Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Going topless: best convertibles

  • By Paul Pottinger
  • The Daily Telegraph
image Volkswagen Eos TFSI offers great value from $49,990. Photo Gallery

Ah, spring: the season in which tops come off torsos and cars alike, to varying effect.

And, given the push-button convenience of the latter these days, the car's upper garb often comes off quicker.

Spring is also, of course, the time when Carsguide preaches to the convertible.

It's a task made easier by the ever-expanding range of topless four-seaters _ cars that combine a decent degree of utility with a goodly serving of desirability _ so that now ever more are converting.

The facility to have it off and on at will (most such lids fold up or down in around 20 seconds and some can do it at 30km/h) is worth a lot more as a selling point than all the kilowatts and cornering force figures in the world combined. Otherwise, just buy a coupe.

Not that BMW's 125i (priced from$63,755) lacks a means of propulsion or is in any way reluctant to address bends.

Even detuned to 160kW/270Nm, this three-litre jobbie is a classic example of the Bavarian's trademark in-line six _ which, combined with rear-wheel-drive dynamics, is unique among current compact convertibles.

Contrary to the hairdryer image of this genre, the only thing soft about the 125i is its roof which, in a world increasingly given to folding metal numbers, is of fabric construction.

For a car that, even by the compromised norm of this type, is knee-crushingly cramped in the back, it's starting to get bloody dear _ though even that's relative, given it's $30K easier on the wallet than the identically engined 325i.

Equally, the Volkswagen Eos TFSI (from $49,990) offers value _ indeed, allure _ that would necessitate spending maybe $40K extra on a more prestigious badge.

The VeeWee also boasts the best top of all these sometimes-roofless Germans: one with a number of variations, all of which enable it to be completely convincing as either a convertible or as a coupe. In either guise, it looks great.

The TFSI shares the Golf GTI's platform and drivetrains: a slick, six-speed manual or a twin-clutch auto driving that sublime two-litre, direct-injection turbo four-potter.

If you tick the optional sports suspension with 18-inch tyres box, it can do a fair dynamic imitation of this now-ubiquitous warmish hatch.

So can Audi's A3 2.0 TFSI Cabrio (from $54,900) _ as it should, given that it has the same underpinnings and go bits as the allegedly humbler Eos.

But although perceived prestige badges can have a disorienting effect on some punters' sense of proportion, the Eos's trick roof is enough to see it shroud out its soft-topped cousin.

It used to be that to go topless in traffic, you had to be Swedish; time was, indeed, that Saab's 9-3 was synonymous with this sort of behaviour.

But that was 10 years ago. Today, a 9-3 Convertible is an unreliable and outclassed alternative to simply wearing a T-shirt that reads: “Clueless”.

Fortunately for Scando enthusiasts, there's Volvo's C70 T5 (from $79,950). No, it doesn't get up and go anything like those mentioned above (despite a worthy 2.5-litre, five-cylinder turbo), much less handle.

But it does have visual presence, GT composure, a smart folding metal roof and _ perhaps more to the Swede-lover's point _ a perceptible quality of having been hewn from something extremely solid and ever-so safe.

Just as Lexus's IS sedan chucked a spanner into the compact prestige segment by doing a rear-drive/six-pots-up-front package that undercut the Germans for value, so too will the Lexus IS250C coupe/convertible.

Seen at the Sydney motor show, this folding-aluminium-roof number is due in these parts in the second half of 2009 _ no doubt priced at a point to cause the Europeans maximum discomfort.

The IS250C has a rear overhang some 50mm longer than the sedan, and Lexus claims class-leading boot space even with the lightweight, three-piece lid folded.

Roof up, it looks better still, with a coupe sleekness that becomes the IS more than the four-door shape.

The IS250C shares the sedan's 153kW/252Nm 2.5-litre V6 and six-speed, paddle-shift automatic.

At $1.19 million, the ultimate convertible costs 20 times more than the least expensive car here, but the Rolls-Royce Phantom Drophead Coupe is quite possibly the world's best car _so this seems only right and proper.

We mention it mainly to have an excuse to run its exquisite likeness, because next to none of us is ever going to get into one.

But it somehow helps to know that those who do have the wherewithal aren't wasting their dough on rubbish.

Besides, as the stock market goes at the moment, a Rolls is probably a better investment than shares.

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 7 comments

  • Dear Barbara. I drive an astra twintop. I have lusted after an MX5 for years but that practical bit of my brain thought you need a back seat for the kids. If you want a fairly cheap 40kish good looking, leather lined, climate controlled cruiser check it out. The roof has malfunctioned twice in two weeks the second time the dealer fixed it properly and for the last year it has not missed a beat. Although not terribly quick and a little wobbly with the roof down it is still nice to drive. Mine is 6 speed manual [the auto is an old 4 speeder and slow] happy shopping.

    Pat of berwick Posted on 17 March 2009 9:34pm
  • I am looking to buy a convertible at LONG last…my kids have finally left home and I want to drive around with the ‘wind in my hair’ (even if I’m not in Paris.). Could someone recommend a reliable, preferably 4 seater coupe/convertible? Preferably with parts that aren’t through the roof. Thank you

    barbara mcquarie of moorabbin Posted on 25 November 2008 5:17pm
  • Had a BMW 650I Sport Convertible in the UK for a while. Stunning car, a second hand one can be picked up for £30K ($75K Aud). Isn’t it time soon to scrap the silly lux car tax and import duty in Australia?
    We are forced to drive substandard cars - for what reason?

    Tom Metzie Posted on 13 November 2008 4:17pm
  • NOT BAD WHATS THE CRUISING SPEED AND CAN IT GO UNDERWATER AS SOME CARS CAN.

    CRAIG ELLIOTT Posted on 29 October 2008 7:07pm
  • And what about the Renault Megane coupe cabriolet….It is as well designed as the Wee Wee, it is automatic as well as manual and reasonnably priced…A good performer too.Test it yourself…go and have a lookm at it…The new version of course.

    guy brehon of Brisbane Posted on 29 October 2008 11:53am
  • Well the Porsche 911 is a 4 seater & didn’t seem to get a mention, in spite of being more fun and ability per dollar than all the others combined. Not cheap (unless compared to the Rolls) but price is obviously not part of the criteria.. And don’t say it’s not a 4 seater, I carry 3/4 people regularly & children ARE people!  You don’t have to drive a Porsche or any car fast to enjoy yourself!

    Geoff Posted on 28 October 2008 8:58pm
  • No, Ash, I didn’t forget about the MX-5. And if it would have been number one – if we’d been talking about roadsters.
    But we’re not. We’re talking about four seaters. As soft as you or I might think some of ‘em, most punters are attracted by the open aspect, not the ability to get round corners quick.
    A Renesis MX???? The man’s a rotary fanatic …
    Cheers - PP

    ———————————

    Come on Paul,
    What, did you forget..the BEST Convertible on the market today, the Mazda MX-5 Roadster Coupe.
    It may not have the straight line speed or power, but, boy what a REAL Drivers ‘Sports Car”., an engineering and handling masterpiece.
    Do you seriously believe any Front Wheel Drive Convertible has the privilege of belonging in the Convertible’s Stable?
    Wouldn’t you love to see an MX-5 Roadster Coupe with a RENESIS Rotary Engine as it’s heart..
    MMMmmm
    Ash

    ASH Grant of SA Posted on 28 October 2008 12:38pm
Read all 7 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links