Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Cheap cars lack safety

  • By Neil McDonald
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    Safety features are accepted in high-end luxury cars from Mercedes-Benz but remain out of reach on cars like the Tata Nano (pictured).

Budget buyers are missing out on the latest lifesaving safety features.

Active safety features like electronic stability control are bypassing the most-needed segment in the car market - budget cars, according to Singapore-based engineering executive, Robert Tan.

With the global explosion of new budget cars from markets like India and China, these systems are critical to help save lives, particularly among younger buyers looking for a cheap car, he says.  "Governments need to be more pro-active to add these potentially life-saving devices into ultra-low and low-cost cars," he says.

"It's not happening fast enough on low-cost cars, those under $15,000."  Tan cost prohibited the full suite of safety features migrating from high-end luxury cars to mid to low-end vehicles.

Such systems are accepted in high-end luxury cars from Mercedes-Benz but remain out of reach on cars like the Tata Nano, he says.  Tan is the engineering director of automotive electronics company Infineon Technologies, which builds safety systems for cars.

Unlike passive safety systems like airbags, which only come into use during an accident, Tan says active safety systems are just as important.  "They help drivers avoid an accident in the first place," he says.

He argues that seatbelt reminder lights and active brake lights are relatively cheap to install on low-cost cars, yet very few have them.  Tan also wants intelligent speed limiters, drowsiness detection devices and brake assist systems in budget cars.

"They are proven to work in high-end cars but are largely unavailable on low-cost cars," he says.  These systems could be piggy-backed on to existing technologies that are already in some cars, he says.

All these things could create an "electronic safety cocoon" for occupants.  European figures already show that electronic stability control systems have helped reduce fatal accidents by more than 30 per cent.

Australia will mandate ESC on all cars and off-roaders from November next year and all vehicles from November 2013.  Tan, who was in Melbourne this week to address a Society of Automotive Engineers Australia safety conference, concedes that cost remains a big hurdle to some of the newer safety systems.

"It is difficult to develop something like radar cruise control on a $5000 vehicle," he says.  However, he says there is no reason low-cost cars should not get seatbelt reminders, speed limiters and brake assist.

"The challenges are cost, then there is original equipment maker acceptance and consumer acceptance," he says.  "Lastly legislation - without legislation there would be no pro-active safety systems."

Comments on this story

Displaying 2 of 2 comments

  • If the government is serious on safety they should just mandate all new cars to be sold as 4-star tested and above. That would bring the price down for safety very quickly and save more lives. A severely injured person costs all taxpayers money (more than a dead person!).

    James Posted on 24 April 2010 12:47pm
  • It comes down to they way car companies market their product. Hyundai for example, the cars they talk about in the ads 5 star value or 5 star prices, they should not be using anything to do with the 5 star unless talking about safety. Also the fact that car companies have safety packs instead of making the safety of curtain air bags standard, this to a young person on a tight budget will make the difference between purchasing these items or not. They do this so they can be the cheapest car. True buyers don't just buy on price, they want all the bells and whistles,however it's clever marketing that changes the buying style. It's only recently that the Corolla has added ESC, yet it's the highest selling car?. It's not the build quality, If it was then ask yourself why do they use a welded door and not a one bit door?. why is it that the new model my knees are above the dash board?. I know, so my knees go through my face when the front airbag goes off. Why is the dash board like a wobble board. You call that quality, I don't think so. See the problem is, people stick to what the know. Toyota HAD a very good name years ago, then they try and same money were ever they can.

    holdenmad of Brighton Vic Posted on 12 April 2010 10:23am

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links