Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Learner drivers need longer

  • By Neil McDonald
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    Delaying full licenses for young learner drivers in Germany has reduced accident rates by 20 per cent.

A European safety expert believes extended learner driving periods are the best way to cut crash rates among young drivers.

More mature guidance for longer is the preferred path of Professor Ulrich Mellinghoff, the vice-president of safety engineering at Mercedes-Benz. He says a 16-year-old or 17-year old learner driver in Germany must be accompanied by someone at least 30 years old for one year.

“We have seen in Germany that this has reduced accident rates by 20 per cent,” he says. "This is a good solution, it gives young people time to learn what is important in real-world traffic.”

Apart from delaying full licenses for beginners, Mellinghoff predicts that future crash avoidance systems will focus on pedestrian safety. Among his crystal ball gazing is 360-degree guidance systems cameras to help drivers monitor conditions, car-to-car communications to report road dangers and better pedestrian-avoidance systems. Mellinghoff says Benz is working on a pedestrian system that not only avoids a pedestrian - like the latest Volvo system that automatically brakes to prevent hitting people - but will steer the car around them.

“We are now working on several different options with prototypes,” he says. Another option is to link any pedestrian avoidance system to the car’s high-beam headlights so they can specifically flash at the pedestrian to warn them. “The first step was night view and the next step to highlight the pedestrian. We can do that relatively cheaply with conventional high beam systems.”

Mellinghoff credits brake-assist systems in today’s German cars with reducing pedestrian accident rates by between 15 to 20 per cent. Car-to-car communication is also getting closer all the time. “I am confident it will be available in two years. It will check between cars on the road conditions, accidents or other problems.” But Mellinghoff says the use of real-time technology to make cars stick to posted speed limits is unlikely. “You can do it but our customers don’t want it. There are situations too when you may need to accelerate to avoid an accident.”

Mellinghoff has clear views on speeding. “I don’t think that speed alone is the problem, it’s the wrong speed in the wrong situation,” he says. In the former West Germany there were 22,000 people killed in car crashes in 1972, but the number has dropped dramatically. "Last year 4100 people were killed and this was with 20 million more people in Germany because of the addition of East Germany, as well as so much more traffic on the roads. And we still have unrestricted speed limits."

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 6 comments

  • So their should be some kind of attitude test???

    james Posted on 13 January 2011 4:52pm
  • Attitudes and skills are equally important. Longer supervised practise may help establish better attitudes and better teaching may inculcate better skills. An interesting piece of research I did found out that in US states, raising the legal driving age to 18 (from as low as 13) and lowering it from 21 in another made practically no difference in injury/fatal collisions in the first few years of driving. Personally I think a younger learner driver age, with initial professional instruction (preferably with the intending supervisor in the car, to "learn" good techniques) and a longer learning period would work wonders, but I don't know if it would overcome the poor attitude many P-Platers have - especially not realising how little control they have over the road and other users.

    Doug of Werribee Posted on 08 November 2010 4:28pm
  • Germany has proven that speed does not kill it is the idiot behind the wheel. It's all about attitude to driving, if you drive with the correct attitude you won't get into any trouble through any fault of your own. Be aware of road conditions and drive accordingly and at times it is certainly safe to drive above the speed limit

    Daryl Douglass of Sydney Posted on 04 May 2010 6:59pm
  • Young drivers need compulsory driver training away from their parents. Parents are the ones teaching their children how to kill themselves by passing on their bad driving habits. None of the restrictions placed on L and P plate drivers in any state have lowered the death rate of these drivers and continue to be a poorly conceived knee-jerk reaction to the accidents.

    Dave of Canberra Posted on 25 March 2010 11:24pm
  • They ADDED the population of Australia and still dropped deaths by 80% ! - what sort of drugs are our politicians on ? =- I agree though 100 in a 40 or 60 zone should mean permanent loss of license for life (along with other offences)

    cmos of brisbane Posted on 23 March 2010 11:53am
  • If you listen to governments around this country all you need to do to save lives is slow down and not drink drive.

    Ben of Broken Hill Posted on 19 March 2010 11:03am
Read all 6 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links