Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

BMW moves away from run-flat tyres

  • By Keith Didham
  • The Mercury
image A change of tyre... some of the new Mini models will be available with a conventional spare tyre rather than run-flats.

The future of controversial run-flat tyres has been placed under a cloud of doubt.

One of the biggest users (and spruikers) of run-flats – BMW – is changing back to conventional tyres on some of its models.

BMW will later this year switch to normal tyres on popular variants of its Mini for international markets.

For Australian Minis, the standard 15-inch wheel will continue to be fitted with a conventional tyre. The larger 16-inch wheel, currently shod with run-flat rubber and selected by more than 90 percent of buyers, will also change to a conventional tyre. Run-flat rubber will now be offered as a $200 option.

The 17-inch wheel will remain with run-flats.

Models with conventional tyres will come with BMW's mobility pack, consisting of an air compressor and glue kit to make temporary puncture repairs.

The move appears to be a cost saving measure by Mini's parent as the world-wide economic crisis hits home. Sources within Mini in Germany say BMW, which has been promoting the virtues of run-flats for years, has been disappointed that rival manufacturers Mercedes-Benz and Audi had not adopted the technology. Their added volume would have reduced the production cost of the controversial tyre for the motoring industry.

Run-flats are essentially a tyre with stiffer sidewalls which allows the car to be driven if the tyre is punctured. They have been widely criticised for their harsh and unforgiving ride, especially if combined with sports suspension set ups.

The lack of a spare wheel however offers substantial weight savings and wins back extra boot space.

At this stage the switch back to conventional tyres has not affected BMW models, sold in Australia, most of which use run-flat tyres.

 

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 17 comments

  • I have a new BMW 123d sports convertible and boy those run flats are real road shakers and if you get a puncture be ready to pay for an expensive replacement.

    robert blackmore of manly Posted on 29 October 2011 8:30am
  • Just changed my 2010 BMW X5 runflats for conventionals and now the ride comfort and handling is superb. Will never use runflats again.

    sisko of willaura Posted on 23 August 2011 2:49am
  • I'm not sure what BMW was thinking but run-flats are simply a flawed concept. They can't be repaired, are madly expensive and only can be used for 200km after being damaged. And retailers don't stock them. If you do replace one you get odd tyres wear rates, so you have to buy 2. Plus they are really noisy, heavy and harsh and wreck the car's ride and handling because the sidewalls don't flex. When I bought my fabulous 320d in 2006 I replaced them with Potenzas after 3000kms, transformed the car and lasted 60,000kms. When I traded it in I put the originals back on and sold it in original condition and saved myself about $2800.

    Timbo2 of Canberra Posted on 15 June 2011 12:53pm
  • I have a 2010 125i fitted with run flat tyres and I am very happy with them. The ride is noticably more compliant than our other car which is fitted with normal tyres. I think BMW has taken on board criticisms about the earlier generation run-flats and the current version are pretty good.

    Garry of Canberra Posted on 15 April 2011 1:04pm
  • Have run 320d since 2006 (2 cars) and average 20+k per year and have not had a puncture yet - Bridgestone?s first car, Pirellis second car. Bridgestone?s rode ok and were good with grip and quite quiet. 1st set lasted 40k. Pirellis are AWFUL! (225/45 x 17 FR; 255/40 x 17 RR). Slightest road deviation jerks steering wheel out of your hand (impossible to relax) and sounds like a Land Rover on Coopers. Done 30k and they are worn 80%. Tempted to run conventionals for noise/ride reasons alone. Cost too I guess.

    Howard Wilson of Brisbane Posted on 17 February 2011 6:24pm
  • you could simply choose to replace your run flats with normal tyres....

    gooku of yourface Posted on 01 November 2010 2:23am
  • I'm sure as with all manufacturers you receive a breakdown service, plus, you can extend this for a reasonable amount so the extra fuel saved on pushing those heavy run flats would cover the breakdown fee, so Danny of Sydney, there's your piece of mind and clean hands too. One phone call and someone will do the donkey work for you. So how can any tyre manufacturer claim these have any benefits when they are unrepairable!

    james of perth of perth Posted on 06 September 2010 10:25pm
  • I always wanted a BMW and was in a position to do so in 2008 and I picked up my brand new 323 only to find it handled like a beat up ford twenty years old. After complaining on several occasions I was told that it was due to the run flat tyres. I did not think it could get any worse until 4 weeks ago I needed to replace the tyres only to be told to park the car in the garage as Bridgestone do not have replacement tyres in Australia dont know when the next shipment will arrive. The car is now in the garage gathering dust as I can not drive it due to lack of tyres available. I am thinking of selling the car now but can not as it is not roadworthy.

    Peter Andriske of Albury Posted on 31 August 2010 3:30pm
  • Runflat tyres are absolutely absurd for Australian roads! I hate them, I have a lovely BMW 320d purchased in 2006. Of course no mention of runflat tyres by the BMW car salesman. I had never even heard of these tyres until I unfortunately picked up my first nail (city driving) a month later and had to replace a brand new tyre! GRRRR... in the next few months I picked up another 2 nails and had to replace another 2 runflat tyres... and most annoying these stupid Bridgestone tyres cannot be sold by all tyre dealers, only those "trained to install runflat tyres". And even then have to be ordered in! How inconvenient to be on holiday in some small country town where no one sells them! Yes, that happened to me... and now I have just had to replace another 3 tyres, they have worn out! A disgrace on the part of BMW and Bridgestone, forcing us to use these stupd tyres. I will never buy another BMW, this is my first and last! My husband wanted to buy me a Mercedes instead - pity I did not listen!

    Roro of sydney Posted on 30 August 2010 10:29pm
  • I have purchased 2 BMW 323i in the past 2 years, I wish I would have driven one a bit longer to fully realise the pitfalls of these dreadfull tyres, they are not suitable for Australian roads and I will not be buying any car with runflats ever again, not that BMW would care.

    Antony Hartung of Gold Coast Posted on 26 August 2010 4:04pm
  • My one year old BMW 120i has a flat tyre and there are no replacement Good Year run flats available in Australia. BMW are incorrect in their run flat tyres for Australian conditions. Being able to drive for 200 kms on a flat does you diddly squat of good if you're in the middle of the Nullarbor and there are no stockists available within cooee. Run flats might be good if you never leave the metropolitan area, but not if you do any country driving. Seriously thinking of selling my one year old car because of this inconvenient issue.

    unhappy customer of WA Posted on 26 July 2010 5:50pm
  • What about the benefits of runflats? Is comfort and a few extra dollars better than your and your family's safety? Blown tyre on a wet freeway or a car ramming into you while you change a wheel or your kids get kidnapped as the car cannot be driven with a flat tyre. It'll not happen to you? Same thoughts for those on the front page of a newspaper.

    Danny of Sydney Posted on 18 May 2010 11:49am
  • I have endured 38,000 miles on Continental and Bridgestone runflats. The ride is dreadful so now I am switching to conventional and will carry a pump and tyre seal. My car is the 330d Coupe.

    Peter Norman of Abbotsley, Cams. UK Posted on 07 April 2010 7:51am
  • I replaced my run flats on my X5 straight away once I found out they were hard and noisy. The best thing I have ever done was to buy Falkens for 190 each

    M Perin of Vic Posted on 24 March 2010 10:13pm
  • I have a Mini Cooper S with these tyres. They are gawd-awful noisy. Also, if you get a flat on a tyre that has some wear on it, they have to be replaced in pairs because of the wheel sensing in the car. I would definitely NOT buy another car with runflats.

    Scott H of Brisbane Posted on 20 March 2010 7:47am
  • My 5 month old BMW 320d sport with 18inch runflats, I got a simple puncture, as they claim they cannot repair them a single replacement tyre was $820. My first and last bmw I will ever buy with these overly expensive non repairable tyres. Audi/Mercedes here I come.

    Garry of Brisbane Posted on 05 February 2010 1:10pm
  • Have had new 118I with run flat tyres for 4 months.Puncture 2 weeks ago .Still waiting for BMW to get new tyre

    John Anthony of Newcastle Posted on 27 January 2010 8:40pm
Read all 17 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links