Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Ute proves a safe bet

  • By Mark Hinchliffe
  • The Courier-Mail
image Holden rated four out of five stars for safety in recent testing.

The iconic Aussie ute has beaten three Asian models in crash-testing, scoring four out of five stars.

But the Australasian New Car Assessment Program results show that more can be done to improve occupant protection in the popular commercial vehicles.

The VE Commodore Ute, which is exported to New Zealand and South Africa, has a range of standard safety features, including anti-lock brakes, electronic brake distribution and electronic stability control.

GM Holden spokesman John Lindsay said it was introducing stability control as standard on all Australian-built cars.

“The recent addition of six airbags as standard on our Commodore sedan range is a further illustration of our commitment to passenger safety in our vehicles,” he said.

The VE Ute also beat the Japanese Mazda BT50 4x4 and Nissan Navara D40 4x4, which rated three stars, while the Indian Mahindra Pik-up rated only two stars under ANCAP's sister program, EuroNCAP.

The Commodore Ute, which was voted most popular car in the 2007 Carsguide Car of the Year awards, was yesterday announced as a finalist in the Australian International Design Awards automotive section along with the Audi TT and R8, VW Eos and Honda Civic Type R. The winner will be announced on May 30.

ANCAP chairman Lauchlan McIntosh said the trend toward improved safety showed that utility vehicles could earn five-star ratings in the near future.

“Manufacturers are building key safety technologies as standard features in many of their models — and while some utes are definitely safer than they were five years ago, more needs to be done,” he said.

In a recent EuroNCAP test, the Navara was declared an “unacceptably high” risk for fatal head or neck injuries in a front-on collision.

Other complaints were “the Navara's passenger compartment became unstable” and “the airbags and seatbelt pre-tensioners were triggered late in the impact”.

After an airbag software upgrade, the vehicle scored three stars.

Nissan Australia is contacting customers to take Navaras back for an upgrade to the airbag software.

The Ford Ranger, which shares the Mazda BT50 platform, is also expected to gain three stars.

Other EuroNCAP ratings for vehicles sold in Australia are the new Fiat 500 fitted with ESC, the Volvo V70 and Peugeot 308 with ESC and knee airbag, which scored five stars, and four stars for the Fiat 500 without ESC, the Peugeot 308 without ESC or knee airbag and the BMW X3.

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 2 of 2 comments

  • I suggest that comparing a 2 wheel drive holden ute, which is based on a passeger car platform, to Asian 4 wheel drive utes, which are based on purpose designed light truck platforms, is as relevant as comparing apples and sardines. Having said that, I agree that the asian utes need to do a lot more about passive and active safety.

    archie itsikson of Brisbane Posted on 02 April 2008 1:36pm
  • Give me the safety and comfort of a sedan or sedan based car any day. Good work Holden with this ute. All cars should meet the same safty standards, whether it is a sedan, wagon, ute or 4x4.

    dave Posted on 27 March 2008 11:35am

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links