Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

BMW 123d: review

  • By Stuart Innes
  • The Advertiser
  • image

    After 10 days testing the 123d, Stuart Innes describes the new BMW as fun, frugal, funky and fast enough for most.

Stuart Innes road tests and reviews the BMW 1-Series 123d Coupe.

BMW's 1-Series Coupe is a sporty little thing, compact, with good handling and (especially with the three-litre turbocharged petrol six-cylinder engine) is very quick. And all in a luxury package befitting the German marque. But what's the result when a four-cylinder diesel engine is put in?

Some f-words emerge, but good ones: It's fun, certainly frugal, funky and fast enough for most.

Diesel engines in sporty cars, including convertibles, have been embraced in Europe for several years now. From here on, it's Australia's turn to show enough maturity to accept them as a way of having motoring driving pleasure with low fuel use and therefore low exhaust emissions.

Engine and gearbox

We tested the BMW 123d Coupe with a two-litre, twin-turbocharged, four-cylinder diesel engine. BMW's engineers have wrung enough out of the turbos and injection/breathing systems to provide an impressive 150kW power, a figure that can stand proud against similar-sized, turbocharged petrol engines. The winner is the diesel's torque, a strong 400Nm of it and from just 2000rpm.

Put this with a six-speed, sporty shifting manual gearbox and BMW claims a 0- 100km/h sprint in 7 seconds. Out on the highway, the overtaking performance is strong 80-120km/h taking just 5.5 seconds using fourth and fifth gear. The maker also says this little diesel coupe will run out to 238km/h. At 110km/h in sixth gear, the manual gearbox car is ticking over at 2100rpm.

A six-speed automatic is a $2280 option, being a sequential with paddleshift changes.

Economy and stop-start system

There's no doubting then the diesel engine's performance, yet fuel economy is right on the money, too. Officially it's rated at 5.2 litres/100km. On our driving, admittedly mostly gently on the throttle, we returned an average of 5.4 litres/100km, including city driving.

BMW fits its ‘stop-start’ system to this car: When the car is stopped and in neutral, the engine automatically switches off. When the driver wants to proceed, just pressing the clutch pedal automatically re-starts the engine, and you're away. It's a fuel saver and helps the planet (ever noticed all the fumes from exhausts on cars stopped long at traffic lights?).

Fit-out and equipment

The 1 Series Coupe comes with sport bucket leather seats, all manual adjustment except for a push-button adjustment of the wings to tighten around the drive's body to help hold him/her in place during cornering. Steering is tilt and reach adjustable. Rear view is not great for a small car but parking sensors, with a graphic display, help.

The steering wheel has as thick rim and feels meaty with power steering not over-assisted, yet there's little feel of the road surface coming to the driver's hands. The rear seat takes only two passengers and, as expected in a small coupe, headroom there is limited for taller people. Boot size is modest but the rear seat back folds forward, 60/40. There's no spare wheel, the battery being under the boot floor.

It has cruise control, rain and light sensors, climate control, stability control, cornering brake control, fog lamps and leather trim. Price of the 123d Coupe is from $57,900.

As usual, BMW knows how to charge for options: the test car's fabulous sedona red metallic paint is $1700, the power sunroof $2920, sat-nav $2860 (but with as modest screen), and the 17in wheels replaced by 18in at $1326. It also had the $2300 M Sport Pack of aerodynamic body kit, sports suspension, M steering wheel and anthracite roof lining.

Driving

The stop-start is disconcerting until you get used to it, some passengers wondering if we'd stalled. Lights and all other gear remain working.  Like any car with an instant fuel-use readout, it encourages economic driving and there's a little set of arrows to suggest going up or down a gear for best efficiency.

The only disappointing aspect of this engine is that I'd expected more refinement from BMW. At idle, it is not as quiet inside as, say, a Mazda3 diesel. Even on the 18in low-profile tyres, road noise is commendably contained.

Most 1-Series buyers will prefer petrol engines. But get used to this idea of a diesel in a sports coupe it's the way of the future.

BMW 123d Coupe

Price: from $57,900 (as tested: $69,006)
Engine: 2.0-litre turbocharged four-cylinder diesel
Power: 150kW @ 4400rpm
Torque: 400Nm @ 2000-2500rpm
Transmission: Six-speed manual; optional six-speed automatic with paddleshift, rear-wheel-drive
Brakes: All disc, ABS, cornering brake control
Fuel use: official, 5.2 litres/100km; our drive 5.4 litres/100km; diesel; tank, 51 litres
C02 emissions: 135g/km
Dimensions: 4360mm long, 1748mm wide, 1420mm high; 2660mm wheelbase
Wheels & tyres: standard, 17in diameter alloy with 205/50 front and 225/45 rear tyres. Test car, 18in alloys, 215/40 front and 245/35 rear tyres.

RIVALS

Audi TT 2.0 TDI diesel Quattro Coupe from $67,700
Peugeot 308 CC S diesel Coupe from $58,490
Volkswagen Golf GTD diesel from $39,290.

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 13 comments

  • Owning both a 120i convertible and a 123d coupe the difference between both is remarkable. The diesel coupe really does make the most congested driving experience in traffic or motorway conditions stress free as the instant response and thrust from the twin turbos can put you into the gaps in traffic even before other frustrated motorists have a chance to block you and prevent lane changes which can come up all too quickly in city driving, and also allows overtaking of slower vehicles with ease and safety on the motorways. All this with an economy to almost match Toyotas Prius but with the performance that would not be believed by anyone who has not experienced a diesel BMW , even owners of other modern diesel vehicles would be amazed by the little coupe’s real world performance and thrust. In my opinion BMW’s best value performance coupe. Must be driven to be believed ... literally. EJD Jnr ( aka Ima Fan ).

    Ejd jnr of Qld. Posted on 30 September 2011 8:50am
  • My manual 123d has done 29,000 km at an average of 5.5 l/100 km although more country than city. The sat-nav software is Sensis - so poor and upgrades are absurdly expensive. Service costs are reasonable and infrequent. The gearing is too low. Taking off in a hurry you are in first for nano-seconds and it will easily pull up any hill in 2 gears higher than most other cars. First to second is still stiff despite the mileage and it is far too easy to get reverse when going for first in a hurry. (Mazda does it much better.) The computer displays are poorly optimised. Rear blind spots are close to dangerous in traffic. But the most irritating aspect is not being able to use my right little finger to activate the indicators while changing gear with my left - not a problem for drivers of automatics. I know it?s a European car thing. But so easy to fix it?s inexcusable and should contravene the ADRs. Aaah, but the performance: it reminds me of a pulsar ET turbo which could worry small V8s in its hey day. Getting the second turbo really going is neck snapping. It corners like it is on rails. The xenon headlight option is almost worth the ridiculous price.

    Ken Muir of Sydney, NSW, Australia Posted on 16 June 2011 10:01pm
  • I have just purchased the 123d convertible and wow this car has got some grunt. Excellent on fuel consumption in comparison with the 120i, which I traded for the 123d. Still have a half tank of diesel at the end of the week saving me around $30 per week. It looks hot, drives like a dream on both freeway and around town.

    Hornet of Southport Posted on 15 April 2011 11:09pm
  • have all the 123d got the twin turbo
    thanks mick

    michael forward of maitland Posted on 02 April 2011 6:46pm
  • Hi I am i the market for one of the above bmw 123d’s, i hear every one say the servicing costs are excesive but have yet to here a dollar figure put up!!!!

    Mckfish Posted on 12 February 2011 11:05am
  • I own a 123d hatch and it is a real beaut. Test drove the GTI and with similar specs and was just as expensive, in fact, I got the 123d for a mid year bargain at a lesser price than the VW dealer down the road. I much prefer the rear wheel drive of the BMW to the front wheel drives of most other hot hatches.

    First time diesel buyer and THIS car is worth it - the twin turbo is a pocket rocket with fantastic fuel economy. I have no regrets at all.

    Steve of Rockhampton Posted on 19 July 2010 9:55pm
  • You say ‘...it’s Australia’s turn to show enough maturity to accept (diesel)...’ and then you say ‘Most 1-Series buyers will prefer petrol engines…’. Are you saying most 1-series buyers are immature?? Actually I’m pretty sure most vehicles out there are petrol. You might want to think twice next time you decide to stupidly insult the majority of Australia Stuart. Besides, there’s nothing immature about knowing that you can get better sports performance from a petrol engine than you can with a diesel.

    alex Posted on 15 July 2010 7:31pm
  • I wonder how many of the people commenting have driven this car.  It is incredible.

    It also won the world best 2.0L engine for 2010.

    No comparison Posted on 13 July 2010 3:55pm
  • You also pay a premium price for service, at least that’s what the dealer tells you. I was contemplating a 1 Series Diesel but when told the pricing on road vs. the starting figure, there was 15K difference. BMW sales through my dealer has been atrocious, and it put me right off. I’ve had an 2005 E46 M3 overseas, and a 2008 Z4 in the garage as my fun weekend car. This car 1 Series is incredibly overpriced, and the maker can no longer claim the premium is because it’s a BMW. I’ve just gone from BMW and straight to VW and bought a brand new reasonably optioned Golf GTD. Miles apart in price, and with Audi quality it’s a worldbeater. I can’t believe I’ve considered another BMW. Just watch the resale. I just watched a mate get a valuation on his Mini Cooper S that’s a year old (55K 12 months ago) and get told it’s worth 28K. If that’s not an indication, what is?

    Nathan of Sydney Posted on 07 July 2010 4:42pm
  • Well, I think the pay rates in America are not as high as in Australia. So may be that balances out a bit. I mean the minimum wages in Australia are higher, compared to America.

    Pranav of Bairnsdale Posted on 30 June 2010 5:39pm
  • It’s down to shipping lol… Australians are ripped off per se. Coles and Woolies are your starting point.

    Jessica Guise Posted on 30 June 2010 3:17pm
  • My mate paid just over USD 50,000 for his M3. And I paid AUD 50,000 for a Ford Falcon XR8! What a rip off with the dollar now trading at such high rates.

    Kunal Posted on 30 June 2010 11:54am
  • Yeah, I don’t get it. How could anyone justify spending $70,000 on the cheapest BMW on the planet? A1 series BMW for SEVENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS? What are people thinking? I’m amazed BMW sells any cars in Australia at such prices. Speaking of, why do Americans pay half as much for the same cars? I looked it up on the BMW USA website and a 128I coupe starts at $28,000. Why are Australians not offered similar prices? If it’s our governments fault, we need to vote the scum out of office. It’s shameful to take advantage of Australians like this. Yes, I will pay 28K, but not 70K… NO WAY!

    Terry Posted on 30 June 2010 4:13am
Read all 13 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links