Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Speculation Holden Commodore to disappear

  • By Karla Pincott
  • Carsguide
  • image

    Holden Commodore to be phased out in favour of a ‘global’ car.

More speculation has emerged that Holden will replace the Commodore brand in five or six years.

Tim Lee, the Shanghai-based president of GM's international operations was quoted in reports in the business press today, which speculated that the Holden Commodore would be phased out in favour of a ‘global’ car.

Lee reportedly said while visiting Melbourne that Holden had been one of the car giant’s strongest sellers in local markets, but that the GM business plan – like that of Ford – was moving towards global platforms.

However he said that GM would maintain "full-line capacity in Australia with designing and engineering, building and selling vehicles", according to reports in the Australian Financial Review and other business media.

The reports also quote Lee as saying that the "In the body shop the best way to do that is to have flexibility and to build two architectures and platforms. Maybe a mini car and a small car or maybe a small car and a compact car, or maybe a compact car and mid-sized car."

"We're going to build a s**t load more great Commodores,” he was quoted as saying.  “It’s still an outstanding motor vehicle and one that we intend to produce for a long time.  But if you look at the motorway here in Melbourne, you see a lot of small cars. You see a lot of more fuel-efficient vehicles on the roads than Commodore.”

The comments come after the release of a South Australian report, detailing that Holden's Elizabeth car manufacturing plant alone is worth more than $1.5 billion to the state economy each year and closure would lead to the loss of up to 16,000 jobs.

Premier Jay Weatherill released the report last week, after the State Opposition called for a cost-benefit analysis before the handover of more taxpayer money to the company. The study by University of Adelaide Business School head Barry Burgan, dated February 4, was handed to the state Manufacturing, Innovation, Trade, Resources and Energy Department. It does not comment on the merits of further taxpayer backing.


Holden is in negotiations with the state and federal governments over a bailout to keep the Elizabeth plant operational beyond 2016 and economists have forecast a $200 million price tag. The Federal Government will contribute the bulk of the funding.


Associate Professor Burgan's report finds there are 2700 people directly employed by Holden in Elizabeth. The company purchases $530 million of goods from ``core'' local suppliers, supporting 5610 jobs and prompts extra employment in retail, transport, construction and other manufacturing. But the report says closure at Holden would also lead to some growth in other industries and reduction in worker wages as supply of labour and resources currently invested in auto manufacturing shifted.

``Note that this report does not consider the issues around what is required to underpin the longer term sustainability of the operations at Holden,'' Prof Burgan writes. ``Nor does this analysis consider the full gamut of benefit and cost considerations in terms of policies to mitigate the risks identified.''

Opposition industry spokesman Steven Marshall said the Government had spent taxpayer money to deliver a report backing its political argument. Taxpayer support for car making needed to be based on a full cost-benefit study, he said.

Mr Weatherill told the South Australian Parliament the Elizabeth plant had long been ``the cornerstone of our state's industrial strength''.

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 13 comments

  • Maybe they want to build something reliable

    Daniel Stanton of sydney Posted on 05 March 2012 9:14pm
  • Michael of Melbourne. Just the kind of comment I would expect from a twat who has no concept of mechanics or anything Australiana. Go get a life you sorry looser and disappear in your imported buzzbox on wheels whilst supporting overseas manufacturers.People like you make me want to vomit you are so un Australian.

    Phill of geraldton Posted on 01 March 2012 12:49am
  • Don't say fleet etc then blame no private buyers, most fleet commodores go to private families in two years via auction or auction and dealer, then they start to carry Aussie kids to school, just five hundred days late.

    protossw Posted on 24 February 2012 10:53pm
  • The Commodore is already a global car built on GM's global RWD platform.

    Mick of Melb Posted on 24 February 2012 11:14am
  • OH no what are the FALCODORE bogans going to follow in the V8 Supercars....

    Michael Of Melbourne Posted on 23 February 2012 10:58am
  • Remember when Holden phased out the wb series? Everyone who could rushed out to get a statesman, ute or van. I think the good old commodore may be on the shopping list before it disappears and we are fed a diet of pussy corolla's & mazda 3's--horrible!

    Loyal to the end Posted on 22 February 2012 10:53pm
  • GM already has a "GLOBAL CAR", it's called the Commodore.

    arthur of frankston Posted on 22 February 2012 9:12pm
  • Holden will drop the Commodore for the cruze but they should leave the statesman on sale. Just make the statesman cheaper. A holden statesman omeg .for the average person who still wants a big car. If holden drop the big car that 2000 units a month they will be missing out.

    matt goss of brisbane Posted on 22 February 2012 8:55pm
  • No surprise. It is inevitable. Once fleet sales (very low profit margin) is excluded, very few people buy these cars. All workers at Holden, Australia should plan for their future when the factory eventually close.

    Tony of Melb. Posted on 22 February 2012 6:42pm
  • This is going to be sad. It took over where Kingswood left off in end on 70's.

    joe Lovestick Posted on 22 February 2012 5:59pm
  • As long as they sell a rear-wheel or all-wheel-drive car, I do not care.

    Aa Ron Posted on 22 February 2012 4:34pm
  • Just change the name of the Cruze to Commodore. Problem fixed....

    The Truth Posted on 22 February 2012 2:49pm
  • "We're going to build a s**t load more great Commodores,” That's one phrase every holden loves reading froma GM executive.

    Dave S Posted on 22 February 2012 1:45pm
Read all 13 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links