Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Top Gear criticised for damage to cars

  • By Paul Gover
  • NEWS.com.au
image Demolition derby... Top Gear Australia co-host Steve Pizzati, who was involved in a number of the expensive stunts on the show.

Car companies are outraged by the "obscene" damage done to their vehicles during filming of the Australian series of popular motoring show Top Gear.

Filming of the Australian series has turned into a demolition derby with a repair bill close to $200,000.

Eager driving and wild stunts have left a trail of destruction behind the Top Gear team that goes beyond the expected bill for bald tyres from slides and burnouts.

Luxury cars have needed total resprays because of flying stones, and lesser brands have reported damage from silly stunts created for the SBS TV series, which is unofficially confirmed for a second series in Australia in 2009.

Some of the most expensive repair bills involved a Lamborghini, which is believed to have sustained about $25,000 damage during filming.

And a group of Holden Astras needed $30,000 to restore them after they were used in a game of "lawn bowls". (See video below)

We have no appetite for automotive Jackass," the spokesman for one of the damaged brands said.

"When they revisit series two, they will encounter a lot of shut doors," said another.

The damage bill for Top Gear goes way beyond anything seen in any form of Australian motoring journalism.

"All we will say is that it turned out to be a very expensive test drive," said Holden spokeswoman Kate Lonsdale of the Astra bowls stunt segment.

The show's producers failed to return the Herald Sun's phone calls, but a later response has been received from one of the show's three presenters, Warren Brown.

 

Related Stories

Top Gear host leaves

Fatal accident linked to Top Gear

Top Gear Australia co-host Warren Brown responds

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 123 comments

  • Idea to have awesome element: You wake up in the center of the night so you think "shit My partner and i probably need to get up throughout like 10 minutes" then you look with a clock and see you have got like 4 more of their time to sleeping.... awesome

    Fellac of usa Posted on 23 January 2012 9:29pm
  • Top Gear Oz is a total embarrassment. The fact that anyone visiting from overseas might actually catch a glimpse of this boring shite with the country's most annoying presenters makes me shudder. How the hell can these lame asses even be considered 'motoring journalists' ? They couldn't host a kids show without the toddlers switching over.

    Macktruck of Melbourne Posted on 16 February 2011 9:28am
  • TGA 2 Blows, same reason as the first season, blatent rip offs, copied ideas, clueless presenters with a barely detectable sense of humour

    Richie Rich of Melbourne Posted on 11 May 2009 9:34pm
  • I hated seeing these 'fellow enthusiasts' bash a crash helmet on the Ford GT supercar door (Pizzani) or abuse that Lamborghini 'from engine-off to redline in neutral within one second' (Warren) or smash up those Astras, all for supposed entertainment 'value'. Instead this reeked of low value, of Lowest Denominator. Not fun, or entertaining, just childish and cringeworthy. By then I'd had more than enough of this particular Brand of motoring enthusiasm. Why can't there be a serious, mature, informative, and yes, truly independant, automotive television show on independant (Government) television? Vale the wonderful Mr Peter Wherrett and his wildly successful 'Torque' television show from the 1970s.

    T Bennett of Canberra Posted on 11 April 2009 6:49am
  • australian top gear 3 idiots just destroying cars //but for top gear uk /// the hosts have got talent and there funny the way they constantly crap on each other.clarkson is a gas hamster and his white teeth funny .and may well hes just weird

    peter proctor of australia Posted on 15 March 2009 12:32pm
  • Typical greedy damn car companies.... no wonder the series sux when the people who financial support the program (advertisers liek ford and holden) are having their cars reviewed.... they pay for adverts to interupt and ruin the show but complain when people dont make their cars like perfect and superior....id liek to see top gear trash a few bad cars that get advertised on SBS just to show the show isn't biased.....

    X Posted on 24 February 2009 2:14pm
  • I think some people forget that Top gear is about showing off the cars most of us could only dream about, They do also show the affordable cars which is good but in my view the car companies complaining about how the cars are treated is just a load of crap because if you watched the UK show you would know that they thrash the cars and if you want your car on the show and the exposure that comes with it you should expect the consequences. All these people agreeing with car companies obviously work for them as any normal person can see what the show is about and that is light hearted entertainment for car enthusiasts. So to Top gear oz I say keep it up boys im sure you will find your feet soon enough and crack the aussie market soon enough

    noboot of Sydney Posted on 17 January 2009 2:25pm
  • Bring on season 2. BUT, with three new hosts, good aussie challenges (using budget purchased cars), no disrespecting new cars, and some working class reviews. I wanna know which family cars might make the best "race" car. So, please bring on the improved version, that way I can stop cringing at the poor 'almost copy' of TGUK.

    Adam Smith of NSW Posted on 26 December 2008 10:42pm
  • "I quite enjoy watching the British Top Gear." followed by.. "I'm anal when it comes to looking after my cars." ..You DO realise Jeremy Clarkson has blown up a Corvette with a goddamn MINIGUN, right? and.. "We are more keen to hear about the latest automobile technology, advances in fuel economy and safety equipment." So WHY are you watching Top Gear?

    J Posted on 23 December 2008 8:04pm
  • I thought the show was highly contrived when I first watched it - too much Aussie "gunga" so to speak and not enough class. I was, frankly, rather unimpressed with the first few shows. But it started to grow on me and as it did, I realised that all I needed to do was give the lads a chance. By the end of the series, I was nodding sagely and looking forwards to series 2. It can only get better, SBS should stick to their guns. TGA is a slow starter, but I think you'll find that the show will soon find it's own niche and own individuality. As for the stunts, I watch Top Gear for some of the insane things that horrify the masses - it's what makes the series so entertaining. As for advertising, I think the auto industry should keep a certain adage in mind: "All publicity is better than none."

    Sonny Heeps of Melbourne Posted on 19 December 2008 1:24pm
  • Top Gear Australia is obviously crap. Consider the negatives: - Presenters have fake personalities, with fake lines and phrases - Presenters are annoying Bogans, in particular that Steve guy - Complete copy of Top Gear UK - The Stig can't drive - Crap cars are presented - and much much more. It is doesn't even compare to "Test drive" on Channel 9. Abolish Top Gear AU, SBS. Instead install Swift and Shift Couriers and Fat Pizza. Talk to Paul Fenech, ask for his opinions; "Top gear stooges"

    Steven A Posted on 19 December 2008 1:10am
  • God knows which show it was but it involved three types of ute haulling gold ore out of the super pit in Kalgoorlie and I could not believe what these morons were doing to those new vehicles. I thought the pommy TG boys were comming to OZ but know such luck we got three dick heads and after the show is AXED we in OZ will still have three dick heads

    K MacPherson Posted on 18 December 2008 12:13am
  • Please Please Please don't bring these idiots back. I watched the first two shows only. The second time was only to give them a fair go but really they are crap. They should never have tried to copy the UK Show, we come off looking like stupid Aussie try hards. I'll never watch it again and I think SBS can do a lot better with their money.

    Mark Usher Posted on 16 December 2008 5:12pm
  • I believe we should give it a chance, just like one of the previous comments, it took TGUK many years to get it right... you can't say once they get to season 4 I will watch it, because if we all thought like that then there won't be a season 4, I say give it a chance, let them find their feet and maybe see if there is a host change or 2. As for the stunt, yes too far, but I'm sure the manufacturers knew what they were getting themselves into. My advice, don't try and mimic TGUK so much, make up our own sayings for the show, and please don't intro the stig the same as TGUK, it was too try hard.

    Shane Ross of Sunshine Coast Posted on 14 December 2008 12:13pm
  • I Watched one show and i was not impressed with the show and others from work thought the same so not do it again as i will not watch it

    Arthur Wilson Posted on 14 December 2008 11:46am
  • Yeah agreed! the Australian top gear really did suck the big one!! they had nobodies on the show doing stupid shit..if they were going to do a series 2 they would need to have new people...preferably a comedian, car enthusiast and gay guy. but then again it still wouldn't be the same...just leave it to the pros... the UK series

    clay Posted on 12 December 2008 8:34pm
  • Series 2, don't you dare....... The Australian motoring enthusiast has been put through enough, the first series sucked something chronic so please spare us the pain and the embarrassment. Surely the producers can see from all the negative feedback that the show has been received very poorly. DON'T DO IT...........

    Danny Feith Posted on 11 December 2008 1:59pm
  • not sure what the car companies are complaining about... they get a 10 minute "advertisement" for their cars and then whinge about paying $30,000 in repair bills... i'd like to see them try and run a 10 minute ad campaign on tv for less money...

    Robert Posted on 11 December 2008 1:22pm
  • TGA is a very poor attempt to clone the highly successful, entertaining and amusing TGUK. I saw a few episodes of TGA, which in my view were an absolutely abysmal attempt to emulate Clarkson, Hammond and May with three Oz dummies that nobody had ever heard of before! One claims to have been a racing driver ... must have been in pedal powered dinkies, I have never heard of him and I have followed motor racing in Oz for over 3 decades! I try to not to miss an episode of TGUK, but you can be sure I will do my best to avoid TGA! If that is the best that SBS can spend money on for television, then they need to go back to radio only!!

    Andrew M of Sydney Posted on 11 December 2008 12:24pm
  • What a joke, this show is an absolute disgrace to Australia. It's not only this appalling mistreatment and disregard/respect for others property but its the fact they have NO driving skill and NO In Depth knowledge the information they pass on to use could be learnt off the f*ing brochure. I love the way Mr. Brown says "it's about a passion for motoring" what automotive enthusiast desires to crash cars into one another to discover the effect of gravity on a car when placed on a ramp?!?!?! "Like the UK Sibling" again, what another outragous comment. Now I'm not the biggest fan of the Original Top Gear....but the Australian one is NOTHING like it and NEVER will be. How can you compare a Ford F6/HSV W427 to M5's/AMG's, this is by far the most ridiculous comment ever. Australian produced cars in realism are lightyears behind German and Japanese engineered cars and they ALWAYS will be. They suffer from poor engineering, poor build quality and lack of real automotive/racing background.

    Andrew W Posted on 11 December 2008 1:09am
  • This is just stupid. The episodes of TGUK I have seen I have enjoyed immensely, but I have never watched TGA. If this is the sort of stuff they do I probably won't be any time soon. As a member of a motoring club I have an appreciation for nice cars, and this stunt just made me cringe. Try doing things like this with $200 bangers you buy from the trading post and it would be funny. To damage brand new cars in this fashion is ludicrous. Grow up guys.

    John Shugg of Campbelltown, 3 hrs East of Bathurst Posted on 10 December 2008 11:53pm
  • I enjoy TG UK and I was looking foward to TG Aus but I have been disappointed and did not watch the last episode or two of TG Aus. I saw the show where the light 4WD's were damaged, I also saw the show with the lawn bowls challenge. Both would have been as funny as all hell if the hosts had been given $1,000 and sent out to buy a couple of crap cars for the stupid stunts. The mix of presenters is not woking for me either, a bit like the early shows of TG UK once they got rid of the solid guy and engaged "Captain Slow" the mix worked. It has taken TG UK 10 years to get 500M viewers and it has taken TG Aus less than one season to alienate at least a handful of the Aussie faithful. If TG Aus gets to season 4 I might think about watching it again as they might have ironed out some of the issues, until then I won't bother with it.

    Chad P Posted on 10 December 2008 10:05pm
  • This is the first time i have seen this and it is one of the most stupidest things i have seen. Using brand new cars? I was cringing just watching what they were doing to those astras. I mean i have yet to watch an episode of TGA but have read reviews and reviews from mates and now i can see why the show is an epic fail. I dont blame the car manufacturers for not offering their cars for season 2. Top gear should be left to the poms.

    Jon Smith of Victoria Posted on 10 December 2008 8:57pm
  • Fair enough that both versions of the show offer wild stunts, which expectedly result in damage, but most of the UK ones feature old cheap cars which are PURCHASED by Top Gear UK, not borrowed new cars. I'm curious to know whether the Toyota Aygo's used were also purchased? I doubt very much they were borrowed for a 'test drive'. To do damage to someone else's vehicle just for the sake of entertainment shows the worst kind of disrespect imaginable to a vehicle lover. And it's not like Australia is short of old cars they could buy and trash...

    Toby Miller of Blackwood Posted on 10 December 2008 8:00pm
  • TGA was crap. SBS dont waste my tax money with another series. I was glad when the UK version came back on.

    paul Posted on 10 December 2008 6:50pm
  • Top Gear Australia was crappity crap crap, with a side order of crap. A total car wreck of a show. I cannot believe they have given it another go for 2009.

    Chris Carr Posted on 10 December 2008 5:33pm
  • it's funny that every time i read an article about TGA, i laugh. probably because the article is a negative point and when TGA was on, it was crap. i don't want shite this back for a second season, put repeats of Top Gear UK on SBS. and with the damage that was caused on these cars it's no reason that the manufacturers are pissed.

    Anthony blyth of Merrylands, NSW Posted on 10 December 2008 3:29pm
  • The pale imitation of the UK show. is a waste of money time and effort. The OZ outfit try to copy and fail miserably. Particularly the little talentless one in the middle. TAKE IT OFF..

    Mike Flanders of Vic Posted on 10 December 2008 1:44pm
  • Don't like it? Vote with your remote control. Nothing speaks louder than bad ratings. Unfortunately millions of people don't agree.

    David Posted on 10 December 2008 8:53am
  • You people are mostly missing the facts... its not the hosts that ruined TGA this year it was the producers and the directors... these hosts had no real idea of the exact format.... The producers have told them to be Ocker wankers... or chosen them because they are ocker wankers because thats what they wanted, you cant for a second blame the cast.... if the director says tone down the stupidity then thats what the cast will do and has done a little, over time... they need the feedback from colums like this to understand and get the format right......as much as I wanted to punch out the cast the first two weeks, I understood it would take time and it has improved..... some of these comments are great and some are just raves from people that gave up after week 2.. I did for a while as well.... ok weve told them cut the ocker crap, cut Steves arrogance..... add some credible driving in with the stupidity but dont cut it out altogether and make it boring.... lets let them know what needs improving... the major problem for me was them acting and speaking like bogans. Im fine with an Aussie accent and Aussie words but the producers wanted these guys to speak like they were at some great ute roundup in the middle of nowhere after theyd finished that first bottle of Bundy.... it has its place, I love spending time with the lads in the utes. I just wouldnt have them as role models for TGA....

    L Devine Posted on 10 December 2008 2:14am
  • OMG yes Mark Skaife as the new host of Top Gear Oz.... and..... get rid of Stig..... bring on ..... The Enforcer smile smile smile smile

    Craig Lounges Posted on 10 December 2008 1:48am
  • After reading these comments I had to comment again... number one: if there wasnt a TG UK to compare it to this show would be getting rave reviews and massive ratings..we are just used to Jeremy being a wanker and laugh at him .I hated, I mean HATED the first 2 shows here but its gradually building into a much better show and I could have punched out the hosts for talking in super ocka, but thats mellowed as well.... I almost cried when Graham Kenedy made his comeback with his late night TV news show because it was so crap when it started, it was embaressing to watch him but he turned it around into a massive success.... so will these guys... number2 : I actually thought the show covered the costs of repairs for acts of stupidity...lol... oops, looks like I was wrong.... As for the comment on Jeremy doing stupid burnouts in the Bentley, that actually made me want one even more so it will probably lead directly to the sale of one of these cars in Australia. I had already been looking at Bently Turbos this last week and 1000 pounds of torque looks like a lot of fun... I thought it would be awesome to buy the car and lend it to one of the drift drivers to use for a demonstration during their national series.... as much as us older guys might not be into drifting, its massive with the young guys, like drag racing and touring cars are for us older reveheads.....And I have lent my cars out all of my life... the kind of cars ive owned are too much fun not to share smile

    Randall Dean Posted on 10 December 2008 1:32am
  • For me it was always Top Gear UK! I have NEVER watched TGA because when I saw the preview of it on the tv, I immediately disliked it! It was those blokes that are so much like bogan types. WTF were the TGA thinking of driving a TRACTOR in Chapel St in Melbourne during peak period? A lot of drivers complained of it, including one mate of mine who lives in Melbourne. He missed his audiologist appointment because of that boneheaded stunt! As for the lawn bowls stunt, that was the most stupidiest and IMMATURE performance I ever seen in my entire life! They actually put those "regular" bogan drivers to shame! I did not laugh at it at all! And those Astras looks like HSV VXR's or they may be the SRi version? If the TGA was run by someone who loves cars like me, I would not do those boneheaded stunts. I would offer information on performance, safety etc as well as questioning a car owner who owned the car being reviewed in the episode. There will be a comparision as well e.g. Lamborghini vs Ferrari. Instead of being informative, I would make it fun to drive unlike the TGA bogans!

    Dave G. of Rockingham Posted on 09 December 2008 10:37pm
  • If this is the end of top gear australia i think we should all be grateful. I for one couldn't even sit through the first episode.Thank God they put the uk version back on.

    Maurice Holmes of Victoria Posted on 09 December 2008 9:47pm
  • Top Gear UK is a good show to watch as the hosts are funny. Two of the Aussie host are great but the dope who is and Aussie with a pommie accent PLEASE what a twat!! and come up with some original ideas or can the show since the crud we had to watch last season was making me consider watching the other more crappy shows..

    Peter Sarles of Perth Posted on 09 December 2008 9:01pm
  • In my humble opinion the behaviour of the clowns on that show was irresponsible and hoonish. What a terrible example they set for those younger impressionable people who may have been watching. How disgraceful that SBS could allow such rubbish to be aired. If they think that abusing cars is testing them, they should go talk to real motoring journalists like those writing in Wheels Mag.

    jon Posted on 09 December 2008 8:47pm
  • Top Gear is the only car show I bother to watch because its entertaining, has some technical merit in its reporting of cars features and it is not drowned in automotive industry marketing hype, or should that be tripe which Wikipedia defines as "... (containing) some of the stomach's last content, giving it an unpleasant odour and causing it to be considered unfit for human consumption". Yep, tripe is the correct word, for if the Australian car manufacturers put a ban on the Top Gear way of road testing then I'm afraid the Aussie show will, just like the tripe, become unfit for human consumption. So Aussie manufacturers I know the damage bill is beyond your expectations, no surprises there, but what a marvellous advert you get for your money if your product stacks up well. How does the cost and benefits compare with your other marketing strategy. For me I am more likely to be influenced by the Top Gear show than any other when it comes to car purchasing.

    Wayne Checker of Hallett Cove (Adelaide) Posted on 09 December 2008 8:29pm
  • As much as I do try to look after my own cars and am dismayed at what a rip-off the Oz version is of the UK version, I think I will have to rebuke the trend and admit that I found the Astra lawn bowls tornament really funny... Probably because I'm not the CEO of Holden and I'm not looking at buying a demonstrator Astra soon. Sometimes you have to appreciate loutish hilarious journalism for what it is. For what it's worth, I don't see any difference between this and the Aygo soccer tournament on the UK version.

    Corey of Bris Posted on 09 December 2008 8:11pm
  • The UK version of Top Gear has sunk to a point where I just cant watch it anymore. The three UK presenters are not funny, not even entertaining. They don't even know anything about cars! The Australian version is even worse than the UK one. I watched it twice, but it was the worst rubbish I have ever seen about motoring. These three presenters like their UK counterparts know nothing at all about performance cars & how to drive them. Come on SBS drop this show now!

    Ray Dowling of Young NSW. Posted on 09 December 2008 7:18pm
  • I'm surprised that there will be a second series. Don't the producers get a ratings done on their show. If they didn't then this series of blogs should say it all. The Aussie show sux!

    Rolf Iszmail of Albury Posted on 09 December 2008 7:13pm
  • Top Gear should be made to pay for all damge to the cars.Also did they go to the bottom of the barrel to pick the three presenters

    RON CAMPBELL of WENDOUREE Posted on 09 December 2008 6:51pm
  • I waited and was saddened, expected to laugh and didn't, waited for local cars to admire and was shocked by the abuse of silly little boys. Their technical expertise was summed up by an inability to understand that the air conditioner keeps the dust outside and rinses the heat exchangers. The pathetic driving efforts on poor roads were a shocking example for the inexperienced. Go away, far away, I can't hope to see the Aussie version recovering

    Michael Nowland of Penrith Posted on 09 December 2008 6:41pm
  • With all the different forms of motor sport in this country we would have thought that SBS could have found three hosts with more cred than these jack asses. All they are is old hoons with no sense, the young kids now days have their cars confiscated for this. Make them pay for the damage.

    Eric Koch of Queensland Posted on 09 December 2008 6:38pm
  • Pathetic performance, typical of people who drive vehicles that don't belong to them!

    James Todhunter of Hamilton South Posted on 09 December 2008 6:36pm
  • Let me have a crack at top gear, i will be better then those losers put together. revving a lambo to the limiter after it has just been started is complete and utter stupidity. they are stupid. get rid of the show

    Mitchell of Penrith Posted on 09 December 2008 6:18pm
  • I have two thoughts on this; 1. Car companies - stop your bitching! It's not like your press cars are NOT tax write-offs anyway... perhaps in future shows that might (God forbid!) actual DRIVE a car should come to YOU and say... "yes that's a great offer... if I can just get you to put it in writing here and I'll take it to my manager and see what we can do!!" Slightly hypocritical... don't you think?? Who's to say any of this crap is true anyway... when did car companies start being honest?? I must have missed this stunning and complete reversion of character! ...and... 2. People who don't like TG Australia - likewise... STOP your bitching!!!!!!!!!!!!! Plenty of us put our hands up for the presenting roles and didn't get them... get over it!! SBS and Freehand (the ACTUAL producers) have little or no interest in your opinion. And despite their early protestations of "we don't want to make a carbon copy of the UK show" - since that is EXACTLY what they have delivered... their BBC masters obviously have them on a VERY short leash! NO ONE CARES WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THE SHOW - IF IT RATES IT'LL STAY ON - IF NOT IT WON'T... that's the way all media (especially Australia's!) is... arrogant and proud!!!!!!!!!

    Troy Swindells-Grose of Melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 6:17pm
  • I watched the first show and saw them running over the sand dunes and ripping the underguard off a rav thought to myself these guys are a bunch of ya hos and turned off. Some shows later flicking channels i saw them in a nissan navara doing donuts in the kimberly as a four whell driver I was agahst some things you just dont do. Little content or information the show presented as a 3 older men playing with cars out of their paypacket with no responsibilty Ya Hos - fools indeded

    David Lucas of Melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 6:12pm
  • What a group of "bozzoes". Watched half of the first episode - and then switched channels. Waste of time for SBS advertisers to promote the show. The clowns on the show have as much 'knowledge' as my Aunt Nora (and she's dead).

    Paul R of Erskineville Posted on 09 December 2008 5:40pm
  • I'm another one who loves UK Top Gear and is entirely indifferent about Top Gear Australia - and i don't like either show smashing up cars that I will probably never be able to afford

    John L of Melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 5:16pm
  • havnt the car compaines seen topgear before what the aussie guys have done is nothing comparied to the uk version at least they didnt play soccor with them like in the uk series

    phillip quaife of melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 4:24pm
  • The hosts of the show are real idiots, first time i watched it, saw one of the them revving hard a cold engine of a million dollar lambo, i swear!! even one of the other guys point it out. pfff even my 5 yr son knows that.

    Dave Posted on 09 December 2008 4:01pm
  • Really why are you still watching the Australian one they drive the arse off cars and then hand them back to the manufacturer its not advertising because they have to sell these cars would you buy a EX demo lambo with $25000 in damage or how about a Astra with a repairs done cause some idiot thinks its funny to play bowls with them... grow up idiots The piece on the GT 40 how is over accelerating mid corner and keep you foot in it till smoke is pouring out of it a good way to review it . I HOPE THEY CANCEL THE AUSTRALIAN VERSION CAUSE IT JUST SUCKS its not funny its not entertaining and really stupid oh and the presenters come on sbs the boys from Fat Pizza does more for car advertising than you ever would.....and know more about cars than these fools

    clayton of lismore Posted on 09 December 2008 3:50pm
  • It reminds me of seeing seven boxters at various stages going north on the putty road one friday afternoon. last one had overcooked it and nosed into a rock wall. I stopped to see if I could help. Turned out to be motoring journalists invited to take the then new boxters up the putty and back down the freeway to assess the cars. This guy was painfully aware that he was going to be late for the post drive dinner. Obviously car companies do risk the odd bend but some of TG Oz stunts were lunacy and did not reflect well on the three presenters.

    Chris Drysdale of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 3:40pm
  • If I was the marketing exec of an aussie based car company I would NOT be lending any cars to the peanuts on Top Gear AU. The "off-road" segments were no better with totally inapropriate "bush bashing". These guys are not helping any motoring causes or making any positive impact on general opinions of folks that drive either 4WDs or performance vehicles - and I am in both camps..

    Tando of NSW Posted on 09 December 2008 3:24pm
  • Car companys you had your free advertising so stop winging , As for those complaining about top gear Australia go and download “ Top Gear series 1 “ UK version it wan’t much better.

    Barney Posted on 09 December 2008 3:12pm
  • What about cars supplied for written media? Do they not cop the same stresses and wear and tear for their road tests? Is there a report written annually stating the cost to motoring magazines for their contribution to repairs to test vehicles by journalists who have no passion for cars and catches public transport trying to create headlines during a quiet week for themselves? Would the spokepersons for these companies have made the same comments if it translated into immediate increased sales? Probably not. Problem here is the cars haven't been handed over to the average "jackass" with a fistfull of dollars (then not our problem anymore), the cars have just been handed back.

    Sheridan - of SE Qld Posted on 09 December 2008 2:39pm
  • Top Gear Aust is a bit short on the UK show - we all know that so why is everyone surprised or even disappointed ? Maybe our illustrious Public Purse Propped up industry manufactures/sellers didn't know or give permission for the cars to be used !! I don't think so really, so why are they complaining they really are getting a big publicity run for their $30,000 costs aren't they? or is that our Tax Money Kevin.?

    Anton Goodrick of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 2:27pm
  • What else would you expect from a bunch of over paid bogans posing as auto journalists! When will SBS wake up to the fact that the vast majority of Australians couldn't give a rat's a**e about this cretinous show! All this show does is perpetuate the mindless stupidity we see every day on the streets.....monkey do as monkey sees.

    Maxwell L. Heazlewood of Tasmania Posted on 09 December 2008 2:15pm
  • I too, agree, as with many of the earlier comments, that SBS Australia should not go to further production of Top Gear Australia. The English original beats it hands down, but at the risk of being overly critical, the Top Gear episode shown last night where Jeremy did ridiculous tyre burn outs in a Bentley, really does make one wonder whether both shows are losing the plot - surely good taste and sensible TV Journalism will be to most motorist's liking without running to absolute nonsense. In depth reporting of how well a car drives and is like to use on an everyday basis is more meaningful. I also regard the STIG thing as now more than old hat - who cares what the Stig does - does anyone else think it good fun, or not? As for the non-nonsensical fiascos doing more with cars than was originally intended - ugh!!

    B. R. Peterson of Eagle Heights Posted on 09 December 2008 2:11pm
  • WOW! What can you say about the die-hard fans of the UK series? Vicious to say the least. Yes cars will be damaged. Yes it takes time to get a smooth format working. Does anyone who has bagged this show, know how long Top Gear UK has been going for? Have you watched any show prior to James May joining? Most likely not. Not as smooth in the early days, that's for sure. My advice to the show is, try to make it feel less scripted, and try not to make a pure copy. I have only watched a few episodes, and it's not for me yet, but I can see it's potential. Keep working at it boys. Let your natural personalities shine through. Shun the non-believers...shuuuunnnnnnnnn n.

    Simon of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 2:04pm
  • Really hope it wasn't the Range Rover people that were worried about the stone chips - though I could understand their confusion as to what could have caused such a blemish! What were TGA thinking with the lawn bowls segment? It might only be an Astra, even a $50K one, but for a show aimed at people who actually like cars ????? And it wasn't funny. I do hope it's back for a second series - remember early Clarkson? - he was a bit on the nose until they got it right. Stop slavishly trying to copy the Brits and let the boys develop themselves - there's a lot more stories they could do and ditto the comment about an actual r-e-v-i-e-w!

    Andrew Lundgren of sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 1:29pm
  • The lawn bowls stunt was a blatant copy of the UK shows soccer with cars and yes they trashed those too! The damage to cars / tyres etc is just a cost of producing the show. Send the bill to SBS Australia or write it off as "advertising the brand" and stop whinging. How far would $30,000 go in an advertising budget? Not only do you get aired nationally but you also get DVD's and the inevitable Youtube videos. Just make sure in future you have a water tight agreement covering damage / insurance etc before you hand over the keys. If you don't want burnouts - put it in writing - just don't expect TGA will accept the contract or put your cars on their show. Personally I'm disappointed with TGA but I love the UK version. Our guys are making us look like yobbo's out to trash cars. I know they can do better. I hope they keep their cheeky sense of Aussie humour but add a touch of class to next years series.

    David Posted on 09 December 2008 1:24pm
  • I so looked forward to TGA over all the months of preamble and even rang my friends to remind them when it started. I needed to ring them back after the first episode and apologize. We were disgusted with the lack of talent (Steve + Charlie) hopeless. Car buffs need to know about cars. I hope this doesn't go next year because my friends and I won't be watching!!!!!!. Well done Carsguide.

    peter walmsley Posted on 09 December 2008 1:13pm
  • Please SBS 'What were YOU thinking' when somehow you thought that your version of Topgear would rate alongside the UK programme. Warren Brown is at times entertaining in what is a very badly cast show. as for the so-called motoring experts, Charlie and Steve, they both carry on like yobo's and drive like hoons. I have been an avid viewer of Topgear for many years, but this Australian series had me channel-surfing and not very interested at all. Perhaps the manufacturers just don't want to be associated with this primetime trash any longer.

    peter alderton of sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 12:58pm
  • I think the producers need to look at Top Gear and realise that you can have the most entertaining shows about old and new cars without the need to play 'fools' in cars. The Police are at their wits end to stop the carnage by younger inexperienced drivers and the Australian show is condoning it at the expense of other people and manufacturers. 'Grow Up' would be my comment and appreciate the gift of driving a new car to show others

    Caz Elliott of Liolydale Posted on 09 December 2008 12:57pm
  • Memo SBS. Leave this tripe to the commercial networks and concentrate on what you do best, quality television.

    Howard Posted on 09 December 2008 12:54pm
  • Damaging cars for the sake of entertainment has been done since the camera starting rolling; it’s nothing knew and will continue, no matter what form it takes, whether it be good intentioned, an accident, stupidity or the purposeful destruction on a movie set. My biggest problem with this show is wondering why the producers tried so hard to copy the British version. No one expected them to, I feel this was most people’s disappointment; we wanted to see our own show, different format and ideas, not a mimic. It leaves the Australian version with 3 presenters that are trying so hard to be eccentric and witty like the British equivalent that it falls flat. Now I don’t know these 3 men that host the Australian show, they may well be fantastic people and great at their jobs, but they always look like they are attending the first day at drama school, shouting all the lines and over-rehearsed. There is nothing natural about the show as it’s copied down to the last segment from the British. Instead of just mimicking a winner you guys, show the viewing public some respect, do it your own way, forget the “Stig” character, forget the 3 men always competing, forget repeating the one liners of Jeremy Clarkson for goodness sake, not only has it been done so much better, it’s still being done. Come up with your own ideas or shelve it and leave it up the originals.

    GW of Sunshine Coast Posted on 09 December 2008 12:37pm
  • Top Gear Australia….Does anyone really care, it’s a little bit like Antonia Kidman or Dannii Minogue the poor untalented sibling tying to cash in on the success of the older sister.... Lets just drop the bogan attempt at matching a great show out of the UK and be done with it….C’mon SBS we all make mistakes….

    Chris of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 12:37pm
  • Gotta say I agree, funny is one thing but no respect for cars is another when the enviroment is now such an issue. Could at least not bash up brand new cars you pillocks

    andrew of melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 12:29pm
  • Hi, It is not just the Car companies getting upset about what these automotive vandals did in the name of entertainment, which for a car show that is targeted at the car enthusiast is not endearing them to the viewer. I run a website for Mokes and we knew about the shark fishing trip long before it went to air so there was a lot of Moke viewers there for the first episode hoping to see something fun about the Moke. To then see them drop one of the rarer Mokes(less than a 1,000 of them built) into salt water and pretty much signed its death warrant fired up a lot of Moke owners for days on my Forum. We managed to get pictures of the car rusting away at the back of the studio in the second last audience and any attempts to try and save the Moke for our 45th anniversary next year is ignored by the email contact I have for show. We are even starting a 'Save the Top Gear Moke' campaign smile So car companies are not the only ones unhappy about the treatment of the cars, ATG are biting both the hands that feeds them so to speak. .

    Terry of www.moke.com.au Posted on 09 December 2008 12:26pm
  • I do not blame Holden for complaining about the damage bill. I read many comments stating that 30k is not a bad deal for some advertising of their cars.......but the lawn bowls stunt and hosts only degraded the Astra's reputation. The astra is a fine reliable automobile and deserves more respect - the show made the astra out to be a cheap joke of a car to viewers.

    Mike of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 12:24pm
  • The British Top Gear has its fair share of stupid acts... like the one last night with Clarkson bursting the rear left tyre amongst his drifting in the Bentley Brooklands? Sorry guys but the lawn bowls and a few others stunts were the closest it got to the British series. Leslie, Grant Jenkins, Mal Irving and David - if you want serious reviews on cars then stick to Channel Nine's Car Show, otherwise don't be so damn hypocritical when the Australian series tries to emulate the British series. Now face it, the British series is rarely serious nowadays so how could you still love the current British series and hate the lawn bowls stunt??? As for being a bad influence on kids, oh please, society can't be blamed for you're stupid kids who think they're invinicible. Watching these series makes me just as likely to do a donut in the middle of Darling Harbour as The Dark Knight makes me want to do a robbery or be a vigilante. Pfft. The suppliers are complain because...? Have they not seen the British Top Gear? Weren't they expecting much of the same from the Australia Top Gear??? This is all much to do about nothing.

    JH of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 12:12pm
  • I couldn't agree more with the manufacturers. At the rate the okker morons that host this pathetic version of the real thing work their way through vehicles with so little regard for them, they'll have to use second-hand ones for their pathetic, childish stunts. Donuts, drfiting, figure-eights - whatever - should not replace some in-depth, albeit cheeky, comment as to a vehicle's performance, handling characteristics and the like. With a bit of luck, the local version of TG will fade into the motoring sunset and we'll have the real thing in its place.

    jJohn Henshaw of Mornington Peninsula Posted on 09 December 2008 12:10pm
  • The origional show from the UK shows polish, humour and so much more quality in production compaired with Australian Top Gear. The guys are trying to emulate this and (being polite) falling down badly to say the least. It is a shame that the car companies have said what they have. After all what did they expect, or have they had heads in the sand and not looked at the antics of Clarkson and co. If you take a car out on a test drive now matter who you are or where you may be (unless it is wraped in cotton wool) you will get damage. So letting them be used for stunts you should expect it.

    Les of Tasmania Posted on 09 December 2008 12:08pm
  • Year, if the show was better, rated higher etc, the manufactures would be probably be a bit happier. But playing lawn bowls with the Astras was a stupid idea, as it didn’t do anything for anyone. However everyone must remember Top Gear UK was pretty poor in its first season as well and it is only because of TGUK that we expect so much from TGA. I still think it is better than the rest of the crap that free to air tv offers in the time slot. Lets hope if TGA comes back they get a bigger budget, better writers for humour etc, better stunts, better starts than Vince Colosimo (what a cock) and Charlie dulls down the arrogance. If this happens we may have a show that the manufactures will be happy to lend a few cars too again.

    Jay Davidson Posted on 09 December 2008 12:02pm
  • yeah the astra bowling was pointless but the balding tyres and flying stones are expected. i mean look at topgear britain they damage car often. like teh stig spinning the koenigsegg ccx at over 200km/h and clarkson crasing a porsche gt3. thats easily over $100000. its topgear get used to it

    hamed of north shore Posted on 09 December 2008 11:54am
  • ten minutes of the first show was enough, second show to give it a chance got about 5 minutes, the show was to stupid.

    peter h Posted on 09 December 2008 11:51am
  • Obviously the manufactuers AND most of the people leaving feedback here haven't watched much of the UK series. 1) Every (and I mean every) car that hits the test track in the UK show is driven sideways with as much smoke as possible. Not a new thing in our version. 2) The bowls thing was making me cringe, but its light damage compared to the two soccer games (not one but two) they had with small cars in the UK show. 3) The aussie version doesn't give any less technical information than the UK version and Jeremy constantly using the word "torques" irks me as much as the local show using words like "grouse". The show is about the lap times, the races, the stunts and the banter. It is not journalism. It isn't meant to be. Get your expectations right and sit back and enjoy it for what it is people!

    Damian of Adelaide Posted on 09 December 2008 11:47am
  • What about all the free advertising that the manufacturers get ? ? ? Maybe this is what is wrong with Australian car makers, like the now defunct Mitsubishi, the car manufacturers have gotten rid of the "car" people in the industry & replaced the with pale faced, punctilious, penny pinching, pernicious accountants who try to save money instead of making money, there is a difference.

    robert smisen of Murray Bridge South Australia Posted on 09 December 2008 11:47am
  • Fairdinkum Morons. Trying to be funny is not their forte. Too many Aussie slang terms. Not so good on the driving skills either. And that blond haired git lets off an air of arrogance when he speaks to guests and his co-hosts, while the fat bugger is no more a cartoonist than he is a comedian. And the little fella can't stop grinning and dacing on his chicken legs. Watched the first episode, and painfully watched the second. No third go for me. If SBS want to make this a success, get rid of the tossers and treat your guests and audience with a bit of respect. Sorry SBS, not TGA for me.

    Steve the Watcher of Lilydale Posted on 09 December 2008 11:47am
  • Ridiculous. The "quality" of TGA left aside (that's another discussion entirely) - these manufacturers aren't aware of the damage they're doing themselves. By providing a vehicle to this show, they are getting free airtime for their brand, demographically targeted at that! I wonder if any of these bean counters have considered the value of the publicity for their brands? Let's keep in mind that UK's TG has crashed Porsches (both a Cayenne and a 911) - a very rare Koenigsegg, and countless other vehicles. To hear local manufacturers complain about "flying stones" suggests that they are wildly out of touch with their consumers, or with the type of show Top Gear is. Personally, I couldn't bring myself to buy from someone who was willfully ignorant about their consumers.

    Laurie of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 11:37am
  • Hmmmm, Mark Skaife for TGA?

    Kanos of NWA Posted on 09 December 2008 11:31am
  • As a car enthuisiast and having done some racing myself, I think they really need to redefine the show to align more with the way the UK show review the cars. The astra stunt was stupid. It proved nothing except for the immaturity of the producers and hosts. Get some new hosts!!! and open up the competition again for more regular people to apply!

    Troy Posted on 09 December 2008 11:29am
  • Hey Aussie promo managers of these car companies! Have you never seen the overseas series? Their stunts have damaged a few cars! Have we had too many complaints by potential customers saying some of yur cars are crap because of what has happened to them on the show? Get real and get a life!

    Chris Moore of Sackville North Posted on 09 December 2008 11:28am
  • Top Gear AUS does not deserve even a Datsun 120 Y...and this is not an insult to the Datsun...What is this show about? Is not funny, is not informative, is not educational, is not entertaining, is not professional. The three Amigos...What were they thinking...!!!!

    Nino of Gold Coast Posted on 09 December 2008 11:25am
  • At least on the UK Top Gear most of the cars they wreack are ones they have to buy for like a 1,000 pounds or that and then they get to do a series of tests with them. Like last week the hosts had to prove to the producers that Aldi's are still number 1. The Aussie Top Gear is just a very cheap rip off hte UK Top Gear them playing lawns bowls was no different really to the UK Top Gear playing football in cars.

    Car Lovers of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 11:24am
  • As a car enthuisiast and having done some racing myself, I think they really need to redefine the show to align more with the way the UK show review the cars. The astra stunt was stupid. It proved nothing except for the immaturity of the producers and hosts. Get some new hosts!!! and open up the competition again for more regular people to apply!

    Troy Posted on 09 December 2008 11:22am
  • At first I thought it was going to be great to be able to view an Australian version of Top Gear , a show that we love so much. But to our horror & dismay the boys on the Austalian show have but both the Top Gear name & us Aussies to shame. I didnt think I would ever say this but the Australian version is disgusting & they dont do what the original show does ie technical knowledge & useful information on normal everyday cars that each consumer will own etc. My 12 yr old son was also not happy with the Aussie show as he never misses an episode of the BBC version. Why cant they have more reputable fellows doing the show like someone from Eastern Creek International Raceway or Willowbank. Guys with more skill & expertise like Skaife, Alan Jones or Victor Bray & son Ben. I can tell you now Peter Brock (may he rest in Peace) would be very disappointed with the show as well.Wake up SBS & TAKE CONTROL OF THIS SITUATION sack these no hopers & do Top Gear Aust as its meant to be.

    Christine G of Marayong Australia Posted on 09 December 2008 11:20am
  • TGA should not be attempting to be a carbon copy of TGUK, you have to earn your viewers respect and sense of humor. Usually, and I use the term loosely - TGUK usually have a point or direction to their stunt's and shenanigans...not just for the sake of it. I think I also side with the general consensus when I saw Warren can stay but...and change the track for Pete's sake...and a format re-think may be in order...I thought I was watching The Car Show.

    Brad of Mittagong Posted on 09 December 2008 11:19am
  • It is a sad reflection on the Australian car industry if those in a position to 'loan' cars to a show such as Top Gear are so niave and so out of touch with popular motoring culture as to expect their cars to be treated with kid gloves. As previously commented Top Gear is not for serious reviews or technical specs, but is unashamedly tounge-in-cheek and irreverant escapism. The Australian version is much too contrived to be funny, no genuine affection between presenters and not enough Australian content to satisfy Australians. They need to move much further left of centre to survive axing. TopGear UK - V8 turbo, TopGear OZ - a Volvo.

    Paul Koppe of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 11:10am
  • I looked at the first 2 episodes and never again. TGA was a pathetic show, driven by an insular, self-important and irritating person more in tune with celebrity chit-chat, reality TV and dodgy tabloid press than duplicating the legacy of the original concept. He may drive a GT2 but, sincerely, his personality reminds me of a dodgy second hand caravan dealer akin to the Norman Conquest of the eleventh century. The others are just followers, trying their best and totally out of tune. Australian motoring is not about doing smokies in Holden or Ford nor smashing old taxis nor making idiots of themselves with pretend 4WD. Australia is about the bush, bush mechanics, surf wagons, utes, aussies characters chasing bulls in their tattered land cruisers, road trains and so on. Pathetic show, idiotic and bad taste. What were they thinking, all right!

    jp of Sunshine Coast - qld Posted on 09 December 2008 11:06am
  • I've been reading thoughts on the show on various forums and news sites. I agree with comments about the show not being the same as the UK version but I could see the difference as the season progressed. Anti hoon laws, the little finger ads, powerful cars for P platers and parents worry. No matter what they do with some of the cars and their 'poor' reviews on the cars, some of the stunts actually do show how good the cars actually are compared against each other. It's a franchise of the UK version and you can't admit that turning a car into a boat is really reviewing a vehicle but neither is driving a few high powered road cars (Vauxhall, BMW, Jag) on sand although it looked fantastic.

    Stephen Posted on 09 December 2008 11:06am
  • CANCEL IT!!!! Leave us with the original not the "light beer version" These aussie guys are morons!~

    Jeremy May Hammond the third of Merry Old England Posted on 09 December 2008 11:05am
  • Ours is an embarrisingly poor attempt at a brilliant product, producers, you have failed miserably. Its obvious the team aren't comfortable with each other. Stupid stunts on a tiny budget, why bother. Get it off air.

    Andrew Posted on 09 December 2008 11:03am
  • Agree with the report and all the ngative comments thus far. The show has not lived up to the UK version as the presenters have been rather bogan in their approach to the subject matter, which is about the technology of the car as well as its application for the wider community. Yes we need light harted relief however not at the expense of the manufacturer who provides the product in good faith and that it will be treated with some respect and returned in the same condition as it was lent out. Unfortunately these presenters have gone flat out trying to impress the the BOGAN minority and have forgotten about the majority, get new presenters before you blow the rest of the budget on mindless acts of vandalism.....

    Jim of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 11:01am
  • I still dont know how I didnt get selected for this show!! The guys they do have all think there jermey clarkson (what a silly idol). Ive watched 1 show and could not get past the fact that none of these guys are passionate about cars. Thats the soul that Aussie Top Gear is missing!!. They say it about car. Im saying it about a show. I wish the Aussie Top Gear took it to the poms, but ofcourse there are contracts and clauses that just dont give the show it spark. The 3 clowns in the Aussie Top Gear should go back to the Admin Jobs and give people that love cars a go!!. Not oh look Ive destroyed a Holden Astra...How Dumb.... Get an Idea. Bottom Gear.

    Bobby Benvenuto of SYDNEY Posted on 09 December 2008 11:00am
  • We guess the drivers enjoyed themselves but to the viewer the Aussie TOP GEAR didn't turn us on at all. We are surprised that you are even contemplating a second series. Very poor show. As for Aussie cars or local ones we didn't see too many

    M & L Wignell of North east victoria Posted on 09 December 2008 10:59am
  • I find the Australian show pathetic and it should be AXED. The British show has more respect and fun with their vehicles and themselves. A much better programme. Glad their back on and hope they stay that way.

    Lisa Stewart of brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 10:57am
  • I cannot believe you would even try to emulate Top Gear UK. I am sure the english one has all the requisite contracts for the 'could be damage' done in their shows. This Australian version is not funny and is cringeworthy at best.

    Susan Palmer of Picton NSW Posted on 09 December 2008 10:49am
  • What did the manufactures think was going to happen, if you watch the British Top Gear, they don't treat the cars with any respect at all and considering our roads are a lot worse you got to expect some damage. But got to say Top Gear australia just does not seem right, they are copying the whole British show and it just doesn't work with the people the are using, but think they just need to replace one person, with someone with a lot more media experience and it won't seem so fake , but then Top Gear Britian took a couple of years to get the team they have now, which works really well.

    John Andrew of Sunshine Coast Qld Posted on 09 December 2008 10:48am
  • You couldn't say that this isn't exactly the same as what happens in the UK version, and the car companies here have surely been warned by their UK counterparts. Anyone who has watched the UK version would be quite clear that some damage would have been sustained to vehicles, and given they drive lots of 'high-end' vehicles, that damge could be substantial.

    Hugh of Sydney Posted on 09 December 2008 10:48am
  • I'm sorry, but I have little sympathy for the car companies who happily loaned their cars to this show in the hope that they will receive some positive PR. Have they not seen the BBC version, with the Toyota Aygo football or the caravan conkers? If they had even half a brain they would have sent representatives along to the filming who would have pulled the plug and taken the cars away if they thought they may be damaged. The costs associated with repairs to these Holden Astras will no doubt be recovered when they are sold to the public as "Executive Demonstrators".

    Steven Buck Posted on 09 December 2008 10:43am
  • $25,000 damage ti a Lambo? Have you seen the option list? They probably blew an indicator bulb... But seriously UK Top Gear > Aus Top Gear which is something I always feared would happen, especially after watching some of the other Australian car review shows... Horrible stuff

    Andrew of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 10:42am
  • Top Gear Australia with these peanuts - WHAT WERE THEY THINKING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Sue of Perth Posted on 09 December 2008 10:42am
  • Honnestly I hope they won't be allowed to do another serie, they are just not worth, please don't bother... I dont' even the name of the blond w@nker trying to act like Jeremy...he is so not made for that show he's the worse TV presenter I've ever seen and their show is just so dull it's not funny, I've been working in design and engineering in the automobile industry around the world for nearly 20 years, I've never seen such an apauling perfomance in a show or even behind the wheel... just do something else but not Top Gear... please let the English crew do what they do best... not you go back where you were before we don't want you...

    christophe lebreton of melbourne Posted on 09 December 2008 10:42am
  • There is a very simple solution. Just stop supporting this program and let it die. From recent media reports, not many people watch this stupid program and the show might end soon anyway. The earlier the better, as it is a waste of petrol by these hoons, apart from senseless damage to cars.

    Tony Posted on 09 December 2008 10:38am
  • All this hate for the show. I can understand that, its not for everyone. But remember Top Gear UK wasn't always the massive juggernaut it is today. Give em time to find their groove and then this show can shine. I dare say hosts and format etc will change, but so too did TGUK. If people actually bothered to watch the whole series rather than dismissing it after 10mins you'd actually notice that its starting to find its own way. Bring on the 2nd season I say, just hope they pull it together and get out of the shadow of TGUK before the viewers have left.

    Kato of Canberra Posted on 09 December 2008 10:34am
  • I agree, the Australian series completely misses the point of the Original series - which was intelligent, witty, humourous and creative. Frankly, the Australian episodes were a disgrace to the Top Gear reputation. If they want to persist with it, call it something other than Top Gear - like Stunt Rev or whatever, because the title is misleading. Thank God the original series is back again and I have something to look forward to.

    Magdalene of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 10:32am
  • Hmmm, I noticed they didn't show how much damage has been done on the British Top Gear. Don't forget, the Astra lawn bowls was inspired by the British Aygo soccer stunt, and plenty of those Toyotas got damaged, too. I'm not defending TGA, I sort of didn't mind it, but I agree its not a patch on the UK version. But fair's fair, let's here the UK damage bill! grin

    Stephen Krech of Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 9:19am
  • And what world does the car manufacturers live in? In every episode of the original program and the Australian (yawn) the presenters spun tyres, slid cars all over the road and abused each vehicle. Did the suppliers think that their car was not going to receive similar treatment? This lack of understanding of what was to happen to their car on a TV program with graphic examples explains how most car builders have got car ownership trends so wrong. When it comes to informative well presented car programs 5th gear is the best, but unfortunately most TV viewing public in Australia would not be able to cope with information at this level, they want entertainment not information. Sad!

    Peter or Brisbane Posted on 09 December 2008 9:04am
  • SBS would be well advised to just stick with its sex programs.

    Deep Throat Posted on 08 December 2008 11:50pm
  • This is a pointless story. Well, unless it is pointing out how manufacturers are showing how pathetically cost-focussed they are here. If your company is a bean-counting one that wants to sell lots of crap cars to 80 yr olds, then sure, go ahead and tell us that $30K was way too much to spend on a good idea that was executed poorly. Instead, they should be touting the program's poor entertainment factor and the poor presentation and the poor production and ... you get my drift. Car manufacturers that want(ed) their cars on Top Gear are all about the X Factor, something that cost doesn't really have anything to do with. They should be lamenting the show's charm (lack thereof) and how poorly that reflects on their brilliant pieces of machinery.

    Not 80 yrs old Posted on 08 December 2008 11:23pm
  • Couldn't agree more. That stupid stunt they pulled with the Astras (playing bowls with them) was just pathetic. These guys show no respect for the vehicles and think the only thing we want to see is tyre smoke. They just don't get it. So happy to see the UK version back on the box for a few weeks.

    David of Gold Coast Posted on 08 December 2008 7:54pm
  • Top Gear Australia is terrible! It was disappointing, boring, awkward, and by no means a comparison to the UK series. This report should hopefully be the last nail in the coffin for the disaster that is SBS' Top Gear Aus. Let's hope its put out its misery soon!

    Viewer of Melbourne Posted on 08 December 2008 6:03pm
  • I do like including the UK version too. But they stop firthy scences which I not going mention. Compared to other cars show we have & had they were very sensibly. How about also our own version of 5th gear. Some of the team were in Topgear now competing. You only might have to see 5th gear in Liftstyle or some Foxtel channel.

    Car Lover Posted on 08 December 2008 5:57pm
  • Now, I am not a fan of TGA - but why are the suppliers whinging? Did they expect their cars will come back in pristine condition when asked to supply cars for stunts? Jeez! Either supply the cars or don't supply the cars.

    Amup of Perth Posted on 08 December 2008 4:23pm
  • Note to topgear: actually REVIEW the cars your driving from a technical point of view and tone down "trying to be funny" thing. Oh, and get some new hosts (except maybe Warren Brown)

    Karl Posted on 08 December 2008 3:27pm
  • I watched the first episode and haven't bothered since. The way these blokes drove on that first show told me that they were hoons and nothing short of stupid. It takes no talent to do a burnout and the message it sends is completely opposite to parents who want their children to have good driver education. I hope the manufacturers shut the door on them. Well done carsguide for letting this story air.

    Mal Irving of Moss Vale Posted on 08 December 2008 2:29pm
  • Um, it's called light entertainment. Australia's got a long history of serious motoring TV shows. Very informative, but with respect, po faced and dull. Most likely, doing it's best to appease the wowsers in this "nanny state" our country has turned into. The show was always about subjectivity and always about the stunts. Why should one have to fit into the pigeon-hole of an anorak-wearing-trainspotter to be deemed a discerning motoring enthusiast? Aaargh!

    Mark of Syd Posted on 08 December 2008 2:23pm
  • They are just a pack of stupid rednecks,with very little technical knowledge or useful information on the cars. their silly stunts and hooning behavior shows poor regard to giving younger at risk drivers an example of mature behavior. I have watched this rubbish twice, but never again.

    Grant Jenkins Posted on 08 December 2008 12:17pm
  • Thats what you get when you let bogans behind the wheels of expensive machinery. Maybe if they spent less time trying to use every Australian 'okka' term and focused more on the cars, they would be better off. Who really cares if a Proton Jumbuck beats a mine dump truck overall. We are more keen to hear about the latest automobile technology, advances in fuel economy and safety equipment. If I were Lamborghini or Ferrari, there would be no way they would get in my cars to trash them.

    Leslie of Sydney Posted on 08 December 2008 11:14am
  • Hahaha, what a joke, crap show mixed with crap drivers. I feel sorry for all the car companies that lent their assets to these idiots. I hope they realise what a bad investments its been. Glory Glory UK top Gear. TOP GEAR OZ, why dont you just crawl a hole and die in there. Losers!

    TRD Posted on 08 December 2008 10:57am
  • I quite enjoy watching the British Top Gear. When I saw the Australian version with the Lawn Bowls stunt I was shocked. I have not watched another episode since. I was informed by my brother that they also did some stupid things in the sand with some small 4WD's. I'm anal when it comes to looking after my cars. Sorry, this show is not for me.

    Steve Claughton of Sydney Posted on 08 December 2008 10:23am
Read all 123 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links