and suddenly the world's a different place. When you try to go back to bed your wife has taken all the sheets out to wash and you're left there, standing alone in a strange new world. That's pretty much me each week but increasingly it's new car buyers who walk back into the vehicle market to find that everything has changed and they're lost.

The station wagon that took the children on holidays and taught them to drive is almost extinct. Now it's SUVs (whatever!) and hatchbacks, crossovers (dressers?) and MPVs. But despite the newcomers and the demise almost a year ago of the Falcon wagon, there's comfort in the Holden Sportwagon that will appease the traditionalists.

VALUE

The Berlina Sportwagon costs $45,490 plus on-road costs and extra for things like a spare wheel - whoa, was that the noise of you falling off your chair? Yes, it's all changed. It's a fair price for what you get - the equipment level is subtle but sufficient - but the Europeans, particularly VW and Skoda, are offering more bling.

TECHNOLOGY

Even though you clearly have been sitting on your hands while the world changed, Holden hasn't. The engine range includes the Berlina's 3-litre direct petrol injection V6 with an adequate 190kW/290Nm running through a six-speed automatic with the ability of the cogs to be manually changed.

The engine is smaller than  before but just as powerful, lighter on petrol and can run quite happily on E85, an 85 per cent blend of sustainable oil from crop waste and 15 per cent petrol.

STYLING

The Sportwagon shares all the VE sedan's muscular torso features and adds a racy tail profile with narrowed side glass. It is smaller in length (by 136mm) and cargo space than its VZ wagon predecessor but the available room is excellent, the rear seats fold dead flat and the hatch is top-hinged so reduces swing length when opening.

Better ergonomics inside and the latest touch-screen controller for most major functions is very welcome - but the buttons are small - though plastic fit isn't great.

DRIVING

Any V6 is inherently imbalanced both in the odd pulsing of the exhaust and the awkward throw-weight of the three-a-side pistons. The Holden V6 doesn't disappoint with the 3-litre - like its 3.6-litre sister - being harsh in feel and noise when pressed. It settles nicely when cruising but the impression isn't great.

The 3-litre is as enjoyable as the 3.6, with sufficient zing to get it away from the lights. Most of that is due to the six-speed auto that closes up the ratio gaps. The box also helps economy with the 11.2 litres/100km coming mainly from suburban driving.

Handling is pretty good for such a big - relatively - car. The steering bites in nicely and there's always the sense that the wagon is confident. The ride is quiet and cushy with the Berlina seats notably streets ahead in comfort compared with the Omega model.

It certainly is a wagon that could swing you back from alternative SUVs.

RATING

7.5/10

FEATURES

Dual-zone climate airconditioning
6-speaker CD/iPod/USB audio
6 airbags
Rear park sensor
Trip computer.

HOLDEN BERLINA SPORTWAGON

Origin: Australia
Price: $45,490
Engine: 3-litre, V6
Power: 190kW @ 6700rpm
Torque: 290Nm @ 2900rpm
Fuel: Standard unleaded/E85
Fuel tank: 71 litres
Economy (official): 9.2 litres/100km
Economy (tested): 11.2 litres/100km
Greenhouse: 220g/km (Corolla: 174g/km)
Transmission: 6-speed automatic, sequential; rear-drive
Brakes: 4-wheel discs, ESC, ABS, EBD, brake assist
Turning circle: 11.4m
Suspension: MacPherson struts (front), multi-link, coils (rear)
Wheels: 17-inch alloy, 225/55R17 tyres; aerosol kit
Dimensions: 4897mm (l), 1899mm (w), 1476mm (h)
Wheelbase: 2915mm
Weight: 1770kg
Tow (max): 1600kg
Boot (seat up/down): 895/2000 litres (Corolla: 450/1121)
Warranty: 3yr/100,000km, roadside assist
Service: 15,000km

RIVALS

Skoda Superb 103TDI Ambition - compare this car
Price: from $43,990
Engine: 103kW/320Nm 2-litre turbocharged common-rail DOHC direct-injection four-cylinder
Transmission: six-speed twin-clutch automated manual
Thirst: 6.5l/100km; 171g/km CO2 

 

 

Subaru Liberty Exiga - compare this car
Price: from $41,990
Engine: 123kW/229Nm 2.5-litre four-cylinder
Transmission: Lineartronic Continuous Variable Transmission, all-wheel drive
Thirst: 8.6/100km combined; 202g/km CO2



 

Volkswagen Passat - compare this car
Price: from $38,990
Engine: 1.8-litre four petrol 118kW/250Nm, 2.0-litre diesel four 125kW/350Nm, 3.6-litre V6 petrol 220kW/350Nm
Transmission: 7-speed DSG, 6-speed DSG, front-wheel drive
Thirst: 7.2L/100km, 5.7L/100km, 9.7L/100km, 95 RON, CO2 168g/km, 151g/km, 227g/km




 

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 5 comments

  • I’ve had the Berlina wagon for over a year and I just don’t want to give it up-unless the next model is somehow better. Acceleration, balance, power, handling, control, comfort and style. Bulky stuff fits easily in the back-as do golf clubs, board, skis-oh and kids with their gear too. With the new quiet racks on top-it looks hot and amazingly- they make no noise! Awesome control in all conditions and a lovely smooth ride. Accelerates to required speeds on cue-despite a G force effect in the upper ranges where the tacho “sticks” at 4-5K RPM if one asks too much. Great memories of Holden are gone before but they finally got it right with this one.

    Roachy of Burraneer,Sydney Posted on 27 March 2012 11:30pm
  • Not getting rid of my Suburban any time soon!

    Richard W of Sydney-Dallas Posted on 08 April 2011 5:16pm
  • I really don’t understand the continued attack on VE’s interior. I thought the old one was nicer than any VW I’ve been in and I actually prefer it to the updated interior, too, at least in the non-sport models. And I certainly can’t work out how a Berlina can possibly score less than an ugly, under-powered FWD wagon like the Superb. Obviously no-one else can either, because I have never seen a Superb wagon on the road. It really makes me wonder where motoring journalist’s heads are at most of the time.

    MotorMouth of Sydney Posted on 29 January 2011 10:35am
  • You should give the MPG.for both E85 and standard petrol, as tested, not the figures provided by Holden, there seems to be a huge discrepancy between the real world and Holden’s dodgy numbers.

    archg Posted on 25 January 2011 8:06pm
  • Sustainable oil? How about fuel. :D

    Makes me nearly choke on my weeties when people tell me that SUVs are safer because they are higher.

    beltedradial of Sunshine Coast QLD Posted on 25 January 2011 12:11pm
Read all 5 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links