Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Holden Barina hatch: review

  • By Mark Hinchliffe
  • The Courier-Mail
  • image

    While most of the cars in the light segment are cute, the Barina is a bit more "masculine and robust". Photo Gallery

Mark Hinchliffe road tests and reviews the Holden Barina hatch.

THE charge of the light car brigade has picked up pace with Holden's new Barina hatch. It leads the charge with a five-star safety rating, a host of standard features and keen pricing.

Holden spokesman John Elsworth says it will change people's perceptions of their light cars. When it arrives in November it will come in one trim level only to make it easier and simpler for Holden, dealers and customers, Elsworth says.

The new TM Barina is built in South Korea, but is part of a global GM platform that included Australian design and testing input. The car will be sold under various names such as Chevrolet Aveo in more than 60 countries. A sedan version arrives here early next year.

VALUE

While the Barina Spark will continue to be sold as a bargain basement model, the new Barina hatch is targeting the over-$15,000 light car segment where buyers expect a little bit more. So Holden has thrown a lot of standard features at its one-trim hatch including Bluetooth with audio streaming, cruise control, rear spoiler, USB/iPod connector, follow-me-home lighting, and 15-inch alloy wheels. An obvious omission, though, is parking sensors.

The five-speed manual transmission is listed at $15,990 and at launch will sell for $16,990 drive away. The six-speed auto adds $2000 to the price. Marketing manager Emma Pinwill says motorists would have to buy the second or third trim level in other models to match the Barina's feature package.

"There are more than 30 brands in this segment - it's one of the most competitive in the world - and consumers demand more advanced value-packed products," she says.

TECHNOLOGY

Holden lead development engineer Adam Shaw says their engineers have injected Holden DNA into the Barina hatch. By that he means the car was tested on our roads and in our weather conditions to calibrate the transmission, ride and handling to suit Australian customer standards for noise and vibration, as well as local standards for fuel economy and emissions.

It is powered by a 85kW 1.6-litre petrol engine. While a diesel engine is available in other markets, Holden is adopting a wait-and-see approach. The automatic transmission has Active Select adaptive shift controls, with a wide ratio spread featuring a long first gear for rapid acceleration and a tall top gear for highway cruising with low fuel consumption. Shaw says it has 11 per cent more power than the TK Barina and 7 per cent more torque.

Yet fuel economy has improved from 7.2 litres per 100km for the manual TK Barina (7.6 auto) to 6.8 (man) and 7.3 (auto). Likewise, CO2 emissions have been reduced from 171g/km (182 auto) to 162/174. Despite the use of lightweight materials and suspension components, the car uses thicker and heavier glass to reduce noise.

DESIGN

Holden designer Richard Ferlazzo says their designer, Ondrej Koromhaz, was sent to South Korea a few years ago to lead the exterior design project for the Barina. "It's a truly global car and we're proud to say that Ondrej is one of our designers," he says. "The objective we gave him was to design a serious small car with a fun spirit."

While most of the cars in the light segment are cute, Feralzzo says the Barina is a bit more "masculine and robust", featuring motorcycle inspiration in the headlights and instruments. "Most small cars have a cheap and cheerful happy look," he says. "This has a little bit of a frown and assertiveness. For a small car it's tough and nuggety."

The cabin features more than 12 storage spaces in the front passenger compartment, including cubby holes above and beside the centre stack, on top of the dashboard, in the doors and centre console, and a two-part glovebox. It comes in seven exterior colours with metallic paint costing an extra $500.

Pinwill says accessories include "lots of bling" such as chrome light surrounds and alloy pedals. "This is a style-conscious market," she says. "It's no secret that this segment is skewed to females, but the sporting orientation gives us the chance to market at males as well."

SAFETY

The Barina has scored a maximum five stars in the latest ANCAP safety ratings. Shaw says this is due to the structural integrity of the body and chassis which includes high-strength steel, crumple zones, tubular door beams, a protected fuel tank and reinforced A and B pillars. There are also five seatbelts with pretensioners in the front, six airbags, collapsible pedals and pedestrian protection in the bonnet and bumpers. It also has stability and traction control, plus a suite of braking safety technology.

DRIVING

The photos show a wide-legged, muscular hatch, but the wide-angle lens shots accentuate the features. It's not that macho in the flesh/metal. However, it is a tidy design with an aggressive set of "teeth and eyes".

Inside, the plastic trim looks a lot softer than it actually is, but it's still good quality with a lot of handy receptacles to store mobile phones, iPods, wallets, coins, etc. The iPod connector plugs are conveniently located in the upper glovebox. Fit and finish is every bit as good as its Japanese and Korean colleagues.

However, the levels of wind and road noise are much better. This feels a refined and civilised car to drive in the city and no less harsh on the open road.  It hits potholes without fuss and feels solid and unshaken. The five-speed manual is a slick gearbox with a light clutch that is easy to use in heavy traffic.

The auto tends to flare and hunt around a bit too much, especially under acceleration or up hills. Steering is light enough for carpark situations with an assured feeling on the highway. The brake pedal feels firm and the stoppers are responsive even though it has drums on the rear like many of its kinfolk.

It may only be a small car, but it feels big inside. The outer limits of the body are difficult to see, so parking sensors would be handy. The front seats have plenty of adjustment and the steering wheel is adjustable for reach and height, so it is easy to get a suitable position for any driver. Rear leg and head room is ok for adults, but boot space is tight. The rear seats fold down and have a 60-40 split for cargo flexibility.

VERDICT

This is a much more civlised and refined model than the TK Barina. Put this on your grocery list if you're looking for a safe, light car with a lot of features.       

RATING

3 stars

HOLDEN BARINA HATCH

Price: $15,990 (manual), $17,990 (auto), $16,990 driveaway (man), $500 (metallic paint)
Warranty: 3-year/100,000km
Service: 15,000km/1 yr
Engine: 1.6-litre 4-cylinder petrol, 85kW/155Nm
Transmission: 5-speed manual, 6-speed automatic, FWD
Fuel: 91 RON ULP, 46-litre tank
Economy: 6.8L/100km (man), 7.3 (auto)
CO2: 162g/km (man), 174 (auto)
Safety: Stability and traction control, 6 airbags, 5-star rating, ABS, Brake Assist, Electronic Brakeforce Distribution
Brakes: ventilated discs (front), drums (rear)
Suspension: MacPherson strut, torsion beam
Dimensions: 4039mm (L), 1735mm (W), 1517 (H), 2525mm (WB)

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 24 comments

  • Just brought a flame red one and it’s amazingly easy to drive!. Engine is so quiet it’s almost hard to tell its running. Feels very safe to drive especially with the six air bags and looks extremely sturdy for a small car. Love the interior and “follow me” head lights. I can’t wait to test it on a road trip with my friends!!!

    Jasmine Dior of VIC Posted on 19 December 2011 5:25pm
  • Looks very nice, distinctively different. Should sell well.

    Roger C of Hamilton NZ Posted on 04 October 2011 11:18am
  • I don’t know what you’re on about Herbie, I’m not a Holden guy at all and I’d have shot myself before buying myself a Barina. But I agree with the reviewer, this car looks a lot more masculine and it would actually be a strong contender in my eyes if it wasn’t a Holden! raspberry

    Cameron B of Mt Gravatt, QLD Posted on 30 September 2011 11:04am
  • The reviewer refers to the lack of rear parking sensors on a hatchback under 4 metres long. Maybe, when your feet hit the ground, you’ll remember you’re comparing a Barina features to that not found on many luxury cars 4-5 times the price tag. Get real or lose your target reader of $15K cars.

    Luke ChiodoGurr of Melbourne Posted on 28 September 2011 6:13pm
  • This thing looks terrible. Haven’t seen it in the flesh yet, but pictures look disgusting. I reckon a pre-schooler could have styled it better. Maybe it looks better in the metal. The engine is very agricultural - you’d pay for the extra 3-4K for the Rio in a couple of years if you travelled 30000-40000 a year, quicker if you did more Ks.

    Herbie Posted on 28 September 2011 11:29am
  • Article says “an obvious omission, though, is parking sensors”. Really? It’s a small hatchback, not a Hummer. You don’t need parking sensors. And given that many of the buyers will likely be people who’ve just got their license, we can assume they know how to reverse-parallel park or similar as it’s a requirement to pass. For the record, I think it’s a good looking car.

    Alasdair of Melbourne Posted on 28 September 2011 10:20am
  • Front looks a bit Lancerish tongue laugh

    Glen Jenkins of Thirlmere NSW Posted on 27 September 2011 8:54pm
  • Hyundai i20 look-a-like? Would buy the Hyundai any day ... better warranty, better fuel economy, after all both, made in same country so might as well buy on those two reasons.

    Wayne Hobbs of Aldinga Beach SA Posted on 27 September 2011 6:27pm
  • Australia, pay more get less! Every car over here is around 2 x the price, yet we only get 50% the car that our overseas friends get! its just not fair! Well I blame the government for over taxing everything.

    Mr_GaZZa of Pertho Posted on 27 September 2011 6:07pm
  • I hired a Barina and a Yaris last week from Hertz. Both <5000km on the clock. I was very surprised. The Yaris was like a sh!tbox from the ‘70s - noisy, rough, truly awful. I would not spend my money on a Yaris in a mad fit. The Barina was like driving a $50k car. Light years ahead in dynamics, quieter, well behaved, lovely little car. Serious. I was not expecting this result.

    Rick of Sydney Posted on 27 September 2011 6:01pm
  • kia 3 to 4 k more

    Stan Posted on 26 September 2011 6:23am
  • So why doesn’t Holden offer a six speed manual gearbox like in the USA with the Chevrolet Sonic?

    World Car? of Sydney Posted on 25 September 2011 9:28pm
  • GM had the chance to make a real point of difference with a diesel,all round discs,reversing sensors and a 5 year warranty.
    I understand that this segment makes little money and is super competitive, but the 3 star rating reflects.what amounts to middling attempt to a segment of which other manufacturers appear to have a far better appreciation.

    Christopher James of Croydon, Vic Posted on 25 September 2011 5:14pm
  • Hey Paolo, Barina is built on a newer version of the same platform as Corsa, so it should be a better car all-round. I think the current Corsa looks bloody horrible, too.
    Dougie, the 1.6 in the Rio has direct injection and costs two grand more as a result. You get what you pay for.

    MotorMouth of Sydney Posted on 25 September 2011 12:06pm
  • This is a review right? Oh hang on, I think it’s just the reproduction of the Holden brochure ... Should a review contain so many quotes and opinions by the car maker and designer? Hardly independent advice.

    jts Posted on 25 September 2011 10:27am
  • Opel’s Corsa would be nice only if Opel themselves weren’t coming over in a year’s time.

    Danny of Sydney Posted on 24 September 2011 11:17pm
  • Put a gen 3 motor in it and I’ll buy it.

    block Posted on 23 September 2011 11:40pm
  • Hmmm. Once again GMH seems to be short-sighted in excluding a properly priced DIESEL version, let’s hope there is sufficient interest to warrant its inclusion? As it stands, it’s not particularly fuel efficient.

    Tony of Melbourne Posted on 23 September 2011 11:26pm
  • Come on who need parking sensor on a small hatch. Defeats the whole point. Still looks cheap, the new Kia Rio looks miles more up-market. The face looks too much like a shrunken Mitsu Lancer (which is proportionally good on a Lancer but ill-fitted on the Barina).

    Phuong of ACT Posted on 23 September 2011 6:10pm
  • Hello? GM? Helloooo? Opel’s Corsa looks alright…

    Paulo of Bris Posted on 23 September 2011 3:17pm
  • Good review for 3 stars - Guess it needs to be a Euro or Japanese brand to get more.

    Jim Kensington of Sydney Posted on 23 September 2011 1:34pm
  • One for the P plate Holden Bogan chicks.

    Holden Lover Posted on 23 September 2011 12:25pm
  • Of course there will be a WRC version, right? Hello? GM? Helloooo?

    Adam of Tas Posted on 21 September 2011 12:45pm
  • Fuel economy is very poor considering that the 1.6 in the RIO gets 5.6l/100 km.

    Dougie Posted on 21 September 2011 11:08am
Read all 24 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links