Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Ford Fiesta Econetic: review

  • By Paul Gover and Alison Ward
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    First impressions of the Ford Fiesta Econetic are positive thanks to its balanced styling and a clever ability to look bigger than it is. Photo Gallery

Paul Gover and Alison Ward road test and review the Ford Fiesta Econetic

There are a lot of reasons to like Australia's newest green car. But here is the clincher: it's a great drive.  The Ford Fiesta Econetic hit Australia with all sorts of claims about fuel economy and emissions, as the blue oval brand touts it as a Prius beater. And with a $15,000 price advantage over the Toyota hybrid.

I looked and listened, but tried to avoid getting caught in the hype despite the judging panel picking the Econetic as the Carsguide Green Car of the Year for 2009.  Me? I took the safe road and voted for the Prius, since I had not driven the Econetic Fiesta.  Now I have and it's become my first-choice car for green driving.

The little Ford has a hugely economical turbodiesel engine that easily returned 4.8L/100km economy during my test drive, with the promise of excellent emissions at the same time, as well as delivering reasonable comfort, a great looking body and the sort of dynamic driving response that made the 'regular' Fiesta my small-car pick for 2009.

The Econetic takes a little adjustment, because you need to shift early and often in the five-speed manual gearbox, but it is a surprisingly rapid little car which can also devour corners without causing any upsets or disappointments.

It's a real pity Ford delivered the test car with giant advertising slogans down the side — it was plain embarassing to be seen at the wheel — because there is so much to like.

and approach to green motoring. The next for Australia is the new Focus.

Drivetrain

Its heart is a 1.6-litre common-rail turbodiesel engine tuned for maximum efficiency. It does not have a stop-start system to kill the engine at the lights, and it's not as advanced as the 'belt-less' Prius petrol motor on cutting parasitic drag, but it has low-resistance tyres, a unique transmission and gears, a lower ride height and wheel covers to cut drag, and a shift light to signal when to pick the next gear. Ford even says it dropped the spare tyre to cut weight, although it obviously also saves money.

The engine makes only 66 kiloWatts, but compensates with 200 Newton-metres of torque, up by nearly 25 per cent from the regular 1.6-litre petrol Fiesta. Its official efficiency claims are 3.7L/100km economy and 98g/km of CO2, joining the Prius as the only cars sold in Australia at less than 100.

Safety

Apart from the green stuff, the latest Fiesta comes with five-star ANCAP safety including seven airbags - one for the driver's knees - and the usual punchy sound system, aircon, power steering and the rest.

The Econetic comes to Australia at a time when the BMW group is making a lot of noise about its BMW 118d and Mini D fuel misers, but the Ford has a massive price advantage. The cheapest Mini is $36,100 and you need at least $44,370 to go shopping for a 118d.  And those prices don't include on-road costs, where the Fiesta is a $24,990 all-in, driveaway deal.

Ford was hoping for big things and the initial reaction has been very positive, with at least 300 delivered since sales began at the start of December.  "Dealers are sold out of our initial stock, which is a good sign," says Sinead McAlary, spokesperson for Ford Australia.

DRIVING - Paul Gover

The Econetic Fiesta is expensive for a car its size, but it is very good value.  You can buy some baby diesels for less but they won't match the Fiesta as a drive or for green-ness, and the hybrids and high-flier Euro greenies are way more expensive.

My only complaints are the manual-only gearbox package, because the vast majority of Australians buy autos, and the lack of electric windows in the back doors. That's it.  It would have been good to have stop-start to cut the engine at the lights, but Ford says it was not available at Fiesta time and is coming first on Focus.

The Econetic test car is tight and responsive with a driver-friendly cabin that also works well for storage, visibility, comfort and light. The front seats could have a better shape, but they are good enough for the job.

As a drive, the Econetic tuning demands you shift as low as 2500 revs — with a green arrow in the tachometer as a reminder — but then pulls strongly anyway. It is a surprisingly brisk little car that punches way above its weight.

It's the same in corners, where the Michelin 'energy' tyres should rob grip as they cut drag. But the car is light, well balanced, responds well to the steering and carries surprising pace through twisties.

I also love the punch for overtaking, and the ability to take most corners a gear higher than normal. The pulling power from the turbodiesel means you can easily kick around a second-gear junction in third and just accelerate away.

The engine is also surprisingly quiet — "To think I used to wear ear muffs to tune a diesel," says Jonathon of the Carsguide team — and the range between fuel stops can easily push beyond 800 kilometres.

The regular Fiesta is good but the Econetic is plain great. It's a class leader with a new edge and the sort of car many more Australians should have on their shopping list.

SHE SAYS - Alison Ward

The Econetic Fiesta is a worthy little party crasher, and not just because of its fuel economy.    This is a grunty little car and Fiesta drivers should feel the good time vibes when behind the wheel. 

First impressions are positive thanks to its balanced styling and a clever ability to look bigger than it is. I don't much like the chunky, front grill, but its not enough to distract you from the party going on inside the car.

The baby diesel engine is a gutsy drive, smooth and easy to handle. The gearshift is light and the pulling power means you don't have to change down as much for suburban turns or roundabouts.

I drove through dry and wet weather and the car continued to handle well. It felt safe cornering. The suspension is good, considering the size of the car, with far less road noise than some of its competitors.  I'm not sot sure about this model only being available in a manual, luckily it is a fun drive and you won't have any trouble with those pesky hill starts.

The seats aren't very comfortable, but you're not going to need a trip to the chiropractor.  At least I didn't need therapy after driving around town and a couple of longer runs on sealed country roads.

The sound system is fantastic.  The entertainment controls on the wheel and centre console are sleek in design and keep the good times rolling. The Bluetooth, voice control and USB port will tick all the boxes for those savvy enough to use them.

But the air-con is disappointing on hotter days and lags behind its Asian-car rivals. Boot space is also a compromise for parents, with little room for a pram or stroller, and I don't like the manual window winders for the rear seats.  The newest Fiesta is not cheap, but it works for youngsters and - get ready for the pun - the Eco-nomically driven among us.

Score 85/100

The Bottom Line: A new benchmark for affordable, environmentally friendly motoring. And a great drive.

Ford Fiesta Econetic LX

Price: $24,990
Engine: 1.6-litre four-cylinder
Torque: 200Nm at 1750 revs
Transmission:  Five-speed manual
Body: Five-door hatch
Seats: Five
Dimensions:  Length 3950mm, Width 1722mm, Height 1471mm, Wheelbase 2489mm, tracks front/rear 1473mm/1460mm
Steering: Power assisted rack and pinion
Suspension: Front MacPherson struts; twist-beam/coil springs rear
Fuel Tank: 40 litres
Fuel Type: Diesel
Fuel Consumption: 3.7/100km combined
Weight: 1088kg
Spare Tyre: Mobility kit
Brakes: Anti-skid disc/drum
Wheels: 14-inch steel
Tyres: 175/65 R14
Safety Gear: Dual front, side, curtain and driver's knee airbags, electronic stability control, traction control, anti-skid brakes, brake assist, emergency brake distribution
CO2 Emissions: 98g/km

RIVALS


Volkswagen Polo 1,9 TDI: 77/100 (from $22,990)
Hyundai i30 1.6 CRDi: 81/100 (from $22,890)
Citroen C3 1.6 HDi: 78/100 (from $23,990)
Peugeot 207 1.6 HDi: 77/100 (from $29,490)

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 20 comments

  • I think the reason for the high price for such a ‘cheap’ car (with SOHC, 5-speed manual, etc etc) could be due to the money spent in R&D on this product. I read a paper in 2007 that discussed Ford’s spending into achieving “super efficient” diesel engines. They found that through the course of their research their current setup for the SOHC 5-speed was the way to go. Even with the price tag: it’s like the K-cars in Japan being more expensive than their Subaru station wagons - you’ll save the money in the long run on fuel (for one). Plus, as stated in the article, it doesn’t disappoint in performance, so as soon as I can, I will purchase one, I just gotta make sure to drive it regularly!

    Anonymous Posted on 08 September 2011 1:23pm
  • Any diesel that can average 3.7 l/100 is engineered well. There’s a reason why it’s got a tall-geared 5 speed, and SOHC, why I don’t know, but if they weren’t meant to be like that they wouldn’t be. And far out, if you are planning on towing with this little thing, you obviously aren’t buying it for economy. Buy a diesel Focus or Golf instead.

    mannix Posted on 27 July 2011 11:09pm
  • The Econetic is a great car. Unfortunately I have just found out that it in fact has a Zero Tow rating IE you can not fit a tow bar. Ford is being very quite about this, for instance the tow pack for the Econetic disappeared off the ford web site just last night. This unfortunately leaves me with a car which will not do what I purchased it to do, and was assured by a Ford dealer it would do which is why I purchased it.

    Michael Peter MC Mahon of NSW Posted on 30 June 2011 3:47pm
  • This article is full of mistakes, Econetic does NOT have 6 speeds, it only has 5, but it SHOULD have 6! The engine should have been, indeed, DOHC, not SOHC which is an expired technology. Not to speak about not having auto, it makes it all weird. Anyway, the price is extremely expensive, Ford should make cheaper cars, we all know what cars we can buy for the same money, and cars, not 1.6 engines.

    Steven of Melbourne Posted on 17 April 2011 10:25pm
  • I was told this evening by a dealership at Brookvale that the Econetic was no longer manufactured and was only created as an introduction for Ford into the diesel/economic market. He said that the LX WT was basically “the new Econetic”. But then again, the dealers will tell you whatever they need to to sell a car!

    A. Batterham of Newcastle Posted on 13 April 2011 7:19pm
  • Drum brakes present less drag on the wheels than disc brakes.  There is also probably a cost benefit when using them too as it is easier to incorporate the park brake mechanism.
    I’m sure this will stir things up, but around town at generally low speeds on a small, light, low powered car, you aren’t going to see much/any performance or feel benefit in using rear disc brakes.
    I don’t see it as an issue with it having rear drums and it’s probably a benefit.  Most people wouldn’t know if you didn’t tell them.

    G Johnson of Sydney suburbs Posted on 25 March 2011 8:16am
  • I decided I was going to buy one of these so I got my daughter to help me with my initial research as I am very busy. She started at our nearest Ford dealer in Springwood who told her the Fiesta Econetic is no longer manufactured. She came home with a brochure on the Fiesta range which seemed to bear out this surprising claim. No Econetic. So, on to Ford’s Australian website, where it is still advertised, but there is no “contact page” or even an email address to ask Ford what is going on. Anyone out there able to clue me in?

    Davidthedave of Bahrs Scrub Posted on 13 February 2011 7:44am
  • I had this car over 7 months. Great car even for long runs.
    The only concern is when their is heavy rain water gets in the boot.
    Has anyone else had this problem?

    Mohamed Nazar of Victoria Posted on 26 December 2010 12:31pm
  • I find the “figures” quite unremarkable when compared to Hyundai’s i30 diesel. It too is 1.6 litre yet it puts out 85kw with 255nm of torque.

    Rustynutz of South Gippsland Posted on 17 July 2010 4:41pm
  • All these cars have drum brakes on the rear in 2010. It is only till you get into the Corolla Class Segment where four wheel disk brakes are offered. Even the Nissan Tiida makes do with drums in the rear and that came out in Australia in 2006. I should know, I drive a Series 1 version of that.

    franz chong of adelaide Posted on 23 June 2010 11:42pm
  • It is definitely a car for big users, I drive about 60 000 km per year, and the saving is about $2300 each year compared to other Fiesta’s, but it has all the safety features, 7 airbags, abs, traction control… and compared to my previous car Focus XR5 turbo, it is a saving of over $5000 of petrol and insurance.
    I just love that car! whoops!

    emmanuel de cosse brissac of Kingscliff NSW Posted on 29 April 2010 4:43pm
  • In answer to Maria, i just bought an Fiesta Econetic and get over 50 miles/gallon, I actually have averaged 4.5l/100 over the last 3000km, which is over 52miles/gallon. Mainly freeway driving at 110 km/h with air conditioning on. I love the blue tooth voice recognition sound system. My previous car was a Focus XR5 turbo but I don’t miss the power as the Fiesta is surprisingly very smooth and quick. The only issue is to find the right nozzle from the diesel pump, as it only takes the small one…sometimes!

    emmanuel de cosse brissac of Kingscliff NSW Posted on 29 April 2010 4:34pm
  • I’ve just been reading all the reviews on this vehicle.  My husband and I recently purchased a brand new Ford Fiesta econetic from a local Ford dealer in the hope that one of the attractions was to achieve more miles to the gallon.  Since we’ve had the vehicle for 3 months now we are only getting 47 -50 miles to the gallon which is very disappointing - we have complained to the dealer who agrees with us that the mileage is lower than expected, we were hoping to achieve nearer the 60 miles per gallon.  When we purchased the vehicle the dealer did say that the car would take 2 or 3 months ‘to loosen up’ and then we will notice the saving in diesel - sadly although we have done nearly 3500 miles, the car is still only achieving 47 to 50 miles per gallon.  We are extremely disappointed.  The car is due to go back to the dealer at the end of the month for an exploratory check, however they have said to us that if there was a mechanical problem with the vehicle we would have had warning lights appearing on the dash board.  This has not been the case.  Overall, so far, we are extremely disappointed with the cars performance and are hoping that the fuel situation can be resolved. Maria

    Maria Collier of South West Posted on 19 March 2010 11:39pm
  • when is the manual due to come to Australia

    s hunter of n s w Posted on 12 March 2010 4:56pm
  • I am waiting for the all new 2010 VW Polo 1.6TDI in May. If I am going to spend mid to high 20’s I will buy European.

    Alex Alex of Doncaster Posted on 23 February 2010 4:54pm
  • Yes, it may be more expensive Kim, but the target market for this car are more primarily concerned about cost. The fact it produces a lot less emissions and uses a lot less fuel is what the potential customer wants. Some people (not really including myself) are prepared to spend money to help the planet and keep cities clean. Personally, I’m waiting for the Focus RS to come out.

    Tim Gardner of Melbourne Posted on 23 February 2010 1:27am
  • I can’t believe how everyone is so gushing about the Fiesta Eco. Yes its a fine car and a worthy fuel miser, but at $25,000! The same Fiesta without the “Eco” badge is $18,000, thats a huge $7000 difference. Lets be generous and say it uses 3Li/100 less than a regular Fiesta. At that rate it would take almost 13 years to repay itself - $540 saving per annum, before you add the capital cost, which would add a further $560 per annum (at 8% finance). So in actual fact, the fuel saving would never actually catch up with the extra cost of capital required to purchase it in the first place! Not exactly a value proposition. Save your $8k, and buy the normal (and very good) Fiesta.

    Kim of Sunshine Coast Posted on 03 February 2010 7:07am
  • Given the favourable review of this diesel model, I would like to see a face off with the Mini Cooper D.  They weigh about the same, they have the same sized diesel engine, but the mini has 6 gears rather than 5, and start-stop, as well as hill start.  But is it $10,000 better, or is the Mini better made and more reliable?  What is the reliability reputation of both models?

    Allan of NSW South Coast Posted on 20 January 2010 6:16pm
  • I have a regular Fiesta, 1.6CL manual, and it sounds like this engine would address some of the few criticisms I have. The 1.6 doesn’t have so much torque down low, and isn’t particularly refined; the diesel, where you would shift a bit earlier, would also suit my driving style - as much as I like a good drive on the Kinglake road or across the Dandenongs, most of my driving is freeway; also, I think journalists over exaggerate how it is to drive - it’s nice, but not fantastic (same with my dads 09 MX5-RC manual; very nice but not as special as reviews make them sound). The emissions figures should be the selling point; I got my CL for 17,990 drive away (before I traded in the Volvo 850) and my first fill was 5.14l/100km; I’ve yet to get worse than 6.9 - you aren’t going to recoup the savings much that way, even if you consider the econotic has 5drs, bluetooth and ESP which I don’t. Co2 reductions however are much better. Finally, do we really need an auto transmission? This would no doubt make the car less fun to drive and perhaps affect fuel economy - I appreciate the importance in this marketplace, but it’s more a local failing of the spec planning than the car itself.

    Alasdair of Melbourne Posted on 16 January 2010 8:17pm
  • Cmon you guys its still got drum brakes on the rear end great for 2010.

    RAW of toowoomba Posted on 12 January 2010 3:49pm
Read all 20 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links