Skip navigation

carsguide.com.au

Used car review: Mazda3 2009-2010

  • By Graham Smith
  • Herald Sun
  • image

    A lack of complaints at Carsguide HQ suggests the top-selling small car is doing the business.

Graham 'Smithy' Smith reviews the used Mazda3 2009-2010: its fine points, flaws and what to watch for when buying it.

The signs of bigger things to come were there early in 2008 when the Mazda3 knocked Holden's Commodore off its long held lofty perch atop the local car market.

What had been unimaginable only a few years earlier when Mazda was struggling against a tide of disinterest and adverse exchange rates to sell its cars had come to be.

The Ford off-shoot was top of the pops. Some dismissed it as a one-off never to be repeated, but here we are a couple of years later and Mazda can boast it had the most popular car of 2011.

Mazda's success reflects the seismic shift in the market away from large cars to smaller ones. It's reasonable to think that shift will be reflected in the used car market, and the Mazda3 could well reflect is new car success in the used car arena.

The BL arrived in 2009 with much of the job done by its predecessor; it only had to build on what had been done and that's what it did. It wasn't revolutionary; rather it was an evolution of the BK model it followed.

A new body, improved cabin, together with worthwhile engine, transmission and suspension tweaks added to its appeal. If you compared the BL with the old BK you would notice the bigger smile on the front of the new model, but apart from that recognisable difference it was pretty much the same as the older car in the looks department.

Two body styles were offered; a sedan for oldies and a hatch for youngies. The sedan's main criticism was its boot, which was on the small side with a highish loading lip; the downside to the hatch was the level of road noise. Inside, the dash was revised; A new display screen and audio controls on the steering wheel, again tweaks to improve on what was already a success.

Like it was with the previous model, Mazda's engine range was made up of two petrol engines and a diesel. The base engine was a 2.0-litre four in the Neo and Maxx models; there was a larger, sportier 2.5- litre four in the SP25, and there was the choice of a 2.2-litre turbo- diesel.

UNDER THE BONNET

the petrol engines boasted a little more power and torque, and better fuel economy. On the road the chassis was agile and responsive and fun to drive. The ride was on the firm side, but not to the point of being uncomfortable.

IN THE SHOP

The Mazda3 has been a solid performer since its introduction and the BL seems to be following the pattern. A lack of complaints at Carsguide HQ suggests the top-selling small car is doing the business. Check for a service record to make sure nothing has been neglected, and inspect bodywork for repairs that indicate a previous crash repair.

UNDER THE PUMP

The base engine is quite a thrifty little unit delivering decent economy at under 8 L/100 km in manual form; the auto is a little thirstier, but still an economical choice. Clearly the SP25, with its sporty bent and larger 2.5-litre engine uses more fuel, but even then the Mazda claim is a quite reasonable 8.6 L/10 km, which was borne out when tested by Carsguide. The most economical engine choice is the diesel, which it is claimed will deliver 5.7 L/100 km.

IN A CRASH

The BL Mazda3 won a five-star tick from ANCAP, that's as good as it can get under the current regime. With front, side and head airbags, ABS brakes with emergency brake assist, traction and stability control it's got the lot when it comes to safety.

AT A GLANCE

Price new: $21,990 to $30,690
Engine: 2.0-litre 4-cylinder petrol; 2.5-litre 4-cylinder petrol; 2.2- litre 4-cylinder turbo-diesel
Transmission: 5-speed auto, 6-speed manual, front-wheel drive
Economy: 7.9 L/100 km (2.0P), 8.6 L/100 km (2.5P), 5.7 L/100 km (2.2TD)
Body: 5-door hatch, 4-door sedan
Variants: Neo, Maxx, Maxx Sport, SP25, MZR-CD
Safety: 5-star ANCAP.

EXPECT TO PAY

$14,500 to $20,000 for the Neo; $17,000 to $22,000 for the Maxx; $19,000 to $24,500 for the Maxx Sport, $22,000 to $27,000 for the SP25; $21,000 to $25,000 for the MZR-CD.

VERDICT

Subtle rework of an already good car makes a good used buy 4 stars

RATING

4 stars

image image
  • Smart looking
  • Well built
  • Improved handling
  • Better fuel economy
  • Small sedan boot
  • Hatch cabin noise

ALSO CONSIDER

  • Ford Focus 2009-2010: Great driving dynamics in an affordable, roomy small family-focused package. Worthy alternative. Pay $11,500-$43,000 3.5 stars.
  • Toyota Corolla 2009-2010: The car for the person who wants reliable, affordable motoring and isn't fussed about cars. The benchmark smallie. Pay $14,500-$27,500 4 stars.
  • Volkswagen Golf 2009-2010: Nice driver, well built, does everything well. Expensive. Pay $15,500- $48,000 3.5 stars.

Comments on this story

Displaying 3 of 8 comments

  • Had 2008 mazda 6 hatch, and have 2010 3MPS. No problems with either. Both fun to drive, and totally reliable. The little company that could- at least in Australia. Zoom Zoom!

    MJ Posted on 05 April 2012 5:31pm
  • Picked up our new Mazda 3 Maxx Sport 2 weeks ago. Was going to buy the Neo but for just a little bit more the Maxx Sport with, bluetooth, climate control, dual to keep the missus happy for not much more appealed more. Apart from the larger engine and wheels of the SP23 we are not missing anything. Got to admit, I have really fallen in love with the Maxx Sport, nice & light but a tight solid one piece feeling of the body. Love the steering, brakes and acceleration - lacks very little compared to the SP23 - just in torque to be expected with the smaller engine. New 5 speed auto is incredibly smooth slurring its gears changes without notice. Build quality & paint work - major improvement - does not seem as 'soft'. Nice and smooth, no vibration and on SMOOTH roads, nice and quite, BUT, drive on a coarse surface and it is noisy - which seems to be coming from the wheel arches. Great car, great price can see why they continue to sell like crazy, just need to make them quieter Mazda.......

    Con Verdis of ROZELLE NSW 2039 Posted on 05 March 2012 8:10pm
  • As mentioned by others above our SP23 has been totally reliable and is still fun to drive. When traveling OS we always seem to get VWs and they always let us down, so we wonder when they win awards here after a short test. Wish Mazda didn't detune the 6 diesel for the 3 or it would be the perfect replacement.

    Daryl Saal of Toowoomba Posted on 27 January 2012 10:30pm
  • I have an 09 SP25 (not this model, I know, but I thought I'd join in). I live in the bush and have done nigh on 60k already, and I love it. Great power and economy and features. Best. Car. Ever.

    Nick M Posted on 25 January 2012 11:48am
  • I got rid of my 2005 SP23 at the end of it's 5 year lease and 160,000 on the clock. No serious issues apart from wear and tear, to be expected when used on rough country and dirt roads. Tyre life was good, brake wear was really good and they were effective. The car only missed one service being on time (6 weeks late) and mechanically was sound. It did have leaks from the power steering when I passed it on, but no other leaks. I did suffer from noise, common especially for that model, both road and mechanical (engine and suspension). Economy was fine, easily getting 600+km to a 50 litre tank. Interior was spotless, except for a wear hole in the driver's footwell carpet, can't really blame Mazda for that. Needed traction and stability from new (now standard, of course), not offered in 2004, Would go Mazda again.

    shebs Posted on 23 January 2012 10:09am
  • We have had a Mazda SP20 and MPS for several years and they are faultless..very reliable and fun to drive. Will definately buy Mazda 3 again smile

    Sean Mac of Brighton Posted on 21 January 2012 2:31pm
  • Our 2004 SP23 is nearing 180,000kms and we have never had a single problem or mechanical failure - just serviced by John Newell Mazda by the book. No squeaks, no rattles, no tears in the seats, the drivers seat has retained its shape, everything works. After 8 years our SP23 still puts a smile on our faces with its handling, steering, braking and performance. There are a few Mazda 3's in our circle of family and friends and their experience is the same.There has been a lot of talk about the Mazda 3 being the number 1 car in 2011 and it is obvious to us why. Really keen on the new CX5 diesel, and if it as good as our SP 23 we will be really happy.

    Con Verdis of ROZELLE NSW 2039 Posted on 15 January 2012 12:16pm
  • The early neo's (09 and '10) missed out on some safety equipment (side + curtain airbags) but could be optioned up with a 'safety pack' ($500 iirc). I believe all late 2010 and onward neo's had it standard. Something to think about if buying an early BL neo.

    Matt Posted on 14 January 2012 3:09pm
Read all 8 comments

Add your comment on this story

Indicates required

We welcome your comments on this story. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name. We also require a working email address - not for publication, but for verification. The location field is optional.

Cars for sale

Sponsored Links